User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Forum > Goal Line Blitz > In Response to Bort's Final Post in the Test Server Thread
Page:
 
wombat killer
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Signalsgt
Originally posted by wombat killer

Originally posted by tpaterniti


Some people are glad testing is being done. Others are outraged.


I haven't seen anyone outraged that testing is being done. Any outrage is directed at who is doing the testing.



Outrage is a strong word, I'm not even annoyed. I can see a clear advantage of being able to run sim after sim to determine plays that are broken at a code level. Then run them over and over to win.

So before I join the pitchfork and lit torch crew, I want to know what exactly was available to these select few and how did their teams do from the time the learned their "secret handshake".


Yeah, I only used the word outrage because tpat did. I like to think no one would ever be outraged by a computer game.
 
Koncorde
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by smallbugger
Originally posted by Koncorde



I suggest you don't tell me what can and can't be tested, or has or has not been tested - as you cannot have that knowledge, let alone the confidence that someone in your league actually gained from the testing taking place on the testing server.


and the issue is we just don't know... we're unsure if bort screwed over everyone huge by giving his friends a golden ticket of knowledge or not


And the fact that 3 or 4 have specifically stated that they have not?

And in some cases haven't even had chance to run a single test?
 
NickyNapoleon
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by smallbugger
Originally posted by Koncorde



I suggest you don't tell me what can and can't be tested, or has or has not been tested - as you cannot have that knowledge, let alone the confidence that someone in your league actually gained from the testing taking place on the testing server.


and the issue is we just don't know... we're unsure if bort screwed over everyone huge by giving his friends a golden ticket of knowledge or not


This is the paramount problem with this whole situation. Nobody knows what all has gone on, and we are getting NOTHING from any of the staff members to help ease teh concerns. Its a problem that this game has had from teh very beginning. Its the ostrich with its head in the sand scenario. If we cant see it, it doesnt exist.
 
sjmay
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by mantis7
Originally posted by tpaterniti

If that is true then so be it. We don't have the resources to do it.


If you are referring to opening up your test servers to everyone, then I call shannanigans...

Do what you need to do to make them available to everyone...If that means that each user only gets X amount of sims in X amount of time, so be it...

If that means each user is limited in total number of sims per season SO BE IT ...

ETC...Etc..

Let EVERYONE have access...

That is the only fair solution man.


Mantis,

As fair as that is, you know that isn't going to happen, logistically that would crash the server from overload at the bare minimum.

A. you are assuming there is more than one test server ( I don't know how many there are, but I would not assume there to be 30 like some people etc)

B. you have to realize with 300K+ users, how many are online at any given time, hence the need for 30 servers,

C. how would you logistically allow everyone their tiny bit of access and regulate it?
 
Link
 
Originally posted by mantis7
Originally posted by Cronus6

You're right. Clearly YOU should be the one to pick the testers for the test server, not the guy who writes the code. How stupid of me.


Everyone should have equal access... end of story...

It is easily doable, without adding many additional resources.


Agreed

 
sjmay
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Signalsgt
Originally posted by


Wrong as it was never advertised as such,

Next.


Wait Wait Wait..in the below text, please respond and put into bold text the part where Bort acknowledges that here is sub-group of testers that will have an advantage over Joe Noob who stumbled upon the site and is interested in making a player.

From the home page:
Goal Line Blitz is a web-based American Football MMORPG. We've written a custom football simulation engine to provide you with the ultimate football experience on the web.

Do you love fantasy football? Ever wished you could play with the pros? Join other football fans from around the world in building the player and team of your dreams, right here.

Player Management

* Create a custom player, at any position on the football field, and assign any name you want
* Train your player from the ground up to be the type of player you want
* Gain experience from playing games to improve your player's abilities
* Sign with teams from around the world and negotiate your contract
* Create custom signature equipment
* And much more!


Own a Team

* Manage every aspect of a football team
* Set ticket and concession prices
* Improve your stadium with new seats, sections, and amenities
* Sign, cut, and trade players
* Set game-by-game strategy
* Play to win the league championship
* And much more!

So either calm down or grow up you douche.


Yea, don't see anything about not having testers, or it being a "level" playing field.
 
Signalsgt
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Cronus6
Originally posted by Signalsgt

Originally posted by


Not sur what you are getting at, that the code doesn't resemble football? So you have a basis to sue?


If you purchase anything that does not do what it represents itself to do that is called fraud. That was more of a response to Cronus's asinine statement that Bort can do whatever he want's because it's "his code". Which would be true if paying for flex wasn't an option.


You're right. Clearly YOU should be the one to pick the testers for the test server, not the guy who writes the code. How stupid of me.


Now now, don't be so hard on yourself. I wouldn't call you stupid, just ill-informed.
 
Bort
Admin
offline
Link
 
Just a quick update - I haven't been on because I'm busy setting up outputs of game data from the test server for people to look at, not because "I don't care." It should be ready later tonight and and I'll post a sticky with links to stuff. I'll have a text file with a list of builds for all the test players and games/replays will be viewable without logging in via a basic list of game by game id, etc.
 
mantis7
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Darkus Black
Originally posted by mantis7

Originally posted by tpaterniti


Many [MMORPG's] allow testers to play and all of them chose testers carefully.


