User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Forum > Discuss GLB Issues With Catch22 > NOT A BUG - CLOSED > Defense AI occasionally not followed
Page:
 
Link
 
Originally posted by SteelersInsider
Originally posted by RAPB

SI wants you to find out yourself... so go like

- split up the inputs like 900 - 600 seconds, 599 - 300 seconds and 299 - 0 seconds
- so per quarter you'd get 3 inputs most likely to be called
- make to each input an output 3-4, cover 0, man under, pass focus, weak side shift and a different combination of blitzers

combinations:
- you know that LILB + SS + FS + ROLB works; the OP posts this plays himself
- he'd probably wanted to call something like LILB+FS+ROLB+LOLB (so the SS would cover the TE)
- try to blitz all 4 LBs too
- try to blitz both ILBs and both safeties
- try both OLBs and both safeties
- don't forget to add an additional blitzer to the LILB + SS + FS + ROLB - combination. Maybe the RILB, the LOLB or one of the CBs.

(just get 12 different combinations)

Then below all, you set an input all blank and the only output "goalline"

There you go! Whenever it shows the goalline defense, you hit a forbidden play.

...

(not funny... isn't it?)



This guy is smart. And then when you find the answer, keep it to yourself though. Or only share with a few select people.

Or you can waste all that time narrowing down stuff and give it to all of your competitors like BB_tw wants me to do.



or you simply don't know but pretend you know something. Again, If you knew, you would have already said it out loud and acted like you are superior to everyone.
 
Link
 
Originally posted by buffalobills_tw
Originally posted by SteelersInsider

The defense I showed was from season 2 and is no longer valid. It was meant to show a point that Bort doesn't tell us everything about all the defenses, not to solve the OP's problems.

I said I would help solve the OP's problems if he let us know what the settings were for that particular defense that is having problems (not his whole defense).

But he wants to keep it a secret. So nothing we can do.


Then show a valid case before you insist it is not a bug. OP doesn't need to give you access to his AI. Since you claim you know what the problem is, you can simply tell him what blitz package cause 3-4 cover 0 being skipped.

Both ways will result him knowing what the problem is anyway.

Again, stop the I-want-to-keep-it-as-secret nosense. If you knew, you would have already said it out loud and acted like you are superior to everyone.



I give up. You don't comprehend. It isn't sinking in. I'm going to go help someone else in the Bug section who wants some help.

 
RAPB
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by buffalobills_tw
...

There are 924 combinations since SI may spin and say setting blitz percentage to players not in the lineup, for example, MLB in 3-4. Besides, I'm pretty sure he doesn't know, otherwise, he would have said it already and laughed at everyone not agree with him.


So what about this one:

- you set your scrimmage up like I said and POST THE COMBINATIONS HERE
- SI just says "yes or no" to the fact that one (or more than one) of those combinations will trigger a failure
- he sends you a PM then prior to the game
- you DON'T OPEN this PM till the game is over

If SI is right, you make a player "I (heart) SteelersInsider" and keep him for at least 2 seasons active and a good guy. If SI can't tell, he makes a player "Pittsburgh - home of the lame" (same deal).
 
Link
 
Originally posted by RAPB
Originally posted by buffalobills_tw

...

There are 924 combinations since SI may spin and say setting blitz percentage to players not in the lineup, for example, MLB in 3-4. Besides, I'm pretty sure he doesn't know, otherwise, he would have said it already and laughed at everyone not agree with him.


So what about this one:

- you set your scrimmage up like I said and POST THE COMBINATIONS HERE
- SI just says "yes or no" to the fact that one (or more than one) of those combinations will trigger a failure
- he sends you a PM then prior to the game
- you DON'T OPEN this PM till the game is over

If SI is right, you make a player "I (heart) SteelersInsider" and keep him for at least 2 seasons active and a good guy. If SI can't tell, he makes a player "Pittsburgh - home of the lame" (same deal).


Why don't we make it easier? SI tells us what blitz package makes 3-4 cover 0 being skipped, if it is proved correctly, I create a player and ..., if not, he create a player and .......

Another interesting thing is that SI said he wanted to help OP but didn't have access to AI. Let's assume OP somehow agrees to give him access and SI checks his "secret" there to find the problem, don't SI plan to let OP know? If so, he couldn't keep it as secret like he wants to do.

Last edited Oct 15, 2008 16:18:41
 
RAPB
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by buffalobills_tw
...

Why don't we make it easier? SI tells us what blitz package makes 3-4 cover 0 being skipped, if it is proved correctly, I create a player and ..., if not, he create a player and .......

Another interesting thing is that SI said he wanted to help OP but didn't have access to AI. Let's assume OP somehow agrees to give him access and SI checked his case there to find the problem, didn't SI plan to let OP know? If so, he couldn't keep it as secret like he wants to do.


