User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Forum > Goal Line Blitz > Is anything being done about the teams with players way over their cap?
Page:
 
oronis
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Ronnie Brown 23
I don't even understand why we have caps if there's going to be level 38 players in 24 cap leagues. Go back to the old system if the new system has huge loopholes.


In a 16 cap league I played vs lvl 40+ players and my team still won. Levels don't mean everything...
 
merenoise
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by jmsne
I am not trying to be a whiner here. I just want a fair playing field, I have no problem facing the teams that belong in this league ie the teams that are within the 34 cap. I do have a problem with a team with 7 40+ guys on it playing in this league. I don't know if I can beat them or not, I don't care if I can.. its not the point. The point is they should be playing in a league more fitting their level rather then circumventing the rules to try and get a cheap trophy whether they can get it or not...


No such thing as a fair playing field when you are talking about this game for the following reasons:

1. Some people have fantastic scouting scripts that other teams don't have access to.
2. Some people have coordinators who have a near total understanding of how to OC/DC.
3. Some people build better players than others.
4. Some people have more time to devote to the game than others.

All removing players over the cap would do is increase the divide between the people who have 1-4 and the people who don't. I'm assuming that your team is heavily stocked on items 2-4 and possibly have access to 1. Should you have to give up all of those things in the interest of fair play?
 
dpell
offline
Link
 
The problem plain and simple is that Bort said he would force the removal of everyone over the level cap. He didn't before the postseason started and now teams were able to sign guys in the lower leagues who were then able to boost. (I have a couple on my lvl 21 capped team who boosted past 21). Now if he puts in such a script he screws over the guys who played by the rules. If he doesn't he screws a lot more people.

It would seem he could write a script to look at sign date and boost date, but then the offseason would go into July.
 
Link
 
Originally posted by cowcards
Enforcing a cap would be freakin sweet.


This. Bort/admins, please do your job.
 
Link
 
Originally posted by oronis
Originally posted by Ronnie Brown 23

I don't even understand why we have caps if there's going to be level 38 players in 24 cap leagues. Go back to the old system if the new system has huge loopholes.


In a 16 cap league I played vs lvl 40+ players and my team still won. Levels don't mean everything...


True, unless your opponents aren't mentally handicapped. Then levels mean a lot, especially when you factor in how powerful some VAs are.
 
dpell
offline
Link
 
Btw, the position matters A LOT. A lvl 47 FS or TE can be overcome, a lvl 47 HB in a lvl 21 cap league is obscene. A few seasons ago we had one in a league I was in and he was scoring 4+ TD's a game just on returns. Then another 5-8 rushing while breaking 30+ tackles before cruise control kicked in.
 
Buxx
offline
Link
 
-2% to all stats per level over the cap .. thatl fix that shit
 
Splitdragon
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by oronis
Originally posted by Ronnie Brown 23

I don't even understand why we have caps if there's going to be level 38 players in 24 cap leagues. Go back to the old system if the new system has huge loopholes.


In a 16 cap league I played vs lvl 40+ players and my team still won. Levels don't mean everything...


what shitty lvl 40 players did you play against.
 
HoyaHater
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by merenoise
No such thing as a fair playing field when you are talking about this game for the following reasons:

1. Some people have fantastic scouting scripts that other teams don't have access to.
2. Some people have coordinators who have a near total understanding of how to OC/DC.
3. Some people build better players than others.
4. Some people have more time to devote to the game than others.

All removing players over the cap would do is increase the divide between the people who have 1-4 and the people who don't. I'm assuming that your team is heavily stocked on items 2-4 and possibly have access to 1. Should you have to give up all of those things in the interest of fair play?


No, because everyone in the league has reasonable, legitimate access to all those things. If they choose not to use them (e.g. #4) or are too stupid to know how to (e.g. #1), that is on them, not Bort.

But other teams in a 34-cap league do not have access to level 47 free safeties. There is no LEGITIMATE way to acquire them. That is patently unfair, and Bort is on record saying it would not be condoned -- and yet, here it is being condoned.

Originally posted by dpell
The problem plain and simple is that Bort said he would force the removal of everyone over the level cap. He didn't before the postseason started and now teams were able to sign guys in the lower leagues who were then able to boost. (I have a couple on my lvl 21 capped team who boosted past 21). Now if he puts in such a script he screws over the guys who played by the rules. If he doesn't he screws a lot more people.

It would seem he could write a script to look at sign date and boost date, but then the offseason would go into July.


