User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Page:
 
Booster4324
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Bort
Originally posted by Booster4324

Hmm nice to see we got a bit of attention. Care to explain the guys on combo playing against - 8s? So if the outputs are where you want them, does that mean you changed things and never bothered to tell us? Because something changed. I can rehash some of the most appropriate examples if you don't want to read over the whole thread.


No, like I said at the beginning of the thread, nothing has changed. I've changed very little this season with the sim, and haven't touched it at all since about day 4 or so (as people always ask me to do that).

Vs lv 8's: cruise control perhaps? Also, there's always a chance of a fumble or int or drop or whatever happening. Nothing is ever 100% in its output. There's always at least a small percentage chance built into the formula.


I edited it but you already replied. In my example we won, but not by 50+. The guy had a 35 carrying and 60 Stength and was level 26. A level 18 whose stats were open caused two fumbles (he had none of the attributes you are referring to). To add ignominy to it a level 16 capped it for a third fumble.

He capped his carrying by boosting shortly thereafter. That promptly led to two fumbles. He was playing against even level competition. IMO there is something wrong with your random number generator. This would grow worse with morale penalties being added in.

Edited to add - The guy who had 1 fumble all of last season and has a 48 carrying and a 60 strength added yet another fumble thi last game. He is on pace for 16. Wheeee
Last edited Oct 11, 2008 11:47:12
 
Bort
Admin
offline
Link
 
50 was just a random number. Cruise control kicks in around a 4 touchdown lead if I recall correctly.

Also, 35 carrying isn't very much. Is he really fast? Momentum figures into the formula. Just because something is to "the cap" doesn't mean it's all that high. 48 isn't even halfway to maximum, while some players have over 100 in some stats with equipment.

Also: LOL, something wrong with the randomizer...the rand() function works just fine.
 
Booster4324
offline
Link
 
Well look over the game, since I am an idiot you tell me what is wrong and why he fumbled 3 times. Twice that we know of to a very mediocre build.

Oh and I was incorrect. It was a loss.

http://goallineblitz.com/game/game.pl?game_id=163974
 
Bort
Admin
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Booster4324
Well look over the game, since I am an idiot you tell me what is wrong and why he fumbled 3 times. Twice that we know of to a very mediocre build.

Oh and I was incorrect. It was a loss.

http://goallineblitz.com/game/game.pl?game_id=163974


I don't know the exact reason why he fumbled 3 times, other than knowing that there were 3 instances where he got hit and the sim generated an output that said "fumble." I don't have a log of every single input and output from every single game. Though I would say that they happened at the end of the game, so I'd guess it was mainly a result of being tired.

Also, I didn't mean to say you are an idiot or anything of the like. Just giving some clues as to how things work.
Last edited Oct 11, 2008 11:56:07
 
Booster4324
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Bort
50 was just a random number. Cruise control kicks in around a 4 touchdown lead if I recall correctly.

Also, 35 carrying isn't very much. Is he really fast? Momentum figures into the formula. Just because something is to "the cap" doesn't mean it's all that high. 48 isn't even halfway to maximum, while some players have over 100 in some stats with equipment.

Also: LOL, something wrong with the randomizer...the rand() function works just fine.


His Speed at the time was 59 IIRC. I would think a 35 carrying would be sufficient against level 18s as it was all of last season. My OP on it

My build is a power/speed blend. I significantly out leveled my opponents in this game I am about to show you. He has yet to boost this season and boosted last season early on. In the latter half of the season he was a surprise hiding on my STs as a blocker for my own team. IOWS he hasn't leveled a lot from the middle of last season. Why is this significant?

Maybe it is just random chance, but against much better competition he fumbled once last season when he was lower level in 135 touches.

He had 19 touches in this 3 fumble game. To date he has 6.

His stats are open for the moment and he is a level 26 RB.
http://goallineblitz.com/game/player.pl?player_id=263685

This is significant as the ones who cause the fumbles are 18 and 16. The highest level player on the defense was 22.


Larry's fumbles. Keep in mind he is 26 and the ROLB that forces his first fumble is 18.

Here is the 1st fumble:
Larry Flanders rush[forced fumble: marcel big boss], fumbled , recovered by Tazmanian Devvil (2.5 yd return) [tackle: Michael Strayhand]
http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=163974&pbp_id=3884313

Here is Marcel Big Boss a level 18 LB whose stats are conveniently open:
http://goallineblitz.com/game/player.pl?player_id=458479


Here is the 2nd fumble:
Larry Flanders rush [missed tackle: I Pitty You Fool] [missed tackle: Moses McKinley][forced fumble: marcel big boss], fumbled , recovered by Big Crusher (0 yd return) [tackle: Carri McKillip]

Same 18th level LB for the 2nd fumble. He has Larry's # now.


Here is the 3rd fumble:
Baabaa Looey pitch to Larry Flanders[forced fumble: Walks Silently], fumbled , recovered by M. T. Jackson (0.5 yd return) [tackle: Deshawn Serna]

This time (well heck his morale is in the dumps) it is a level 16 FS causing the fumble.

We have eliminated strength, SAs, and fumble gear; in at least this one scenario, I suggest Bort look into his randomizer and/or morale effects of fumbles.

