User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Forum > Suggestions > nfratami says: Endorsements - There Needs to Be More Than 1 Given Per Position
Page:
 
nfratami
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by jvguballa

The real flaw in the system here isnt the low chance of receiving endorsements, it's that you lose the gear at the end of the season. In the OP, Nef talks about the 1.7% (or whatever it was) chance of getting EQ if you're the most famous player. Even if that is true your player plays is going to play for 10+ seasons if he's any good and if you have 5-6 players (which a lot of people do) you're actually quite likely to receive and endorsement at some point.


You really aren't quite likely at all, with the given scenario in the op you would still not be very likely in that scenario in relation to the example you provided, and keep in mind that the scenario in the op is somewhat of a best case scenario.
Last edited Feb 15, 2009 15:36:09
 
jvguballa
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by nfratami
Originally posted by jvguballa


The real flaw in the system here isnt the low chance of receiving endorsements, it's that you lose the gear at the end of the season. In the OP, Nef talks about the 1.7% (or whatever it was) chance of getting EQ if you're the most famous player. Even if that is true your player plays is going to play for 10+ seasons if he's any good and if you have 5-6 players (which a lot of people do) you're actually quite likely to receive and endorsement at some point.


You really aren't quite likely at all, with the given scenario in the op you would still not be very likely in that scenario in relation to the example you provided, and keep in mind that the scenario in the op is somewhat of a be case scenario.

scenario


If you have a 1% chance of getting the endorsement each season (so you're a pretty good builder but you're not elite) you have nearly a 10% (9.8% but w/e)chance over 10 seasons to get an endorsement (for all intents and purposes you'll play for 11 or 12 seasons).

If you have x players your chance of getting and endoresment at some point are ____

1 player = 9.6%
2 players = 18.3%
3 players = 26.1%
4 players = 33.3%
5 players = 39.7%
6 players = 45.5%
7 players = 50.1%
8 players = 55.4%
9 players = 59.7%
10players = 63.6%

Yes there was some rounding done in the math and yes I did just flat out assume the 1% thing, but minus a little fine tuning I dont see anything extremely off on those numbers. Sure I would like my players to get endorsements and while I currently only have 5 guys that 40% chance of ever getting one seems kinda depressing, but it would kill the fun a bit if that number shot up to realy high.
 
craazyraiderz
offline
Link
 
+1
 
Drago
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by nfratami
Originally posted by Drago

Originally posted by nfratami


Originally posted by Drago



Originally posted by nfratami




Originally posted by Drago





Originally posted by VladtheImpaler1






Well, just like in real life, I would hope that the endorsements would go to the players earning more fame that season.
You don't see 3rd string "fresh out of college/ suck really bad in NFL " players getting endorsements for Nike do you?


His name was Ryan Leaf. His name is Brady Quinn.

So whoever earns the most fame should just get the equipment hands down then... no lottery system?


this was never said, more putting words in peoples mouths


Are you so stupid you can't make it through five sentences without remembering what was said in the very first one?



didn't read his post actually, but this still holds true to the OP


ITT: ignorance.

Read up on it.


it is ignorant to be busy and to skim posts and respond to them, ok?

my mistake that i thought you would still be arguing against the op

oh wait that is right you dont have an argument against the op except YOU DON'T KNOW THE FORMULA or KEEP THAT SHIT RARE


Funny how because I think your idea, and your assumptions are absolute shit... that I suddenly don't have an argument. There is a certain mystique to a single lottery winner per position.

Your claims that if the piece doesn't go to the most elite person on the team then it's wasted are also a bunch of bullshit.

I love how you've openly said there are players on your team that do not matter. Why don't you throw some more of them under the bus.

The fact is even if the EQ doesn't go to the best player, it will still go towards helping the team.

Sorry you're too stupid to understand that.
 
Link
 
sooo, anyways....
I'm gonna go out on a limb here and ask that if Bort or DD reads this, do you guys think maybe one of those famous "admin polls" is in order? I think that might solve alot of the bickering, if everyone was able to just cast their vote kinda thing and we can all at least feel like we had a say in the matter. Could possibly look something like:

Endorsement Deal Quantity Vote ( vote for your choice , this isn't a guarantee it will be implemented, just a representation of the community's feelings towards the matter. )

A: Keep it the same way it's currently described in the fame F.A.Q. (1 per position/ per league )
B: Keep it the same way, but increase it to 2 per position / per league
C: Increase it to 2 per position / per conference
D: Keep it the same way, but increase it to 3 per position / per league
E: Increase it to 3 per position / per conference

Whatcha think guys?

 
whoshotjr
offline
Link
 
+1. More endorsements = more fun & more stuff to look forward to.

