Originally posted by Bort
Originally posted by Gart888
Originally posted by Bort
Originally posted by Gart888
Bort,
Any immediate plans to implement some sort of code that punishes offenses for making repetitive play calls? I get the sinking feeling that whatever you do to fix SI Slam will work to balance that one play, but eventually another 'god' play will make itself known and we'll have the exact same thing happen all over again.
Something to encourage diverse play calling would not only solve the current issue, but go a long way in preventing this from happening again, in the future, with different play.s
I have tested it and it doesn't do a whole lot unless you buff a lot of defenses' abilities. You could have 1000 vision, but if you can't make it past a blocker, you're still screwed.
Well then how about instead of buffing the defenses abilities, you penalize the offenses abilities? Something like out of position penalties, but for the entire offense?
Sounds counter-intuitive. Why would the offense play worse when they run the play over and over? A more intuitive idea would maybe be an increasing stamina usage every time the same play is called or something, but it still doesn't make that much sense.
Also, do you buff the defense/nerf the offense to the point where a crap team can shut down a really good team if the good team runs the same play over and over? Just because I run up the gut every play, should I get shut down by lv 1's when I'm level 60?
There's also the issue that some formations don't really have that many plays. We've added a couple more, but sometimes you're forced to run certain plays many times. Some HS and college teams literally run 3 plays.
Very valid points. It does seem counter intuitive to penalize the offenses abilities if they call the same play over and over again.
No, of course you don't buff them to the point where a crap team loses to a terrible team. Maybe something along the lines of bring a 1 seed down to the level of a 9 seed? Same league, but quite a bit worse.
If you want to stick to 'realistic' options (although personally i think you should be willing to toss out some realism for the sake of playability), your best bets are probably
- morale loss to offense for running the same play over and over again. unfortunately, that morale loss will likely be easily negated by the morale gain from all of their pancakes, first downs, and whatever else gives us morale during the game.
- increase in defensive reaction time to plays they've seen over and over again. i'm sure you could put some modifier into vision checks at the start of plays right?
Neither of these options really get to the root of the problem though.