This is simply untrue. I don't know if you actually believe this, or you are just a 'company man' or fanboy or whatever you want to call it...But MANY rpgs allow ALL users to be on the test servers, especially PVP rpgs (which esentially this IS a PVP rpg)....

I will name 3 right now to stave off the 'no they don't' crowd:

Sony - Planetside

NCsoft - City of Heroes / City of Villians

Secondlife



Don't forget that they have massive resources available to them to be able to afford that. This is a startup company with very little initial capital investment. This is not based on me being a 'company man' either. The comparisons are world's apart for those games and this one.


Dark,

It would be simple to address this problem by limiting the amount of time/sims that each user could use the test servers....The demand for test servers would probably be very low during the season, and may be more around playoffs and offseason, but with limitations on # of sims per user or something along those lines, would be feasable.

Thank you for listening.
 
tpaterniti
Lead Mod
offline
Link
 
Well I don't do tactics for anyone. I build my players and that is it. Most of them get 5 level ups a season including boosts. That's 25 skill points which usually translates to about 5-8 attribute points I could change them a season. Not much I can do to change them now except equipment, but as I said our testing does not involve finding optimal ratios of things. Like what is the optimal ratio of speed to agility for a DE? All I know about it has been trial and error on real GLB. There is no need to test it right now since there does not appear to be any problem with how those aspects of the game are working. What we may do is test a player with 15 jump the snap and see if, for example, the DE always gets penalties but never anything good, or if he always gets sacks and never gets penalties. If he does either bort will change it. If it seems reasonable he will leave it alone. The goal is to make the game intuitive and balanced. If you have 15 in jump the snap you expect a certain outcome and that outcome should happen. No more, no less. We test so that what you expect to be true about the game turns out to be true in actuality so we don't create elements of the game that seem to be a waste of skill points or vet points.
 
Dpride59
offline
Link
 
This is completely illogical. I want everyone to understand the problems about what is going on. I feel completely outraged about these things that are said in here which I don't agree upon. I hope a remedy is near,, I cannot handle this anymore. I demand a solution to this problem for it is needed. Plz stop the unfairness of the issues at hand. Or bans will be given
 
wombat killer
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Koncorde
Originally posted by smallbugger

Originally posted by Koncorde




I suggest you don't tell me what can and can't be tested, or has or has not been tested - as you cannot have that knowledge, let alone the confidence that someone in your league actually gained from the testing taking place on the testing server.


and the issue is we just don't know... we're unsure if bort screwed over everyone huge by giving his friends a golden ticket of knowledge or not


And the fact that 3 or 4 have specifically stated that they have not?

And in some cases haven't even had chance to run a single test?


Tpat stated he gave out any information he learned to anyone that asked.
 
sjmay
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Koncorde
Originally posted by smallbugger

Originally posted by Koncorde




I suggest you don't tell me what can and can't be tested, or has or has not been tested - as you cannot have that knowledge, let alone the confidence that someone in your league actually gained from the testing taking place on the testing server.


and the issue is we just don't know... we're unsure if bort screwed over everyone huge by giving his friends a golden ticket of knowledge or not


And the fact that 3 or 4 have specifically stated that they have not?

And in some cases haven't even had chance to run a single test?


Don't let direct quotes stand in the way of their outrage.
 
Cronus6
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by mantis7
Originally posted by Cronus6

You're right. Clearly YOU should be the one to pick the testers for the test server, not the guy who writes the code. How stupid of me.


Everyone should have equal access... end of story...

It is easily doable, without adding many additional resources.


So EVERY Windows user should have access to the early, unstable Alpha and Beta builds of the "free" Windows service packs?

I mean we DID pay for Windows and will eventually get the service pack (once it's stable and tested) right?
 
Link
 
Originally posted by sjmay
Originally posted by Signalsgt

Originally posted by



Wrong as it was never advertised as such,

Next.


Wait Wait Wait..in the below text, please respond and put into bold text the part where Bort acknowledges that here is sub-group of testers that will have an advantage over Joe Noob who stumbled upon the site and is interested in making a player.

From the home page:
Goal Line Blitz is a web-based American Football MMORPG. We've written a custom football simulation engine to provide you with the ultimate football experience on the web.

Do you love fantasy football? Ever wished you could play with the pros? Join other football fans from around the world in building the player and team of your dreams, right here.

Player Management

* Create a custom player, at any position on the football field, and assign any name you want
* Train your player from the ground up to be the type of player you want
* Gain experience from playing games to improve your player's abilities
* Sign with teams from around the world and negotiate your contract
* Create custom signature equipment
* And much more!


Own a Team

* Manage every aspect of a football team
* Set ticket and concession prices
* Improve your stadium with new seats, sections, and amenities
* Sign, cut, and trade players
* Set game-by-game strategy
* Play to win the league championship
* And much more!

So either calm down or grow up you douche.


Yea, don't see anything about not having testers, or it being a "level" playing field.


Seriously kid quit posting. You know absolutely nothing about laws and how they work.

 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.