User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Forum > Suggestions > XP bonus for playing at or above your level
Page:
 
Ken1
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by FairForever
This would be viable if there were more than 1 team per conference promoted.

The way it is now, you're stuck with menial competition? Get a menial team.

Ideally, as Serenity said, a small XP boost for playing better opponents with no XP penalty for playing worse ones would be good.

The fact is that the Silverymoon Elves had two players leave, and two players join (or something to that extent). Continuity should be rewarded, not punished.


The idea is to give the players who are too high level for their league incentive to leave.

People who've put together teams with many players way above their opponents' levels will, of course, be really angry about this; but they should realize they managed to use a very flawed system extremely well (to their credit), but now they have to suck it up and compete on a fairer playing field.

Without the exp penalty, there's nothing to keep teams from continuing to stockpile players well above league levels. With it, most top players won't sign and take the 10% exp hit (though they still would be allowed to).

There should be a pretty generous fudge factor for players who've been on a team for more than a season, but even that should have some limit.
Last edited Jun 7, 2008 01:56:56
 
FairForever
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Ken1
Originally posted by FairForever

This would be viable if there were more than 1 team per conference promoted.

The way it is now, you're stuck with menial competition? Get a menial team.

Ideally, as Serenity said, a small XP boost for playing better opponents with no XP penalty for playing worse ones would be good.

The fact is that the Silverymoon Elves had two players leave, and two players join (or something to that extent). Continuity should be rewarded, not punished.


The idea is to give the players who are too high level for their league incentive to leave.

People who've put together teams with many players way above their opponents' levels will, of course, be really angry about this; but they should realize they managed to use a very flawed system extremely well (to their credit), but now they have to suck it up and compete on a fairer playing field.

Without the exp penalty, there's nothing to keep teams from continuing to stockpile players well above league levels. With it, most top players won't sign and take the 10% exp hit (though they still would be allowed to).

There should be a pretty generous fudge factor for players who've been on a team for more than a season, but even that should have some limit.


That's stupid. The level cap was a much better idea, because it promoted continuity. Stick with your team for the long haul.

And there is something to keep teams from stockpiling high level talent. The fact that there's only so many high-leveled guys in the game, and the fact that the level gap shrinks every season quite significantly.

The Level cap allows for long-term development. The truth is that many of the Elves started out as level 1s or 4s last season. Punish them now because they've stuck together and played well?
 
Thaliko
offline
Link
 
its all works great if properly set up. Since it is a single person getting affected on not teams and basing the level on league median not opponent. Say next year the mean/median in a typical usa A league will be 15. Now if you add in a 5 point margin only players level 9 or under and plaers level 21 and over will be effected. If your team has a lot of players over level you should have moved up already or be moving up this year. Also if possible have no top end cap in pro's and increase level margins in higher leagues as needed.
Last edited Jun 7, 2008 05:43:55
 
Link
 
Originally posted by Thaliko
its all works great if properly set up. Since it is a single person getting affected on not teams and basing the level on league median not opponent. Say next year the mean/median in a typical usa A league will be 15. Now if you add in a 5 point margin only players level 9 or under and players level 21 and over will be effected. If your team has a lot of players over level you should have moved up already or be moving up this year. Also if possible have no top end cap in pro's and increase level margins in higher leagues as needed.


I agree with this idea, it'll only affect 5-10% of PLAYERS in the teams and would prevent players dropping down that are really high level leveling up as fast. If you are the owner of a team trying to win by just buying higher level talent and not actually playing the game with a plan (Chelsea/ Cowboys anybody?) then you deserve to level up slower. Likewise if you have a great plan but are getting pounded early in the season then the leveling bonus will ensue closer games as you level up quicker.

Of course if you run the team and you wanted to get the most XP for your back ups and have a stronger squad then you would play your back ups in perceived blow outs as they would not be penalised by the level bonus.

Good work Bort
 
Enkidu98
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by FairForever

The Level cap allows for long-term development. The truth is that many of the Elves started out as level 1s or 4s last season. Punish them now because they've stuck together and played well?


No, a level cap punishes teams just as much if not more than this suggestion of Borts. This suggestion _encourages_ but does not enforce. Meaning, Players who try to go down just to rack up stats etc, might be less inclined to go down because they know they will also face penalties. Meaning that only those teams that are together because they have been playing together a long time and want to stick with their personnel may have higher level players.

With Level caps and Salary caps, it is _possible_ to force a team that is demoted, or force a team who failed to get promoted, to have to break up their team so they can meet the restrictions placed on their league and THAT is a "BAD IDEA"®

Would you like your team to be forced to drop players and send them elsewhere because you've played together for three seasons but now your salaries are too high for the league you are in? or your levels are too high? Sometimes a 'superior' team can lose in a playoff game... this means they are not promoted that year, this means they are tougher perhas than their league opponents. Shold the be forced to strip themselves of their players jsut so a whiner can look at the numbers and think they can win?

I would suggest Bort consider two options.

Option #1 is this idea he has in this thread. A 'Carrot' instead of a stick. This encourages free agents without personal attachments to actually play to their level or suffer slow character development.

Option #2 is to consider promoting and demoing more teams each season. I would suggest that the four teams who play in each leagues conference finals be prmoted and the eight teams with the worst records in the League above be exchanged each season. This accomodates more league parity, and eliminates teams that maybe should have advanced but didn't because of a missed kick upset, etc.