Also when processing the endorsements, have some sort of check that the player is still active (e.g. if the agent has been inactive for the 2 weeks prior to the endorsements, they are out of the lottery).



 
Mofo
offline
Link
 
This suggestion has my support.
 
nfratami
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Drago

Funny how because I think your idea, and your assumptions are absolute shit... that I suddenly don't have an argument. There is a certain mystique to a single lottery winner per position.


No, you don't have an argument because you don't have an argument, all you have been able to say is "YOU DONT KNOW THE FORMULA" "I AM IN THE MINORITY AND I WANT MYSTIQUE". To shoot down my argument you claim that I want 50% of the game to have equipment. Seriously, the fact that your argument is driven by you wanting mystique in a text based game? God damn.

Originally posted by Drago

Your claims that if the piece doesn't go to the most elite person on the team then it's wasted are also a bunch of bullshit.

I love how you've openly said there are players on your team that do not matter. Why don't you throw some more of them under the bus.

The fact is even if the EQ doesn't go to the best player, it will still go towards helping the team.


I have never said anything specifically about players on my team, but it isn't surprising that you manipulate my words further. Nor have I said that players don't matter. My point simply was that with more endorsements there will be more chances for excitement for teams.

How about this stupid fuck... (I figure if maybe I throw insults it will make my argument better just like yours)

My 5th WR who mostly spends all his time on special teams could get the award, and you know what, it would help the team, I HAVE NEVER SAID IT WOULDN'T (nice how you find the smallest irrelevant loopholes again). It just wouldn't help the team a lot, probably wouldn't change the outcome of any game, and would be absolutely nothing to get excited about.

Sorry, if I feel that "endorsements" should have a slightly(be sure not to take slightly and manipulate it into 50% of the game having equipment) larger impact, by giving equipment to slightly more people.

And isn't there still mystique if the #1 item given to the lottery winner is head and shoulders above the other couple of guys from that position who get runner up items? I'm not saying give everyone who wins the absolute best piece.

Originally posted by Drago

Sorry you're too stupid to understand that.


Translated...

Originally posted by Drago

I'm too stupid to understand that in its current suggested form endorsements are a waste of time and better stuff could be added to the game. Odds are they will go to players that don't cause excitement (one of the benefits of endorsements you pointed out) and will just not matter. I am also guilty of coming into this thread, dropping insult after insult and derailing what was once a good discussion all for the sake of mystique.


 
F8n4tune
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by nfratami
Even if you are the most famous player in your league for you, you really don't have a good chance of getting an item, and with the odds you will see below, most people won't ever see an endorsement item.

For my example I will use DEs.

For this example let us say that each team in a league has 3 DEs (conservative estimate this will most likely be more but this will just go to show you how unlikely it will be to get an endorsement item).

Now let us say that the DEs in your league average at 500 fame. Let us now say that your player is tops in the league for DE fame with 900.

Endorsements are said to be done in a lottery system. I assume it will work as in the equation below.

So...

3 DEs x 32 teams = 96 DEs in the league (conservative estimate)

Take 96 DEs and multiply that by average fame of 500 and you get 48,000 total fame for DEs in your league.

Now your DE is the most famous with 900. but his chances aren't good to win the lottery.

900/48000 = 1.875%

So, In conclusion even if you are the most famous player at your position in your league, you are probably not going to get an endorsement, probably ever.

Increase the number of items per position, it doesn't make any sense to add an item like this that won't increases the enjoyment of the vast majority of the game.

You could have the lottery take the top 5 selected for each position and make items 1-5 deteriorate in quality from 1 to 5. I'm sure you guys could have some other ideas.

Edit: typo


This seems pretty logical and much more fair to the community as a whole to me..
 
Garret Quest
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by VladtheImpaler1
sooo, anyways....
I'm gonna go out on a limb here and ask that if Bort or DD reads this, do you guys think maybe one of those famous "admin polls" is in order? I think that might solve alot of the bickering, if everyone was able to just cast their vote kinda thing and we can all at least feel like we had a say in the matter. Could possibly look something like:

Endorsement Deal Quantity Vote ( vote for your choice , this isn't a guarantee it will be implemented, just a representation of the community's feelings towards the matter. )

A: Keep it the same way it's currently described in the fame F.A.Q. (1 per position/ per league )
B: Keep it the same way, but increase it to 2 per position / per league
C: Increase it to 2 per position / per conference
D: Keep it the same way, but increase it to 3 per position / per league
E: Increase it to 3 per position / per conference

Whatcha think guys?



I like the Idea of 1 Local Endorsement per Team + 2/3 per League/Conference. Every Team has at least 1 player with something, even if it is a lesser version of the Conference awards.
 
Drago
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by nfratami
Originally posted by Drago


Funny how because I think your idea, and your assumptions are absolute shit... that I suddenly don't have an argument. There is a certain mystique to a single lottery winner per position.


