User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Forum > Announcements > Season 4 is over! What's in store for season 5 and beyond?
Page:
 
johndoe1986
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by lbrlove

Well, if you read the actual announcement, you will notice that there will be new persistent "items" as well.

But let's hypothetically say you are correct, that these are just small additions to player stats. So why do them? If everybody is eligible to collect performance-enhancing items, then it becomes an arms race. So what good is it? Now everybody needs to invest more time in just being competitive with everyone else. More time, less enjoyment, just to have a reset status quo.

Here is what it really comes down to: it is easy to give in to short-sighted players who actually *want* an arms race (a la fantasy MMORPG), and program for them (e.g. "magic items", a la carte training, etc). It will probably make your game more money too, at least in the short run. Moreover, Bort as much as said that the admins were nostalgic for traditional MMORPGs, kind of a ideological giveaway.

It is hard to actually model football, a complex sport full of strategy, athleticism, and human toughness. It appears from the announcement that the admins have really sold out toward the former. Many of us would rather they take the hard road in earnest.


The point of these additions was to give players a few more options in what they can do for customization. I believe they did that.

The persistent items are simply greater variety of equipment you can use.

Generally, the more time you spend on a game, the better you should be at that game.

Also, thanks for starting off your response by attacking 'whether I read the post'. You're case is much stronger because of it.

All said and done, I do think fixing certain aspects of the sim should be #1, but this does add some needed stuff for those player only people.
Last edited Sep 13, 2008 13:04:27
 
Zramsay
offline
Link
 
People actually pay money for this? Wow...
 
Link
 
Originally posted by Statalyzer

Geez, can we quit the stupid item complaint? Not one of them has any validity at all.

Here's what you had before the new changes: You could have your stats or SA's increased by a "heat-seeking missile" or "bugspray" or "spiked helmet". You could wear equipment (that is to say, ITEMS) such as "Gloves of Speed", "Doo-rag of Agility", "Shoes of Vision".

And that was ok, but "Gloves of Catching" are not okay? The new items make the game make more sense than it did before.


Here's what I had to say to people like you several pages back:

Originally posted by EpsteinsMother

I just joined in season 4, and I didn't really like the equipment bonuses in the first place, but of course I bought them -- if a level 8 player doesn't have any equipment, he's giving up almost 3 levels worth of skill points to another level 8 who has upgraded and custom equipment. I'd be playing at a huge disadvantage and it wouldn't send a message to anyone.

Those people who are saying things like, "You're already wearing a Shirt +4, so what's the difference?" or "So don't use the new equipment if you don't like it" are missing the point -- perhaps on purpose. I'm here for the football simulation aspect of the game. The equipment RPG aspect doesn't appeal to me, and I'm disappointed to see the game going even further in that direction. I'd be much happier to see all equipment removed. Adding Goggles of Swim Move is a sign to me that maybe this game isn't going in a direction that's worth my time and money. I'm glad I discovered that before I put too much money into it.

 
football1036
offline
Link
 
Nice thats sweet. when does season 5 start?
 
allstarpdc
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Statalyzer

Geez, can we quit the stupid item complaint? Not one of them has any validity at all.

Here's what you had before the new changes: You could have your stats or SA's increased by a "heat-seeking missile" or "bugspray" or "spiked helmet". You could wear equipment (that is to say, ITEMS) such as "Gloves of Speed", "Doo-rag of Agility", "Shoes of Vision".

And that was ok, but "Gloves of Catching" are not okay? The new items make the game make more sense than it did before.

And the you have owners who want Bort to only mess with plays and ignore players so that for 31 days players mostly can't do anything useful except log on every other day, check the team forum, and change your personal tactics.


Your argument is completely insane. Our upgrades every 8 levels and CE are all uniform. Anyone can get them & they are just part of player progression. I.E. every level 24 player should have +16 points to add to his attributes. Where he/she decides to put them (based on their knowledge of the game) can give a strategic advantage.

