User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Page:
 
jdros13
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by fallingmercury
Originally posted by tdm13

Originally posted by Hikariu


Originally posted by cdcollins



Originally posted by islander1




Originally posted by tdm13





So you don't think that maybe, in those instances, the OT and G failed their snap vision check while the DE fired FS and TV at once, propelling him off the line and leaving your OT and G in the dust?

Couldn't possibly happen!


Not when the RDE is lining up ahead of the other linemen at the LOS. It is not humanly possible for a lineman, regardless of ability, to run through two guys right next to each other unscathed. If you think thats actualyl possible in football, then you're a moron who should cease and desist from posting.


This.




I do think it's possible. and this isn't football, it's dotball. WAY different. In dotball, this can occur and it did. Multiple SAs fired at once and your O-linemen failed vision checks. It's that simple.


IMO you're just saying that the O-line "failed vision checks".

And seriously, if there's a vision check to see where the DE lines up, that's retarded. I mean, the DE lines up in the same 6' space every down and you can see where he's lined up for like 20+ seconds before the play.

Maybe the O-line needs to form a search party?

And damn, there are OTs with 70+ vision getting exploited here. IT'S NOT VISION.... Ugh.


There is obviously a roll to see if First Step fires. I'm assuming the OLine has a similar roll to see if they counter it. I don't know what attributes would come into play there, but I'm guessing Vision and Agility would be 2 of them.
 
SWVAHoo
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Deathblade
Originally posted by cdcollins

It's like saying a Gremlin is better than a Pinto.
And in fact, you were the very one that shouted me down and ridiculed me the most...


Wat?

I barely even posted in S3 lol


I know, back before you were a mod.

But I was having a conversation about 3:00 AM with Bort about RL blocking mechanics, trying to show him how O-linemen have range of motion, which was (and still is) non-existent in GLB. Simply put, they have a blocking radius. Something I know from first-hand experience.

And you jumped in and bashed me with everything you had.

I remember things.
 
jdbolick
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by jdbolick
I think there are a couple of issues at work here. First, even when an offensive lineman "wins" his blocking roll against a defensive lineman and pushes them away, it doesn't do so straight upfield, but rather along the angle of engagement. So if the LG is blocking the RDE at something like 10 o'clock, then shoving the RDE away would just push him to the side, where he would then ping-pong off the LT. Compound that with a change I think I remember Bort making a while back about a delay before blockers can re-engage defenders, and that defensive lineman has a chance to come forward through the gap before he can be blocked again. Lastly, Bort reduced the angle at which offensive linemen can pass block, meaning with just a little more forward progress you're no longer allowed to be blocked. Add all these things up along with the break block burst, and it's not hard to see why these things are happening.

Maybe one potential fix is to have O-line shove directly back upfield instead of along the angle of engagement, and apply something like Bort's April 16th change for run blocking linemen who rotate their bodies to protect the RB to do the same thing in pass blocking for the QB. So basically the LG would try to drop and move to his left more in order to cut off that RDE.

Plausible? Off-base?
 
kurieg
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by DL24
Originally posted by Rage Kinard

Has anyone tested it on the test server using different OT/OG builds against a DE built like TPat's?


It don't matter, it's a full-blown bug. This definitely needs to be fixed.


It's not a bug. It's a consequence of game design.

A bug is an ability designed to give +25% instead giving +100% or more.

When people just blitz the ROLB to tie up the LOT and the DE's continue to own LGs, what will people say then?

 
Rage Kinard
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by jdros13


First Step is the key.


I agree completely.

This was one of the worst boost to an SA idea ever FWIW. It had exploit written all over it from the time Bort decided to have FS make a player accelerate beyond top speed because high agility made FS useless.

 
jamz
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by cdcollins
Originally posted by Deathblade

Originally posted by cdcollins


And some of us were shouted down and ridiculed for suggesting this in Season 3 and 4...


It is better than it was in S3-4 anyway.

At least Guards appear to try and hold their zone, instead of both guards instantly double teaming the NT.


It's like saying a Gremlin is better than a Pinto.
And in fact, you were the very one that shouted me down and ridiculed me the most...



Oh snape!

The allegations against GLB site Moderator Deathblade, are grave.

Questions swirl in the midst of the great GLB scandal of DEs vs Gs.

Will Deathblade retain the services of Malachorn, the Johnny Cochran of GLB Right's laws to work his case, and proclaim his innocence?

