snypah!
Forum > Goal Line Blitz > Playoff Profit sharing...
wombat killer
offline
offline
I find it interesting that people are concerned about the 5-8 teams but don't really care about the teams that missed the playoffs.
Nixx
offline
offline
Originally posted by tmoon
...who needs to win home field for the revenue if there is not a reward. If I can set in a league and make no effort with my team and make the playoffs (not hard to do) and get massive revenue why do I even need to try during the regular season.
Wow. Nobody said there would be no reward for being the home team. We don't know how it will work exactly, but chances are the home team will still get more than the away team. You say the home team gets 'no reward', but the away team gets "massive revenue". Make up your mind.
If you can make the playoffs with no effort then your league must suck. That will probably change once the gutted team change is implemented.
...who needs to win home field for the revenue if there is not a reward. If I can set in a league and make no effort with my team and make the playoffs (not hard to do) and get massive revenue why do I even need to try during the regular season.
Wow. Nobody said there would be no reward for being the home team. We don't know how it will work exactly, but chances are the home team will still get more than the away team. You say the home team gets 'no reward', but the away team gets "massive revenue". Make up your mind.
If you can make the playoffs with no effort then your league must suck. That will probably change once the gutted team change is implemented.
McGruffHawk
offline
offline
Originally posted by Groucho
Originally posted by McGruffHawk
Maybe that's the difference . . . I have always felt the system was unfair, even though I have always benefited from it.
Unfair how? Everybody is given the same chance to build up their stadium vs. throw money at free agents. If you make the wrong choice, I feel you should live with the consequences rather than get a free handout from the teams that made the right choice.
Unfair because I KNOW many owner who have been financially responsible, fielded quality teams, and because we play in a VERY competitive, deep league, have still fallen outside the top 4 teams. They make the playoffs, which is a huge accomplishment in my main league, but get shafted in the revenue stream.
Let me put it this way for the sake of clarity. As a #1 seed, I make (hypothetically) $3 million in revenue from my first home playoff game. The #8 seed makes $100,000. I make 30x what they make.
I can guarantee that I am not 30x better than that team. I can guarantee that I did not try 30x harder. I can guarantee that I am not 30x a better manager.
I would rather take the 20=30% hit from my team's revenue if it meant that these teams, who in many ways are nearly equal to mine, have the opportunity to make themselves more competitive.
Originally posted by McGruffHawk
Maybe that's the difference . . . I have always felt the system was unfair, even though I have always benefited from it.
Unfair how? Everybody is given the same chance to build up their stadium vs. throw money at free agents. If you make the wrong choice, I feel you should live with the consequences rather than get a free handout from the teams that made the right choice.
Unfair because I KNOW many owner who have been financially responsible, fielded quality teams, and because we play in a VERY competitive, deep league, have still fallen outside the top 4 teams. They make the playoffs, which is a huge accomplishment in my main league, but get shafted in the revenue stream.
Let me put it this way for the sake of clarity. As a #1 seed, I make (hypothetically) $3 million in revenue from my first home playoff game. The #8 seed makes $100,000. I make 30x what they make.
I can guarantee that I am not 30x better than that team. I can guarantee that I did not try 30x harder. I can guarantee that I am not 30x a better manager.
I would rather take the 20=30% hit from my team's revenue if it meant that these teams, who in many ways are nearly equal to mine, have the opportunity to make themselves more competitive.
McGruffHawk
offline
offline
Originally posted by wombat killer
I find it interesting that people are concerned about the 5-8 teams but don't really care about the teams that missed the playoffs.
That's why I like an idea proposed earlier that awarded a piece of playoff revenue to be divided among the non-playoff teams.
A system that rewards top seeds with the lion's share, while still distributing income to lower seed and non playoff teams is in the best interest of the competitive nature of the leagues.
I find it interesting that people are concerned about the 5-8 teams but don't really care about the teams that missed the playoffs.
That's why I like an idea proposed earlier that awarded a piece of playoff revenue to be divided among the non-playoff teams.
