User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Forum > Goal Line Blitz > NERF THE FUMBLES NOW!!!
Page:
 
headsigh
offline
Link
 
afaik, Bort doesn't tend to answer questions about the money side of the game.
 
Bort
Admin
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by dpride59
Teams saw team depth/morale is key, they signed huge rosters, got 10-12 special team only players 3-4 motivational speakers and 45 guys to play o/d. And a Stud Kr, rb who would have been a good #2 Rb, and made him KR/PR only and went 15 return man. The teams who didn't adjust to the sime didn't do this. Now teams who did this are going to dominate less depth teams bc of the morale hit/ stamina drain for special teams. If you do not have depth this season is going to be a long ass one for you.


I do see that as a problem as well. I'm thinking there needs to be a roster limit next season, really. There's no reason to have 100 players on your team unless you're trying to hoard them or take advantage. NFL doesn't allow it, even though teams could afford it.
 
headsigh
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Bort
Originally posted by dpride59

Teams saw team depth/morale is key, they signed huge rosters, got 10-12 special team only players 3-4 motivational speakers and 45 guys to play o/d. And a Stud Kr, rb who would have been a good #2 Rb, and made him KR/PR only and went 15 return man. The teams who didn't adjust to the sime didn't do this. Now teams who did this are going to dominate less depth teams bc of the morale hit/ stamina drain for special teams. If you do not have depth this season is going to be a long ass one for you.


I do see that as a problem as well. I'm thinking there needs to be a roster limit next season, really. There's no reason to have 100 players on your team unless you're trying to hoard them or take advantage. NFL doesn't allow it, even though teams could afford it.


Then why didn't you consider it this season?

You're kind of passive-aggressive sometimes.
 
Bort
Admin
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Punk Rock Jocks
I think the PT va needs to be nerfed or at least add a missed tackle penalty, like how the JTS va has the +1% chance of jumping offsides, because combined w/ the Sure Tackler va, the defender becomes nearly unstoppable.


I'm not sure the frequency needs any changing, really. Maybe more missed tackles, but if you've got 70-80 tackling or more like some guys do, you've paid the price to try and use power tackling more.

It's another one of those delicate balance things. Nobody wants their player to fumble 10 times, but somebody who built their player to force lots of fumbles would like it to actually do something.
 
Link
 
Originally posted by kalkmanc
well over 1000 carries when adding up regular season and scrimmage games, 0 career fumbles.

http://goallineblitz.com/game/player.pl?player_id=1063035


Only about 50 carries this season, including scrimmages. Your other 950+ carries aren't relevant in this discussion. It's also easy to not fumble against gutted teams.
 
FairForever
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by lolMurp
Originally posted by Bort

Originally posted by dpride59


Teams saw team depth/morale is key, they signed huge rosters, got 10-12 special team only players 3-4 motivational speakers and 45 guys to play o/d. And a Stud Kr, rb who would have been a good #2 Rb, and made him KR/PR only and went 15 return man. The teams who didn't adjust to the sime didn't do this. Now teams who did this are going to dominate less depth teams bc of the morale hit/ stamina drain for special teams. If you do not have depth this season is going to be a long ass one for you.


I do see that as a problem as well. I'm thinking there needs to be a roster limit next season, really. There's no reason to have 100 players on your team unless you're trying to hoard them or take advantage. NFL doesn't allow it, even though teams could afford it.


Then why didn't you consider it this season?

You're kind of passive-aggressive sometimes.


Because it's never been an issue in the past?

I remember season 1/2 when everyone was crying for roster MINIMUMS.
 
headsigh
offline
Link
 
When is that Sportsmanship thing being implemented yet?
 
Bort
Admin
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by lolMurp
Originally posted by Bort

Originally posted by dpride59


Teams saw team depth/morale is key, they signed huge rosters, got 10-12 special team only players 3-4 motivational speakers and 45 guys to play o/d. And a Stud Kr, rb who would have been a good #2 Rb, and made him KR/PR only and went 15 return man. The teams who didn't adjust to the sime didn't do this. Now teams who did this are going to dominate less depth teams bc of the morale hit/ stamina drain for special teams. If you do not have depth this season is going to be a long ass one for you.


I do see that as a problem as well. I'm thinking there needs to be a roster limit next season, really. There's no reason to have 100 players on your team unless you're trying to hoard them or take advantage. NFL doesn't allow it, even though teams could afford it.


Then why didn't you consider it this season?

You're kind of passive-aggressive sometimes.


Didn't really come up as a problem until preseason was nearly done. I'm not going to force people to drop half their roster 2 days before the season starts. If we let them know this season, they will have time to prepare.
 
headsigh
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by FairForever
Originally posted by lolMurp

Originally posted by Bort


Originally posted by dpride59



Teams saw team depth/morale is key, they signed huge rosters, got 10-12 special team only players 3-4 motivational speakers and 45 guys to play o/d. And a Stud Kr, rb who would have been a good #2 Rb, and made him KR/PR only and went 15 return man. The teams who didn't adjust to the sime didn't do this. Now teams who did this are going to dominate less depth teams bc of the morale hit/ stamina drain for special teams. If you do not have depth this season is going to be a long ass one for you.