Now how often you go "shopping" is supposed to make you a better player?! And you say that makes more sense?!

And yes...we would like Bort to allow us to have more than run inside/outside and pass short/med/long as play-calling choices. This isn't TECMO BOWL (which is still one of the best video games ever).

If you are bored & want more to do in the game...go be a GM. There are tons of teams that need good ones. That is a far better alternative than playing this game like its a gridiron version of D&D.
 
lbrlove
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by johndoe1986
Also, thanks for starting off your response by attacking 'whether I read the post'. You're case is much stronger because of it.


Are you saying I was incorrect? Below are the lines - from before any mention of temporary items - quoted from the actual original announcement from Bort.

Originally posted by Bort
New items

We have decided to embrace our RPG roots and expand the equipment some. No +1 crossbows of haste, but you can get "gloves of catching" or similar.

- There is a new "advanced" item store. The equipment in this store give starting bonuses, as opposed to the "blank" basic items in the regular store.

- These items can give more than the standard +X to attributes. You can also gain +'s to SA's, even if they aren't on your position's SA tree. Also, there are some special "+X% to chance to catch the ball," or "+X% chance to force fumble" etc. items as well.

- These items cannot be upgraded with cash alone. You also need Bonus Tokens, as described above. Upgrades to them can occur at the same intervals as normal gear (level 8/16/24 etc).

- When you visit the store, 3 items that are level and class appropriate are randomly generated. You don't have to buy them. They will stick around until you "refresh" the store or choose to buy one.


If someone chose to take your statement at face value...

Originally posted by Statalyzer
The only real change in gameplay was the temporary stat boosts.


...they would have been misled. So yes, my case was made *much* stronger by referring to the authoritative article. Are you actually miffed about that? If so, I am sorry you feel that way. The point is to make sure we are talking about the admins' proposals and philosophy, not yours or mine.
 
Sling-n-Bling
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Llyranwyar
Originally posted by FBGProfessor

I agree. There were alot of ideas about items and this seems like the wrong way to go. Don't mind that players can buy items--but why turn it into RPG? Are there really that many kids playing the game? I would guess the core of people care more about being able to choose which side to run the ball.

The Rich Get Richer aspect is also a serious problem--there are so many ways in which the game does this and in the long run, you will lose owners and players when people realize they have no chance to compete. The success of a game like this, like the NFL, is parity. Parity also means that skill in tactics becomes decisive. We are moving further and further away from that IMO.

Originally posted by pumph


Originally posted by easycheez





I'm okay with the changes but I'm saddened that the emphasis is on the RPG 'one game boost' items and not the ability to play call. I think that people with football knowledge should be able to actually create plays (to an extent) so that a grown-man with play calling know-how can outplay a 14-year old kid that has players with tons of boosting items.




AMEN.




AMEN.

One thing I liked about this game is that it was fresh and completely different from the RPG MMO's. It was browser sport MMO. I read the new introductions and my heart sunk. I remember thinking OMG Bort introduced "POTTING" into a athletic MMO. WTF. Then there are the special +1 stat items. It made me sick to think about having to get your 'blues'and 'Purples' for a starting position on the raid, I mean team. Don't try to be W.O.W.-sports.

I really think Bort should have been spending his time more wisely by increasing the flexibility and detail in plays and ironing out some old problems. I am assuming that most people who own teams and GM get far more enjoyment in developing their strategies and rosters to complement their play styles. Allowing players to customize their play styles further would only enrich the game.

Applying his energy toward figuring out how to 'grease the wheels' for promotion and relegations would have been a much better use of his time than revamping training. Training was useful and practical no matter what take you have on it. Despite your opinion on slow-building, the training aspect wasn't dragging the game down like the competition levels in leagues.