A system that rewards top seeds with the lion's share, while still distributing income to lower seed and non playoff teams is in the best interest of the competitive nature of the leagues.
McGruffHawk
offline
offline
Originally posted by Nixx
Teams should be rewarded for playing well and getting a top seed, but not to the extent they are now. Sharing will result in more balanced and fun leagues. Who doesn't want that?
Hell yeah!
Teams should be rewarded for playing well and getting a top seed, but not to the extent they are now. Sharing will result in more balanced and fun leagues. Who doesn't want that?
Hell yeah!
Phantom_Opera
offline
offline
Originally posted by wombat killer
I find it interesting that people are concerned about the 5-8 teams but don't really care about the teams that missed the playoffs.
whats so interesting about that? o_O
I find it interesting that people are concerned about the 5-8 teams but don't really care about the teams that missed the playoffs.
whats so interesting about that? o_O
Phantom_Opera
offline
offline
Originally posted by McGruffHawk
Originally posted by wombat killer
I find it interesting that people are concerned about the 5-8 teams but don't really care about the teams that missed the playoffs.
That's why I like an idea proposed earlier that awarded a piece of playoff revenue to be divided among the non-playoff teams.
A system that rewards top seeds with the lion's share, while still distributing income to lower seed and non playoff teams is in the best interest of the competitive nature of the leagues.
WRONG!!!
Originally posted by wombat killer
I find it interesting that people are concerned about the 5-8 teams but don't really care about the teams that missed the playoffs.
That's why I like an idea proposed earlier that awarded a piece of playoff revenue to be divided among the non-playoff teams.
A system that rewards top seeds with the lion's share, while still distributing income to lower seed and non playoff teams is in the best interest of the competitive nature of the leagues.
WRONG!!!
Crushr
offline
offline
Originally posted by Groucho
Originally posted by McGruffHawk
Maybe that's the difference . . . I have always felt the system was unfair, even though I have always benefited from it.
Unfair how? Everybody is given the same chance to build up their stadium vs. throw money at free agents. If you make the wrong choice, I feel you should live with the consequences rather than get a free handout from the teams that made the right choice.
How is it unfair?? Anyone who looks at what each team makes in the playoffs, with an unbiased view has to say "wow thats a huge disparity in payouts". If you don't see it that way, then I can't help you. I am also sick of the argument that just because you make a 1-4 seed in the playoffs that somehow you have put more work into your team or are smarter financially than the 5-8 seeds. Its just not true! It might be but in some cases but certainly not always true. And if you think this is a handout, wrong again. How is it a handout? You still have to earn a spot in the playoffs to see a significant gain. You are still putting hours into tactics/recruiting/ building team websites etc.. And lest you forget, we all started this game on a handout! 500k I believe!
Originally posted by McGruffHawk
Maybe that's the difference . . . I have always felt the system was unfair, even though I have always benefited from it.
Unfair how? Everybody is given the same chance to build up their stadium vs. throw money at free agents. If you make the wrong choice, I feel you should live with the consequences rather than get a free handout from the teams that made the right choice.
How is it unfair?? Anyone who looks at what each team makes in the playoffs, with an unbiased view has to say "wow thats a huge disparity in payouts". If you don't see it that way, then I can't help you. I am also sick of the argument that just because you make a 1-4 seed in the playoffs that somehow you have put more work into your team or are smarter financially than the 5-8 seeds. Its just not true! It might be but in some cases but certainly not always true. And if you think this is a handout, wrong again. How is it a handout? You still have to earn a spot in the playoffs to see a significant gain. You are still putting hours into tactics/recruiting/ building team websites etc.. And lest you forget, we all started this game on a handout! 500k I believe!
mstucchi
offline
offline
How about a 60/40 split of ticket revenue to higher seeded playoff team and home team gets all the concessions?
Sao
offline
offline
It shouldn't be this hard.
Allow the visitor to perform 1 day playoff sales on THEIR stadium but at 25% of capacity. Make the visiting owner strategize on the ticket price which gets them involved be it a good choice of price or bad...it's on them.