In no way should a salary cap or a level cap be introduced as the only function of a level/salary cap is to appease whiners who are under the impression they wont be able to win. They will have 16 games at which they gain experience at a far faster rate then their more experienced opponents. By the end of a season, the 'inferior' teams can win in the playoffs. Just take a lokk at all the leagues and note how many of the 'favourites' made it all the way to league promotion. In wuite a few leagues, the 'best' team was knocked out of the playoffs by teams they had manhandled earlier in the season.
 
Tha Answer
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Bort
Ok, so here's a positive reinforcement idea instead of level caps, to "encourage" parity instead of force it. This has been brought up before, but I'm posting it here for further review:

(note this is in "suggestions," not "announcements")

Power gamers and those looking for loopholes to pwning n00bs care about one thing: XP. They want to be uber player, gain the max XP possible, and look at their pretty attributes.

1) For every game you play, the experience an individual player gains is modified based on the levels of your opponents (or of the league) compared to your own, with say, up to a 15% modifier.

2) If you play a team or at a level (see two options below) that's around the same level as you, you get the same XP as you get now.

3) If you play a team or at a level (see two options below) that's better than you, you get an XP bonus.

4) If you play a team or at a level (see two options below) that's worse than you, you get less XP.

Levels could be based on:
1) The average level of the other team, weighted toward starters. A "better" team would be one that was, say, 3 levels higher than you on average. And worse, would be say, 3 levels lower (could be 4/5, dunno).
2) Or, the average level of the league, weighted towards the top. You get a bonus for being below the avg.

Shoot holes in it! What are the exploits?




I think its a good Idea Bort, its like this if your team is the better team then what can you learn from the not so good team? Answer: nothing, but if your team is not a good team and you're playing against a good team you learn from the better team, for an example, your man get beat on a pass, because you was playing the man too close, that should tell you next time play them, to play off him so you don't get beat or ask for help over the top the next time,but I do agree that the better team shouldn't get Penalized for being the better team they should just get the reguler XP and not the bonus.

 
David Cain
offline
Link
 
heres a pretty cool game to try
http://s1.gladiatus.us/game/c.php?uid=57460
 
Tha Answer
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by David Cain
heres a pretty cool game to try
http://s1.gladiatus.us/game/c.php?uid=57460


LOL

 
Piemaster
offline
Link
 
I like the idea in principle. I think most of the problems people have with it can be resolved by only having the negative reinforcement (too high a level and you gain less XP) and not the positive reinforcement (too low a level and you get more XP). Although this looks like all stick and no carrot, sometimes it's a stick that's necessary. The problems I see with the positve reinforcement are threefold.

1. As people have pointed out, it's demoralising to see really bad players get rewarded for being bad.

2. Owners of good teams might get repeatedly spammed by low level players to let them on their team 'so they can get more XP'.

3. Owners (especially new ones) of teams in high leagues might be tempted to gut the team and then fill them with their (and their friend's) low level players so they can farm loads of XP.

I also think it is far better to base the XP loss on league average and not opponents. It's a bit unfair penalising XP just because their opponents that week are particularly bad. It's good players playing in bad leagues we want to prevent, not good players playing against bad individual teams.
Last edited Jun 7, 2008 09:08:55
 
dalith
offline
Link
 
This just sounds like a means to power level your friends. There is absolutely no reason for this because you make more XP when you are a lower level than when you are at a higher level.

Why not just come out and say you want to be able to use Flex Points to level your guy as high as you want?
 
Cedo
offline
Link
 
For players against, i hope you will not complain against higher level come to your league and win the championship... That's a way to avoid that. I think is the better idea i heard, not the best because no one seems to be able to find it (or even it exists...)
 
Lightw4re
offline
Link
 
XP Bonus for players who are like 10 hours a day on the game could be nice.
 
Piemaster
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Cedo
For players against, i hope you will not complain against higher level come to your league and win the championship... That's a way to avoid that. I think is the better idea i heard, not the best because no one seems to be able to find it (or even it exists...)


I don't think there is a perfect solution, or somebody would have thought of it by now. It's just a case of finding the best one out of all those that have been thrown out there. This is why Bort is creating all these threads, to see which ideas people can find obvious flaws with, which are good and which might be good with modifications.
 
avgbrad
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by drifter
Originally posted by rbedgood

Originally posted by James1985


I dont like it you punish good team and reward bad ones.

After a few Seasons the best teams will be together threw moving up or down in Leagues.

It will take time just let it do its work.

All players no matter the level the competition or the league should earn XP the same way.

My Vote for XP based on level
100% no


It isn't punishing teams...just players that are completely out of their level. For example if a BBB league had an average level of 10, and signed a player who was level 18, that one player on the team would get less XP than if he'd just signed one level up where the average was 13 or 14.

It makes sense. The rest of his team still gets all their XP, it just lowers the incentive for a Lv18 to sign in a low level league. If he does, the rest of the league (including his teammates) will catch him quicker than they would've without this penalty.

If he wants to stay ahead of lower level players all he has to do is head to the appropriate league level.




THe problem is that there are bad teams at good levels. Based on the "highest level" leagues post the other day, AAA#2 is #4 IIRC with an average level of 14.xx The best teams in the league are more like 18.xx. Why should the best teams in the 4th hardest league in the game be punished because there's so many bad teams in ALL of the leagues that the average level is 14? Unless the leagues are blown up and realigned for more parity, this is an awful idea. If that happens it might have merit.



Totally agree
 
thunderdoozer
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by dalith
This just sounds like a means to power level your friends. There is absolutely no reason for this because you make more XP when you are a lower level than when you are at a higher level.


 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.