User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Forum > Suggestions > Opponent Scouting Page - need ideas
Page:
 
yello1
Preacher
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by feedy
any chance you could get it throw out the blowout games? I'd really hate to have skewed stats


Yeah, this would be key.
 
yello1
Preacher
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by butler312
But why does it matter if you know the splits by player if you can't change your defense based on which player is in the game? On defense you have to gameplan around the HB position as whole. You kind of have to treat it as if both HBs are just 1 HB combined together. Unless you are going to gamble and hope that a specific HB is in the game at a specific time. Because if you set your defense up to defend one and the other is in the game you are just really screwed.


Because you CAN adjust to the situations that player is being used in.

If you know his speedy back is the one being used mostly in the Red Zone, or his Bulky Back is the one being used in 3rd and Short, and neither one of them is being used in 3rd and long, then you can set up your defensive player selections (MLB1, 2, LOLB1, 2 etc) accordingly.

Same same his running or blocking FB, or his blocking v receiving TE etc etc.

Now this is all stuff you can do from films of course. But to have it boiled down on the scouting page - or at least to let your scouts enter what they find here like this, would be helpful.
 
butler312
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by yello1
Because you CAN adjust to the situations that player is being used in.

If you know his speedy back is the one being used mostly in the Red Zone, or his Bulky Back is the one being used in 3rd and Short, and neither one of them is being used in 3rd and long, then you can set up your defensive player selections (MLB1, 2, LOLB1, 2 etc) accordingly.

Same same his running or blocking FB, or his blocking v receiving TE etc etc.

Now this is all stuff you can do from films of course. But to have it boiled down on the scouting page - or at least to let your scouts enter what they find here like this, would be helpful.


So wouldn't it be much more useful just to stick to the reports of the team in the red zone, or on 3rd and short, or 3rd and long, or any of other situations. Again, no need to break it down by player.
 
pottsman
offline
Link
 
This can not be overpowered. There are so many ideas on here that will turn this into an auto-scout. Bort, please, make us actually do some work on our own, no matter what. If you take all the effort out of scouting, then there will be less of a gap between those who are good and put effort into it, and those who do nothing.
 
BP
offline
Link
 
The Greasemonkey scouting programs out there are fine for the most part and don't need to be recreated on the site. For Example, The new replay thing you have going on is actually worse then the Script that we all had and now can't use, cuz it doesn't have the "Next Possession" button.

If you need to add something in there I'd suggest being able to tag replays and then on your Offensive/Defense AI and then also your custom D creator tabs, being able to pull those up there and have a small screen that's running the replay at a decent speed over and over again.

In the Defensive creator you should be able to import that play and have it running as a background underneath the play you are making, so that you you get your spacing right.

In your OAI and DAI...be able to reference the play by important a small window that runs the play you are scouting against over and over so you can call the right plays.

That would be a next logical step.

Being able to tag players would be cool...I'm assuming that you Tag

Joe Williams WR

and then on your depth chart you could have a custom tab just for the guys you tagged and a depth chart to cover them? Like Joe Williams is a fast stud, so you have your depth chart with just your fastest 2 CB's to cover him..no matter where he lines up? That'd be pretty tight.
Edited by BP on Aug 12, 2009 13:43:31
 
Valhalla
offline
Link
 
Given that I would assume with DPC plays that most people will still have a need to watch the replays, the ability to filter or re-sort the replays by formation, down and distance would be great.
 
yello1
Preacher
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by butler312
So wouldn't it be much more useful just to stick to the reports of the team in the red zone, or on 3rd and short, or 3rd and long, or any of other situations. Again, no need to break it down by player.


Sigh.

Knowing that they do plays X and Y and Z in a situation is useful. That tells you what SETS to use against it.

Knowing that they do it with their Stud Player X is ADDITIONALLY useful, because it tells you what PERSONNEL to use against it.

BOTH are useful. One does not replace the other.
 
yello1
Preacher
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by pottsman
This can not be overpowered. There are so many ideas on here that will turn this into an auto-scout. Bort, please, make us actually do some work on our own, no matter what. If you take all the effort out of scouting, then there will be less of a gap between those who are good and put effort into it, and those who do nothing.


Why is it that making a game hard is seen as such a virtue?

Usually its seen as a limitation on a game. Something that detracts from its appeal. That reduces the number of customers and therefore revenue.

Having to go to the Scouting page and figure out what it means would be work enough.

Requiring players to spend 20 hours going over films every two days to scout the next game is flipping insane.

And in case you were wondering, Insane is NOT a desirable game feature.

Not that I am entirely opposed to leaving something in the tank for the workaholic to do. But that is not a reason to make the game an arcane niche for those without jobs or social interactions.
Edited by yello1 on Aug 12, 2009 14:12:44
 
The Big House
offline
Link
 
How about a way to see like, their trade history and see who they signed also? I know there already is a tab devoted to it, but i could a section that says who they traded who in their past seasons, and who they have signed the past years and also who they have released?
 
Link
 
Originally posted by yello1


Or alternatively you could just have a complete listing of the plays he has carried the ball on like his

Joe HB
Breakdown of Touches
40% HB Sweep
39% HB Slam
20% Off Tackle
1% HB Screen





There needs to be some form of actual scouting to go on. You shouldn't be able to have the ingame scout do all the work for you. It should only give you the tools to make it easier without giving you all the information.
I'm a big fan of having to put effort into a team and I like my GM's that show this as well. I don't like GM's that just run a script and go by that without actually breaking down the film their selves.

 
Link
 
Originally posted by pottsman
This can not be overpowered. There are so many ideas on here that will turn this into an auto-scout. Bort, please, make us actually do some work on our own, no matter what. If you take all the effort out of scouting, then there will be less of a gap between those who are good and put effort into it, and those who do nothing.


This 100 fold tbh.
 
Mightyhalo
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by driftinggrifter
There needs to be some form of actual scouting to go on. You shouldn't be able to have the ingame scout do all the work for you. It should only give you the tools to make it easier without giving you all the information.
I'm a big fan of having to put effort into a team and I like my GM's that show this as well. I don't like GM's that just run a script and go by that without actually breaking down the film their selves.



Well if it gets this in depth without actually having to do anything other than hit a button, then I probably won't like it much. If it was interactive and forced the DC/OC to still use a scouting program that Bort installs where they have to ask for certain things, then it wouldn't be as bad.



 
Link
 
Originally posted by Mightyhalo
Originally posted by driftinggrifter

There needs to be some form of actual scouting to go on. You shouldn't be able to have the ingame scout do all the work for you. It should only give you the tools to make it easier without giving you all the information.
I'm a big fan of having to put effort into a team and I like my GM's that show this as well. I don't like GM's that just run a script and go by that without actually breaking down the film their selves.



Well if it gets this in depth without actually having to do anything other than hit a button, then I probably won't like it much. If it was interactive and forced the DC/OC to still use a scouting program that Bort installs where they have to ask for certain things, then it wouldn't be as bad.






P/Much
Anybody can read but only good GM's can breakdown gametape and discern what it is. Only dedicated GM's can give the time to help mold your team identity. Those are the Gm's I want and the one I try to be.
I don't want to be able to whipp a gameplan together in 5 mins. there is no skill in that.
 
Mightyhalo
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by driftinggrifter

P/Much
Anybody can read but only good GM's can breakdown gametape and discern what it is. Only dedicated GM's can give the time to help mold your team identity. Those are the Gm's I want and the one I try to be.
I don't want to be able to whipp a gameplan together in 5 mins. there is no skill in that.


Agreed.
 
DeadKennedys
offline
Link
 
Show their favored running and passing direction: Left, Middle or Right?
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.