User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Forum > Game Changes Discussion > Archived Changes > Extended Plateau Discussion
Page:
 
Dpride59
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by jrry32

Actually dpride, I said cutting it off at D440 would be easier because it would avoid all of these workarounds and look, I was right because now no one is satisfied with the workaround.


No shit, you got an under achieving wr, and like 9 stud s6d0 dots. Your self serving blindly biased half ass way of jumping to the shittiest conclusion on the map every time is as money as me dunking on your vertically challenged ass in real life
 
kurieg
offline
Link
 
I see that Bort wants some penalty that naturally scales with how far along the dot is from day 441 to day 480. At least, I'm guessing that's rationale for freezing decline.

Some suggested ways of making the new change more fair to everyone:

1) Keep the whole freeze training/VPs at day 440. Freeze 441-480 old dots at their current decline and build. The decline already naturally provides an offset to their accumulated training/VPs.

2) Keep the whole freeze training/VPs at day 440. Freeze 441-480 old dots at their current decline. Strip their VPs accumulated from day 441+, and halve their decline penalty.

3) Make VP/Training continue until day 480. We then have one season of moderate growth, and 2 complete plateau.
 
nyfoot2003
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Mstr_October
I am referring to this current season, which if extended plateau had existed prior to now, would not have existed for these 440-480 dots. Isn't this the argument? That the players that are currently in their first season of decline would not have gotten to train THIS season under these new plateau rules and should be punished with some sort of decline to make up for this season's gain?

If this season was allowed to play out without a freeze, they would get 8 days of Pre-season, 40 days of season, plus 8 days of off-season to train and acquire BTs, which is actually 168 BTs on Light training.

Next season's players will not get that extra season of training until they reach true decline, so to make it fair, we have to erase the added VAs, and figure out a TRUE decline to set these players that equals the training and BTs that they accumulated this season, which I figure is somewhere between 1 and 2%, not 5%.




No, because this system that gives you 3 bonus tokens per train has only been around for 1 season, and every single dot has gotten the same number of bonus tokens from it. Season 5 dots have 1 extra season of training under the old system, which at most translates to 66 bonus tokens. NOT 168. The old system you got 1 bonus token every 5 training points. Please read over my words again carefully and hopefully you will understand then.
 
23yrwej
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Dpride59
Originally posted by jrry32


Actually dpride, I said cutting it off at D440 would be easier because it would avoid all of these workarounds and look, I was right because now no one is satisfied with the workaround.


No shit, you got an under achieving wr, and like 9 stud s6d0 dots. Your self serving blindly biased half ass way of jumping to the shittiest conclusion on the map every time is as money as me dunking on your vertically challenged ass in real life


You can dunk?

I am not trying to self serve at all, Bort cutting it off at D480 allows Booster to play another season. Cutting it off at D440 allows my S6 dots to be on top, I just think that his workaround here sucks. It doesn't make sense. I mean, it doesn't have a huge effect on me, I can just retire Booster but if he's going to do it, he might as well do it right. And again, I was right, Bort's workaround has pissed everyone off. Cutting it off at D440 would have made it easier.

EDIT: But I do find it funny how hypocritical you are, the only reason you are for cutting it off at D480 is for your own interests. So don't play like you give a shit about anyone other than yourself.
Edited by jrry32 on Jun 25, 2010 19:47:58
 
CanadianBacon
offline
Link
 
Love the idea!
 
Voltron
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by kurieg
I see that Bort wants some penalty that naturally scales with how far along the dot is from day 441 to day 480. At least, I'm guessing that's rationale for freezing decline.

Some suggested ways of making the new change more fair to everyone:

1) Keep the whole freeze training/VPs at day 440. Freeze 441-480 old dots at their current decline and build. The decline already naturally provides an offset to their accumulated training/VPs.

2) Keep the whole freeze training/VPs at day 440. Freeze 441-480 old dots at their current decline. Strip their VPs accumulated from day 441+, and halve their decline penalty.

3) Make VP/Training continue until day 480. We then have one season of moderate growth, and 2 complete plateau.


