User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Forum > Suggestions > Coaches - ideas for them to spend money on (and other ideas)
Page:
 
whitewolf
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Bort
Well, it changes my plan a little, but not entirely, if we make the coach training temporary. The same skills & skill names would apply and work; just would make them temporary bonuses instead of permanent. I'd have to make it limit it to being able to be opened to a certain number of players or something to balance it, though, since it wouldn't take training points anymore. I think the player would have to pay extra cash to use it, too.


You could make a coach specialize in a position or stat. A coach that helps "blocking" is only going to be of interest to certain players. Also, making players pay for the training should be no problem, I know my players all have a lot of cash to burn, especially since the teams they are on pay for equipment.
 
Bort
Admin
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by pottsman
I think he more meant that if a player was on say the Cininati Shockers, retires, he can give a bigger bonus coaching the Shockers than he could to coaching some random team.

And if he wasn't...I am. Small bonus, but something. He knows the locker room, the local fans love him.


Hm...some sort of "remembered" chemistry or something along those lines? Maybe a coach could have a "comfort" bar that fills up over time as he stays with a team, which would limit the amount of points he has to spend or makes skills act if they are lower leveled if it is not full. One of the coaching styles could even make it fill quicker, as a wrinkle.
 
InRomoWeTrust
Lead Mod
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by pottsman
I think he more meant that if a player was on say the Cininati Shockers, retires, he can give a bigger bonus coaching the Shockers than he could to coaching some random team.

And if he wasn't...I am. Small bonus, but something. He knows the locker room, the local fans love him.


Sort of like Wade Phillips hiring Dat Nguyen as a LB's coach. (ib4 who? comment)

He led the Cowboys in tackles for like 3 seasons, but had to retire due to a neck injury. So for the comparison, Dat Nguyen would be "better" than Wade Phillips hiring Bill Romanowski.
Edited by Mat McBriar on Sep 3, 2009 22:31:36
Edited by Mat McBriar on Sep 3, 2009 22:31:23
 
Bort
Admin
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by whitewolf
You could make a coach specialize in a position or stat. A coach that helps "blocking" is only going to be of interest to certain players. Also, making players pay for the training should be no problem, I know my players all have a lot of cash to burn, especially since the teams they are on pay for equipment.


That's basically the idea already. You have to unlock each trainable attribute as a skill, with more trainables requiring higher training or coaching abilities to be able to buy. Training focused coaching styles get a free one to start with, while others have to buy the first with skill points.
 
whitewolf
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by AngryDragon
Originally posted by pottsman

I think he more meant that if a player was on say the Cininati Shockers, retires, he can give a bigger bonus coaching the Shockers than he could to coaching some random team.

And if he wasn't...I am. Small bonus, but something. He knows the locker room, the local fans love him.


yep, that is what I meant.


I like this idea. I've always been a fan of things that promote loyalty, and it would be available equally.

It's also like how I really hope the Patriots sign Bruschi as an LB coach since he just retired. He's a great guy, both in skills and in attitude.
Edited by whitewolf on Sep 3, 2009 22:32:26
 
pottsman
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Bort
Originally posted by pottsman

I think he more meant that if a player was on say the Cininati Shockers, retires, he can give a bigger bonus coaching the Shockers than he could to coaching some random team.

And if he wasn't...I am. Small bonus, but something. He knows the locker room, the local fans love him.


Hm...some sort of "remembered" chemistry or something along those lines? Maybe a coach could have a "comfort" bar that fills up over time as he stays with a team, which would limit the amount of points he has to spend or makes skills act if they are lower leveled if it is not full. One of the coaching styles could even make it fill quicker, as a wrinkle.


I think you're still missing the point we're going for. You love the Blazers, right? How would you feel if the Blazers signed Clyde Drexler as a coach? You'd be happier than if they signed "random other coach". When a coach goes to the team he played for, bonus.
 
Saris
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Bort
I'd have to make it limit it to being able to be opened to a certain number of players or something to balance it, though, since it wouldn't take training points anymore.


That's where a coaching points system or a coaches fund bar might come into play.

For maybe 5% of his seasonal bar, he could hire a medium strength trainer for a specific DT for the remainder of the season. For the rest of the season that DT would have +3 Strength. It could also be possible to hire a shorter term trainer for a player for a cheaper cost, or a Superior Trainer giving say a +5 strength bonus for a steeper cost.

