User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Forum > Goal Line Blitz > Demotion Ideas for the WPL
Page:
 
Link
 
Originally posted by turnit643
Originally posted by Zoblefu

Originally posted by turnit643

Originally posted by Zoblefu



Keep it simple

Top 1 from each conference goes up each year. Top 2 this season only.

Keep always 2 teams per conference in pro league. This means one gets demoted every year, even if it was 2nd place and the other was first.

This way you ALWAYS promote the winners, and you just really compete against the others from your conference to "stay" in the world league. You can request demotion if you want however (if you would normally stay) and get another team to come up from your league.


Why, in a World League, would you just want teams to compete with only teams from their old region to stay? It's a World League, no?


You're still competing against everyone for bragging rights about who is best, but the world league (this way) will always contain the best 2 teams a league has to offer. It gives fair representation to all leagues, and has no problems with promotion/demotion, so it seems like the easiest way.

But as you bolded and pointed out, if you want to STAY in the world league you need to be the best team from your league, period. If you aren't the best from your league, then the next season the pro champion will get a chance to see if they're the best from their league, etc.


Same problem as discussed in the other one above. Say OPL's 4 teams dominate in the first season of the WL, all four make the Final Four of the WL. Two of them have to leave? When all four of the USAPL's failed to even make the playoffs and only two of them have to leave?


The way to fix this is:
Once you make the WPL you lose your league identity. You are in the WPL. If you don't make the playoffs you get demoted to random regions (no choice). You are in the WPL and maybe thats the price you pay for being demoted. Its the only way to make this thing work out fair tbh. Maybe bort gives demoted teams an "options" list so he can do the best possible but when it comes down to it you probably can't have your WPL cake and eat it too.
Edited by ImTheScientist on Jul 27, 2009 18:54:27
 
the man of doom
Miracles happen
offline
Link
 
where did my +1 go to?
 
PackMan97
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Bort
Let's say the following happens:

We end up with 16 teams from one region in the WPL. For whatever reason, they all start to suck suck, or most of them suck at the same time, and they all miss the playoffs. Now we have to send down 16 teams to the same region, and demote an additional 14 teams. Unlikely scenario, but it would suck.


Yes, it would. That's the devil's deal that every league would make. If you are over represented in the World League and they all start to suck at the same time, dealing with that is gonna hurt.
 
Zoblefu
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by turnit643
Originally posted by Zoblefu

Originally posted by turnit643

Originally posted by Zoblefu



Keep it simple

Top 1 from each conference goes up each year. Top 2 this season only.

Keep always 2 teams per conference in pro league. This means one gets demoted every year, even if it was 2nd place and the other was first.

This way you ALWAYS promote the winners, and you just really compete against the others from your conference to "stay" in the world league. You can request demotion if you want however (if you would normally stay) and get another team to come up from your league.


Why, in a World League, would you just want teams to compete with only teams from their old region to stay? It's a World League, no?


You're still competing against everyone for bragging rights about who is best, but the world league (this way) will always contain the best 2 teams a league has to offer. It gives fair representation to all leagues, and has no problems with promotion/demotion, so it seems like the easiest way.

But as you bolded and pointed out, if you want to STAY in the world league you need to be the best team from your league, period. If you aren't the best from your league, then the next season the pro champion will get a chance to see if they're the best from their league, etc.


Same problem as discussed in the other one above. Say OPL's 4 teams dominate in the first season of the WL, all four make the Final Four of the WL. Two of them have to leave? When all four of the USAPL's failed to even make the playoffs and only two of them have to leave?


Yes, exactly. Best teams from each league stay, even if it means a playoff team has to go and a 13th place team gets to stay. It gives the world league an equal distribution always from the leagues, and makes promotion/demotion simple.

I'm going for KEEP IT SIMPLE
Edited by Zoblefu on Jul 27, 2009 18:55:48
Edited by Zoblefu on Jul 27, 2009 18:55:37
 
ICRockets
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by FairForever
Originally posted by ICRockets

Originally posted by FairForever


Originally posted by ICRockets



Originally posted by Bort




Added to OP.

Caveats:

- Special treatment cannot be given to a certain region or regions, just because some people think that region is better. Biases should be determined by stats, wins, losses alone.
- Think long term. Encouraging the regions to even out as far as talent is a GOOD thing.
- Team owners would prefer to go back to the region they came from. If we can make that happen, it is best.


My idea accomodates all of that.

2 demoted teams go to each region every year. There's no "We need to push an extra team down a rung to fill it out right". The BEST demoted teams are likely to get their LAST choice of region, thus ensuring that the most competitive teams are going to the most competitive leagues unless other teams specifically request to do so. AND I have a safeguard against frequent demotees going to the same league over and over and dominating outclassed competition.


That's a horrible system. The best demoted teams should have first choice.

Your system ensures that there will always be imbalances in the Pro League.


