User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Forum > Discuss GLB Issues With Catch22 > NOT A BUG - CLOSED > Medium Coverage pushes me over the edge
Page:
 
tautology
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Bort
Originally posted by islander1

Originally posted by Bort


Buk, I know what I changed. It was one line of an if statement.

If the defender doesn't go right for the ball, he continues to play as if he were playing coverage on the player, which includes having to have reaction time, etc.

Going for the ball is the same no matter if you're going for a PD or int - he still has to turn and head right at the receiver, which means if he doesn't knock it down he'll likely get beat since he would then have to turn around again as the receiver catches it behind him. Thus the "help over the top" part for medium.


We all know this Bukowski is a serial whiner. Appreciate you posting an explanation.


I read in the other thread about an idea for a possible 4th setting - that might be a reasonable idea. Maybe it could make the player head for a point near but still outside the player, or something of the like, so he has a better chance of getting the PD?

What would it be called?


So just to be clear, you are saying that was foremrly no essential difference between Aggressive and Medium settings? (I ask because it seemed to me that there was...)

I suggest "Blanket Coverage" for a new setting. No route jumping (putting yourself badly out of position), but play the ball aggressively.
 
vrshah
offline
Link
 
Bort, it seems like right now there are 9 combined coverage options for DBs as is (3 coverage x 3 INT aggressiveness).

What would a fourth option add that the other three do not?

It seems like you are making coverage more relatable to INT aggressiveness and that is not correct. Coverage should be how tight a CB sticks to a WR not how much he wants to make a play on the ball.

Coverage (loose,medium,tight) should be based on agility and somewhat vision whereas INT aggressiveness should be vision,jumping et. al.

Your definition of coverage as is, is overlapping with INT aggressiveness too much, no?
 
Bukowski
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by islander1
Originally posted by Bort

Buk, I know what I changed. It was one line of an if statement.

If the defender doesn't go right for the ball, he continues to play as if he were playing coverage on the player, which includes having to have reaction time, etc.

Going for the ball is the same no matter if you're going for a PD or int - he still has to turn and head right at the receiver, which means if he doesn't knock it down he'll likely get beat since he would then have to turn around again as the receiver catches it behind him. Thus the "help over the top" part for medium.


We all know this Bukowski is a serial whiner. Appreciate you posting an explanation.


Is that fucking necessary?

We're trying to get something done.

If you don't like it, get out of the thread.
 
Bort
Admin
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by sirallan
I heard blanket coverage
Think that would work out fine.

But what is the difference between medium and loose right now?


Over the top help makes medium play like aggressive, while lack of it makes it work like the non-aggressive setting.
 
islander1
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Bort
Haha, bump may be coming soon. I think it's needed for sure.


quoted for awesomeness.
 
Link
 
What I said in the other thread was a % bar.
So allow the CB to go for the PD 80% of the time + Int 20% of the time.
 
Link
 
Just call it "tight" coverage having the CB closer to the WR would make guys a little happier, maybe a fix/edit for the graphics making the one dot be closer to the other.
 
islander1
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Bukowski
Originally posted by islander1

Originally posted by Bort


Buk, I know what I changed. It was one line of an if statement.

If the defender doesn't go right for the ball, he continues to play as if he were playing coverage on the player, which includes having to have reaction time, etc.

Going for the ball is the same no matter if you're going for a PD or int - he still has to turn and head right at the receiver, which means if he doesn't knock it down he'll likely get beat since he would then have to turn around again as the receiver catches it behind him. Thus the "help over the top" part for medium.


We all know this Bukowski is a serial whiner. Appreciate you posting an explanation.


Is that fucking necessary?

We're trying to get something done.

If you don't like it, get out of the thread.


How about you stop crying about something new every other day. Crying about leaving, crying about not buying more flex, blah blah blah blah blah.

Everything that doesnt go your way ends up in a bug thread. It's comical.
 
Link
 
Originally posted by Bort
Originally posted by sirallan

I heard blanket coverage
Think that would work out fine.

But what is the difference between medium and loose right now?


Over the top help makes medium play like aggressive, while lack of it makes it work like the non-aggressive setting.


Alright makes sense. The big thing I think that changed was that just because the defense was running a cover 2 the CB didn't assume that he had coverage help over the top. Personally I like the change but obviously it wasn't a big hit.
Help over the top should result in the CB playing more aggressive and no help should be the CB playing less aggressive and giving up more catches, but what do I know
 
Bort
Admin
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by tautology
So just to be clear, you are saying that was foremrly no essential difference between Aggressive and Medium settings? (I ask because it seemed to me that there was...)


As far as deciding when to go for the ball, yep, it was the same code block getting activated. I'm not sure if that bug has been there all along or not, but it definitely was not working as intended.

There's a couple other differences relating to reaction time and bonuses/penalties, etc, but as far as the AI logic for player movement it was doing the same thing.
 
The Lurker
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by sirallan
What I said in the other thread was a % bar.
So allow the CB to go for the PD 80% of the time + Int 20% of the time.


I like this idea.
 
Bort
Admin
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by vrshah
Bort, it seems like right now there are 9 combined coverage options for DBs as is (3 coverage x 3 INT aggressiveness).

What would a fourth option add that the other three do not?

It seems like you are making coverage more relatable to INT aggressiveness and that is not correct. Coverage should be how tight a CB sticks to a WR not how much he wants to make a play on the ball.

Coverage (loose,medium,tight) should be based on agility and somewhat vision whereas INT aggressiveness should be vision,jumping et. al.

Your definition of coverage as is, is overlapping with INT aggressiveness too much, no?


I suppose I could "create" that fourth option by making it so if you're set to "close" and "aggressive" it would do what I was thinking with a "move to just above the receiver" action or something.
 
Bukowski
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by islander1
Originally posted by Bukowski

Originally posted by islander1


Originally posted by Bort



Buk, I know what I changed. It was one line of an if statement.

If the defender doesn't go right for the ball, he continues to play as if he were playing coverage on the player, which includes having to have reaction time, etc.

Going for the ball is the same no matter if you're going for a PD or int - he still has to turn and head right at the receiver, which means if he doesn't knock it down he'll likely get beat since he would then have to turn around again as the receiver catches it behind him. Thus the "help over the top" part for medium.


We all know this Bukowski is a serial whiner. Appreciate you posting an explanation.


Is that fucking necessary?

We're trying to get something done.

If you don't like it, get out of the thread.


How about you stop crying about something new every other day. Crying about leaving, crying about not buying more flex, blah blah blah blah blah.

Everything that doesnt go your way ends up in a bug thread. It's comical.


And everything that is a bug, turns into you bashing everyone that tries to get the SIM fixed.

Why do you troll this forum, if you despise it so much?

Why are you even wasting your time in this thread, if you're so much against it?

You bash anyone that ever has anything to say, other than GLB is perfect. You really should apply for moderator status, you would fit right in.
 
Link
 
yeah me too
but it'll only be activated when the "over the top" situation is happening
 
Bort
Admin
offline
Link
 
Now that I think about it, It really sounds like people want to be able to go in and try to break up passes every time without the risk of getting beat, which isn't necessarily the best option for game balance. There does need to be a risk/reward kinda thing.

In RL, if a CB dives in and tries to break up the pass, he could easily fall down or miss it and fly past, etc.
Last edited Nov 28, 2008 21:02:01
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.