User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Forum > Goal Line Blitz > League Moving Based on Median and Max Level of Players on Team
Page:
 
Dpride59
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by merenoise
Originally posted by dpride59

Originally posted by chaotic646


Bort, since you wont give me a direct answer to my other questions will you answer this?

I have a team full of CPU's and a level 45 K. Will that level 45 K protect my team from getting capped?

100% yes. IF you have any player over level 34 you cannot play in a capped league


Wouldn't a series of higher caps be an easier solution:

Bottom Level capped at 13
Next Level capped at 21
Next Level capped at 29
Next Level capped at 37
Next Level capped at 45
Next Level capped at 53
and so on.


No, not in my opinion. The point is after 34 you should be getting promoted at some point out of the bottom tiered leagues. This is why there are going to be branches of uncapped. The top 32 highest leveled uncapped teams will get the top branch and so forth until they have as many slots, as there are uncapped teams. Then the others will be placed in capped regions to as many teams allow for.

 
JcWildcat
Lead Mod
offline
Link
 
Okay, that is what common sense would tell me and has told me. However, with Bort skirting around the answer that didn't give me much confidence. (Read my edit where I said what you say makes sense btw). As long as it's 100% certain I will be uncapped then placed with like median levels then that's fine and no problem.

I am still worried for the folks that have recruited their rosters but don't have anyone on their roster to keep them uncapped though.
 
Dpride59
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by JcWildcat
Okay, that is what common sense would tell me and has told me. However, with Bort skirting around the answer that didn't give me much confidence. (Read my edit where I said what you say makes sense btw). As long as it's 100% certain I will be uncapped then placed with like median levels then that's fine and no problem.

I am still worried for the folks that have recruited their rosters but don't have anyone on their roster to keep them uncapped though.


He already hinted at waiting until after day 1/2 b4 he is going to reshuffle leagues. This would solve all the problems of day 1 contracts. Also if you are going to have "an entire roster overhaul, and have 0 level 34 or over players after day 2 contact support like today, ( since they are so slow) and say " I will not be have level 34 players signed until day 3. Which would be a pretty rare case. But since the reshuffle wont happen until after day 2 no one is going to be facing this problem.
 
JcWildcat
Lead Mod
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by dpride59
Originally posted by JcWildcat

Okay, that is what common sense would tell me and has told me. However, with Bort skirting around the answer that didn't give me much confidence. (Read my edit where I said what you say makes sense btw). As long as it's 100% certain I will be uncapped then placed with like median levels then that's fine and no problem.

I am still worried for the folks that have recruited their rosters but don't have anyone on their roster to keep them uncapped though.


He already hinted at waiting until after day 1/2 b4 he is going to reshuffle leagues. This would solve all the problems of day 1 contracts. Also if you are going to have "an entire roster overhaul, and have 0 level 34 or over players after day 2 contact support like today, ( since they are so slow) and say " I will not be have level 34 players signed until day 3. Which would be a pretty rare case. But since the reshuffle wont happen until after day 2 no one is going to be facing this problem.


Well if that's the case, then no one should have anything to worry about then. I was figuring that he would do it all on day 41 rollover to day 42. That would be a problem for some folks, not so much if it's done after Season 9 is going though.

Think we would all like to know what the plan is for sure though (not hinted at), but like you said he may not know the total plan as of yet.
 
Dpride59
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by JcWildcat
Originally posted by dpride59

Originally posted by JcWildcat


Okay, that is what common sense would tell me and has told me. However, with Bort skirting around the answer that didn't give me much confidence. (Read my edit where I said what you say makes sense btw). As long as it's 100% certain I will be uncapped then placed with like median levels then that's fine and no problem.

I am still worried for the folks that have recruited their rosters but don't have anyone on their roster to keep them uncapped though.


