User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Forum > Suggestions > Has there been any discussion of instituting NCAA overtime rules?
Page:
 
SwagOnLock
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by SwagOnLock
I'm happy to see the dissent because 1) you're among the first to disagree with the idea and 2) the VERY first to give any substantial reason why.

I understand what you're saying about going out and stopping somebody. That's football, play defense, get it done, I get it. But a sudden death overtime makes absolutely no sense in a sport where there are specific defensive units, and specific offensive units. In hockey? Sure. Everyone on the ice has to play defense, and everyone on the ice has to play offense. In soccer? Same deal. Football isn't like that.

In football, you're only playing one half of a team against the other half of a team. It goes against the very spirit of the sport.


I'll add basketball to this, it was so obvious I forgot to mention it.
 
czman
offline
Link
 
Taking the game more towards college is the wrong way to go. Bort is trying to create an NFL sim.

32 teams
16 games
playoff structure
the plays are indicative of NFL type plays more than college or high school.
Lastly, the overtime system. I doubt he will ever change it.

It is clear what Bort is trying to simulate.....American Pro Football.

I for one hope he fixes the issues with mechanics that cause problems and leaves overtime the way it is.
 
SwagOnLock
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by czman
Taking the game more towards college is the wrong way to go. Bort is trying to create an NFL sim.


Whoops. Thanks for playing. See ya later.
 
czman
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by SwagOnLock
Originally posted by SwagOnLock

I'm happy to see the dissent because 1) you're among the first to disagree with the idea and 2) the VERY first to give any substantial reason why.

I understand what you're saying about going out and stopping somebody. That's football, play defense, get it done, I get it. But a sudden death overtime makes absolutely no sense in a sport where there are specific defensive units, and specific offensive units. In hockey? Sure. Everyone on the ice has to play defense, and everyone on the ice has to play offense. In soccer? Same deal. Football isn't like that.

In football, you're only playing one half of a team against the other half of a team. It goes against the very spirit of the sport.


I'll add basketball to this, it was so obvious I forgot to mention it.


Basketball plays an entire period it does not have sudden death.

 
Knick
Sknickers
offline
Link
 
I like the way most is set up.

However I feel College OT is vastly superior to NFL OT.

That said, you are probably the opposite.
 
SwagOnLock
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by czman
Originally posted by SwagOnLock

Originally posted by SwagOnLock


I'm happy to see the dissent because 1) you're among the first to disagree with the idea and 2) the VERY first to give any substantial reason why.

I understand what you're saying about going out and stopping somebody. That's football, play defense, get it done, I get it. But a sudden death overtime makes absolutely no sense in a sport where there are specific defensive units, and specific offensive units. In hockey? Sure. Everyone on the ice has to play defense, and everyone on the ice has to play offense. In soccer? Same deal. Football isn't like that.

In football, you're only playing one half of a team against the other half of a team. It goes against the very spirit of the sport.


I'll add basketball to this, it was so obvious I forgot to mention it.


Basketball plays an entire period it does not have sudden death.



No I know just merely pointing out how football is entirely unique.
 
czman
offline
Link
 
The other problem with this idea is the huge XP bug that could happen.

If two owners get together and punt every down the game will never end everyone will get max XP. I am sure two gutted teams would try this.

Plus Bort's servers would start to smoke and I think the GLB universe would implode.
 
czman
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by czman
The other problem with this idea is the huge XP bug that could happen.

If two owners get together and punt every down the game will never end everyone will get max XP. I am sure two gutted teams would try this.

Plus Bort's servers would start to smoke and I think the GLB universe would implode.


The college system only works because it assumes people want to win. That is not the case in GLB.
 
SwagOnLock
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by czman
The other problem with this idea is the huge XP bug that could happen.

If two owners get together and punt every down the game will never end everyone will get max XP. I am sure two gutted teams would try this.

Plus Bort's servers would start to smoke and I think the GLB universe would implode.


You're right, there is no imaginable fix for this. Lock thread. Idea over.
 
Knick
Sknickers
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by czman
Originally posted by czman

The other problem with this idea is the huge XP bug that could happen.

If two owners get together and punt every down the game will never end everyone will get max XP. I am sure two gutted teams would try this.

Plus Bort's servers would start to smoke and I think the GLB universe would implode.


The college system only works because it assumes people want to win. That is not the case in GLB.


fuck...........
 
czman
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by SwagOnLock
Originally posted by czman

The other problem with this idea is the huge XP bug that could happen.

If two owners get together and punt every down the game will never end everyone will get max XP. I am sure two gutted teams would try this.

Plus Bort's servers would start to smoke and I think the GLB universe would implode.


You're right, there is no imaginable fix for this. Lock thread. Idea over.


Sorry man. It was fun while it lasted.
 
SwagOnLock
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by czman
Originally posted by SwagOnLock

Originally posted by czman


The other problem with this idea is the huge XP bug that could happen.

If two owners get together and punt every down the game will never end everyone will get max XP. I am sure two gutted teams would try this.

Plus Bort's servers would start to smoke and I think the GLB universe would implode.


You're right, there is no imaginable fix for this. Lock thread. Idea over.


Sorry man. It was fun while it lasted.


Haha. Yeah I was being very sarcastic. It would be exceedingly easy to not count XP in this overtime system. That's more of a nitpicky thing than the PAT issue.

 
czman
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by SwagOnLock
Originally posted by czman

Originally posted by SwagOnLock


Originally posted by czman



The other problem with this idea is the huge XP bug that could happen.

If two owners get together and punt every down the game will never end everyone will get max XP. I am sure two gutted teams would try this.

Plus Bort's servers would start to smoke and I think the GLB universe would implode.


You're right, there is no imaginable fix for this. Lock thread. Idea over.


Sorry man. It was fun while it lasted.


Haha. Yeah I was being very sarcastic. It would be exceedingly easy to not count XP in this overtime system. That's more of a nitpicky thing than the PAT issue.



Even if you do not count XP the game would never end. There would be no way to end it. Even if you did not allow punts teams could still do kneel downs once implemented. Teams could also put a non-kicker at the kicker position and miss every 40 yard FG.
 
SwagOnLock
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by czman
Originally posted by SwagOnLock

Originally posted by czman


Originally posted by SwagOnLock



Originally posted by czman




The other problem with this idea is the huge XP bug that could happen.

If two owners get together and punt every down the game will never end everyone will get max XP. I am sure two gutted teams would try this.

Plus Bort's servers would start to smoke and I think the GLB universe would implode.


You're right, there is no imaginable fix for this. Lock thread. Idea over.


Sorry man. It was fun while it lasted.


Haha. Yeah I was being very sarcastic. It would be exceedingly easy to not count XP in this overtime system. That's more of a nitpicky thing than the PAT issue.



Even if you do not count XP the game would never end. There would be no way to end it. Even if you did not allow punts teams could still do kneel downs once implemented. Teams could also put a non-kicker at the kicker position and miss every 40 yard FG.


Teams could do the same thing with the system we have now. What's your point?
 
czman
offline
Link
 
The other problem is people could view it as a way to win awards. Play terrible defense and just keep letting each other score. We would have two gutted teams HBs getting 50 TDs when they played each other.

Again the college system only works because people want to win.
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.