Originally posted by merenoise
No such thing as a fair playing field when you are talking about this game for the following reasons:
1. Some people have fantastic scouting scripts that other teams don't have access to.
2. Some people have coordinators who have a near total understanding of how to OC/DC.
3. Some people build better players than others.
4. Some people have more time to devote to the game than others.
All removing players over the cap would do is increase the divide between the people who have 1-4 and the people who don't. I'm assuming that your team is heavily stocked on items 2-4 and possibly have access to 1. Should you have to give up all of those things in the interest of fair play?
No, because everyone in the league has reasonable, legitimate access to all those things. If they choose not to use them (e.g. #4) or are too stupid to know how to (e.g. #1), that is on them, not Bort.
But other teams in a 34-cap league do not have access to level 47 free safeties. There is no LEGITIMATE way to acquire them. That is patently unfair, and Bort is on record saying it would not be condoned -- and yet, here it is being condoned.
Originally posted by dpell
The problem plain and simple is that Bort said he would force the removal of everyone over the level cap. He didn't before the postseason started and now teams were able to sign guys in the lower leagues who were then able to boost. (I have a couple on my lvl 21 capped team who boosted past 21). Now if he puts in such a script he screws over the guys who played by the rules. If he doesn't he screws a lot more people.
It would seem he could write a script to look at sign date and boost date, but then the offseason would go into July.
There's nothing wrong with sign-and-boost. It is a widely used and legitimate tactic. All you have to do is set the script to look for players more than a few levels above the cap. A lv 47 is "more than a few levels" above a 34-cap. A 36 or 37 would be fine.