User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Forum > Suggestions > Coaches - Item Crafting
Page:
 
Cronus6
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by MTDewJoe
Uh no. This is one of the strangest ideas for a football "sim" I've run across. Maybe players can have mana points so they can cast spells too


It's really not much stranger than the current "magical" equipment system.
... Or the VA system.

The fact that right now (with enough money) I could move 32 points from strength into speed or catching or w/e is pretty damn "magical" imo.
 
pottsman
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Bort

Hm. That is an interesting idea to reward boosters. Basically the coach would have 2 or 3 free boosts if he were high enough level?


Essentially, yes. Meanwhile, it makes it so that the player who doesn't boost (or only boosts from time to time, or became a nonboosting dedicated special teamer) can still be a coach if he goes 440, but just won't be as good of a coach as someone who boosted every season.

The other thing it does, which I'm a big fan of...is it stratifies the first generation of coaches. If all coaches start at level 1, then world league teams will have coaches just as good as peewee teams next season, and similar things for the next few. If a segment of coaches start out at higher levels, though, they'll naturally flow towards pro (where teams need the extra help) and the lower leveled ones will filter towards the cloud. Plus, it will let you see how unbalanced things can get sooner.

The only issue is to figure out just how to award the levels. Most coaches will be starting from player levels over 60, so you can't have the bonus be too big, but you also need some amount of stratification (can't just use "over level 50 +1 level")
 
Link
 
Originally posted by Bort
Ah, that's an interesting take. You can only teach the SA's you learned? It would probably make the +% bonuses more popular.


I think this would be exploited to shit if it doesn't work off a players natural abilities and bonuses from SAs. When a player retires he should have all his AEQ deleted so he doesn't have any bonuses that he didn't really build into his player. Otherwise, agents will be tailoring their player before retirement for EQ crafting. They'll shop for a buffet of AEQ to choose from and then swap around to be able to craft any bonus EQ they want. Somehow you have to be able to lock their player for coaching. I say strip the AEQ, lock shopping, and go from there.

This rewards the players who spent their SP on their SAs. Why should someone who got lucky AEQ shopping be a better coach? There are some players who didn't touch SAs and used 2 or 3 pieces of AEQ to get a cheap 10 in an SA that isn't even part of their positions tree. Or what about the guys who only raised an SA to 4 and used CE and AEQ to get an easy 11. Seems cheesy that they should be a better EQ maker than a guy who actually paid the cost of getting an SA to 10 the hard way.

This would hurt a lot of my players, but it seems more fair. My SS has +break block and +make tackle AEQ, but I don't think he should be able to teach those skills if they are not in his SA tree. I'm sure the +make tackle is in the Wrap Up SA, but the break block should be left up to the LBs and Dline guys to craft.

Edited to add: unless you want them to be able to craft anything. That would make it so your EQ manager can benefit all positions on the team. Who knows, but I don't like the idea of people being able to craft stuff their player never actually used in games.
Edited by notgoing2argue on Sep 5, 2009 18:39:56
 
Tlik
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Jed
Then can coaches take 2 of those items, throw em in the horodric cube to combine em, and put rules in them?


so i'm gonna need to start farming prubies and pamethysts... at least i have time to get a headstart now.


can we re-roll the item after we roll it the first time?
 
DTRAIN
offline
Link
 
Lets add the Owners and Co Owners. Maybe they could have pts to help ticket/concession sales. have it effect how fast the team chem replenishes. also how fast the team recovers its morale. Maybe being in those positions could have a prestige meter. the longer they own a team the more prestige they have. also maybe a total win/loss counter on their id page when in those positions. Head Coach may have the win/loss counter also. Every team could have a win/loss counter as long as the same owner has the team.

 
sportskidd
offline
Link
 
bort aways makes good suggestions
 
BDawk
offline
Link
 
I think the whole thing sounds far-fetched, a coach making equipment. Maybe there could be a sort of implementation of a equipment facility or maybe a coach slot that deals with equipment.
 
crd521
offline
Link
 
If the coach can attain the horadric cube via THIS game somehow, then let em use it, otherwise go play Diablo and let the rest of us work on how to make this good idea work as good as it has the potential to.

Edited by crd521 on Sep 5, 2009 20:25:29
 
Mr. Likable
offline
Link
 
Coaches should only affect that which they were. Like bonuses based off of their abilities, SAs, and VAs. I also think to coach an agent would have to have a player, before they can Coach somewhere.
 
Asdzx2
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Jed
Then can coaches take 2 of those items, throw em in the horodric cube to combine em, and put rules in them?


Im going to Jah my items.
 
vinman
offline
Link
 
Scrap the whole idea,this will be a miserable failure.
 
hoyaboy1
offline
Link
 
This is really cheesy.
 
GosuPho
offline
Link
 
Have some position specific items.
 
ryan_grant-25
offline
Link
 
Bort, please do not add coaching.... i am a loyal customer and addict of your game... but i think this could ruin it, i didnt really like veteran abilities, but it would not make as big of an impact as i expected it to make, but coaching staffs could ruin the game. this game is meant for builds and tactics to be dominant, but coaching will give higher leveled players the advantage again, sure anybody can get coaches.... but i just dont think this needs to be a part of the game, we already have coaches, they are called GM's, if you want, every agent could be given a job for the team and spend their SP's per team... that might work... but players i dont think will work.
 
didymus
offline
Link
 
If this is a legit possibility.......

please include coaches that enhance the +5 game boost bonus.

The other side of the coin.

 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.