User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Forum > Suggestions > New Plays/Playbooks
Page:
 
Bort
Admin
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by GG
[This is kinda the problem here, because Bort has programmed the football skills very HIGH by default to allow low level players to actually play a good standard of football that makes it as realistic as the pros in terms of completions, catches, etc.


Probably because I give in to bitching too often. Everyone wants their player to be perfect.
 
ron2288
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by GG
EDIT....

CBs and WRs could play WR and CB as well.

And OL is simple enough...all OL can play in the OL. Dont allow anyone else.


your on top of it ...i think Boert should hire you as his sidekick...
 
Gustoon
offline
Link
 
Just had a look at all the new AI and custom settings, wow!!!! Can't wait to try all these out. This should make lower levelled teams much more competitive against higher levels, if used properly.
Good Stuff, like it
 
GG
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Bort
Originally posted by GG

[This is kinda the problem here, because Bort has programmed the football skills very HIGH by default to allow low level players to actually play a good standard of football that makes it as realistic as the pros in terms of completions, catches, etc.


Probably because I give in to bitching too often. Everyone wants their player to be perfect.


The thing I mean by that is that i totally understand and agree it needs to be done to allow low level teams/players/leagues a realistic high standard of football, otherwise it'd be impossible to play/enjoy GLB.

But the area that leaves open is where you see level 30 WRs who have 100 speed, 60 agility, and they leave everything else at 20 and they can get away with it. Their player scores 16 TDs, goes for 1,600 yards, only drops 12 balls all season...YET....they only have 15 confidence, 20 vision, 20 catching, 15 carrying etc. That's where it's a problem. It's that kind of non-realism of builds that shouldnt mean good/successful players like that. Things like confidence, vision, stamina should be made even more important. And things like throwing, catching, carrying, etc (all the football skills) should be made lower as they get higher in levels.
Last edited Nov 2, 2008 03:55:34
 
Deathblade
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Bort

Probably because I give in to bitching too often. Everyone wants their player to be perfect.


That you do Bort...that you do Not that it is always bad, but the vocal people are sometimes in the minority, and a lot of times they are not doing it in the best interest of the game, they are doing it in their own best interest.

Could you make it so that football skills are more important as you level or something like that? It seems like it would already be in place, but like make it so that 20 carrying on a level 1 is great, but to keep that same "greatness", by level 40, carrying would need to be like 60-70.
 
GG
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Deathblade

Could you make it so that football skills are more important as you level or something like that? It seems like it would already be in place, but like make it so that 20 carrying on a level 1 is great, but to keep that same "greatness", by level 40, carrying would need to be like 60-70.


Exactly what I mean. The higher level you go, the more you need pts in your football skills otherwise you get worse.

 
Amyrlin
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by GG
Originally posted by Bort

Originally posted by GG


[This is kinda the problem here, because Bort has programmed the football skills very HIGH by default to allow low level players to actually play a good standard of football that makes it as realistic as the pros in terms of completions, catches, etc.


Probably because I give in to bitching too often. Everyone wants their player to be perfect.


The thing I mean by that is that i totally understand and agree it needs to be done to allow low level teams/players/leagues a realistic high standard of football, otherwise it'd be impossible to play/enjoy GLB.

But the area that leaves open is where you see level 30 WRs who have 100 speed, 60 agility, and they leave everything else at 20 and they can get away with it. Their player scores 16 TDs, goes for 1,600 yards, only drops 12 balls all season...YET....they only have 15 confidence, 20 vision, 20 catching, 15 carrying etc. That's where it's a problem.


Hmm.

I can think of a couple solutions to this.

1) As the player's level increases, his football skill requirement increases. A player with a football skill below the required level incurs a penalty when he tries to use that skill - the lower the skill, the more penalty. (Basically what DB said.) On the flip side, maybe a player with a football skill higher than some (higher) level would get an added bonus?

2) When a player tries to do something, the relevant football skill(s) are compared to the relevant physical skill(s). If the football skill is lower than a certain threshold computed from the physical skills, the player incurs a penalty - again, the lower the football skill, the higher the penalty. So a player with 30 strength may only need 20 throwing to perform adequately - but a player with 70 strength would require 45 throwing to perform at the same level. A player with 70 strength and 20 throwing would throw horribly. (IMO the best solution.)
 