I see his point though. A lot of owners and GMs don't even bother to watch the gamefilm closely and try to find out themselfes. They just put some wierd blitz settings in and/or never keep track of their plays.

Now if there's a post just saying:

Never do the following:

3-4, cover 0:
blitz any of these combinations
- ... + ... + ...
- ... + ... + ...
- ... + ... + ...
have any of these combinations
- ... underneath, ... focus

3-4, cover 1: blitz any of these combinations
- ... + ... + ...
- ... + ... + ...
- ... + ... + ...

... all of these non-caring GMs make use of what some guys found out. And they probably don't even understand what they are doing!

So I really understand the idea of "won't give away what you don't earned" - while helping some caring and interested guy once in a while.
 
Link
 
Since he wants to help OP, how about he let OP know the blitz package cause 3-4 cover 0 to be skipped? he'd let OP know anyway no matter it is OP gives him AI access or SI tells OP what to look for. In this case, we don't know his secret and OP can verify the bug.
Last edited Oct 15, 2008 16:35:15
 
Link
 
Originally posted by buffalobills_tw
Since he wants to help OP, how about he let OP know the blitz package cause 3-4 cover 0 to be skipped? he'd let OP know anyway no matter it is OP gives him AI access or SI tells OP what to look for. In this case, we don't know his secret and OP can verify the bug.


I did tell you and the OP what to look for:

A combo that doesn't exist in Bort's defensive playbook. We've established now that some offenses don't exist. I'm also telling you that some defenses don't exist. RAPD has gone about showing you how to "test" for them.

Especially since it looks like Hazy has alot of bad teams in his league, he still has 20+ quarters of football to play before the playoffs, right? Test 20 different combinations of the defense that isn't working and see which one it is. Problem solved.

Then when he finds the answer, he can post it here for everyone to know or he can keep it to himself.

Rather than give him the answer, RAPB and I just showed you and the OP how to test things out and solve your own problems. If 20 quarters isn't enough to find the error, do what alot of us like Tim Harper and myself are doing: schedule additional scrimmage games.

But we pay 15 FP's for those. I sure as hell am not going to give up a secret that it took me 3 scrimmage games (45 FP's) to find. 45 FP's is shit (45 cents), but it is the more of the time factor like I said.

Last edited Oct 15, 2008 16:51:02
 
Link
 
BB-

Why are you upset about this? You aren't even on the OP's team? (from what I can see)

Nor have you even linked to an error that you found in your own AI.

You are just being lazy and trying to get free secrets without even at least doing the work that hazy did in narrowing it down a little.....

Last edited Oct 15, 2008 16:53:28
 
Link
 
Originally posted by SteelersInsider
BB-

Why are you upset about this? You aren't even on the OP's team? (from what I can see)

Nor have you even linked to an error that you found in your own AI.

You are just being lazy and trying to get free secrets without even at least doing the work that hazy did in narrowing it down a little.....



Why? because I simply don't trust you.

If you knew what caused 3-4 cover 0 to be skipped in defense AI, you would have already said it and acted like you are superior to everyone. Besides, you just said it yesterday that you didn't know much about 3-4, but then suddenly you said you knew what caused this bug.

And stop calling me lazy. If I'm lazy, I won't even spend time to write my own greasemonkey script to do scouting. Also stop mixing up user errors in AI and bug in skipping plays, they are different. I don't want to know your so called secret, I'm doing pretty well in defense AI. You wanted to help OP, tell him what blitz package would cause 3-4 cover 0 being skipped, don't use vague words like you usually do. OP can verify if you are real or not. I don't want to have FP involved in this since it may violate rules. I'd offer to run my scouting script for your team this offseason if it is proved true and you only need to tell OP.

Last edited Oct 15, 2008 17:07:07
 
Link
 
what does trusting me have to do with anything?

trust the other 1,988 owners who aren't having this problem.

The more elaborate your defenses, the more chances you have of hitting a defense that doesn't exist. And I did notice from watching a few games that Hazy has some blitzes that 90% of teams haven't tried to run (like his "base" defense of the double safety blitz). I don't have all 9,000+ combinations (or however many there are) mapped out, but I told you what the answer is.

Yes, it's time consuming to find it, but Bort would have to do the exact same thing and spend all day finding. Then when he did find it, he would just see that he didn't make a play for that combo yet. Then he could either make that combo (and waste another day) or he could just choose to mark it on his list of things to add (which has to be 40 pages long by now). In which case, he'd just ignore this thread (like he has chosen to do).

 
Link
 
Originally posted by SteelersInsider
what does trusting me have to do with anything?

trust the other 1,988 owners who aren't having this problem.