Mind you, this seems to be intermittent.

Hence my comment on your random number generator. I remember when a game that I loved had a problem with accuracy due to the fact the seed number they used to base the generator off of was whacked in certain locations. Why? It used a number based off the players location. Some places had a number location that borked the who generator. Believe it or not, I am trying to help, but your other reasons don't fit the profile of what is happening.
 
Booster4324
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Bort
Originally posted by Booster4324

Well look over the game, since I am an idiot you tell me what is wrong and why he fumbled 3 times. Twice that we know of to a very mediocre build.

Oh and I was incorrect. It was a loss.

http://goallineblitz.com/game/game.pl?game_id=163974


I don't know the exact reason why he fumbled 3 times, other than knowing that there were 3 instances where he got hit and the sim generated an output that said "fumble." I don't have a log of every single input and output from every single game. Though I would say that they happened at the end of the game, so I'd guess it was mainly a result of being tired.

Also, I didn't mean to say you are an idiot or anything of the like. Just giving some clues as to how things work.


Then post the formula and we can find out. A lot of these fumbles are happening at the beginning of the games when the score is close and players with decent stamina are coughing it up right off the bat.

Alternately, consider an actual test server. Something where players can test out ANY changes to code. I don't code anymore (unless you count HTML) but that is what you need brother. Changes in one area of code can change tons of things.

 
Bort
Admin
offline
Link
 
Yes, all RNG are pseudorandom, but a proper seed, such as one based on the timer, process id, and /dev/random should make sure that things are "random" enough.

I'm not going to post the formula, since that would end up causing more fumbles as people min/maxed it LOL. Also, if I decide I'm going to make any changes, it's not going to bee in week 11 of the season since all that does is get us a litany of complaints.
 
Booster4324
offline
Link
 
Can you consider an actual test server to check changes then? Something with an accelerated schedule? Say two games a day so we can test out stuff like this?

I love this game too, but I am losing interest as things change too rapidly. Maybe my RBs need 60 carrying. But 30 was fine last season when I was a mere 5 levels lower. The fumbles cost the team I own two games basically.

Maybe I am way off base here, but something sure seems changed. Without a peek under the hood there is no real way to tell.

Frankly, you need at the very least an actual coder who can understand the changes and communicate them to us.
 
vandiar2
offline
Link
 
Yeah Fumbling is getting out of control. I fumbled, and lost 2 in the scrimmage game we just played. I have 49 carrying, and 3 into cover up. I have fumbled 6 times this season so far.
 
Barnsie
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Bort
Current fumble maths give the proper outputs where I want them, folks.

Some things to look at:

- Are you running out of gas or low on morale?

- Is the defender hitting you running at full speed?

- Are you winning by 50+ points and going on cruise control?

- 48 carrying or lv 3 cover up vs a 100 str/80 tackling defender or a guy with lots in big/monster hit etc is not going to keep you from fumbling, especially when you're running at high speeds on the elusive setting.


First, thanks for providing some information for us to look over.

That said, personally, I'm finding the fumbling to happen quite a bit early, before a huge lead or before running out of gas should reasonably be kicking in. Certainly not winning by 50+ at that point.

Next, 48 carrying and level 3 cover up, I would think is pretty good to not cause fumbles that much. It's weird, because the "100str/80 tackling defender" (do these actually exist) are hardly the ones causing the fumbles, but typically CBs of all players, who surely don't have that. Rarely do I find that the D-lineman causes the fumble, and he's the one most likely to fit your description.

I don't see how the fumbles can have increased so much from last season without any tweaks. The same teams that we were playing last season were not causing nearly the same amount of fumbles.

The one point that you make that I do think has a big part in this is the "running at full speed". Certainly my guys have gotten faster since last season, so that's the point that sticks out the most to me. Perhaps it is better to stick with slower power HBs, if that means you can get away with 48 or so carrying.
Last edited Oct 11, 2008 13:15:34
 
oldskool
offline
Link
 
Maybe it's the fact that CBs are running at high speeds (especially early in the game) giving them an overly large to-fumble ratio boost?
 
ferr
offline
Link
 
In my combo HB's first 10 games this season he had 1 fumble, then I put my first point into stiff arm, and in the 5 games since then he has had 8 fumbles. Not even exaggerating, as soon as I put my FIRST POINT into stiff arm, he started fumbling like crazy.

Is stiff arm bugged? Help me out, Bort.

http://goallineblitz.com/game/player_game_log.pl?player_id=332583

Consider comparing my results to the other running back on my team that I share a near equal load with, http://goallineblitz.com/game/player_game_log.pl?player_id=64993
 
Booster4324
offline
Link
 
Bort said nothing changed. It is your build or your imagination. Any evidence to the contrary is ignored.
 
Zickzack
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Booster4324
Bort said nothing changed. It is your build or your imagination. Any evidence to the contrary is ignored.

I think the word you are looking for there is incidental.

 
Booster4324
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Zickzack
Originally posted by Booster4324

Bort said nothing changed. It is your build or your imagination. Any evidence to the contrary is ignored.

I think the word you are looking for there is incidental.



Incidental would imply there isn't an actual problem.
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.