User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Forum > Game Changes Discussion > Announced Changes > Change to Age Based League Structures Discussion Thread
Page:
 
Thranduil
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by QB Eater
As an owner, I am afraid of this happening. It is always WORK getting your team together each off season, and if many players are retired over this, and it seems likely many non-boosters will retire, it will only be harder. As soon as it gets too hard to recruit my team, I will quit. I'll give it a chance, but this does not look like it was well thought out.


I don't think it was well thought out at all - it's probably going to cause a lot of chaos when it is implemented between the mass retirements and other roster chaos it will cause.

My main player has been on QB Eater's team for the last two seasons, and while I was hoping for him to stay on the team as we made it into the A leagues, it looks like he will be unable to remain with the team in season 20.

That player was created on day 33 of the season, which means that by the time the change is implemented, he will be 287 days old, while much of the rest of the team will be 280 days old, thus on different sides of a hard age cap.

It's pretty annoying that he'll be forced off a team that he's been on for a few seasons because I created him a few days early a year ago.


 
kb2120
offline
Link
 
If the Incentive program gives flex/reward points for winning, the exploiting of Competitive and Normal levels with overhauled rosters will be the name of the game.
 
Hamakto
offline
Link
 
I am all for doing leagues by Effective Levels.

If this gets put into place, I will probably end up dropping my team and eventually most of my players as time goes bye.

From reading and talking to other players, EL is the best way to determine how fair and balanced teams are. Heck, hide the actual player level from anyone but the owner and just make the Effective Level the only value that shows.

That would go farther towards play balance than anything else.

Heck, I do have a level 38 on my team roster that has an EL of 54. He won Defensive Player of the Year.

Hamakto
 
xsujx
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Hamakto
I am all for doing leagues by Effective Levels.

If this gets put into place, I will probably end up dropping my team and eventually most of my players as time goes bye.

From reading and talking to other players, EL is the best way to determine how fair and balanced teams are. Heck, hide the actual player level from anyone but the owner and just make the Effective Level the only value that shows.

That would go farther towards play balance than anything else.

Heck, I do have a level 38 on my team roster that has an EL of 54. He won Defensive Player of the Year.

Hamakto


ELs are iffy at best.
 
im4ut999
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Thranduil
I don't think it was well thought out at all - it's probably going to cause a lot of chaos when it is implemented between the mass retirements and other roster chaos it will cause.

My main player has been on QB Eater's team for the last two seasons, and while I was hoping for him to stay on the team as we made it into the A leagues, it looks like he will be unable to remain with the team in season 20.

That player was created on day 33 of the season, which means that by the time the change is implemented, he will be 287 days old, while much of the rest of the team will be 280 days old, thus on different sides of a hard age cap.

It's pretty annoying that he'll be forced off a team that he's been on for a few seasons because I created him a few days early a year ago.




That is exactly what is wrong with this age cap, and the way it was done, specifically. A hard age limit, based on the oldest player on the team, invokes thoughts of, well, no thought process.....

It seems if age is the plan, a simple average age, with a max offset. A full team of players created on day 39 are not much better than a team of players created on day 41. So this seems like a change that just makes no sense.

A player created on day 39 becomes a liability, since he is either the oldest player on the team (by 1-2 days), forcing the team up a cap, or the youngest, putting the team at a disadvantage.

Also, having every league be exactly one season in create age, is far tighter than the current league limits. I suppose this is done to prevent SSB and non-boosters from having ANY advantage, but it just makes little sense....
 
Thranduil
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by 1hottie
Ya know, I don't boost my players every season anymore.... they are better players if I DON'T do that. Just in case anyone
in the Adm. or you Catch or Bort or anyone else wants to know....here is the history of MY OWN PURCHASES HERE...

my first day on the site... forward........

2009-01-18 17:58:32 signup used 400 free flex

2009-01-30 19:49:57 purchase 1200
etc...