He already hinted at waiting until after day 1/2 b4 he is going to reshuffle leagues. This would solve all the problems of day 1 contracts. Also if you are going to have "an entire roster overhaul, and have 0 level 34 or over players after day 2 contact support like today, ( since they are so slow) and say " I will not be have level 34 players signed until day 3. Which would be a pretty rare case. But since the reshuffle wont happen until after day 2 no one is going to be facing this problem.


Well if that's the case, then no one should have anything to worry about then. I was figuring that he would do it all on day 41 rollover to day 42. That would be a problem for some folks, not so much if it's done after Season 9 is going though.

Think we would all like to know what the plan is for sure though (not hinted at), but like you said he may not know the total plan as of yet.


Hell no. He doesn't even release capped teams until day 43-47 or something. I Think he just doesn't know how the reallignment will look because there are so many off season changes. I just hope teams with 0 players over 31 in say "BBB USA#9 named NBA JAM" ARe in a 31 capped branch. Would hate to have to play vs level 35+'s
 
JcWildcat
Lead Mod
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by dpride59
Originally posted by JcWildcat

Originally posted by dpride59


Originally posted by JcWildcat



Okay, that is what common sense would tell me and has told me. However, with Bort skirting around the answer that didn't give me much confidence. (Read my edit where I said what you say makes sense btw). As long as it's 100% certain I will be uncapped then placed with like median levels then that's fine and no problem.

I am still worried for the folks that have recruited their rosters but don't have anyone on their roster to keep them uncapped though.


He already hinted at waiting until after day 1/2 b4 he is going to reshuffle leagues. This would solve all the problems of day 1 contracts. Also if you are going to have "an entire roster overhaul, and have 0 level 34 or over players after day 2 contact support like today, ( since they are so slow) and say " I will not be have level 34 players signed until day 3. Which would be a pretty rare case. But since the reshuffle wont happen until after day 2 no one is going to be facing this problem.


Well if that's the case, then no one should have anything to worry about then. I was figuring that he would do it all on day 41 rollover to day 42. That would be a problem for some folks, not so much if it's done after Season 9 is going though.

Think we would all like to know what the plan is for sure though (not hinted at), but like you said he may not know the total plan as of yet.


Hell no. He doesn't even release capped teams until day 43-47 or something. I Think he just doesn't know how the reallignment will look because there are so many off season changes. I just hope teams with 0 players over 31 in say "BBB USA#9 named NBA JAM" ARe in a 31 capped branch. Would hate to have to play vs level 35+'s


I don't see why you would move to an uncapped league, with not a single player over the cap on the roster. Only reason I could see him doing so would be accounting for boosting, but doubt he would. Don't know though and neither does he lol. May have to release the one's over the cap you want though day 42 if you can't get them traded.
Last edited Apr 1, 2009 15:33:25
 
Bort
Admin
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by chaotic646
Originally posted by Titus Pullo



That is why you would do the league reshuffle on D4 or D5, after everyone has had a chance to fill their season 9 rosters. YOU set the league reshuffle date as D? of season 9 and announce it so that everyone knows exactly what is going on. Have it occur a few days after the season starts but before the first game. Then you pause the season long enough to reshuffle all the leagues based on everyones season 9 rosters. Trying to reshuffle the leagues before people have their season 9 rosters set is just going to cause major problems for teams who have been blindsided by this sudden surprise reshuffle of yours.


This.


How would you do a shuffle on day 4 or 5? 2-3 games would have been played with a completely different schedule in a different league. It HAS to be done before the season starts.
 
Bort
Admin
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by chaotic646
Bort, since you wont give me a direct answer to my other questions will you answer this?

I have a team full of CPU's and a level 45 K. Will that level 45 K protect my team from getting capped?


Yes.
 
Bort
Admin
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by dpride59
Originally posted by JcWildcat

Okay, that is what common sense would tell me and has told me. However, with Bort skirting around the answer that didn't give me much confidence. (Read my edit where I said what you say makes sense btw). As long as it's 100% certain I will be uncapped then placed with like median levels then that's fine and no problem.