So what happens if the best demoted team decides he wants to go to OPL? Say we're talking about Bonn Dynamo. They rocked WEPL, did well in Worlds, but fell just short of the playoffs. But they were close, and feel that if they get back to the World League, they can make it happen this time. All they have to do is get back. So naturally they're going to choose the WEAKEST league possible to be demoted into, so they have the easiest road back to the World Pro League where they feel they belong.

You really think the best option is to FACILIATE THAT?!


Well, to be fair, your overall system is pretty dumb. But I'll play along.

1) End-of-season tankfest. Two 0-14 teams, let's see who can throw the game to get a better choice of leagues!

2) Punishing good teams. Why should a 9th place team have a harder time getting back into WPL than a 14th place team?

Answer those.

3) OPL Inferiority. The weakest team joins the weakest league. The league will never get any better. Bort is trying to have long-run parity in league strength. This goes against that directly.


You're missing another major component of my plan. It's not an automatic 'Here's how Bort ranks the leagues now...so the worst teams in WPL go to the worst Pro region' kind of thing. The assumption is that most teams will set up their preference ranking to return to their original league, and that wherever possible this is the ideal scenario when teams are demoted.

However, it's not a 100% clean system, and we're going to run into situations where certain teams aren't going to get their first choice, whatever it is.

Look, if a SEAPL team finishes last in the WPL, odds are they're going to want to go back to SEAPL. If an APL team finishes last in the WPL, odds are they're going to want to go back to APL. By focusing on the teams that finish LAST and going up the ladder from there, you're going to get the most teams filing back to their original league. But if we turn it around, and let the 9th or 10th best team from a given conference in WPL get THEIR first choice, they're obviously going to choose the path of least resistance in anticipation of getting back to WPL.
 
the man of doom
Miracles happen
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by crazy454
Originally posted by Joebarber

Originally posted by Havoc


[

If you promote 2 teams from each Pro league you will have to demote half of the WPL each season (dont you think that is a lot?)... why not just promote the league champion from each region and demote only 8 of the 32 teams...


Do it like European soccer.

8 Pro champs auto promote and replace the bottom 8 WPL teams.

8 Pro runner ups play an additional playoff game against WPL teams #17-24. Winner plays in WPL the next season.

I really like this plan tbh


+1


+1
works IRL

should be fine here right?
 
lukin83
offline
Link
 
1. You initially promote the top 4 from each region's pro league.

2. You divide the WL into divisions based on region (APL, USAPL, CPL, EEPL, WEPL, OPL, SAPL, and SEAPL) and set it up similar to the NFL playoffs (division winners and 4 wild cards get in from each conference).

3. The bottom 2 teams in each division after the first season relegate back to their respective region.

4. The two conference champions from each pro league then promote to the PL.


Seems simple. No one loses their regional affiliation and the top teams get to stay in WPL where they belong. The only downside I can see is that it does not guarantee you stay in the same conference when relegating, but at least everyone gets to stay in the same region.
 
kwankwan
offline
Link
 
Is the idea with the WL that you play teams from all around the world, or the BEST in the world... It would be great to know the theory behind all this.. would make the decisions a lot easier.

A playoff game with the worst of the best (#2 region team in WL) vs. the best of the worst (winner of the PRO conference game). Winner gets in the WL..
 
Galkuris
offline
Link
 
I'm thinking one of the best things for the future of GLB would cause the most crying now.

USA AAA1 teams that go Pro and get demoted have a 50-50 shot of going back to USA AAA1. Do the same for the WL.

Teams would get over it. You got demoted so why does it matter to where? If we want true parity then it should not matter where you end up demoting to.
 
Link
 
Originally posted by lukin83
1. You initially promote the top 4 from each region's pro league.

2. You divide the WL into divisions based on region (APL, USAPL, CPL, EEPL, WEPL, OPL, SAPL, and SEAPL) and set it up similar to the NFL playoffs (division winners and 4 wild cards get in from each conference).

3. The bottom 2 teams in each division after the first season relegate back to their respective region.

4. The two conference champions from each pro league then promote to the PL.


Seems simple. No one loses their regional affiliation and the top teams get to stay in WPL where they belong. The only downside I can see is that it does not guarantee you stay in the same conference when relegating, but at least everyone gets to stay in the same region.


ETA: Don't like
Edited by ImTheScientist on Jul 27, 2009 19:00:47
 
kwankwan
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by lukin83
1. You initially promote the top 4 from each region's pro league.

2. You divide the WL into divisions based on region (APL, USAPL, CPL, EEPL, WEPL, OPL, SAPL, and SEAPL) and set it up similar to the NFL playoffs (division winners and 4 wild cards get in from each conference).

3. The bottom 2 teams in each division after the first season relegate back to their respective region.

4. The two conference champions from each pro league then promote to the PL.


Seems simple. No one loses their regional affiliation and the top teams get to stay in WPL where they belong. The only downside I can see is that it does not guarantee you stay in the same conference when relegating, but at least everyone gets to stay in the same region.


This is NOT a bad idea.
 
FairForever
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by ICRockets
Originally posted by FairForever

Originally posted by ICRockets


Originally posted by FairForever



Originally posted by ICRockets




Originally posted by Bort





Added to OP.

