User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Forum > Game Changes Discussion > Archived Changes > Extended Plateau Discussion
Page:
 
nyfoot2003
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by RyanCane26
sup


You don't understand that we have all had the same # of days in this new system. Read my post above..At most we have 66 extra bonus tokens. That is assuming you train on intense every day since day 1. If you think 66 bonus tokens is worth a 5 percent decline, you built your dot wrong.
 
NorDoor
offline
Link
 
The new change to the new change= me retiring players for flexies.
 
GranpaQB
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by NorDoor
The new change to the new change= me retiring players for flexies.


Same here. Went from good to useless in one " SMALL" change.
Edited by GranpaQB on Jun 25, 2010 19:16:17
 
boomer82
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by NorDoor
The new change to the new change= me retiring players for flexies.


Yep. If my player is still going to have all the negatives of decline stuck with him without any of the benefits (extra VPs) then good bye.

I'd be fine with giving up the extra VPs if he got his decline reset to 0.
 
RyanCane26
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by nyfoot2003
You don't understand that we have all had the same # of days in this new system. Read my post above..At most we have 66 extra bonus tokens. That is assuming you train on intense every day since day 1. If you think 66 bonus tokens is worth a 5 percent decline, you built your dot wrong.


it has nothing to do with s5 dots, it has to do with i'm losing 96 bonus tokens from day 441-473 that i had planned on using to upgrade equipment that I've spent non-refundable bonus tokens on making
 
BP
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by jdbolick

And actually, me not liking something has a pretty damn good record of meaning it wasn't the best choice for GLB. The problem here is that I understand the context while you don't.




All anybody has to do is look at your players on Austin to know what the motive behind your stance is...transparent. There is no arguing with someone who refused to accept anything but the solution that fits them the best...good luck with ur dots
Edited by BP on Jun 25, 2010 19:22:29
 
jdbolick
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by BP
All anybody has to do is look at your players on Austin to know what the motive behind your stance is...transparent. There is no arguing with someone who refused to accept anything but the solution that fits them the best...good luck with ur dots

Kudos for not only ignoring a logical argument you couldn't even begin to answer, but also embarrassing yourself yet again with a stupid assumption. Ask someone on AWFB if I hadn't already said that I prefer to retire my guys regardless of what happens with the plateau unless they're desperately needed. Moreover, the only three that would even apply to are the offensive linemen. I am not arguing this out of selfish personal interest, I am arguing this because I am vastly more intelligent than you are.
 
Mstr_October
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by nyfoot2003
It's not 150 extra bonus tokens. It is AT MOST 66. read my post above. S5 dots have had exactly the same # of seasons training under the new system as S6 and after. The extra season was a year and a half ago when ppl didn't know what bonus tokens were actually worth and when you only got 2 every 5 days if you decided to go all out on them. 3 X 22=66 not 150


I am referring to this current season, which if extended plateau had existed prior to now, would not have existed for these 440-480 dots. Isn't this the argument? That the players that are currently in their first season of decline would not have gotten to train THIS season under these new plateau rules and should be punished with some sort of decline to make up for this season's gain?

If this season was allowed to play out without a freeze, they would get 8 days of Pre-season, 40 days of season, plus 8 days of off-season to train and acquire BTs, which is actually 168 BTs on Light training.

Next season's players will not get that extra season of training until they reach true decline, so to make it fair, we have to erase the added VAs, and figure out a TRUE decline to set these players that equals the training and BTs that they accumulated this season, which I figure is somewhere between 1 and 2%, not 5%.




 
Mstr_October
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by BP


All anybody has to do is look at your players on Austin to know what the motive behind your stance is...transparent. There is no arguing with someone who refused to accept anything but the solution that fits them the best...good luck with ur dots


Your argument is as fail as the company in your avi.

5% decline does not equal the gains they received this season. Simple.

If VAs were removed, and decline was at 2%, I say bravo, but 5% is too stiff of a penalty for what was received.

I mean, fairness was your argument, but now you don't want to be fair to this specific group of dots. Make up your mind, do want fairness and balance, or just to argue with people for the sake of argument?
 
boomer82
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by BP
Originally posted by jdbolick


And actually, me not liking something has a pretty damn good record of meaning it wasn't the best choice for GLB. The problem here is that I understand the context while you don't.




All anybody has to do is look at your players on Austin to know what the motive behind your stance is...transparent. There is no arguing with someone who refused to accept anything but the solution that fits them the best...good luck with ur dots


This solution isn't the best though. Should be 3 options for <480 players:

1) Freeze your player as is, will not decline further but will not gain VPs & whatever else
2) Reset decline on your player but forefit any VPs gained during that time. Will not gain additional VPs etc.
3) Continue with your player. Will continue to decline & gain VPs etc. under the current system.
 
razor9
offline
Link
 
Guys, why are we still talking about this? Are they really going to change their minds yet again and make yet another announcement? The answer is no. I suggest we all move on and spend our energy elsewhere.
 
jdbolick
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by razor9
Guys, why are we still talking about this? Are they really going to change their minds yet again and make yet another announcement? The answer is no. I suggest we all move on and spend our energy elsewhere.

History says that GLB will change its mind at least three more times before this is implemented, then they'll change it again in a season or two when this turns out to be a disaster.
 
23yrwej
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Dpride59
Originally posted by Bukowski

Who were these people so upset about the change yesterday?


Gart and, jrry. 4000 people in support and gart saying he will fill his roster with s5d0 if it doesn't get changed. He forgot to mention 80% of his dots suck, and he hated the idea of losing to the kai for another 3 seasons. lmao



Actually dpride, I said cutting it off at D440 would be easier because it would avoid all of these workarounds and look, I was right because now no one is satisfied with the workaround.
 
EagleOtto
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by razor9
Guys, why are we still talking about this? Are they really going to change their minds yet again and make yet another announcement? The answer is no. I suggest we all move on and spend our energy elsewhere.


I'd rather let management know how disappointed I am first, count the money i'll save next season by retiring all my season 5 guys, calculate how many players i can fully boost off my retirement flex without spending another cent, then walk away...
 
23yrwej
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Bort
I really don't feel like changing things yet again, but we could just chop the frozen decline pct in half if that works better.

We're not going going to add a convoluted buy-back system or "this set of guys gets 10 TP's and this set gets 20" etc for one generation of dots. More confusing than its worth.

Also, in the end somebody's going to be unhappy, no matter what the deal is. People with 481 day players are bummed, there are people who are just confused, and people who don't seem to like anything are angry as always. At some point you gotta say "that's it" and go with something.


As I said, 5% is just crazy for thinking it evens up that season of training if you do the math. After you workout some of the math 1-2%(for S5 D0 dots) is a fairly fair compromise instead of the 5%.
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.