Originally posted by Atatakakunai
Originally posted by Ken1
Originally posted by tackleb0x
the WR that's blocking shouldnt be able to block 2 or 3 players 99% of the time. The lack of AI on the play is being exploited.
I've shut down, and had teams playing against me shut down, the WR screen.
It can be done. You just can't blitz all the frigging time.
There shouldn't be any defense that shuts everything down. In fact, whether or not the defense called is appropriate to stop the offensive call should have more, rather than less, effect on success.
lol blitzing has nothing to do with that play.
the point is that it is a one go play, it is really hard to defend. I have gotten a slight hang of it out of the 3-2-6, problem then is that formation is incredibly weak against the run, then if you move to a cover 1 to assist the run that leaves the possibility (and yes it DOES freakin happen) that all 3 CBs get blocked by one WR and that safety is too far over to make an effective play, it can go for 6 easily.
It's just overall the way defenders react, there is no going for it, there is no motion, because the pass happens so fast they all freeze in place while one WR sets himself up perfectly to block all the CBs while the other catches the ball, then a light goes off in the CBs heads 'oh yeah we're supposed to be doing something, anyhing at all right now! I know, let's run into this defender!' it's ridiculous, no matter what kind of vision, no matter what kind of speed/agility IT IS AN EXPLOIT. it takes you way overcompensating to stop it and when you way overcompensate to one side you open up easy up the gut runs.
the argument that 'you should be able to guess absolutely perfectly what play I am going to run even though I can set it to run randomly one of these two plays out of the exact same formation' is pretty much BS anyhow, all we have to guess by is where you are on the field and what formation you are in, if these plays will work any time for a large gain or a touchdown you could run either one of them off first down, or off second down, only time you'd have to run the screen is if it is 3rd a long, and even then if you decide to take a '4 down' approach to it you could run it up the gut and get 7 yards, then I;d have to guess which one you do to pick up that extra 3 yards.
The idea that this play is not overpowered is pretty stupid.
Except that I've used it in games or had it used against me in games, and result in something like 5 uses, 3 completions for 2 or fewer yards, 1 incompletion, and 1 gain of 12 yards or so.
That happens a lot.
There are a lot of ways to defend the play well, some of which are in the "predesigned plays." There shouldn't be a "one defense fits all."
As to overuse of any play, there you have a reasonable complaint. If you call a play too often, regardless of the play, it should gradually lose effectiveness.
But since I've seen lots of games where the WR screen was shut down by one or both teams, I don't think it's reasonable to say it's overpowered.