No, you don't have an argument because you don't have an argument, all you have been able to say is "YOU DONT KNOW THE FORMULA" "I AM IN THE MINORITY AND I WANT MYSTIQUE". To shoot down my argument you claim that I want 50% of the game to have equipment. Seriously, the fact that your argument is driven by you wanting mystique in a text based game? God damn.


I don't have an argument because I don't have an argument? Great logic there. Making public schools everywhere proud. All your moronic ass has done here is went around screaming, "HERE'S WHATS GOING TO HAPPEN - HERE IS EXACTLY WHO IS GOING TO GET THE PIECE OF EQUIPMENT... THE MOST WORTHLESS PLAYER ON YOUR ROSTER IS GOING TO GET THE GEAR! THEN IT WON'T MATTER AT ALL. I HAVE TONS OF WORTHLESS PLAYERS ON MY TEAM THAT SHOULDN'T GET THE GEAR UNLESS I DO FIRST! LIKE, 60-70 PIECES OF GEAR SHOULD BE RELEASED!"

Originally posted by nfratami
Originally posted by Drago


Your claims that if the piece doesn't go to the most elite person on the team then it's wasted are also a bunch of bullshit.

I love how you've openly said there are players on your team that do not matter. Why don't you throw some more of them under the bus.

The fact is even if the EQ doesn't go to the best player, it will still go towards helping the team.


I have never said anything specifically about players on my team, but it isn't surprising that you manipulate my words further. Nor have I said that players don't matter. My point simply was that with more endorsements there will be more chances for excitement for teams.

How about this stupid fuck... (I figure if maybe I throw insults it will make my argument better just like yours)

My 5th WR who mostly spends all his time on special teams could get the award, and you know what, it would help the team, I HAVE NEVER SAID IT WOULDN'T (nice how you find the smallest irrelevant loopholes again). It just wouldn't help the team a lot, probably wouldn't change the outcome of any game, and would be absolutely nothing to get excited about.

Sorry, if I feel that "endorsements" should have a slightly(be sure not to take slightly and manipulate it into 50% of the game having equipment) larger impact, by giving equipment to slightly more people.

And isn't there still mystique if the #1 item given to the lottery winner is head and shoulders above the other couple of guys from that position who get runner up items? I'm not saying give everyone who wins the absolute best piece.


Actually dumbfuck, you've said it several times "What if your #5 LB gets the piece? Then it won't even matter!" Well every player on my team matters - I'm sorry you're stuck on a sack of shit team in a sack of shit league that has players that don't matter. It's really simple to connect the dots on that one - as much as you'd like to backtrack and wish you'd never brought that point up... exactly like you know "how the pieces will be distributed."

Sorry if I'm better at keeping track of your moronic ideas than you are. Maybe you should just take an extra dose of meds this morning.

You also jumped on my idea for not marketing it "to the masses" - so there's your 50% number retard.

Originally posted by nfratami
Originally posted by Drago


Sorry you're too stupid to understand that.


Translated...

Originally posted by Drago


I'm too stupid to understand that in its current suggested form endorsements are a waste of time and better stuff could be added to the game. Odds are they will go to players that don't cause excitement (one of the benefits of endorsements you pointed out) and will just not matter. I am also guilty of coming into this thread, dropping insult after insult and derailing what was once a good discussion all for the sake of mystique.




Hey, if endorsements are a waste of time to you - then just stop with your little whiny bitch thread about how it's not fair you're probably not going to get a piece next year.

"Odds are..." the odds are actually that you don't know how they will be distributed moron, in fact, the odds of that are 100%. So what happens next season when only starters get the pieces because it's tied into something your little peabrain couldn't wrap itself around?

Endorsements shouldn't be given out to pipsqueaks in pussy ass leagues with weak ass teams like yours anyway.

I think I suddenly realized why you're talking about non-starters getting pieces... look how many piles of trash you own on any team.
 
nfratami
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Drago


I don't have an argument because I don't have an argument? Great logic there. Making public schools everywhere proud. All your moronic ass has done here is went around screaming, "HERE'S WHATS GOING TO HAPPEN - HERE IS EXACTLY WHO IS GOING TO GET THE PIECE OF EQUIPMENT... THE MOST WORTHLESS PLAYER ON YOUR ROSTER IS GOING TO GET THE GEAR! THEN IT WON'T MATTER AT ALL. I HAVE TONS OF WORTHLESS PLAYERS ON MY TEAM THAT SHOULDN'T GET THE GEAR UNLESS I DO FIRST! LIKE, 60-70 PIECES OF GEAR SHOULD BE RELEASED!"



Pointing out that someone doesn't have an argument is actually pretty logical when they don't.