Leave the Home Team's revenue stream alone. Don't allow visitors to piggy back on a larger (or even smaller) stadium than their opponent. Keeping the share independent of the home team can prevent any visitors complaining "their stadium is smaller than ours. The 7th seed got more than me because they played a team with a larger stadium" argument.
You want more money for playoffs? Get into the top 4 and construct stadiums smartly. If you do those things, you will reap the benefits.
Allow the visitor to perform 1 day playoff sales on THEIR stadium but at 25% of capacity. Make the visiting owner strategize on the ticket price which gets them involved be it a good choice of price or bad...it's on them.
Leave the Home Team's revenue stream alone. Don't allow visitors to piggy back on a larger (or even smaller) stadium than their opponent. Keeping the share independent of the home team can prevent any visitors complaining "their stadium is smaller than ours. The 7th seed got more than me because they played a team with a larger stadium" argument.
You want more money for playoffs? Get into the top 4 and construct stadiums smartly. If you do those things, you will reap the benefits.
FairForever
offline
offline
Originally posted by mstucchi
How about a 60/40 split of ticket revenue to higher seeded playoff team and home team gets all the concessions?
Too little to reward home teams IMO.
75/25 with home concessions is good for me.
How about a 60/40 split of ticket revenue to higher seeded playoff team and home team gets all the concessions?
Too little to reward home teams IMO.
75/25 with home concessions is good for me.
jktooley
offline
offline
Originally posted by Nixx
spot would reduce the money he is making just to lower someone else's.
I've seen big name owners in top leagues say they would sell tickets cheap on purpose to screw the other team if revenue sharing was put into place. I'm not sure if they were just being a troll or joking, but never underestimate a humans ability to be a jerk.
Not a bad idea IMO.
spot would reduce the money he is making just to lower someone else's.
I've seen big name owners in top leagues say they would sell tickets cheap on purpose to screw the other team if revenue sharing was put into place. I'm not sure if they were just being a troll or joking, but never underestimate a humans ability to be a jerk.
Not a bad idea IMO.
jktooley
offline
offline
Originally posted by Sao
It shouldn't be this hard.
Allow the visitor to perform 1 day playoff sales on THEIR stadium but at 25% of capacity. Make the visiting owner strategize on the ticket price which gets them involved be it a good choice of price or bad...it's on them.
Leave the Home Team's revenue stream alone. Don't allow visitors to piggy back on a larger (or even smaller) stadium than their opponent. Keeping the share independent of the home team can prevent any visitors complaining "their stadium is smaller than ours. The 7th seed got more than me because they played a team with a larger stadium" argument.
You want more money for playoffs? Get into the top 4 and construct stadiums smartly. If you do those things, you will reap the benefits.
good idea here too
It shouldn't be this hard.
Allow the visitor to perform 1 day playoff sales on THEIR stadium but at 25% of capacity. Make the visiting owner strategize on the ticket price which gets them involved be it a good choice of price or bad...it's on them.
Leave the Home Team's revenue stream alone. Don't allow visitors to piggy back on a larger (or even smaller) stadium than their opponent. Keeping the share independent of the home team can prevent any visitors complaining "their stadium is smaller than ours. The 7th seed got more than me because they played a team with a larger stadium" argument.
You want more money for playoffs? Get into the top 4 and construct stadiums smartly. If you do those things, you will reap the benefits.
good idea here too
Tito716
offline
offline
Give teams 5-8 the money equivalent to their average concession sales from the season.
This is simulate merchandise sold to fans in their home market.
"I have to go get a new Cobra Kai hat before I go to watch the game at the sports bar."
Let teams 9-16 sell tickets to their scrimmages at expected prices, no concessions. Pool and evenly split the money.
Everyone gets more cash, home playoff teams get their money.
This is simulate merchandise sold to fans in their home market.
"I have to go get a new Cobra Kai hat before I go to watch the game at the sports bar."
Let teams 9-16 sell tickets to their scrimmages at expected prices, no concessions. Pool and evenly split the money.
Everyone gets more cash, home playoff teams get their money.
You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.






























