Sorry guys... I can't find that combine spreadsheet on my HDD. I am sure someone has a copy of it?
Forum > Suggestions > Weight Classes
SportsFrk
offline
offline
My bias tells me I don't like it because my FS, who I want to be fast, is 200 pounds and is "overweight" by his BMI.
Unbiased, I like the idea. And OMGweight really did seal the deal.
Unbiased, I like the idea. And OMGweight really did seal the deal.
SWVAHoo
offline
offline
Disagree strongly on any base 40-yard-dash time under 4.1. The best of the best track stars BARELY do this.
satandole666
offline
offline
I didn't read all of the thread but...
I like the thought that height/weight can have an effect on the player (moreso than now). However, I haven't cared for the numbers I've seen thrown around. This should never have more effect than spending old fashioned SP. Any numbers over 5-10% are unrealistic IMO, it'll force cookie cutting more than anything.
I like the thought that height/weight can have an effect on the player (moreso than now). However, I haven't cared for the numbers I've seen thrown around. This should never have more effect than spending old fashioned SP. Any numbers over 5-10% are unrealistic IMO, it'll force cookie cutting more than anything.
my only qualm with this is you would pay the SP's to get 100 speed but not really be 100 speed. or pay the FP's to get 100 agility but not really be at 100 agility.
TheInfinity
offline
offline
Originally posted by cdcollins
Disagree strongly on any base 40-yard-dash time under 4.1. The best of the best track stars BARELY do this.
Not to mention you'll be hard pressed to find an elite sprinter thats 160lbs. For the realism, its a touch on the real side and a touch on the unrealistic side. Hard to really get it perfectly right, especially with the fact that you do have freaks in the NFL who are huge but run fast and slow pokes who are small but don't run particularly fast. Not to mention the little guys that will block the hell out of dudes (i.e. 205lb Hines Ward).
Disagree strongly on any base 40-yard-dash time under 4.1. The best of the best track stars BARELY do this.
Not to mention you'll be hard pressed to find an elite sprinter thats 160lbs. For the realism, its a touch on the real side and a touch on the unrealistic side. Hard to really get it perfectly right, especially with the fact that you do have freaks in the NFL who are huge but run fast and slow pokes who are small but don't run particularly fast. Not to mention the little guys that will block the hell out of dudes (i.e. 205lb Hines Ward).
kretchfoop
offline
offline
Here is what I understand about this game...and what I know about real life...
GLB: Agility has a large deal to do with acceleration...speed has next to nothing to do with aglity...you need both.
Real life: Agility is the same thing as your level of your quick-twitch muscle fibers as modified by your anticipation (GLB vision). You can be cerebral and know the game or you can have natural talent. Studs have both and we hear about them...but we also hear about those that dominate in one of them.
I honestly don't think...if agility is being used in the way that I understand...that weight should not have too much to do with speed. Assuming that the game suffers from the same range restrictions as college/NFL, everyone is agile and fast...but the heavier players should have a disadvantage in agilty moreso than speed...while having a disadvatage in both. However, they are bigger bodies and should have an advantage in raw strength. I big body should be better able to take down another big body and suffer when trying to take sown an agile runner. Seems to be working that way. Strategy would be more important and more realistic if this were implemented.
GLB: Agility has a large deal to do with acceleration...speed has next to nothing to do with aglity...you need both.
Real life: Agility is the same thing as your level of your quick-twitch muscle fibers as modified by your anticipation (GLB vision). You can be cerebral and know the game or you can have natural talent. Studs have both and we hear about them...but we also hear about those that dominate in one of them.
I honestly don't think...if agility is being used in the way that I understand...that weight should not have too much to do with speed. Assuming that the game suffers from the same range restrictions as college/NFL, everyone is agile and fast...but the heavier players should have a disadvantage in agilty moreso than speed...while having a disadvatage in both. However, they are bigger bodies and should have an advantage in raw strength. I big body should be better able to take down another big body and suffer when trying to take sown an agile runner. Seems to be working that way. Strategy would be more important and more realistic if this were implemented.
TheInfinity
offline
offline
Originally posted by kretchfoop
Here is what I understand about this game...and what I know about real life...
GLB: Agility has a large deal to do with acceleration...speed has next to nothing to do with aglity...you need both.