I am still worried for the folks that have recruited their rosters but don't have anyone on their roster to keep them uncapped though.


He already hinted at waiting until after day 1/2 b4 he is going to reshuffle leagues. This would solve all the problems of day 1 contracts. Also if you are going to have "an entire roster overhaul, and have 0 level 34 or over players after day 2 contact support like today, ( since they are so slow) and say " I will not be have level 34 players signed until day 3. Which would be a pretty rare case. But since the reshuffle wont happen until after day 2 no one is going to be facing this problem.


No, that's not possible to do - it has to be done during the offseason so that schedules can be properly generated for the teams.

The only option I really see working is being able to request the cap (or uncap) you want ahead of time so you can be sorted based on that instead of what your team level is. It would have to be overridden if your team was higher leveled, so you couldn't say "put me in 13" but then fill your team with lv 50's, but if you're below the requested level then no problem.
 
Snakebite99
offline
Link
 
So in other words, this isnt going to help teams with players in the 35-40 range, as theyll still be in an uncapped league with plenty of teams with 45-52 players? How is this any different than what we have now with capped 34 leagues being the max? Would be nice to have a 40 capped league after the 34 capped league, then maybe a 48, then finally uncapped, and adjust these on a season to season basis relative to the median level in Pro leagues.

Example:
Season 9
SA BBB - level 21 cap (28 at midseason)
SA A - level 34
SA AA - level 40
SA AAA - Level 48
SA Pro - Uncapped (median of say 50?)

Then in season 10, youd change to -
SA BBB - Level 34
SA A - Level 40
SA AA - Level 48
SA AAA - Level 52
SA Pro - Uncapped (median of say 54-55)

Season 11
SA BBB - Level 40
SA A - Level 48
SA AA - Level 52
SA AAA - Level 58
SA Pro - Uncapped

So on and so forth. Of course players would be grandfathered so that no one would ever be kicked off a team if theyve been with them since the previous cap allowed, but at some point, those teams SHOULD be promoting to the next level. A good example of what it would look like after 4-5 seasons would be the USA league. Right now, youd have BBB teams capped at 40 (other than grandfathered players obviously), A would be 48 cap, etc. USA pro now has a lot of level 54-56 guys in it so that's kind of the model im looking at. Of course itd need some fine tuning, but this would assure relatively balanced competition each season, as well as makign sure you have enough players to go around for the AAA and Pro leagues, rather than seeing teams move their high level guys to lower leagues like you see now. Just a thought, flame away
 
Dpride59
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Bort
Originally posted by dpride59

Originally posted by JcWildcat


Okay, that is what common sense would tell me and has told me. However, with Bort skirting around the answer that didn't give me much confidence. (Read my edit where I said what you say makes sense btw). As long as it's 100% certain I will be uncapped then placed with like median levels then that's fine and no problem.

I am still worried for the folks that have recruited their rosters but don't have anyone on their roster to keep them uncapped though.


He already hinted at waiting until after day 1/2 b4 he is going to reshuffle leagues. This would solve all the problems of day 1 contracts. Also if you are going to have "an entire roster overhaul, and have 0 level 34 or over players after day 2 contact support like today, ( since they are so slow) and say " I will not be have level 34 players signed until day 3. Which would be a pretty rare case. But since the reshuffle wont happen until after day 2 no one is going to be facing this problem.


No, that's not possible to do - it has to be done during the offseason so that schedules can be properly generated for the teams.

The only option I really see working is being able to request the cap (or uncap) you want ahead of time so you can be sorted based on that instead of what your team level is. It would have to be overridden if your team was higher leveled, so you couldn't say "put me in 13" but then fill your team with lv 50's, but if you're below the requested level then no problem.


1 question which will answer 1000 complaints if this happens. If a team saids " keep me 31 and under" Then they go out and have 1,2, 45 players over 31. How will support handle this. Just cut said players from team?