While there is room and perhaps demand for things like 'locker room' attributes, that is really just bells and whistles. More focus needs to be paid attention to the heart of the game and making that better first. Adding the 'everything else' in too soon will detract from the game. Its already hard enough for people to field teams, based on the experience of some friends. Really, isn't the 'locker room' attributes really the mentality of the agent behind the player? You already have the field general abilities in place.

I just think there is too much emphasis being placed on the periphery of the game before the play on the field has been worked out. Let the agents, GM's, and Owners create the drama through good competion and smack talk. If you keep upsetting the apple cart and force people to relearn aspects of the game every season, they're going to become disenchated and quit.



As Bort already said, last season was all about updates to the GP and play calling aspect. He has plans for more of that but he wants to keep the MOB entertained as well. It's not just about the coaches and game play. Lose the MOB and there is no GLB. Most agents are not GMs and this game needs to get bigger for them too. The bells and whistles mean a lot to this games success.

I think GLB neads a bigger staff. It seems like they should have no poblem with revenue!!! Good for them, they created it but changes happen so slowly. IMO this needs a bigger full time staff so all those things Bort would like to work on but doesn't have the time gets done EACH season! No reason why it couldn't. Just need to invest more into the company and make this game reach its potential sometime this decade. Most everyone actually wants more changes as does Bort of course.

Stay ahead of the game instead of always trying to catch up to the vision. The slow growth could be the end to this games success. Bort, you need more help. You don't need to be doing a lot of the things you're doing everyday. (You keep us posted all the time on what that is) Someone else can do a lot of that programimg too! You're control the direction it goes and let others do the very involved work it takes to make that happen. This game is only going forward as fast as you let it and that's the only thing getting in the way of this being everything we want it to be. You've got to be able to hire the resourses by now for it to take off. Men spend money on here like it porn and for the majority of us more. This is big business...

We still don't have the score of the game avaliable in play by play while your watching the game. It seems like that would be easy to do and wouldn't it be great if all Bort had to do is tell a staff member to take care of it. Solved and on to the next thing.
Last edited Sep 13, 2008 14:07:05
 
Link
 
You could create a kind of "insurance" for players to protect them from injuries. Players should never have to buy this innsurance mind you it should be taken as a given. If agents got the base flex point cost of the player/10 per game injured plus an extra bonus for each boost applied on the player of the number of boosts purchased * flex point cost of the level/ 20 per game. Something like this aleviates some of the cost and benefits players who support the game. Injuries which are long term could give the agent the option to retire his player and get a higher percentage return on his flex points say 85-90% with the chance of such injuries increasing with the length of time in the league.

Teams should also not be overlooked with injuries, if a player is out injured the team he is on should at the very least get his salary paid from an innsurance fund and probably they should get a little more to cover cost of replacing him...

Injuries don t nesecarily have to be looked at as a bad thing for agents or teams. If they are made in such a way as to give something back to the agent or team and to offer a chance to retire an old player for a premium it can be used to bring in fresh blood.
 
telencephalon
offline
Link
 
Hey everybody, let's all go shopping together for pantyhose!

They've done a pretty good job up to this point not getting sucked into the gayness factor that plagues a lot of RPGs, but this shopping b.s. is just over the top. Totally ridiculous and inconsistent with a football sim, imo.
 
thehazyone
NFL Replacement Refs SUCK
offline
Link
 
http://goallineblitznews.com/

I've made a few comments in the main thread but with the speed and insanity that typically follows a Bort announcement of new changes, they as usual got lost in the shuffle. I thought I would go through line by line and look at the different changes Bort outlined. This is, as always, just one man's opinion... but it's a man who knows a lot about football and has put a lot of time and money into GLB, so take that for what it's worth.

- Every night, every player gets his daily XP, no matter what. You don't need money or anything special. It's just the normal daily XP gain to simulate the player growing over time.

This is a very good change. Often times, when I had a player that was under 70 energy I had to choose between no focus on training or hurting my team by training on relaxed and being less than 100 energy because I wanted the daily XP gain.