Real life: Agility is the same thing as your level of your quick-twitch muscle fibers as modified by your anticipation (GLB vision). You can be cerebral and know the game or you can have natural talent. Studs have both and we hear about them...but we also hear about those that dominate in one of them.
I honestly don't think...if agility is being used in the way that I understand...that weight should not have too much to do with speed. Assuming that the game suffers from the same range restrictions as college/NFL, everyone is agile and fast...but the heavier players should have a disadvantage in agilty moreso than speed...while having a disadvatage in both. However, they are bigger bodies and should have an advantage in raw strength. I big body should be better able to take down another big body and suffer when trying to take sown an agile runner. Seems to be working that way. Strategy would be more important and more realistic if this were implemented.
You're 100% right in your analysis of real life. The trouble I have with it is that in real life the bodies are big because they need Strength at those positions. If people in Goalline Blitz needed the strength, they wouldn't be so fast. But thats the argument I've been plugging to no avail for a good while now. Is it the way I'm wording it? Or am I just wrong in that we should make strength more valuable for positions like Lineman and Linebacker as opposed to making their weight augment things?
Here is what I understand about this game...and what I know about real life...
GLB: Agility has a large deal to do with acceleration...speed has next to nothing to do with aglity...you need both.
Real life: Agility is the same thing as your level of your quick-twitch muscle fibers as modified by your anticipation (GLB vision). You can be cerebral and know the game or you can have natural talent. Studs have both and we hear about them...but we also hear about those that dominate in one of them.
I honestly don't think...if agility is being used in the way that I understand...that weight should not have too much to do with speed. Assuming that the game suffers from the same range restrictions as college/NFL, everyone is agile and fast...but the heavier players should have a disadvantage in agilty moreso than speed...while having a disadvatage in both. However, they are bigger bodies and should have an advantage in raw strength. I big body should be better able to take down another big body and suffer when trying to take sown an agile runner. Seems to be working that way. Strategy would be more important and more realistic if this were implemented.
You're 100% right in your analysis of real life. The trouble I have with it is that in real life the bodies are big because they need Strength at those positions. If people in Goalline Blitz needed the strength, they wouldn't be so fast. But thats the argument I've been plugging to no avail for a good while now. Is it the way I'm wording it? Or am I just wrong in that we should make strength more valuable for positions like Lineman and Linebacker as opposed to making their weight augment things?
Deathblade
offline
offline
Originally posted by TheInfinity
You're 100% right in your analysis of real life. The trouble I have with it is that in real life the bodies are big because they need Strength at those positions. If people in Goalline Blitz needed the strength, they wouldn't be so fast. But thats the argument I've been plugging to no avail for a good while now. Is it the way I'm wording it? Or am I just wrong in that we should make strength more valuable for positions like Lineman and Linebacker as opposed to making their weight augment things?
Strength needs to be more beneficial to defense. At least I am guessing this change would be leaning more towards defense...since most offenses have "normal" builds, it is the defense that has 9 out of 11 positions build like CB's.
You're 100% right in your analysis of real life. The trouble I have with it is that in real life the bodies are big because they need Strength at those positions. If people in Goalline Blitz needed the strength, they wouldn't be so fast. But thats the argument I've been plugging to no avail for a good while now. Is it the way I'm wording it? Or am I just wrong in that we should make strength more valuable for positions like Lineman and Linebacker as opposed to making their weight augment things?
Strength needs to be more beneficial to defense. At least I am guessing this change would be leaning more towards defense...since most offenses have "normal" builds, it is the defense that has 9 out of 11 positions build like CB's.
Dianwei32
offline
offline
Originally posted by TheInfinity
You're 100% right in your analysis of real life. The trouble I have with it is that in real life the bodies are big because they need Strength at those positions. If people in Goalline Blitz needed the strength, they wouldn't be so fast. But thats the argument I've been plugging to no avail for a good while now. Is it the way I'm wording it? Or am I just wrong in that we should make strength more valuable for positions like Lineman and Linebacker as opposed to making their weight augment things?
Finally, we agree on something. Strength needs to play a bigger role, and I'm all for Strength helping to determine a player's weight (all that muscle weighs something).
Random thought: What if players could have certain weight classes removed as options based on their Strength? Not in extreme cases, but OL/DL/Power HBs (positions with very high Strength) could not access the lower weight classes.
