User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Forum > Suggestions > Suggestion to help with low down GM's trading away players
Page:
 
oldskool
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by crazy454
Originally posted by oldskool

What's stopping me from hiring 80 GMs to do everything for my team, and then getting to cherrypick amongst their results to build my team? If they sign someone I don't want I pass on them, if they trade improperly I renege on it, if they try to release someone I stop it......


You forgot to add, if they find good players you sign them.

All those things you mentioned make a ton of sense. It would make building a team easier and more efficient.


Except for the player who has all his other contract offers auto-rejected only to find the owner vetoed the move and he's back in the market.
Or the guy who breaks off talks for trades only to have an owner jump in at the last second and nix it so they're all stuck with teams that now hate them for wanting to be traded out.
Or the guy who wants his release and negotiates a contract through PMs with a new team only to find he's still on his old team thanks to an owner blocking the release to be a douche.

It requires a complete overhaul of the signing, releasing and trading mechanics to have an extra OK required before it actually happens, and all it does is reward lazy owners who "let" GMs do all the work because they don't have to risk anything on THEIR investment by letting someone else run it.
 
CDZYO
offline
Link
 
Owners don't need more "protection" from GMs. Yes, it can be tough to run a franchise, and it can be tougher to find the right GM. Sometimes you hire Bill Parcells, sometimes you hire Matt Millen. It happens.

I'm not a fan of this suggestion.
 
23yrwej
offline
Link
 
Basic summary:
-Crazy has a decent idea.
-People make the same old comment don't give the GM powers which we know doesn't happen either ways.
-Prokop makes himself look like an idiot.
-A bunch of arguing
-The suggestion is basically lost because of the arguing.

Crazy my opinion is that it's a decent idea but the problem with allowing owners to retract trades is that they will anger people by accepting a trade then retracting it as soon as they get a better offer. You used to be allowed to retract trades until 2 AM EST but it just angered people. And the whole owner approval when making trades is basically just giving them trade powers, they can always just work trades out through PMs and PM the owner to finish it so adding that would basically change nothing.
 
Mr. Me2
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by prokop
Originally posted by crazy454



LOL I have seen people that were "truly trusted" it takes one wrong thing said and they give it to you.


doubt it.


Then you haven't been around. I've seen it happen. I've even seen the bitching about it on the forums after the fact.
 
Mr. Me2
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by oldskool
Originally posted by crazy454

Originally posted by oldskool


What's stopping me from hiring 80 GMs to do everything for my team, and then getting to cherrypick amongst their results to build my team? If they sign someone I don't want I pass on them, if they trade improperly I renege on it, if they try to release someone I stop it......


You forgot to add, if they find good players you sign them.

All those things you mentioned make a ton of sense. It would make building a team easier and more efficient.


Except for the player who has all his other contract offers auto-rejected only to find the owner vetoed the move and he's back in the market.
Or the guy who breaks off talks for trades only to have an owner jump in at the last second and nix it so they're all stuck with teams that now hate them for wanting to be traded out.
Or the guy who wants his release and negotiates a contract through PMs with a new team only to find he's still on his old team thanks to an owner blocking the release to be a douche.

It requires a complete overhaul of the signing, releasing and trading mechanics to have an extra OK required before it actually happens, and all it does is reward lazy owners who "let" GMs do all the work because they don't have to risk anything on THEIR investment by letting someone else run it.


I wasn't aware that you could offer trades to a player who already had a trade pending. In fact, I'm pretty sure it didn't work the last time I tried, so there would be no "pending offers rejected" that you are talking about. This is trades, not free agent contracts.
 
papaschnay2
offline
Link
 
I can see the benefits of this idea.

If one of my GMs goes hog wild on my team and I don't log on in the first hour of it happening, damn right I'd want to fix it. I wouldn't care if I pissed other people off, everyone's out for #1 anyways, aren't they?