It has everything to do with trusting you since 1999 owners don't see a blitz package cause 3-4 cover 0 to be skipped. And why did you try to imply this phenomenon doesn't exist when you claim you know what cause 3-4 cover 0 being skipped and it is a secret?

And the following is my edit words in case you don't see it:

And stop calling me lazy. If I'm lazy, I won't even spend time to write my own greasemonkey script to do scouting. Also stop mixing up user errors in AI and bug in skipping plays, they are different. I don't want to know your so called secret, I'm doing pretty well in defense AI. You wanted to help OP, tell him what blitz package would cause 3-4 cover 0 being skipped, don't use vague words like you usually do. OP can verify if you are real or not. I don't want to have FP involved in this since it may violate rules. I'd offer to run my scouting script for your team this offseason if it is proved true and you only need to tell OP.

Last edited Oct 15, 2008 17:22:22
 
thehazyone
NFL Replacement Refs SUCK
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by SteelersInsider
The defense I showed was from season 2 and is no longer valid. It was meant to show a point that Bort doesn't tell us everything about all the defenses, not to solve the OP's problems.

I said I would help solve the OP's problems if he let us know what the settings were for that particular defense that is having problems (not his whole defense).

But he wants to keep it a secret. So nothing we can do.


LOL you're thick SI. Real thick. The DAMN RIGHT play was called 5 times in the OP, I've said this numerous times yet you continue to ignore that very fact. Don't you get that. There is no reason for it to be called correctly 5 times and then incorrectly once. Every time this error has occurred for me, the correct play has been called at other times in the game. If it was something with my AI (which I know it isn't), it would never call the correct play.

Honestly, I'm done with this. If they don't want to fix it fine. I KNOW it's a bug. I am 1000% positive of it. I'd wager my entire poker bankroll on it, that's how confident I am.

I'll quit bumping this. You all can debate it all you want, but it's gotten to the point of ridiculous.
Last edited Oct 15, 2008 22:09:59
 
thehazyone
NFL Replacement Refs SUCK
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by SteelersInsider
Originally posted by buffalobills_tw

Since he wants to help OP, how about he let OP know the blitz package cause 3-4 cover 0 to be skipped? he'd let OP know anyway no matter it is OP gives him AI access or SI tells OP what to look for. In this case, we don't know his secret and OP can verify the bug.


I did tell you and the OP what to look for:

A combo that doesn't exist in Bort's defensive playbook. We've established now that some offenses don't exist. I'm also telling you that some defenses don't exist. RAPD has gone about showing you how to "test" for them.

Especially since it looks like Hazy has alot of bad teams in his league, he still has 20+ quarters of football to play before the playoffs, right? Test 20 different combinations of the defense that isn't working and see which one it is. Problem solved.

Then when he finds the answer, he can post it here for everyone to know or he can keep it to himself.

Rather than give him the answer, RAPB and I just showed you and the OP how to test things out and solve your own problems. If 20 quarters isn't enough to find the error, do what alot of us like Tim Harper and myself are doing: schedule additional scrimmage games.

But we pay 15 FP's for those. I sure as hell am not going to give up a secret that it took me 3 scrimmage games (45 FP's) to find. 45 FP's is shit (45 cents), but it is the more of the time factor like I said.



It's not just one defense. It's random. It's happened to at least six different formation specific defenses that I have. I posted another example a few pages back with the precise info. Not sure what more you would need.

I test plenty. All the time. This is a bug.

Oh yea, I said I was done with this thread.

Someone lock this bad boy.
 
keedon
offline
Link
 
True that. Today my LBs didn't weak side shift when it was supposed to. And no, I didn't make a mistake because the only time I run this particular formation, I weakside shift my LBs. It happened some of the times but other times, it didn't.
 
Link
 
Originally posted by buffalobills_tw
Originally posted by SteelersInsider

what does trusting me have to do with anything?

trust the other 1,988 owners who aren't having this problem.


It has everything to do with trusting you since 1999 owners don't see a blitz package cause 3-4 cover 0 to be skipped. And why did you try to imply this phenomenon doesn't exist when you claim you know what cause 3-4 cover 0 being skipped and it is a secret?

And the following is my edit words in case you don't see it:

And stop calling me lazy. If I'm lazy, I won't even spend time to write my own greasemonkey script to do scouting. Also stop mixing up user errors in AI and bug in skipping plays, they are different. I don't want to know your so called secret, I'm doing pretty well in defense AI. You wanted to help OP, tell him what blitz package would cause 3-4 cover 0 being skipped, don't use vague words like you usually do. OP can verify if you are real or not. I don't want to have FP involved in this since it may violate rules. I'd offer to run my scouting script for your team this offseason if it is proved true and you only need to tell OP.



I have a good scouting script, but watching the games is much better.
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.