Or rather than trainers and cost it could be called something like Time or Concentration. A coach only has a limited amount of each to devote to so many players.
Edited by Saris on Sep 3, 2009 22:35:15
 
Bort
Admin
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by pottsman
I think you're still missing the point we're going for. You love the Blazers, right? How would you feel if the Blazers signed Clyde Drexler as a coach? You'd be happier than if they signed "random other coach". When a coach goes to the team he played for, bonus.


Ah, well if we had this bar I referred to, hiring a former player as a coach could start it filled up or higher. That might be a good mechanic to simulate that, and encourage loyalty of some sort.
 
AngryDragon
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Bort
Hm...some sort of "remembered" chemistry or something along those lines? Maybe a coach could have a "comfort" bar that fills up over time as he stays with a team, which would limit the amount of points he has to spend or makes skills act if they are lower leveled if it is not full. One of the coaching styles could even make it fill quicker, as a wrinkle.


That is very cool. Could region and/or tier also be added to the comfort bar? That might be way too much but a coach who played in USA his whole career might be more adapted to working in the USA rather than Canada.

I guess it might be hard to gather that much player history since old teams may have gutted or moved to a different region in their past. Maybe if it only gathered data from their last team.
 
Seth4444
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by pottsman
I think you're still missing the point we're going for. You love the Blazers, right? How would you feel if the Blazers signed Clyde Drexler as a coach? You'd be happier than if they signed "random other coach". When a coach goes to the team he played for, bonus.


Potts, I agree with you 500%
 
Link
 
Originally posted by Bort
That's basically the idea already. You have to unlock each trainable attribute as a skill, with more trainables requiring higher training or coaching abilities to be able to buy. Training focused coaching styles get a free one to start with, while others have to buy the first with skill points.


But it can't be permanent--its got to be temporary training gains, or it takes the LONG TERM BUILD out of the agent's hand and places it at the mercy of whatever good/crappy coach they signed with.
 
Bort
Admin
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Saris
That's where a coaching points system or a coaches fund bar might come into play.

For maybe 5% of his seasonal bar, he could hire a medium strength trainer for a specific DT for the remainder of the season. For the rest of the season that DT would have +3 Strength. It could also be possible to hire a shorter term trainer for a player for a cheaper cost, or a Superior Trainer giving say a +5 strength bonus for a steeper cost.


Ok, let's say each coach has a set amount of training points per season.

What if the could assign one of his unlocked trainable options to a particular player by spending some, and it give that guy a +X bonus to whatever the attribute is. Then if he wants to change it to somebody else, it costs him more training points. Eventually he'd run out if he kept changing it around.
 
DavidD458
offline
Link
 
I would give coaches special abilities similar to what players have.

Could include: bonuses to increase to team morale, increase to player stamina, increase to player confidence, increase to players vision, increase to franchise cash / fan support.

I think a coach should have a bonus to either offense, defense, or special teams, depending on which position he played. Additionally, I wouldn't add a smaller bonus to the actual position he played, like SS or FS or QB or WR. Reason being is, if you're more advantaged to have a CB coach than a K, no one would sign a kicker as a coach.
 
jearly
offline
Link
 
For those of you who don't want a coach to affect training or in-game performance: what the hell is a coach to do? Training players and coaching them in game is exactly what a coach does.

I agree that a coach shouldn't make a player get magically faster for one game, that coach could point something out in the opponent's offense/defense that improves the player's playmaking (e.g boost to vision/stamina/confidence).

yeah, signing with a bad coach hinders you, but it no way hinders your long-term build. most people only sign 1 season contracts anyway because a bad owner could affect your build (you get benched and lose as season of xp).

Having good/bad coaches actually enhances a team's ability recruit. A great way to turn around a crappy team would be to go and hire the best coaches out there.
 
WalterManning
offline
Link
 
I would think that if your using game money for this position it should be high enough that team can not just give a coach x number of funds so that they can unlock whatever needs to be unlocked. All prices should be so high it would take a coach some time to get what ever it is they can get. Give a pay scale for this position so that it can not be abused. Have it connected to the team some how so that if a team does give this position x number of funds they could have a penalty put against them during x number of games. Would have to be a high one just for the abuse that this might cause.
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.