Originally posted by PackMan97 So...any chance we'll have situations where they bounce off the uprights?
I can just see now...this replay shows it was good! BUG! OMG! FIXORZ THE GAMEZ!
This is why I was saying that the angle, or the axis or something needs to be altered slightly, cause a few of the ones that say "made" appear to be outside the goal posts.
the problem is probably the viewing angle... as you can see, since it's 3D, the goal posts don't appear vertical. If you extend them way up into the sky, they span a much wider range than they do way down at ground level.
Originally posted by Octowned The problem with things like onside kicks (and IMO 2 point conversions) is that you run the risk of abuse. I know people here already said "so make the sim so that it is not worth the attempt on a regular basis." Well, sure, that's easy to do for equal matched games. But how do you ensure that for blowout games? It is hard to balance every matchup like that, and you'd get overpowered teams in leagues (and most leagues AA or below have one or two) attempting onside kicks every time.
The problem is, the formulas that lead to balance in close to evenly matched games break down (in terms of balance) in blowout wins. And why turn 96-0 games that were awful enough to watch into ones where the opposing offense NEVER touch the ball? You end up with even more frustrated leagues because of overmatched teams, and the undermatched teams having play time issues.
Having a balanced code that prevents abuse while still allows SOME chance of success would be a near impossible task.
Just use the same formula Madden does...the chart that coaches have that tells them when it mathematically makes sense to go for 2
Originally posted by AngryDragon can we block the kicks?
Originally posted by Bort This'd remedy that, actually. Counts as a full play now, since the full extent of the blocking and all that is simmed now. Still needs some DC slots, etc, etc, but that's just busy work in the end.
Also, because the players' movements are being simmed fully, FG blocks could be worked in fairly easily I think.
Then I could convert XP's to use the same engine, and that would allow 2 point conversions to be added more easily as well, since the XP wouldn't be tacked on to a TD replay, but run as a separate play.