User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Forum > Goal Line Blitz > In Response to Bort's Final Post in the Test Server Thread
Page:
 
sjmay
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by UsCtRoJaNs1820
Originally posted by awesome

Originally posted by sjmay


Originally posted by Saerin



the whole thing that gets me here is this

1)Bort has mentioned the Test server more than once since.

and

2) I seriously doubt if many of the people crying "FOUL!! I didnt get to use the test server" had has access to the test server that they would claim it was "cheating" to be a tester.

Now since Bort has said he was going to release all the data, people can finally quit whining about the subject.


LOL Now i know you are dreaming, people quit whining on GLB?

I can GUARANTEE you that as soon as Bort releases the data, you are gonna get a whole new crop of

but I can't UNDERSTAND WHAT THE DATA MEANS, type of posts.


No, we are already stating our concerns with the formatting of the data. As is currently being proposed, it will be in the form of "reports," filtered by mods/testers. This means, by necessity, that there is still information that they have access to that we won't. If they have access to raw data, so should we.


The tester blog isn't the solution just a cheap fix imo



It was never meant to be a solution, but you guys clamored after the same data, you are now getting it.
 
tpaterniti
Lead Mod
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by UsCtRoJaNs1820
Originally posted by tpaterniti

Yes I believe I should still be able to play. I know you don't and we'll have to agree to disagree on that one.


My point exactly then. You've already learned something from that tester server that has already helped you and how you're going to build your players and tell others on your team and teams you GM for in the future. Not cool and any testers team will be tainted


non sequitur much?
 
Signalsgt
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by sjmay
Originally posted by smallbugger

Originally posted by Koncorde


Originally posted by smallbugger



read their posts...they say it is "unlikely" fellow guys got an advantage.... that's not a no

The guys that have come forward are respected guys... and they are honest enough not to come out and say their was not an advantage. Thus Bort opened a door to a select buddies that could have been used to beat normal paying customers that didn't know they were going against Bort's favorites


The lack of a "no" does not mean a "yes".

I see lots of coulds, maybes, and ifs and no actual dids, would and ares.


like I said the door was open, and that is Bort's fault. I asked it before.... you loose a league championship as a normal user to a "tester". Did they have an upper hand? .... well at least they had the chance didn't they?


I will give you that much, granted.

Now, how much does losing a league championship, matter? Right now, when you KNOW powerbacks are dialed way up, when you KNOW coverage is a bit screwy, when you KNOW other things about the sim are a bit screwed,

How much does loosing that championship now mean vs improving the game to it means something?


I agree with you 100% to that point. The only thing that it does affect is in-game money. To teams that have a maxed out stadium and the cash to pay for equipment upgrades for every player on the team it means nothing. To those that play off cash meant the difference between upgrades or equipment it could mean quite a bit.

So after the data is parsed, the only thing GLB as an entity could owe is a couple million dollars of in-game cash to owners.

 
Koncorde
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by UsCtRoJaNs1820
The tester blog isn't the solution just a cheap fix imo



That's exactly what it is. Nail, on, head. Well done. Job complete. We can close this thread now, I think we're sorted.
 
Link
 
tpaterniti I have to say that you are wrong with your thinking. Of course you are going to want to keep playing because you will have gained an unfair advantage. Put yourself in someone else's shoes.
 
awesome
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by tpaterniti
If you are a conspiracy theorist chances are you will never be satisfied no matter how much info is revealed.


Take the ad hominem elsewhere. You are a mod, for chrissakes.
 
Weather
offline
Link
 
The question that has not been clearly answered, which is really the key point in this issue:

Originally posted by mantis7

Darkus, I think the question is this:

COULD someone use the knowledge from the test server to gain an unfair advantage over another paying customer...

Lets assume you did not, which I am more than willing to do...

COULD someone else though...That is the point...Is it a possibility...???

If it is, then this issue needs moire than a wink and a nudge and some locked threads IMO.
 
cbarge
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by awesome
Originally posted by tpaterniti

If you are a conspiracy theorist chances are you will never be satisfied no matter how much info is revealed.


Take the ad hominem elsewhere. You are a mod, for chrissakes.


Wasn't really an ad hominem TBH.
 
sjmay
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by smallbugger
Originally posted by sjmay

Originally posted by smallbugger


Originally posted by Koncorde



Originally posted by smallbugger




read their posts...they say it is "unlikely" fellow guys got an advantage.... that's not a no

The guys that have come forward are respected guys... and they are honest enough not to come out and say their was not an advantage. Thus Bort opened a door to a select buddies that could have been used to beat normal paying customers that didn't know they were going against Bort's favorites


The lack of a "no" does not mean a "yes".

I see lots of coulds, maybes, and ifs and no actual dids, would and ares.


like I said the door was open, and that is Bort's fault. I asked it before.... you loose a league championship as a normal user to a "tester". Did they have an upper hand? .... well at least they had the chance didn't they?


I will give you that much, granted.

Now, how much does losing a league championship, matter? Right now, when you KNOW powerbacks are dialed way up, when you KNOW coverage is a bit screwy, when you KNOW other things about the sim are a bit screwed,

How much does loosing that championship now mean vs improving the game to it means something?


it matters enough that I spent hours scouting and spent money on this game. Those that discount how much the current game matters really need to understand the BETA tag is bullshit. Bort is now selling a game, thus the need to not have us paying customers be the "testers" ourselves anymore


Trying to get this damn quoting done right lol,

Anyways, I spend the same amount of hours scouting, well for important games, and I spend money on this game as well, but you have to put in context, and yes Bort is selling a game, but as been previously mentioned, you still have 300K users who will bring bugs to the attention of the staff, and then you have the testers, to test that bug to make sure it is legit etc, it still doesn't take away from the "beta" tag, as the game is evolving/changing, call it beta or not, it really doesn't matter at this point.
 
wombat killer
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by tpaterniti
If you are a conspiracy theorist chances are you will never be satisfied no matter how much info is revealed.


And if you are a cheater you will always lie to protect yourself. See how silly of an argument that is.
 
Link
 
Originally posted by awesome
Originally posted by tpaterniti

If you are a conspiracy theorist chances are you will never be satisfied no matter how much info is revealed.


Take the ad hominem elsewhere. You are a mod, for chrissakes.



You'll notice that many of the mods are no good. They can get away with saying anything they want. The fact of the matter is that yes you can get an advanatge by being a tester and that should not be.
 
sjmay
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by awesome
Originally posted by tpaterniti

If you are a conspiracy theorist chances are you will never be satisfied no matter how much info is revealed.


Take the ad hominem elsewhere. You are a mod, for chrissakes.


Despite what he said being the truth, being a mod, he shouldn't be allowed to be truthful?
 
nickr1
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by tpaterniti
Yes I believe I should still be able to play. I know you don't and we'll have to agree to disagree on that one.


Bort at one time mentioned that some of the testers were burnt out on the game and might be willing to give up their players/teams and become dedicated testers for a season or two. Is this still being considered or were their no members of the test team willing to go that route?
 
sjmay
offline
Link
 
Signals,

Pretty much, which, as a team owner, who would love that cash right about now, doesn't really matter as I got a team full of great agents who can survive without that lol.
 
wombat killer
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by sjmay


I can see that, and just refresh my memory, working on 3 hours sleep is wearing my patience down,

Where did I ever say that no one had the right to feel upset? I probably have said it wasn't rational, but I never denied the right to feel upset, I also have said that it hasn't mattered, in the past etc.


If you knew that, then why ask the question? Maybe its just me, but the impression I got from your post was you didn't feel people had the right to feel upset.

 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.