User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Forum > Goal Line Blitz > GLB Wiki Beta - http://www.glbwiki.com
Page:
 
Procrustes
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by DrunkenOne
Originally posted by GeneralMakaveli
Originally posted by dkgojackets

I thought the whole point was for users to be able to learn what canada pro actually is.

It is, and we are glad most of you are helping but some of the stuff don't need to be there.

Hi, we are from canada pro and are thus uniquely aware of what needs to be there or not.


ha, well... the last thing we want to do is invent some arbitrary conflict between glbwiki and the CPL.

yes, the wiki isn't technically "academic", but we do want it to be professional. it was intended to be a resource for everyone on GLB... not merely an extension of the forums or a repository for in-jokes. as it stands, no outsider visiting the CPL page will really "learn what canada pro actually is". if you truly want that to be the case, you need to objectively describe your memes/etc. for example, how is a non-CPL person supposed to know what this means?
http://www.glbwiki.com/index.php?title=Canada_Pro#Hypno_Toad

as much as possible, we'd like to keep glbwiki from turning into glbmyspace.
 
DrunkenOne
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Catullus 16
Originally posted by DrunkenOne

Originally posted by GeneralMakaveli

Originally posted by dkgojackets


I thought the whole point was for users to be able to learn what canada pro actually is.

It is, and we are glad most of you are helping but some of the stuff don't need to be there.

Hi, we are from canada pro and are thus uniquely aware of what needs to be there or not.


ha, well... the last thing we want to do is invent some arbitrary conflict between glbwiki and the CPL.

yes, the wiki isn't technically "academic", but we do want it to be professional. it was intended to be a resource for everyone on GLB... not merely an extension of the forums or a repository for in-jokes. as it stands, no outsider visiting the CPL page will really "learn what canada pro actually is". if you truly want that to be the case, you need to objectively describe your memes/etc. for example, how is a non-CPL person supposed to know what this means?
http://www.glbwiki.com/index.php?title=Canada_Pro#Hypno_Toad

as much as possible, we'd like to keep glbwiki from turning into glbmyspace.

you should watch futurama its a pretty underrated show imo
 
Procrustes
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by DrunkenOne
you should watch futurama its a pretty underrated show imo


i'm aware... but that wasn't my point. you do get what i'm saying, right?

 
Vando
offline
Link
 
I'm pretty sure that anyone visiting the CPL page will learn exactly what CPL actually is.

Terrible, yet awesome.
 
Vando
offline
Link
 
We're not going to create a bunch of 'lets pretend this is like FOR REALS FOOTBALL' pages, just so you know. If you remove the creative freedoms the CPL guys will just stop editing anything at all, and you'll have zero content from one of the most active leagues in the game.

I think it's telling that the CPL entry has THREE TIMES as many views as the next nearest entry.
 
Procrustes
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Vando
I'm pretty sure that anyone visiting the CPL page will learn exactly what CPL actually is.
Terrible, yet awesome.


this is where we disagree. precious little on the CPL page is actually explained, just laundry-listed. if you want to see a more encyclopedic way to document memes, consider:
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_Internet_phenomena

note that there's a proper way that even goatse can be discussed:
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Goatse.cx


Originally posted by Vando
We're not going to create a bunch of 'lets pretend this is like FOR REALS FOOTBALL' pages, just so you know. If you remove the creative freedoms the CPL guys will just stop editing anything at all, and you'll have zero content from one of the most active leagues in the game.
I think it's telling that the CPL entry has THREE TIMES as many views as the next nearest entry.


well again, we really don't want content merely for the sake of content... all that does is create maintenance headaches and/or issues like this one. please correct me if i'm wrong, but i haven't seen any CPL people create pages that explain the game mechanics of GLB (which is the primary point of the wiki). to be completely frank: if all the CPL can offer is myspace-esque contributions, i think we'd greatly prefer "zero contributions" instead.