Bort
Admin
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Amyrlin
2) When a player tries to do something, the relevant football skill(s) are compared to the relevant physical skill(s). If the football skill is lower than a certain threshold computed from the physical skills, the player incurs a penalty - again, the lower the football skill, the higher the penalty. So a player with 30 strength may only need 20 throwing to perform adequately - but a player with 70 strength would require 45 throwing to perform at the same level. A player with 70 strength and 20 throwing would throw horribly. (IMO the best solution.)


That's already kinda how it works. Whenever I've cranked up the effect, the bugs forum goes crazy
 
Llyranwyar
offline
Link
 
Let's say that a QB1 spot was put in.

Let's say that there are several teams that build a pure passer and a pure runner and switch them out per play.

Lets say that bort makes the changes to allow the DC to scout the other team, identify that the Team uses a pure rushing QB1, and make a QB rush specific defensive selection.

Then lets say the team in question running the QB is aware that this is an important game against a DC who will put the time in to do all that. You still get screwed when he makes the last minute switch to pocket pass QB1 offense. He reverses his offense to put his rush QB at QB and pass QB at QB1. Suddenly everything is reversed and you are defending the run on pass plays and vice versa.

The only way I could think of to fix that, is to instead make the DC able to create a list of "seleceted player names" for your opponent that would trigger your alternate defenses. Have fun figuring out all of those special characters.

I just see that getting very complex.
Last edited Nov 2, 2008 04:10:20
 
GG
offline
Link
 
Another area that could do with tweaking is stamina.

Think of those speed DEs or speed WRs with just 15 stamina and 80-100 speed. What you see currently is them being able to play 3 or more snaps without seeing any change in their speed. What should happen tho with only 15 stamina is that it has a real effect on their physical attributes...their speed will get slower, their strength will get weaker, their agility will get stiffer.

This would happen in consecutive plays they play, and over the course of a game. Instead, currently, they retain their top speed/strength all thru the game even tho they have stamina at about 15-30.

Low stamina should mean they TIRE more and more and has a real effect on their speed, strength, agility, jumping.
Last edited Nov 2, 2008 04:09:11
 
Deathblade
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Llyranwyar

The only way I could think of to fix that, is to instead make the DC able to create a list of "seleceted player names" for your opponent that would trigger your alternate defenses. Have fun figuring out all of those special characters.

I just see that getting very complex.


Well...there could be a box on the defensive input box where you can insert a name, and if the name matches a player on the other team, then that input triggers. Or hell, it could even be done by player ID, manually inserted by the DC.

Something like "_______ is in game". It could be filled in with..."#124567 is in game"
Last edited Nov 2, 2008 04:13:33
 
Mike Rogers
Lead Tester
offline
Link
 
Bort did you decide not to set a minimum number of plays per group???

If thats the case then I can send you a PM about a planned Exploit that is already doing the rounds.
 
Amyrlin
offline
Link
 
Ah.

I'd suggest announcing during this off-season that football skills will be much more important in season 7 - WRs will need catching, RBs will need carrying, LBs will need tackling, etc.

Then when season 7 comes, nobody can claim to have been taken by surprise and that their builds are now junk. Not that it was really a valid complaint in the first place. I mean, most of us are aware that wide receivers do, in fact, need to be able to catch the ball, and have built accordingly. People that think WRs need speed speed speed and no catching SHOULD drop passes. There's a reason why Troy Williamson ain't a star...
 
Bort
Admin
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Mike Rogers
Bort did you decide not to set a minimum number of plays per group???

If thats the case then I can send you a PM about a planned Exploit that is already doing the rounds.


go for it - min plays is currently 1 per group since some groups only have 2 plays I think.
 
Deathblade
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Mike Rogers
Bort did you decide not to set a minimum number of plays per group???

If thats the case then I can send you a PM about a planned Exploit that is already doing the rounds.


You may as well just post it...if Bort finds it bad enough, he will change it, and it isn't like someone can take advantage of it for tomorrow's games.
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.