Maybe something like if you have <=30 STR, you can choose aney weight class. with 30-40 lightweight gets closed, with 40-50 middleweight and lower are closed. 50-60 light heavyweight and lower are closed... etc. The 10 STR interval was just an example, if Bort likes the idea he can make better intervals. The gist of it is just that a player's "minimum weight" increases with added muscle mass (increased Strength), that would solve the problem of having 160 lb speedy DE's, especially if all the O-linemen are 300+ and get a bonus to blocking for being so huge.
The cutoffs might need to be position specific though... I just remembered that my HB has 80 Strength, and while I would like him to be a little beefier (he's 201 lbs right now, I would like a good 230-240), I don't want him to be 300+ with the O-line.
You're 100% right in your analysis of real life. The trouble I have with it is that in real life the bodies are big because they need Strength at those positions. If people in Goalline Blitz needed the strength, they wouldn't be so fast. But thats the argument I've been plugging to no avail for a good while now. Is it the way I'm wording it? Or am I just wrong in that we should make strength more valuable for positions like Lineman and Linebacker as opposed to making their weight augment things?
Finally, we agree on something. Strength needs to play a bigger role, and I'm all for Strength helping to determine a player's weight (all that muscle weighs something).
Random thought: What if players could have certain weight classes removed as options based on their Strength? Not in extreme cases, but OL/DL/Power HBs (positions with very high Strength) could not access the lower weight classes.
Maybe something like if you have <=30 STR, you can choose aney weight class. with 30-40 lightweight gets closed, with 40-50 middleweight and lower are closed. 50-60 light heavyweight and lower are closed... etc. The 10 STR interval was just an example, if Bort likes the idea he can make better intervals. The gist of it is just that a player's "minimum weight" increases with added muscle mass (increased Strength), that would solve the problem of having 160 lb speedy DE's, especially if all the O-linemen are 300+ and get a bonus to blocking for being so huge.
The cutoffs might need to be position specific though... I just remembered that my HB has 80 Strength, and while I would like him to be a little beefier (he's 201 lbs right now, I would like a good 230-240), I don't want him to be 300+ with the O-line.
chief31
offline
offline
I think the big negative in this is that so many players have been built within the existing peramaters of what value SPEED has, and that value will be taken away, again, with absolutley no compensation. (Same with othet attributes, but Speed is the easy discussion.)
I am all for improving the game. But, if you specifically terminate a players build, then you really owe it to them to allow them to redistribute the players SP.
I have always been in favor of 'respecs' 'rerolls', or whatever you prefer to call it.
The season four changes had players who were made to be amazingly fast that were amazingly effective, have the nerf stick change the effectiveness of the attribute that was so effective for them.
Was that the right thing to do? Yes. (In fact, I don't think they hit it hard enough.)
But they just left all of those players to deal with it. Three season of "wow, this SPEED stuff really works" and convincing your customers that that is the way to build players, to "SPEED is good, but you over-paid for it. Sorry, no refunds."
They sell the effectiveness of SPEED being like (+10 value) then, after you have prchased the product, they specifically diminish that value for you, with absolutely no remorse.
If you want to find out how well the changes that are being made work, then allow everyone to experiment with build types. Otherwise, you will just have to wait for a few seasons to actually see the results, while the new build projects get up to spedd. But then, other changes will be made in the meantime, and you never really will see the actual results.
I think that when you make a major change to the value of the product, you should allow everyone an SP refund on each player.
But then, I know how utterly popular that is around here.
I am all for improving the game. But, if you specifically terminate a players build, then you really owe it to them to allow them to redistribute the players SP.
I have always been in favor of 'respecs' 'rerolls', or whatever you prefer to call it.
The season four changes had players who were made to be amazingly fast that were amazingly effective, have the nerf stick change the effectiveness of the attribute that was so effective for them.
Was that the right thing to do? Yes. (In fact, I don't think they hit it hard enough.)
But they just left all of those players to deal with it. Three season of "wow, this SPEED stuff really works" and convincing your customers that that is the way to build players, to "SPEED is good, but you over-paid for it. Sorry, no refunds."
They sell the effectiveness of SPEED being like (+10 value) then, after you have prchased the product, they specifically diminish that value for you, with absolutely no remorse.
If you want to find out how well the changes that are being made work, then allow everyone to experiment with build types. Otherwise, you will just have to wait for a few seasons to actually see the results, while the new build projects get up to spedd. But then, other changes will be made in the meantime, and you never really will see the actual results.
