User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Forum > Game Changes Discussion > Archived Changes > Extended Plateau Discussion
Page:
 
P.B.
offline
Link
 
The only ones bitching are the people with a bunch of season 5 dots. Season 6 dots will be bitching as soon as they learn they can't complete their builds because training stops at 440.

Season 5 dots were retiring anyways.


In a good solution everyone should bitch a little.
 
P.B.
offline
Link
 
Everything evens out in a few seasons.
 
nyfoot2003
offline
Link
 
People need to stop saying that S5 dots have 160 extra bonus tokens. Bonus tokens were BRAND NEW when S5 dots were made. It was literally the first season of AEQ. Most people didn't even know how good they were/didn't try to get them every time for the stop.

IN ADDITION

people are forgetting that in the old training system, you only got AT MOST 1 bonus token every 5 training points, which is 2 bonus tokens every five days, or around 22 bonus tokens in a 55 day season. When we did the transition, bort gave us 3 new bonus tokens for each old one we had. That means the one additional season only had 66 extra bonus tokens assuming we trained on combo every single day throughout that extra season. Stop saying it is 160 because at most it is 66.

66 extra bonus tokens doesn't get you close to an extra piece of AEQ and it is not worth forcing us to lock in our decline. Taking away the vet points is fair, but you should take away the decline.
 
reddogrw
HOOD
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Bort
Originally posted by reddogrw

cut off VA's at day 440

so you get:
400-440 - plateau on XP, VA's and training + BT's
441-480 - train + BT's - easing towards a plateau if you will
481-560 - 2 seasons of pure plateau
561+ training + VA's resume, decline starts (and you can also go just get TP and skip getting VXP back)

addresses all the concerns and eases into the plateau - no dot ever has an advantage due to when they were built

http://goallineblitz.com/game/forum_thread.pl?thread_id=4116391


You'd still have to remove VA's from existing 440-480 guys...and it's not the true 3 seasons we were looking at.

Also, what if I only boosted like 3 times and get 12 days? How long can I train? It is much easier to just say "cut off during the extra days" due to this.


ok - remove the VA's

what is so sacred about 3 purely plateau seasons?

1 season with only training and 2 with nothing - doing nothing at all for 3 seasons will be pretty boring don't you think?

guess I will just sit back and see where we end up
 
Mstr_October
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by BP
this is wrong. Those dots had a chance to play past 440 and enjoy their dots for an extended period, longer then sub 440 dots. Just to say roll them back and take the VA's back and don't freeze basically leaves them with an unfair BT and training advantage AND extra days of sim enjoyment watching their players. That's extremely unfair. To just freeze them and not take the stuff back and give them 3 seasons of plateau gives them an unfair Vet Point/BT advantage...which is why this whole thing came up.


So you think -5% decline is fair to these players? Do you honestly think that the 1 season of:

A. Light training and 150 BTs
B. Normal training and 100 BTs
C. Intense training and 50 BTs.

that they got this season is = to a -5% decline to all skills?

How many Skill Points do you feel this season of training netted these players? Do you care? What would be fair, truly?

If you take away the extra VAs and freeze decline right now. THAT would be fair. I hope you understand what fair is, and not what is advantageous to one set group.
 
Dpride59
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Bort
Well, I haven't exactly written the freeze code yet. It's not exactly complicated, but still gotta do it.

We'd also prefer to have a little warning as to "hey you can't train any more" ya know?


It would even out if they keep the va's they have and don't decline anymore. 0 tears IMO
 
jdbolick
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by BP
because you say so? Freezing decline and rolling back the VA's is fair, know why? cuz that dot had extra time to train and accumulate BT's and training gains that are still in his build, and also played at the highest lvl longer.

Evidently you have no familiarity the concept known as mathematics. A 5% penalty to physical attributes along with the 2.5% penalty to everything else is vastly larger than the effect gained from extra training and bonus tokens. So any S4d40+ or S5d0 dots who choose to enter an extended plateau would clearly be inferior to their S5d40+/S6d0 counterparts, just not as completely useless as they would be with frozen decline and rolled-back VAs. Honestly, if that's the "solution" then Bort should just not allow anyone over Day 440 to enter the extended plateau and be done with it, because those dots are going to be irrelevant anyway.

Originally posted by
Don't even pretend like you can define when I "embarrass" myself....

You embarrassing yourself doesn't need any comment from me to be a reality, I just want you to stop doing it.

Originally posted by
Understand now? just because YOU don't like something doesn't mean it isn't the best choice, don't embarrass YOURSELF by not understanding what's going on here....

And actually, me not liking something has a pretty damn good record of meaning it wasn't the best choice for GLB. The problem here is that I understand the context while you don't.
 
nyfoot2003
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Mstr_October
So you think -5% decline is fair to these players? Do you honestly think that the 1 season of:

A. Light training and 150 BTs
B. Normal training and 100 BTs
C. Intense training and 50 BTs.

that they got this season is = to a -5% decline to all skills?

How many Skill Points do you feel this season of training netted these players? Do you care? What would be fair, truly?

If you take away the extra VAs and freeze decline right now. THAT would be fair. I hope you understand what fair is, and not what is advantageous to one set group.


It's not 150 extra bonus tokens. It is AT MOST 66. read my post above. S5 dots have had exactly the same # of seasons training under the new system as S6 and after. The extra season was a year and a half ago when ppl didn't know what bonus tokens were actually worth and when you only got 2 every 5 days if you decided to go all out on them. 3 X 22=66 not 150
Edited by nyfoot2003 on Jun 25, 2010 18:58:15
 
AngryDragon
offline
Link
 
I think this guy will make the cut but I am not 100% sure since everybody is talking about season 5 dots.

http://goallineblitz.com/game/player.pl?player_id=907855

He is season 4 day 44. I think he will be exactly 480 days old. I hope at least.
 
DONKEIDIC
pinto
offline
Link
 
How does this simple thing get so far out of hand?
 
ChicagoTRS
offline
Link
 
tbh ending VAs at 440 is a positive to me...less VAs is a good thing...
 
Supahfli
offline
Link
 
I agree that taking away Vet pts is fair, but the decline should also go away, or at least be toned down.

I just did some quick math, and to make up for my players decline at 462 days old right now, it would take 26 SP to get his main 4 physical attribs to where they were pre decline. That doesn't take into account the rest of his attribs. There is no way 1 season of training equals that SP loss.
Edited by Supahfli on Jun 25, 2010 19:03:28
 
nyfoot2003
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by BP
because you say so? Freezing decline and rolling back the VA's is fair, know why? cuz that dot had extra time to train and accumulate BT's and training gains that are still in his build, and also played at the highest lvl longer.

Don't even pretend like you can define when I "embarrass" myself....

Understand now? just because YOU don't like something doesn't mean it isn't the best choice, don't embarrass YOURSELF by not understanding what's going on here....


No, you are wrong. We have all had the same amount of time to get bonus tokens under the new system. S5 dots have AT most 66 extra bonus tokens, which barely does you anything. This is assuming they trained on intense every sngle day their first season, which is unlikely to me, since back then we didn't really know how powerful AEQ would be. Don't you remember what back in S5?
 
RyanCane26
offline
Link
 
Please reimburse S6 dots who planned on finishing their AEQ from Day 441-480
 
RyanCane26
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by pboggs
The only ones bitching are the people with a bunch of season 5 dots. Season 6 dots will be bitching as soon as they learn they can't complete their builds because training stops at 440.


sup
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.