User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Page:
 
OttawaShane
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by RAPB
Originally posted by OttawaShane

Originally posted by caesarrodneybengal


Maybe the FS is being juked badly by the ball carrier. Imagine in real life why a person would take that path. Maybe they thought that the ball carrier would go a different way and that screwed their pursuit angle up


In real life, a defender that far away wouldn't so completely change their path.

...


That's the key problem: If the coverage assignment or ball carrier is FAR away, the defender should focus on getting "in the region" first (for a safety: getting between the ball carrier and the endzone). So if the HB/WR jukes, head fakes, spins, cuts... the defender shouldn't worry but keep going full speed till he's close. THEN he might focus on the current movements of the ball carrier.



At one point (I think 809 years ago), Bort seized on a suggestion by a user to have two zones of awareness. One further away and one close in. The player would react differently to things happening in each zone - presumably that includes juking etc, and the player with sufficient vision would behave as a player should.

Sadly, haven't seen reference to it since - and all evidence shows that it hasn't been fixed without Bort mentioning it.

I vote to roit.
 
taz20075
offline
Link
 
I think this counts too....


http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=207612&pbp_id=11488461
 
Link
 
Originally posted by OttawaShane
Originally posted by RAPB

Originally posted by OttawaShane


Originally posted by caesarrodneybengal



Maybe the FS is being juked badly by the ball carrier. Imagine in real life why a person would take that path. Maybe they thought that the ball carrier would go a different way and that screwed their pursuit angle up


In real life, a defender that far away wouldn't so completely change their path.

...




That's the key problem: If the coverage assignment or ball carrier is FAR away, the defender should focus on getting "in the region" first (for a safety: getting between the ball carrier and the endzone). So if the HB/WR jukes, head fakes, spins, cuts... the defender shouldn't worry but keep going full speed till he's close. THEN he might focus on the current movements of the ball carrier.



At one point (I think 809 years ago), Bort seized on a suggestion by a user to have two zones of awareness. One further away and one close in. The player would react differently to things happening in each zone - presumably that includes juking etc, and the player with sufficient vision would behave as a player should.

Sadly, haven't seen reference to it since - and all evidence shows that it hasn't been fixed without Bort mentioning it.

I vote to roit.


I think you hit on the issue.....The two versions of vision. The close up and the farther away. I think when you get closer is when the vision goes wonky, for lack of a better word.

I still wish Bort would come and talk to us about this....

 
OttawaShane
offline
Link
 
I actually think that its vision and how players react to the further-away plays that is the issue, but yeah...

Bort, where are you?
 
Tobysmith6922
offline
Link
 
Bump for Bort.....
 
UmYeah
offline
Link
 
It seems like when the player with the ball begins his movement, the safety gets glitchy and moves to where the ball carrier seems to be going. But since it is the beginning of movement, the safety is making the wrong calculation for where to go. And by the time the ball carrier starts moving full speed, the FS is in a bas position to make a play. It seems like it would be an easy enough fix that hopefully Bort will acknowledge. A FS needs to be the last line of defense (in most cases) and this bug makes that impossible. And this is certainly a bug, not a problem with vision. A FS should know to be the last line of defense regardless of vision.
 
RAPB
offline
Link
 
If at all, a dumb safety (low vision) would overreact and head too deep. He'd sure prevent the TD run, but would turn towards the ball carrier too late - this giving up another few yards.
 
numone
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Robbnva
Originally posted by numone

my FS seems to be fine. Do you have enough vision points and enough into the super vision SA?


seriously? I just saw the stats of your FS and nothing to brag about


seriously? I just looked at the team he is on and it is only a half full roster with me being the only FS and playing over 70 plays a game. Hmm maybe that is why?
 
NiborRis
offline
Link
 
This actually looks like the same weird loop, only after an interception? There's also some bizarreness going on as he hits the sideline.
I should hope that no matter how bad his vision is he can figure out which way the endzone is.

Ack, left off the link: http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=198751&pbp_id=11845086
Last edited Oct 29, 2008 16:50:26
 
OttawaShane
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by NiborRis
This actually looks like the same weird loop, only after an interception? There's also some bizarreness going on as he hits the sideline.
I should hope that no matter how bad his vision is he can figure out which way the endzone is.

Ack, left off the link: http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=198751&pbp_id=11845086


he may not have caught the ball as soon as it appears...its like he was running after the ball, perhaps bobbling it until he got control, then immediately turned around upfield.

One theory, anyway, and I'm not prone to defending how FS vision works here
 
Link
 
Im not sure Bort cares much about fixing the Pathing issues, theres just too many of them that have been around for too long.
 
Tobysmith6922
offline
Link
 
Bump for Bort....
 
minjit
offline
Link
 
It's probably not even a problem with the algorithm Bort is using because it's a fairly simple algorithm, but just a bug in the code...

I mean the algorithm isn't hard, based the FS's vision, he should be able to estimate the player's speed to a certain accuracy and he knows his speed so you have two time dependant vectors and you draw them and the FS should run to where they intersect (unless it's past the endzone). Sure, it takes some graph theory on deciding the best path, but there are tons of algorithms out there. Here the vision accounts for how accurate the FS's vector is and everything else is fairly straight forward. I'm sure that's how Bort's is implemented or some variation on that and that's not the issue.
Last edited Nov 2, 2008 21:35:53
 
minjit
offline
Link
 
I wish Bort would actually just acknowledge that the issue still exists and discuss what he's doing to address it atm. It's a bit frustrating being in the dark.
 
RAPB
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by minjit
It's probably not even a problem with the algorithm Bort is using because it's a fairly simple algorithm, but just a bug in the code...

I mean the algorithm isn't hard, based the FS's vision, he should be able to estimate the player's speed to a certain accuracy and he knows his speed so you have two time dependant vectors and you draw them and the FS should run to where they intersect (unless it's past the endzone). Sure, it takes some graph theory on deciding the best path, but there are tons of algorithms out there. Here the vision accounts for how accurate the FS's vector is and everything else is fairly straight forward. I'm sure that's how Bort's is implemented or some variation on that and that's not the issue.


That's EXACTLY the issue!

Because in football, this is NOT what players do:

- when beeing far away, only a REALLY DUMB kid is running straight for the man
- smart players calculate the ESTIMATED speed and direction LATER ON (not the present one!!!) - so they don't care if the guy is moving slowly or changing direction RIGHT NOW (for as they are there, he either is tackled already or heading towards the endzone)
- other players - especially safeties - got assignments that they care more about than the actual opponents position and direction: secure the endzone is more important than getting close to the man first; so a FS/SS rather far away will head for the endzone FIRST and turn towards the ball carrier not before he's deeper and able to prevent the easy TD-run

So the general "chase-down" logic is not realistic for the safeties at all. The "secure the endzone" logic should override as long as the safeties are rather far away from the ball carrier.
Last edited Nov 3, 2008 08:40:07
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.