- Energy is now de-coupled from the training system. Every night every player gets set to 100 energy for the next game. You will still get to see how far you went down during the game. In fact, the energy bar will 100% reflect the player's ending freshness level. Energy's effect on performance will be dialed up little by little over the course of the season to encourage the use of depth (Injuries are also on the horizon now). Since it's not coupled with training any more, we are free to do more with it.

This one is interesting and I'm curious as to how it will actually play out. I do hope that it does encourage depth because as a fan of football, I've always found it a bit unrealistic that teams could get away with carrying 3 WR's, 1 QB, and 6 OL, but that's been the case for some time. I really think energy should have more of an in game effect, so I'm hoping this will accomplish that. Of course this is also easy for me to say since my team is very deep and this would benefit my team, so I'm sure a good argument could be made for the counter point.

As for injuries, this has been one of the more hotly debated topics of discussion in the thread. I'm a bit mixed on this. While injuries are realistic in the game of football, I'm not sure that when people are paying money for an individual player that they should be randomly given injuries. I could live with a temporary in game, one game, reduction of effectiveness as long as the injury is listed and it shows how it reduced the player's abilities so that teams would be able to understand how injuries were effecting their team and players.

- You cannot be assigned to a depth chart if you played a game for a different team within the last day. Because of the energy change, no same-day or next day games; since this is a bonus XP loophole. Plan your trades accordingly. Just think of it as the player requiring a day to get to your team and get settled in.

With the energy change, this is pretty much a no brainer prevention to players trying to maximize XP.

- Training no longer directly affects your stats every time you train. Instead, it fills up a little bar of "training progress" for each stat you train, which shows up under your current attributes. When that bar reaches 100%, you gain a +1.

I like this, mainly because it's easier to keep track of how your players training is progressing and improving your player.

- Training no longer processes nightly as a 2-3 hour event, except to deal with salary and the daily XP gain. Should be quicker to process.

Again, another good thing. Involves the player more in the training process. Click a button and boom your player trains and you see the immediate effect in their attributes.

- There is a new currency for training called training points. You gain 2 training points per day automatically. You can stockpile up to 10 points (amount subject to change if needed ) and they carry over from season to season. You can use these points to do your training updates when you see fit, when you log on, using a new training interface kinda like the skill points interface. Relaxed training is gone. There is now "normal" and "intense" training.

I really like this... a lot. Now you don't have to set training on a daily basis. You can do it once every 2-3 days, even 5 days, if you want. I do think they should increase the amount of points you can stockpile, up to say 20 or so. This would alleviate concerns for people that go on vacation for two weeks and don't have access to a computer.

Normal training costs 2 training points, $40 x your level, trains 1 attribute, and gives you the option of a "secondary" activity to do with it. More on that below. Intense training costs 5 points, $120 x your level, trains 2 attributes at once, and gives ~ 25% bonus more points than normal, but does not allow a "secondary" activity. It does, however, give you a "bonus token." More on those below as well.

Ooooo... options. This is a good thing. It makes training more strategic. Do you do normal training so you can do the secondary activity and train attribute or do you do intense training so you can train two attributes and get the bonus token. It will require the player to make a conscious decision as to how to train their player. Me likey.

- There's some small randomness involved in each training as well, with the chance of a "big breakthrough" training happening that gives a larger bonus and some "yay!" feedback when it happens.

I like this too, it's nice to see your player receive a bonus from working hard toward a particular goal and figuring a correct strategy out. I can already see all kinds of "guides" coming out on how to get so and so breakthrough. I know I plan on keeping records of where I put all my training points for when those breakthroughs do occur.

- When choosing intense training, you are rewarded with a bonus token. You can stockpile as many as you want, but only 5 can carry over to the next season.

Again I like the idea, but why limit the number of bonus tokens a person can stockpile? If someone wants to save 20, let them. It's their choice.