I do see that as a problem as well. I'm thinking there needs to be a roster limit next season, really. There's no reason to have 100 players on your team unless you're trying to hoard them or take advantage. NFL doesn't allow it, even though teams could afford it.


Then why didn't you consider it this season?

You're kind of passive-aggressive sometimes.


Because it's never been an issue in the past?

I remember season 1/2 when everyone was crying for roster MINIMUMS.


Back in season one I remember kickers/punters were the highest paid players in the game.
 
Gyuri1
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Bort
Originally posted by Punk Rock Jocks

I think the PT va needs to be nerfed or at least add a missed tackle penalty, like how the JTS va has the +1% chance of jumping offsides, because combined w/ the Sure Tackler va, the defender becomes nearly unstoppable.


I'm not sure the frequency needs any changing, really. Maybe more missed tackles, but if you've got 70-80 tackling or more like some guys do, you've paid the price to try and use power tackling more.

It's another one of those delicate balance things. Nobody wants their player to fumble 10 times, but somebody who built their player to force lots of fumbles would like it to actually do something.


Another approach would be to have Mr. Reliable apply the 3% not fumble chance on 2nd, 3rd and 4th downs as well as ST. At the moment, defensive players get +3%/level force fumble chance with a VA (when, combined with Sure Tackler, loses some of its downside) and ball carrier have nothing to combat it with except on 1st downs.
 
LuZ KiD
offline
Link
 
Any clue of what will be happening next season
 
Link
 
Originally posted by Bort
Originally posted by Punk Rock Jocks

I think the PT va needs to be nerfed or at least add a missed tackle penalty, like how the JTS va has the +1% chance of jumping offsides, because combined w/ the Sure Tackler va, the defender becomes nearly unstoppable.


I'm not sure the frequency needs any changing, really. Maybe more missed tackles, but if you've got 70-80 tackling or more like some guys do, you've paid the price to try and use power tackling more.

It's another one of those delicate balance things. Nobody wants their player to fumble 10 times, but somebody who built their player to force lots of fumbles would like it to actually do something.


But there's a difference in having it do something and having it do too much. 10 fumbles on a season is acceptable. 10 fumbles in a game? Well we might as well be playing against wookies, gargoyles, hobbits, jesus, and other imaginary characters.
 
Dpride59
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Bort
Originally posted by Punk Rock Jocks

I think the PT va needs to be nerfed or at least add a missed tackle penalty, like how the JTS va has the +1% chance of jumping offsides, because combined w/ the Sure Tackler va, the defender becomes nearly unstoppable.


I'm not sure the frequency needs any changing, really. Maybe more missed tackles, but if you've got 70-80 tackling or more like some guys do, you've paid the price to try and use power tackling more.

It's another one of those delicate balance things. Nobody wants their player to fumble 10 times, but somebody who built their player to force lots of fumbles would like it to actually do something.


These guys with all this strength tackling forced fumble are getting toched on hb screens. That will be the price they pay when teams just expose these guys in pass defense. I see no problem really. People adjusted builds to bury power backs.
 
Bort
Admin
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Gyuri1
Originally posted by Bort

Originally posted by Punk Rock Jocks


I think the PT va needs to be nerfed or at least add a missed tackle penalty, like how the JTS va has the +1% chance of jumping offsides, because combined w/ the Sure Tackler va, the defender becomes nearly unstoppable.


I'm not sure the frequency needs any changing, really. Maybe more missed tackles, but if you've got 70-80 tackling or more like some guys do, you've paid the price to try and use power tackling more.

It's another one of those delicate balance things. Nobody wants their player to fumble 10 times, but somebody who built their player to force lots of fumbles would like it to actually do something.


Another approach would be to have Mr. Reliable apply the 3% not fumble chance on 2nd, 3rd and 4th downs as well as ST. At the moment, defensive players get +3%/level force fumble chance with a VA (when, combined with Sure Tackler, loses some of its downside) and ball carrier have nothing to combat it with except on 1st downs.


Return man already gives you a "not fumble" bonus.

Edit: ah, I misread. You think there needs to be a VA like "cover up?"
Last edited Apr 26, 2009 16:07:41
 
Deathblade
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Gyuri1
Another approach would be to have Mr. Reliable apply the 3% not fumble chance on 2nd, 3rd and 4th downs as well as ST. At the moment, defensive players get +3%/level force fumble chance with a VA (when, combined with Sure Tackler, loses some of its downside) and ball carrier have nothing to combat it with except on 1st downs.


I much prefer David vs. Goliath to Sure Tackler. I figure if they aren't bigger, and aren't stronger, breaking a tackle isn't really a huge concern....and David vs. Goliath will always trigger when you need it, and allows you to tackle players that would be near impossible to tackle by rerolling.

Anyway...I would much prefer making a viable "hold onto the ball" VA. Maybe even give it a downside to encourage high carrying builds rather than the VA. Like +3% chance to not fumble, -1% chance to gain extra yardage during the tackle?
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.