All of your caps are bullshit, I don't want the gear, have never said I should, it is just my opinion that more items should be given out, and you disagree.

Originally posted by Drago


Actually dumbfuck, you've said it several times "What if your #5 LB gets the piece? Then it won't even matter!" Well every player on my team matters - I'm sorry you're stuck on a sack of shit team in a sack of shit league that has players that don't matter. It's really simple to connect the dots on that one - as much as you'd like to backtrack and wish you'd never brought that point up... exactly like you know "how the pieces will be distributed."

Sorry if I'm better at keeping track of your moronic ideas than you are. Maybe you should just take an extra dose of meds this morning.

You also jumped on my idea for not marketing it "to the masses" - so there's your 50% number retard.


Arguing the same things back and forth and taking my words out of context.

I never said give equipment to the masses, I said more pieces = would please the masses in that...

More pieces > More Team Excitement > Masses Pleased

Originally posted by Drago

Hey, if endorsements are a waste of time to you - then just stop with your little whiny bitch thread about how it's not fair you're probably not going to get a piece next year.

"Odds are..." the odds are actually that you don't know how they will be distributed moron, in fact, the odds of that are 100%. So what happens next season when only starters get the pieces because it's tied into something your little peabrain couldn't wrap itself around?

Endorsements shouldn't be given out to pipsqueaks in pussy ass leagues with weak ass teams like yours anyway.


Great logic, I said endorsements in their current form were a waste of time, gee I guess the next step would be...I don't know making a suggestion on how to make them not worthless?

Odds are that we don't know anything about anything, I said in the first post that it was an assumption, and have continuely said that I could be wrong, I just wanted to have a discussion about that, you could be right maybe only starters will get it. Maybe they will take that idea from you. Then the thread will have served a purpose. Only starters getting the item would be stupid to all the teams that share roles etc etc, great suggestion though.

Yeah endorsements shouldn't be given out to me, they should only be given to dudes like you who found the game 30 days before me, congrats.

Originally posted by Drago

I think I suddenly realized why you're talking about non-starters getting pieces... look how many piles of trash you own on any team.


What sense does that even make, even if a majority of my players weren't starters I would be arguing against them?!?
 
Link
 
You know nfratami, it takes one helluva a little man to bitch and complain about something that hasn't even been implemented yet. Already crying about how the "impact player" won't get the gear, claiming you know the only "logical" ways they'll be distributed.

Personally I'd STFU and let it play out for year one then formulate your list of complaints. For most of us it's kind of hard to bitch and moan about things that don't yet exist.

By all means, keep on with yourself though - it's entertaining.
 
nfratami
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Clinton Esquire
You know nfratami, it takes one helluva a little man to bitch and complain about something that hasn't even been implemented yet. Already crying about how the "impact player" won't get the gear, claiming you know the only "logical" ways they'll be distributed.


I really am not bitching and complaining at all I have been open to others suggestions and thought and then you and Drago (most him) take extreme offense to my suggest (a suggestion that many support). If anyone is guilty of bitching and complaining it is the two of you.

I provided my OPINION, I always said that my thoughts and discussion were based on what I thought to be a logical assumption, I have always said that it may not be right. I have never said that any other way isn't possible, I have said that some ways aren't likely, like Drago saying maybe only starters will be eligible? lol.

The mods chose to make this an epic suggestion, maybe some of them have seen how endorsements were handled on the test server and think that this is relevant. Who knows? But it is a topic that warrants discussion, and even the dickhead act of you and Drago has provided information and opinion on the subject. That is the point of this forum.

Originally posted by Clinton Esquire
You know nfratami, it takes one helluva a little man to bitch and complain about something that hasn't even been implemented yet. Already crying about how the "impact player" won't get the gear, claiming you know the only "logical" ways they'll be distributed.

Personally I'd STFU and let it play out for year one then formulate your list of complaints. For most of us it's kind of hard to bitch and moan about things that don't yet exist.

By all means, keep on with yourself though - it's entertaining.


This isn't a list of complaints, maybe that is your and Drago's problem, you are viewing this all wrong. I provided my OPINION and wanted to inspire a discussion on the topic.

I love how me providing my opinion on something that was been announced that it is going to be implemented (isn't that existence) is bitching and moaning.

Besides, if you haven't noticed the suggestion forum has a lot of topics dealing with things that don't exist, I mean that is why it is the suggestion forum?

Originally posted by nfratami
I'm sure you guys could have some other ideas.


Originally posted by nfratami

Yeah, there are a lot of possible solutions


My only intent was to spark some discussion about an issue, you guys are taking it so seriously it is ridiculous.
 
groveboy101
offline
Link
 
Drago, what is your whole problem with more than one person getting an endorsement deal?
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.