TBH, on my team I don't have this problem...but I could DEFINITELY see how this could take effect. Crazy, I LIKE the idea...just my humble opinion
 
PatsFan94
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by prokop
or dont give GM trading privileges


Nah man the guy had been a trustworthy GM for 3 full seasons before he decided to go off on the team.
 
oldskool
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by silenthatred
I wasn't aware that you could offer trades to a player who already had a trade pending. In fact, I'm pretty sure it didn't work the last time I tried, so there would be no "pending offers rejected" that you are talking about. This is trades, not free agent contracts.


I said "breaks off talks", i.e. PM of "Trade accepted by so-and-so, sorry you didn't win, hope you find that player!" sent, a day later "oh plz trade for me again owner rejected trade at last minute and it didn't go through".
 
Mr. Me2
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by oldskool
Originally posted by silenthatred

I wasn't aware that you could offer trades to a player who already had a trade pending. In fact, I'm pretty sure it didn't work the last time I tried, so there would be no "pending offers rejected" that you are talking about. This is trades, not free agent contracts.


I said "breaks off talks", i.e. PM of "Trade accepted by so-and-so, sorry you didn't win, hope you find that player!" sent, a day later "oh plz trade for me again owner rejected trade at last minute and it didn't go through".


No you said "Except for the player who has all his other contract offers auto-rejected"
Unless I'm crazy, "breaking off talks" isn't the same as "auto-rejected."
 
SwagOnLock
offline
Link
 
He said both
 
blump
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by oldskool


Except for the player who has all his other contract offers auto-rejected only to find the owner vetoed the move and he's back in the market.
Or the guy who breaks off talks for trades only to have an owner jump in at the last second and nix it so they're all stuck with teams that now hate them for wanting to be traded out.
Or the guy who wants his release and negotiates a contract through PMs with a new team only to find he's still on his old team thanks to an owner blocking the release to be a douche.

It requires a complete overhaul of the signing, releasing and trading mechanics to have an extra OK required before it actually happens, and all it does is reward lazy owners who "let" GMs do all the work because they don't have to risk anything on THEIR investment by letting someone else run it.


The idea of "trade with owner approval" checkbox trumps all of your objections.

The trade wouldn't go through until the owner accepts, the way I see it. The GM could set up the trade, offer it, PM the guy and let him know he's just waiting for the owner to click the button.

 
The UnderDawg
offline
Link
 
Case in point, go look up Muddslinger949, hes an owner in the GLBPA. Check the black listed owner list.
 
BoxwrencH
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by SwagOnLock
Originally posted by Kcirdor

Originally posted by SwagOnLock


I don't have any problem with this really. Though there are ways for a proactive owner to prevent this from happening in the first place.


why is it that when people come up with good stuff to add to the game to make it more rounded. We get these types of responses. "there are ways to do so already". This is a crock of bs. Rather then say this why not offer an idea up to improve the suggestion.


Well I literally just explained this, and quite reasonably at that, so:

Originally posted by SwagOnLock

I think there's just a school of thought on here that believes there's no pressing need to implement things that his. Don't give any GMs trade permissiesourceful and using their heads.


Here's my solution to this. Don't give any GMs trade permissions. Have them PM you, or post in the forum, when they have identified a trade target. They still do all the legwork of tracking down a player worth trading for, all you as an owner have to do is actually go through with it. The GM still carries out his responsibilities, and there is a 0% chance of any funny business.

Be proactive.



Because trades are time sensitive and there is a window of opportunity. If Bort makes the check box the last thing to approve before the trade goes through, you've locked in the potential player and all is well. With your method, by the time the owner reads the pm from his GM, the player has signed with another team - your competition. 0% your GM got the trade done.

I like the idea - bump for Bort and his ever overloaded admin staff to implement a good idea and possibly save them time for dealing with support tickets from owners with this problem.
Last edited Nov 15, 2008 22:41:07
 
Kcirdor
offline
Link
 
why would someone want to GM if they couldn't offer trades? that is retarded. Let them offer the trades but make it so the owner has to accept the trade before it is official. Anything objecting to this is just someone trying to bash a good idea.
 
Kcirdor
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by oldskool
What you're suggesting is that owners get the benefits of letting other people do the grunt work for their team while eliminating the risk that comes along with it.


yay, you understand.
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.