- You can turn in 4 bonus tokens to get a +5 temporary boost for your next game to any attribute you like, and at the same time be awarded 1 Skill Point to spend as you like. Only one temporary boost from bonus tokens can be active at a time, and it doesn't count toward playoff games. You can still get the +1 SP though.

I've seen a lot of complaints on this one that typically go along the lines of "it wouldn't be fair if my team lost because someone used their bonus tokens in a game against me." Ummm, you could use your too ya know. That's the main reason I like this as it creates an additional strategic element to the game. Think of it like the big pre-game pep talk before the rivalry game. It gets the players fired up. If another team doesn't use them, it's kind of like the team that just takes for granted the fact that they will win. I can see something like this leading to a few more upsets than we currently have, especially when the teams aren't too far apart (I don't think +5 temporary boosts will be enough for some teams though). I do think you should be able to use them in the playoffs though... if a team wants to save their bonus tokens for the playoffs, that would be a great use for them I think.

- You can also turn in 10 bonus tokens along with some cash to upgrade one of the new advanced items with a +1 to an attribute.

I'd have to see one of the advanced items to see if this is worthwhile but just from basic math I would think it wouldn't be because for 4 bonus tokent you get a +1 SP automatically meaning you would get 2.5 for 10. Only +1 for 10? I don't see how this makes any sense, but like I said I'll have to see how it works before making final judgment. On the surface though, this isn't something I'll be doing.

- There is a new "advanced" item store. The equipment in this store give starting bonuses, as opposed to the "blank" basic items in the regular store. These items can give more than the standard +X to attributes. You can also gain +'s to SA's, even if they aren't on your position's SA tree. Also, there are some special "+X% to chance to catch the ball," or "+X% chance to force fumble" etc. items as well.

I've seen a lot of complaints about this one too, about how it is turning a football game into WoW or Diablo, but if you think about it, it's not really. All it's doing is giving the player additional choices as to how to develop their players. If they want to focus a little more on catching, they'll get a item that will help them do so. Each player has the same opportunity, so the complaints are way off base.

- These items cannot be upgraded with cash alone. You also need Bonus Tokens, as described above. Upgrades to them can occur at the same intervals as normal gear (level 8/16/24 etc).

More strategic choices = good. 'Nuff said.

- When you visit the store, 3 items that are level and class appropriate are randomly generated. You don't have to buy them. They will stick around until you "refresh" the store or choose to buy one.

I was a bit concerned about this until I read down further. The last thing I wanted was the ability for a person to just keep hitting refresh until they got the item they wanted, but since you can only refresh once (and it's a risk to do so) and entering the store costs (you can only do it when you do normal training), I have nothing wrong with this. Another strategic choice.

- Also when you visit the store, you are also given the opportunity to purchase a "one time use" item. These are food/drink items like "energy drink" etc that give you a +3 temporary boost to an attribute for your next game. Only one boost can be active at a time, and you can't use them during playoffs.

This is similar to the 4 bonus token boost, so yea, I like it. Some players get more pumped up for playing a certain team, nothing unrealistic about this. And if someone really thinks a +3 boost to one attribute to one player will make a difference, they seriously are under estimating the game and AI.

- When you choose "go shopping" as your secondary training option, you get a "shopping token" that gives you one opportunity to "refresh" the advanced item store.

This is what I was talking about above. Thank goodness.

- We will be expanding the item selection over the season to include some special unique items that are very rare, as well as some items that work together in "sets" to give you an extra bonus if you have the whole set. If you've played other RPG's, you know what we're talking about here.

Now this is the one thing I hate, mainly because it sounds like the kind of thing that is not available to everyone. Now if there is an x% chance of getting a rare item every time you go to the store (meaning that x is fixed and not random) then I'm fine with it. The strategic choice of going to the store numerous times to get the items is the player's choice. If x is random, however, then it all becomes guesswork and I'm not a big fan of that. It wouldn't be fair if one player received his item's 20% of the time while another player didn't receive any of them in 20 visits.