Also instead of having everyone contact support and them being flooded, could you do something to basically say what is your teams aim for the cap planning at: 1624/31 etc... or uncapped. With, a message or poll that reads "teams who are over the cap will have player released or be forced to move up to uncapped" or however you wanted to do it? Bort: It would have to be overridden if your team was higher leveled, so you couldn't say "put me in 13" but then fill your team with lv 50's, but if you're below the requested level then no problem. --- I understand this, but ......


Some sort of announcement needs to be made, bc 80-90% of teams in bottom tiers do not read this, and will need to be walked trough process. So to maybe send a options list to the owners of every BBB, or Bottom tiered A league team, and ask them point blank where to be put and what cap there team will be at, ( or plans for cap so you can put a restriction on this) and make it clear that teams who have higher level players outside cap options will be punished accordingly.

Suggestion: get on top of this now so you see where you stand with league structure, and where teams will be at. I am apart of a few teams, that are well planned out for the next season so you could start getting numbers right now, and it would make your off season move a lot smoother


Last edited Apr 1, 2009 16:51:11
 
Dpride59
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Snakebite99
So in other words, this isnt going to help teams with players in the 35-40 range, as theyll still be in an uncapped league with plenty of teams with 45-52 players? How is this any different than what we have now with capped 34 leagues being the max? Would be nice to have a 40 capped league after the 34 capped league, then maybe a 48, then finally uncapped, and adjust these on a season to season basis relative to the median level in Pro leagues.

Example:
Season 9
SA BBB - level 21 cap (28 at midseason)
SA A - level 34
SA AA - level 40
SA AAA - Level 48
SA Pro - Uncapped (median of say 50?)

Then in season 10, youd change to -
SA BBB - Level 34
SA A - Level 40
SA AA - Level 48
SA AAA - Level 52
SA Pro - Uncapped (median of say 54-55)

Season 11
SA BBB - Level 40
SA A - Level 48
SA AA - Level 52
SA AAA - Level 58
SA Pro - Uncapped

So on and so forth. Of course players would be grandfathered so that no one would ever be kicked off a team if theyve been with them since the previous cap allowed, but at some point, those teams SHOULD be promoting to the next level. A good example of what it would look like after 4-5 seasons would be the USA league. Right now, youd have BBB teams capped at 40 (other than grandfathered players obviously), A would be 48 cap, etc. USA pro now has a lot of level 54-56 guys in it so that's kind of the model im looking at. Of course itd need some fine tuning, but this would assure relatively balanced competition each season, as well as makign sure you have enough players to go around for the AAA and Pro leagues, rather than seeing teams move their high level guys to lower leagues like you see now. Just a thought, flame away


Bad idea imo. No BBB should be over 50 +, and if they are something is seriously flawed. A team with a avg group of level 44 players can win in A, I have a few over 34 players and I am flat out getting rid of them. The core of my team is level 28, and we were able to compete with the level 40 guys (who are built horribly) only losing by 10 pts. The biggest defeat we got all season was by another slow build squad of level 35's.

Basically well built 35-40 teams should dominate and get promoted within 1-2 seasons. The group of level 35 players in our league "college town" Went 15-1 in the most competitive division of usa BBB. You will play the higher teams but as this stage there is no reason you can't compete and get promoted.
Last edited Apr 1, 2009 16:00:24
 
Snakebite99
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by dpride59
Bad idea imo. No BBB should be over 50 +, and if they are something is seriously flawed. A team with a avg group of level 44 players can win in A, I have a few over 34 players and I am flat out getting rid of them. The core of my team is level 28, and we were able to compete with the level 40 guys (who are built horribly) only losing by 10 pts. The biggest defeat we got all season was by another slow build squad of level 35's.

Basically well built 35-40 teams should dominate and get promoted within 1-2 seasons. The group of level 35 players in our league "college town" Went 15-1 in the most competitive division of usa BBB. You will play the higher teams but as this stage there is no reason you can't compete and get promoted.