There's nothing wrong with sign-and-boost. It is a widely used and legitimate tactic. All you have to do is set the script to look for players more than a few levels above the cap. A lv 47 is "more than a few levels" above a 34-cap. A 36 or 37 would be fine.
 
jmsne
offline
Link
 
You could set the script to boot people 5 levels or more over the cap and I wouldn't have a problem. I just want some enforcement of it because teams getting to keep 7 players 6+ levels over the cap is immensely gay and needs to be stopped.

Here is my reaction to the 1-4 stuff.

1. If they don't or do that is up to each individual team and their coordinators and owners. Bort in no way enforces script caps.
2. If your coordinators suck, go get new ones or learn how to do it yourself. Bort in no way enforces a no changing GMs or learning the AI rule.
3. If you build shitty players, get a build advisor I do that myself for two teams and there are lots of people out there willing to do it. Bort does not make rules on how you can allot your SPs
4. If you don't have enough time to play the game and compete on the level you want and at a fair level switch to casual leagues. The time required there is much less. Bort makes no restrictions on the amount of time you spend on the game.

5. If you have players 5+ levels of the cap.. Well no one else can go out and sign players to "catch up" Bort restricts my access to signing higher level players. Everything else being equal that is the only true disadvantage out there. I love it when people bring up builds > levels. My team is built on builds > levels. I follow the rules and I expect every other team in every league to do so. If you dont want to follow the rules don't play the game.
 
Doug_Plank
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Buxx
-2% to all stats per level over the cap .. thatl



 
Outlaw Dogs
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by oronis
Originally posted by Ronnie Brown 23

I don't even understand why we have caps if there's going to be level 38 players in 24 cap leagues. Go back to the old system if the new system has huge loopholes.


In a 16 cap league I played vs lvl 40+ players and my team still won. Levels don't mean everything...


Their are always exceptions to every rule, and just because you beat a team with lvl 40s doesn't mean that every team has a bunch of crappy of lvl 40s. If what Bort wants is to be in place he needs to have hard caps at the Min & max side.
 
jamz
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Blamo
Originally posted by Firenze

Originally posted by jmsne


Is anything being done about the teams with players way over their cap?


Nope.


Bort posted a thread in one of the team forums I'm a part of and basically said wtfmate and made them cut two of their high leveled players. One of them was just signed three days ago, so Bort even went ahead and cut him manually at the teams request. And the team was technically still within the median level range even with the high leveled players.


If you make Bort's watch list, and don't comply... bad things happen man, very bad things.

Something like, having your whole team turned into DEs...
 
cowcards
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by merenoise
Originally posted by jmsne

I am not trying to be a whiner here. I just want a fair playing field, I have no problem facing the teams that belong in this league ie the teams that are within the 34 cap. I do have a problem with a team with 7 40+ guys on it playing in this league. I don't know if I can beat them or not, I don't care if I can.. its not the point. The point is they should be playing in a league more fitting their level rather then circumventing the rules to try and get a cheap trophy whether they can get it or not...


No such thing as a fair playing field when you are talking about this game for the following reasons:

1. Some people have fantastic scouting scripts that other teams don't have access to.
2. Some people have coordinators who have a near total understanding of how to OC/DC.
3. Some people build better players than others.
4. Some people have more time to devote to the game than others.

All removing players over the cap would do is increase the divide between the people who have 1-4 and the people who don't. I'm assuming that your team is heavily stocked on items 2-4 and possibly have access to 1. Should you have to give up all of those things in the interest of fair play?


That is absurd. Everyone has the ability to get or have any of these. 1-4 is what seperates the good players from the bad ones. Not everyone has access to being able to have guys 4+ levels over the caps. That is unfair.
 
WolfbattXIX
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Outlaw Dogs
Originally posted by oronis

Originally posted by Ronnie Brown 23


I don't even understand why we have caps if there's going to be level 38 players in 24 cap leagues. Go back to the old system if the new system has huge loopholes.


In a 16 cap league I played vs lvl 40+ players and my team still won. Levels don't mean everything...


Their are always exceptions to every rule, and just because you beat a team with lvl 40s doesn't mean that every team has a bunch of crappy of lvl 40s. If what Bort wants is to be in place he needs to have hard caps at the Min & max side.


How do you cap the backend? (Get you minds out of the gutter, I am being serious)

I mean I have a team that is in an uncapped league. We were put their based on our record in BBB last season. All of our players were FA on day 41 and we are now mostly level 3s and CPU level 1 players.

So if you are bottom capping what do you do about gutting or Teams like mine that are moved up. Now mind you, being in BBB last season we were not given a choice of where we wanted to end up. We were just assigned.
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.