we know the CPL page is popular... but that's largely because of the established CPL community checking it out, not because the larger GLB community found it a valuable informational resource. also, a significant number of its views are a direct result of the edits/rollbacks that have arisen. the CPL page could 100x more views and i don't think any of us would see it differently.

i fully understand the 'quantity' argument... but there are also certain thresholds of allowable 'quality', otherwise an excess of content just becomes an excess of spam. if you copied a phonebook into a page, we'd have to clean that up, too. i'm not sure what you mean by a "lets pretend this is like FOR REALS FOOTBALL" page, but it honestly sounds more like what we're looking for.

i apologize if any of this sounds harsh, but it would be nice to restore a sense of proportion to the wiki effort. in other words: the popularity of certain low-priority pages (CPL/etc) has stolen time and focus away from high-priority pages, like this one:
http://www.glbwiki.com/index.php?title=Offensive_AI

perhaps if that page could be developed instead, it too would garner a lot of views.
 
Vando
offline
Link
 
I thought the primary point of the wiki was to provide a reference point for the game too, yes. But I thought a SECONDARY point of it was to provide a reference point for the history of the community, which let's face it is a far longer term draw than the game itself.

Also I'd edit the Offensive AI page, but if you want it to say more than 'Bort please give us some bloody offensive AI because this sucks' then you should probably find someone else.

Oh and the 'FOR REALS FOOTBALL' thing means the people roleplaying their teams and players. We don't do that, but at the same time we don't fuck with the people that do (not on the wiki, at any rate). Each to his own, and all that.

My final point is that you can't expect internet forum users to be churning our wikipedia-standard entries on their first go. It just doesn't happen that way. Screaming at them that THIS IS WRONG is only going to make them give up and/or get mad at you.

And stop using big words. This isn't a management seminar.
Last edited Oct 3, 2008 08:50:17
 
Hikariu
offline
Link
 
Um relax and have fun much? Next topic.
 
Procrustes
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Vando
I thought the primary point of the wiki was to provide a reference point for the game too, yes. But I thought a SECONDARY point of it was to provide a reference point for the history of the community, which let's face it is a far longer term draw than the game itself.
Also I'd edit the Offensive AI page, but if you want it to say more than 'Bort please give us some bloody offensive AI because this sucks' then you should probably find someone else.
Oh and the 'FOR REALS FOOTBALL' thing means the people roleplaying their teams and players. We don't do that, but at the same time we don't fuck with the people that do (not on the wiki, at any rate). Each to his own, and all that.
My final point is that you can't expect internet forum users to be churning our wikipedia-standard entries on their first go. It just doesn't happen that way. Screaming at them that THIS IS WRONG is only going to make them give up and/or get mad at you.
And stop using big words. This isn't a management seminar.


- sure, a "history of the community" would be great. but 'history' involves being dispassionate, objective, and factual. again, it's not about content, it's about tone/style.

- okay... and i guess that's another point. as much as possible, we'd like to avoid raw opinion. more than anything, we're trying to develop game documentation... and i guess our primary audience would be newbies.

- fine...

- granted, but i don't think anyone's screaming "THIS IS WRONG". however, we do seem to have conflicting ideas about what is allowable/appropriate... and i guess we're already discussing this in the glbwiki private forum.

- dude... i'm sorry you have a problem with it, but this is how i write. trust me, i'm already trying to keep it casual. regardless of your misperception, let's try to keep this discussion positive. no need to randomly start baiting each other for no good reason.
 
Procrustes
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Hikariu
Um relax and have fun much? Next topic.


good point.

since this is a limited issue, how about we not crowd this thread and instead move to the glbwiki private forum (which was created for this purpose)?
 
djfivenine
offline
Link
 
Been chipping away at my team page.
 
morbo
offline
Link
 
Who's in charge of the glbwiki forum? I'd like an invite
 
Deathblade
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by morbo
Who's in charge of the glbwiki forum? I'd like an invite


Sent
 
Krunchy
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by morbo
Who's in charge of the glbwiki forum? I'd like an invite


Yeah me too.
 
Nixx
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Krunchy
Yeah me too.


Invite sent.
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.