Now, I am Not saying I have spent a ton of money here.. but you all add that up. I own three teams and renew them every
season. I did retire some of my early players for the flex, yes.. but my history of purchase is right there for everyone to see.....
I HAVE spent money here Bort and Catch !!! And this was all under the current system !!! AND YOU WANT MORE??
I would be willing to bet a paycheck that there are others out there that have just about the same flex purchase record as I do,
Heck more I'm sure and are as upset with the new
COMING SYSTEM as I am. You know WE all can go somewhere else to spend our money.... I like it here. But with the changes,
I may be one of the ones that will leave. Note I said MAY. The jury is still out with me and I will be taking a LONG look at how
this new System is going to work before I make up my mind for sure.


That's $111 in the last 12 months if you purchased flex at full price. Seems like a decent amount of money to me.

The three metrics gaming companies should be concerned with are Reach, Retention and Revenue.

These changes seem likely to have a negative impact on Retention and Reach (less people promoting GLB). Not really sure what the impact will be on Revenue, but even if these changes increase ARPPU (Average Revenue per Paying User), it isn't going to do much good if the total number of paying users decreases by more, which is definitely possible.

A move that negatively affects two of these metrics and has a potentially detrimental effect on the third doesn't seem like a very good idea to me. Based on the numbers people have talked about regarding flex purchases before, GLB's revenue per user numbers seem like they might be pretty decent compared to other MMORPGs, so it's not the area they should be optimizing first anyway. I could be wrong though since those numbers are private.
 
im4ut999
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by xsujx
ELs are iffy at best.


They're MUCH better than level alone....and the biggest affect on EL appears to be VA points, as an older team with equivalent EL, will overpower another team, all other things being equal.

Bad builds are bad builds, bad AI are bad AI, EL gives an indication of build quality in comparison to other players at that level....
 
MarBro456
Diamond Cutter
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Hamakto
I am all for doing leagues by Effective Levels.

If this gets put into place, I will probably end up dropping my team and eventually most of my players as time goes bye.

From reading and talking to other players, EL is the best way to determine how fair and balanced teams are. Heck, hide the actual player level from anyone but the owner and just make the Effective Level the only value that shows.

That would go farther towards play balance than anything else.

Heck, I do have a level 38 on my team roster that has an EL of 54. He won Defensive Player of the Year.

Hamakto


So......... you want your level 38 to play against my boosted level 57 http://goallineblitz.com/game/player.pl?player_id=1566878 ????? So much for EL. Every time you hit boost, you lose on the effective level. Make a new OL... boost him x 3 then apply your 30 SPs... already he will be level 4/ EL 3... Try it...
 
Dadx4
offline
Link
 
Won't this also lead to owners having to "re-roll" their entire roster every season? For example next season I am going to be in A which is cap 60. So I do the one year contracts and re-roll my roster in order to compete. Take the chemistry hit and recover it around day 18. Then season 20 comes and I have 12 guys that stay on but the rest leave and I can't find quality players...so I could release the 12 guys that wanted to stay and sign all 4's... I am sorry but this just makes no sense at all.
 
bigtisme
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Dadx4
Won't this also lead to owners having to "re-roll" their entire roster every season?


I am not sure why you would think this?

Its possible to keep an entire roster together just like before.
 
Link
 
Level caps + max age limits was and is the best idea. No explanation for why they wouldn't go for that.
 
Dadx4
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by bigtisme
Originally posted by Dadx4

Won't this also lead to owners having to "re-roll" their entire roster every season?


I am not sure why you would think this?

Its possible to keep an entire roster together just like before.


I do all of my guys 1 year deals, believe it or not only about half stay on but this season we are going from 46 cap to 60 cap. I hate to lose so in order to compete I don't have a choice but to re-roll the roster. Now for season 20 I might just try to sign all 70's wouldn't that mean they would have to put me in world league??? lol
 
Dadx4
offline
Link
 
Also I know that if teams were to "demote" before they would lose some stadium....will this still exist? I have never asked for a demotion and never will. All I am saying is if say and African pro team with a full stadium decides to go lvl 1's in season 20 won't they be able to keep the cash and stadium and everything else?
 
Dadx4
offline
Link
 
Another thing as well. I am suppose to go A this season but I want to be in World league why can't I just sign cpu for this season instead of bustin' my butt to try and sign 60's to be competitive and then go all lvl 70's for season 20 and be in the world league/usa pro? I just want to make sure you all have thought this through....
 
Link
 
There won't be A, AA, AAA anymore.
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.