I think that when you make a major change to the value of the product, you should allow everyone an SP refund on each player.
But then, I know how utterly popular that is around here.

TheInfinity
offline
offline
Originally posted by Dianwei32
Originally posted by TheInfinity
You're 100% right in your analysis of real life. The trouble I have with it is that in real life the bodies are big because they need Strength at those positions. If people in Goalline Blitz needed the strength, they wouldn't be so fast. But thats the argument I've been plugging to no avail for a good while now. Is it the way I'm wording it? Or am I just wrong in that we should make strength more valuable for positions like Lineman and Linebacker as opposed to making their weight augment things?
Finally, we agree on something. Strength needs to play a bigger role, and I'm all for Strength helping to determine a player's weight (all that muscle weighs something).
Random thought: What if players could have certain weight classes removed as options based on their Strength? Not in extreme cases, but OL/DL/Power HBs (positions with very high Strength) could not access the lower weight classes.
Maybe something like if you have <=30 STR, you can choose aney weight class. with 30-40 lightweight gets closed, with 40-50 middleweight and lower are closed. 50-60 light heavyweight and lower are closed... etc. The 10 STR interval was just an example, if Bort likes the idea he can make better intervals. The gist of it is just that a player's "minimum weight" increases with added muscle mass (increased Strength), that would solve the problem of having 160 lb speedy DE's, especially if all the O-linemen are 300+ and get a bonus to blocking for being so huge.
The cutoffs might need to be position specific though... I just remembered that my HB has 80 Strength, and while I would like him to be a little beefier (he's 201 lbs right now, I would like a good 230-240), I don't want him to be 300+ with the O-line.
So the strong get stronger based on the heavy weight bonus and the fast get faster based on the light weight bonus. I'm glad we see eye-to-eye on the whole Strength needs to be more important thing. But with this weight class stuff, I don't think I'm ever going to agree, not because I'm stubborn but because I have yet to hear a great reason as to why this will be useful. I firmly believe SP spending will cover all of our Strength/Speed problems once Strength actually has some value compared to Speed at some positions.
Originally posted by TheInfinity
You're 100% right in your analysis of real life. The trouble I have with it is that in real life the bodies are big because they need Strength at those positions. If people in Goalline Blitz needed the strength, they wouldn't be so fast. But thats the argument I've been plugging to no avail for a good while now. Is it the way I'm wording it? Or am I just wrong in that we should make strength more valuable for positions like Lineman and Linebacker as opposed to making their weight augment things?
Finally, we agree on something. Strength needs to play a bigger role, and I'm all for Strength helping to determine a player's weight (all that muscle weighs something).
Random thought: What if players could have certain weight classes removed as options based on their Strength? Not in extreme cases, but OL/DL/Power HBs (positions with very high Strength) could not access the lower weight classes.
Maybe something like if you have <=30 STR, you can choose aney weight class. with 30-40 lightweight gets closed, with 40-50 middleweight and lower are closed. 50-60 light heavyweight and lower are closed... etc. The 10 STR interval was just an example, if Bort likes the idea he can make better intervals. The gist of it is just that a player's "minimum weight" increases with added muscle mass (increased Strength), that would solve the problem of having 160 lb speedy DE's, especially if all the O-linemen are 300+ and get a bonus to blocking for being so huge.
The cutoffs might need to be position specific though... I just remembered that my HB has 80 Strength, and while I would like him to be a little beefier (he's 201 lbs right now, I would like a good 230-240), I don't want him to be 300+ with the O-line.
So the strong get stronger based on the heavy weight bonus and the fast get faster based on the light weight bonus. I'm glad we see eye-to-eye on the whole Strength needs to be more important thing. But with this weight class stuff, I don't think I'm ever going to agree, not because I'm stubborn but because I have yet to hear a great reason as to why this will be useful. I firmly believe SP spending will cover all of our Strength/Speed problems once Strength actually has some value compared to Speed at some positions.
makbeer
offline
offline
it should also have an effect on ability to be tackled/make tackles
so there would still be some viability to a slightly heavier WR, who while not as fast would be a pain in the rear for 160 lb CBs to bring down
so there would still be some viability to a slightly heavier WR, who while not as fast would be a pain in the rear for 160 lb CBs to bring down
You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.




