Caveats:

- Special treatment cannot be given to a certain region or regions, just because some people think that region is better. Biases should be determined by stats, wins, losses alone.
- Think long term. Encouraging the regions to even out as far as talent is a GOOD thing.
- Team owners would prefer to go back to the region they came from. If we can make that happen, it is best.


My idea accomodates all of that.

2 demoted teams go to each region every year. There's no "We need to push an extra team down a rung to fill it out right". The BEST demoted teams are likely to get their LAST choice of region, thus ensuring that the most competitive teams are going to the most competitive leagues unless other teams specifically request to do so. AND I have a safeguard against frequent demotees going to the same league over and over and dominating outclassed competition.


That's a horrible system. The best demoted teams should have first choice.

Your system ensures that there will always be imbalances in the Pro League.


So what happens if the best demoted team decides he wants to go to OPL? Say we're talking about Bonn Dynamo. They rocked WEPL, did well in Worlds, but fell just short of the playoffs. But they were close, and feel that if they get back to the World League, they can make it happen this time. All they have to do is get back. So naturally they're going to choose the WEAKEST league possible to be demoted into, so they have the easiest road back to the World Pro League where they feel they belong.

You really think the best option is to FACILIATE THAT?!


Well, to be fair, your overall system is pretty dumb. But I'll play along.

1) End-of-season tankfest. Two 0-14 teams, let's see who can throw the game to get a better choice of leagues!

2) Punishing good teams. Why should a 9th place team have a harder time getting back into WPL than a 14th place team?

Answer those.

3) OPL Inferiority. The weakest team joins the weakest league. The league will never get any better. Bort is trying to have long-run parity in league strength. This goes against that directly.


You're missing another major component of my plan. It's not an automatic 'Here's how Bort ranks the leagues now...so the worst teams in WPL go to the worst Pro region' kind of thing. The assumption is that most teams will set up their preference ranking to return to their original league, and that wherever possible this is the ideal scenario when teams are demoted.

However, it's not a 100% clean system, and we're going to run into situations where certain teams aren't going to get their first choice, whatever it is.

Look, if a SEAPL team finishes last in the WPL, odds are they're going to want to go back to SEAPL. If an APL team finishes last in the WPL, odds are they're going to want to go back to APL. By focusing on the teams that finish LAST and going up the ladder from there, you're going to get the most teams filing back to their original league. But if we turn it around, and let the 9th or 10th best team from a given conference in WPL get THEIR first choice, they're obviously going to choose the path of least resistance in anticipation of getting back to WPL.


You're making a huge assumption though. What if a CPL team finishes last? Now, going to CPL means probably not making WPL again. So they pick SEAPL. Etc. etc.

You're making a huge assumption that the worst leagues are going to finish 13-14-15-16. If this doesn't happen, your plan falls apart. And of course, it doesn't address the teams getting relegated from a conference are 2x OPL, 2x APL, 2x SEAPL, 2x EEPL... now what? Half still don't go to their own conferences (at best)

And you didn't address any of my points either. Definitely not #1.
Edited by FairForever on Jul 27, 2009 18:58:51
 
jamz
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by kwankwan
Originally posted by lukin83

1. You initially promote the top 4 from each region's pro league.

2. You divide the WL into divisions based on region (APL, USAPL, CPL, EEPL, WEPL, OPL, SAPL, and SEAPL) and set it up similar to the NFL playoffs (division winners and 4 wild cards get in from each conference).

3. The bottom 2 teams in each division after the first season relegate back to their respective region.

4. The two conference champions from each pro league then promote to the PL.


Seems simple. No one loses their regional affiliation and the top teams get to stay in WPL where they belong. The only downside I can see is that it does not guarantee you stay in the same conference when relegating, but at least everyone gets to stay in the same region.


This is NOT a bad idea.


Do not want.
 
The Lurker
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by lukin83
1. You initially promote the top 4 from each region's pro league.

2. You divide the WL into divisions based on region (APL, USAPL, CPL, EEPL, WEPL, OPL, SAPL, and SEAPL) and set it up similar to the NFL playoffs (division winners and 4 wild cards get in from each conference).

3. The bottom 2 teams in each division after the first season relegate back to their respective region.

4. The two conference champions from each pro league then promote to the PL.


Seems simple. No one loses their regional affiliation and the top teams get to stay in WPL where they belong. The only downside I can see is that it does not guarantee you stay in the same conference when relegating, but at least everyone gets to stay in the same region.


Best way to do it if you want to ensure equal league representation.
 
Saris
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Galkuris
I'm thinking one of the best things for the future of GLB would cause the most crying now.

USA AAA1 teams that go Pro and get demoted have a 50-50 shot of going back to USA AAA1. Do the same for the WL.

Teams would get over it. You got demoted so why does it matter to where? If we want true parity then it should not matter where you end up demoting to.


I agree Galk random demotion elliminates the most roadblocks and solves the most problems.
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.