The bolded part above bothers me a bit in that this discourages teams from staying together, but that's your choice, so whatever. The other problem with the current set up is that nothing is stopping pro teams from gutting, and bringing their guys to A and AA leagues. I suppose the arguement is "who cares, no one cares about A or AA trophies", which is partly true, but it doesnt stop from making lower leagues totally unfun because you have such a huge disparity down there, from teams loaded with level 45-50 guys, to "farm" teams loaded with level 8s. This is what i wish was more balanced.
 
Dpride59
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Snakebite99
Originally posted by dpride59

Bad idea imo. No BBB should be over 50 +, and if they are something is seriously flawed. A team with a avg group of level 44 players can win in A, I have a few over 34 players and I am flat out getting rid of them. The core of my team is level 28, and we were able to compete with the level 40 guys (who are built horribly) only losing by 10 pts. The biggest defeat we got all season was by another slow build squad of level 35's.

Basically well built 35-40 teams should dominate and get promoted within 1-2 seasons. The group of level 35 players in our league "college town" Went 15-1 in the most competitive division of usa BBB. You will play the higher teams but as this stage there is no reason you can't compete and get promoted.


The bolded part above bothers me a bit in that this discourages teams from staying together, but that's your choice, so whatever. The other problem with the current set up is that nothing is stopping pro teams from gutting, and bringing their guys to A and AA leagues. I suppose the arguement is "who cares, no one cares about A or AA trophies", which is partly true, but it doesnt stop from making lower leagues totally unfun because you have such a huge disparity down there, from teams loaded with level 45-50 guys, to "farm" teams loaded with level 8s. This is what i wish was more balanced.




Why would a pro team want to play at lower competition? I Wouldn't even spend money on this game if I didn't want to face the best competition from a equal standpoint( All things being equal level/creation date) I don't think this is a problem at all since 95%of agents want their players to play at the highest level possible.

Getting rid of my level 34-37 players hurts me a little bit, but I will just have to get a few more agents on board. I don't have a team of 34-37 players they were just the minority of roster so shedding them is just something I must do to play equal competition which will actually be more fun. . I think farm teams are a good thing, and keep people together for yrs its the reason many like this game. Working with a group of agents, and having fun for seasons after seasons. I think if bort polices this and puts alot of time into it to make sure we have balance it will go along way.








BTW Don't forget this Powers that be.


1 question which will answer 1000 complaints if this happens. If a team saids " keep me 31 and under" Then they go out and have 1,2, 45 players over 31. How will support handle this. Just cut said players from team?

Also instead of having everyone contact support and them being flooded, could you do something to basically say what is your teams aim for the cap planning at: 1624/31 etc... or uncapped. With, a message or poll that reads "teams who are over the cap will have player released or be forced to move up to uncapped" or however you wanted to do it? Bort: It would have to be overridden if your team was higher leveled, so you couldn't say "put me in 13" but then fill your team with lv 50's, but if you're below the requested level then no problem. --- I understand this, but ......


Some sort of announcement needs to be made, bc 80-90% of teams in bottom tiers do not read this, and will need to be walked trough process. So to maybe send a options list to the owners of every BBB, or Bottom tiered A league team, and ask them point blank where to be put and what cap there team will be at, ( or plans for cap so you can put a restriction on this) and make it clear that teams who have higher level players outside cap options will be punished accordingly.

Suggestion: get on top of this now so you see where you stand with league structure, and where teams will be at. I am apart of a few teams, that are well planned out for the next season so you could start getting numbers right now, and it would make your off season move a lot smoother
Last edited Apr 1, 2009 16:31:07
 
mantis7
offline
Link
 
How will this work if most of my players are level 34 or lower but I have a couple around level 38 and one in his 40's?

We are all friends but I really don't want to be reshuffled into a super hard league just because of a couple of players...


I am nervous about this!
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.