- We're going to be starting very small with the fame update, and will work in more options and bonuses gradually. I'm going to start with bonuses from winning trophies, championships, and reaching certain season milestones, and add bonuses for various stuff here and there.

I'm not a big fan of fame, but mainly because I don't get how it's going to work. When Bort says winning trophies does this mean league leaders and such? This is problematic for several reasons. One, some conferences are disproportionate to others. I know in the league my team is in, the Eastern Conference has 7 gutted teams while the Western has 2. How is that fair to the West? All the league leaders are going to come out of the East? Also, I think this type of things takes away from teams playing as a team as now you're going to try and stat pad so your player wins a league leader award. I know when my team plays a gutted team, that we try and split the touches and playing time equally, but with these changes it looks like I'd be better served to keep my starters out there and get them the biggest possible numbers. Yea, not a fan. Again though, I'd like to see a more clearly defined statement of how this works.

- Team training fun should be ready to go shortly. Check the post in the suggestions forum about it. It's basically a bank account for players to pull money from to upgrade equipment.

Thank God, you know what a pain in the ass it is to send out contracts for players to get level 32 equipment bonuses? This will make that much easier.

- Get started on doing something with both of Drifter's suggestions, "locker room attributes" and "veteran skills."

This, along with the new training system, will help alleviate some of the boredom higher level players face.

- I want to add some more offensive plays to the playbook. I would like to solicit the community to submit or come up with some that we can put in. This came up before, but it didn't get very far. Maybe I could come up with a play designer... Once we get more plays put in, we can expand the offense AI options.

Many people are complaining about the new update because they thought this should have taken priority. I understand their complaints, this does need to get done, but something needed to be done for the players so I also understand why this didn't get done right away. I would definitely say this along with fixing gutting should be the number one priority for season 6.

- Get 2 pt conversions in play and improve special teams tactics options.

This is good... sucks to be down by 8 and know that you have to score twice. Or that you can't kick an onside kick and just have to watch helplessly as the other team runs down the clock.

- The main thing I want to focus on, though, is figuring out a good way to deal with sold gutted teams so we can have it ready to go for next season's promotions and relegations. I want to be able to reset them and send them to a bottom tier, but I will have to figure out the logistics, as I've been trying to do for a while.

Yes please... currently the BIGGEST problem at GLB. It needs to be fixed sooner rather than later.

- And last but not least: We will have a new Admin starting in a couple of days to help us out with forum patrol. He doesn't have a name picked out yet, but I'm sure you'll all show him the courtesy you do to the rest of us.

I feel sorry for this guy.
 
johndoe1986
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by lbrlove

Are you saying I was incorrect? Below are the lines - from before any mention of temporary items - quoted from the actual original announcement from Bort.


Yes sir, I am saying that is incorrect. I said:

Originally posted by johndoe1986

....Basically, new equipment was added and training only occurs in increments of 1....


This is where I mentioned the persistent items in my post. The point I was trying to make, which seemed to have been missed, was that this is not a significant change to game play. The single game boosts, however, are a real change in gameplay. The rest are just more options in equipment than +4/+8/+12/+16/+20 to the stats of your choice.

On a separate note, I pretty much agree with everything Hazy (above) posted. That man makes good points.
Last edited Sep 13, 2008 14:39:36
 
osutuba
offline
Link
 
Thanks for posting your web page (Goal Line Blitz News). I hope you will be able to post announcements and updates regularly. I get tired of fishing through crap to find the gold nuggets of valuable info.
Last edited Sep 13, 2008 14:45:39
 
donsta1185
offline
Link
 
when does the season start up?
 
NTNSTY
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by MTDewJoe
blah blah blah wah wah wah

Just put it in and lets run with it Bort so we can start the next season


 
osutuba
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by donsta1185
when does the season start up?

Yeah ... I'm getting anxious, too ...
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.