Will judge Pallow be not only fair, but swift, and just when he must make the most difficult decision of his reign as GLB's Superior Justice of the Peace, presiding over an offense by one of his own?

Tune in to next week's Episode of As Judge Judy Pallow's Court Turns featuring Donahue, only on the GLB network.
Edited by jamz on Jul 15, 2009 10:51:15
 
tdm13
offline
Link
 
And as a further point, offenses still score LOADS of points, so why can't you throw the D-Line a bone on this one? If D-Line gets a nerf again (or O-Line gets a buff again), this whole community will go insane.

And if you say that my statement isn't true, look at the Drygerian/Cincinnati game. 73-52? LOL. If this is nerfed, people will scream bloody murder and I will gladly lead that charge, no matter how foolish I'll look.
 
SWVAHoo
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by fallingmercury


IMO you're just saying that the O-line "failed vision checks".

And seriously, if there's a vision check to see where the DE lines up, that's retarded. I mean, the DE lines up in the same 6' space every down and you can see where he's lined up for like 20+ seconds before the play.

Maybe the O-line needs to form a search party?

And damn, there are OTs with 70+ vision getting exploited here. IT'S NOT VISION.... Ugh.


QFT.
 
SWVAHoo
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by jamz
Originally posted by cdcollins

Originally posted by Deathblade


Originally posted by cdcollins



And some of us were shouted down and ridiculed for suggesting this in Season 3 and 4...


It is better than it was in S3-4 anyway.

At least Guards appear to try and hold their zone, instead of both guards instantly double teaming the NT.


It's like saying a Gremlin is better than a Pinto.
And in fact, you were the very one that shouted me down and ridiculed me the most...



Oh snape!

The allegations against GLB site Moderator Deathblade, are grave.

Questions swirl in the midst of the great GLB scandal of DEs vs Gs.

Will Deathblade retain the services of Malachorn, the Johnny Cochran of GLB Right's laws to work his case, and proclaim his innocence?

Will judge Pallow be not only fair, but swift, and just when he must make the most difficult decision of his reign as GLB's Superior Justice of the Piece, presiding over an offense by one of his own?

Tune in to next week's Episode of As Judge Judy Pallow's Court Turns featuring Donahue, only on the GLB network.


I LOLed.
 
Deathblade
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by cdcollins
I know, back before you were a mod.

But I was having a conversation about 3:00 AM with Bort about RL blocking mechanics, trying to show him how O-linemen have range of motion, which was (and still is) non-existent in GLB. Simply put, they have a blocking radius. Something I know from first-hand experience.

And you jumped in and bashed me with everything you had.

I remember things.


p sure you are probably remembering someone else
 
SWVAHoo
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Deathblade
Originally posted by cdcollins

I know, back before you were a mod.

But I was having a conversation about 3:00 AM with Bort about RL blocking mechanics, trying to show him how O-linemen have range of motion, which was (and still is) non-existent in GLB. Simply put, they have a blocking radius. Something I know from first-hand experience.

And you jumped in and bashed me with everything you had.

I remember things.


p sure you are probably remembering someone else


I'm positive, TBH.
 
TxSteve
Not A Mod
offline
Link
 
just go find the posts in question - then you guys can settle this once and for all!


 
tdm13
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by cdcollins
Originally posted by fallingmercury



IMO you're just saying that the O-line "failed vision checks".

And seriously, if there's a vision check to see where the DE lines up, that's retarded. I mean, the DE lines up in the same 6' space every down and you can see where he's lined up for like 20+ seconds before the play.

Maybe the O-line needs to form a search party?

And damn, there are OTs with 70+ vision getting exploited here. IT'S NOT VISION.... Ugh.


QFT.


It is vision. The O-line has to pass a check to defend against FS/TV firing. If your vision check is failed, you are at a disadvantage. FS/TV/vision pass vs vision fail leads to this "bug".
 
Deathblade
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by cdcollins
I'm positive, TBH.


Well, it would be kind of retarded since I supported having the O-line fixed, and blasting you for suggesting to fix them. (hell, I even photoshopped images to kind of show the "blocking radius" that you are speaking of)
 
tdm13
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by tdm13
And as a further point, offenses still score LOADS of points, so why can't you throw the D-Line a bone on this one? If D-Line gets a nerf again (or O-Line gets a buff again), this whole community will go insane.

And if you say that my statement isn't true, look at the Drygerian/Cincinnati game. 73-52? LOL. If this is nerfed, people will scream bloody murder and I will gladly lead that charge, no matter how foolish I'll look.


 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.