I like option 3, but DD didn't like it because then it only counts as 2 complete plateau and not 3.
 
avgbrad
offline
Link
 
i'm for anything that pisses kai and stern off

this seems p win
 
ufshowboat
I has 7 titles
offline
Link
 
So I read through a ton of this long post to confirm exactly what I thought.....

Theres only a couple jokers in here who whined about the extended decline... their post count probably in the 100s alone while the majority of people disagree.... but those couple whiners got them to make a change and now everybody is pissed
 
jdbolick
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by ufshowboat
So I read through a ton of this long post to confirm exactly what I thought.....

Theres only a couple jokers in here who whined about the extended decline... their post count probably in the 100s alone while the majority of people disagree.... but those couple whiners got them to make a change and now everybody is pissed

Actually the initial proposal left S5 dots overpowered, whereas the new proposal makes them worthless. I have no idea why they simply aren't frozen exactly the way they'll look at the end of this season. They'll still be worse than S6 dots, but not worthless.
 
TCR
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by ufshowboat
So I read through a ton of this long post to confirm exactly what I thought.....

Theres only a couple jokers in here who whined about the extended decline... their post count probably in the 100s alone while the majority of people disagree.... but those couple whiners got them to make a change and now everybody is pissed


That is the way I see it also.
 
jdros13
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Bort
I really don't feel like changing things yet again, but we could just chop the frozen decline pct in half if that works better.

We're not going going to add a convoluted buy-back system or "this set of guys gets 10 TP's and this set gets 20" etc for one generation of dots. More confusing than its worth.

Also, in the end somebody's going to be unhappy, no matter what the deal is. People with 481 day players are bummed, there are people who are just confused, and people who don't seem to like anything are angry as always. At some point you gotta say "that's it" and go with something.


if you cut it in half I think it's a win personally and you accomplish the perceived goal of having more dots who are ready to compete at the upper levels which in turn will push more dots down a bit.
 
Dpride59
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by ufshowboat
So I read through a ton of this long post to confirm exactly what I thought.....

Theres only a couple jokers in here who whined about the extended decline... their post count probably in the 100s alone while the majority of people disagree.... but those couple whiners got them to make a change and now everybody is pissed


ding. What we need to do is post those users comments in every thread during recruiting season

Originally posted by jdbolick

I have no idea why they simply aren't frozen exactly the way they'll look at the end of this season. They'll still be worse than S6 dots, but not worthless.

No one does.
 
23yrwej
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by jdbolick
Originally posted by ufshowboat

So I read through a ton of this long post to confirm exactly what I thought.....

Theres only a couple jokers in here who whined about the extended decline... their post count probably in the 100s alone while the majority of people disagree.... but those couple whiners got them to make a change and now everybody is pissed

Actually the initial proposal left S5 dots overpowered, whereas the new proposal makes them worthless. I have no idea why they simply aren't frozen exactly the way they'll look at the end of this season. They'll still be worse than S6 dots, but not worthless.


I still don't like that.
Edited by jrry32 on Jun 25, 2010 20:04:13
 
jdros13
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by jdbolick

Actually the initial proposal left S5 dots overpowered, whereas the new proposal makes them worthless. I have no idea why they simply aren't frozen exactly the way they'll look at the end of this season. They'll still be worse than S6 dots, but not worthless.


that is what the proposal is - frozen at their decline at the end of the season (480 = -5%, 472 = -4%, 464 = -3%, etc). Cut that in half and I think it's close enough personally.

If you are talking about the VA's (just realized that is probably what you mean)....they needed to go.
Edited by jdros13 on Jun 25, 2010 20:05:07
 
23yrwej
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Dpride59
Originally posted by ufshowboat

So I read through a ton of this long post to confirm exactly what I thought.....

Theres only a couple jokers in here who whined about the extended decline... their post count probably in the 100s alone while the majority of people disagree.... but those couple whiners got them to make a change and now everybody is pissed


ding. What we need to do is post those users comments in every thread during recruiting season


Originally posted by jdbolick


I have no idea why they simply aren't frozen exactly the way they'll look at the end of this season. They'll still be worse than S6 dots, but not worthless.

No one does.


I agree, do it. Sounds like a great idea.
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.