Originally posted by Thorn
However if we ever do find that a tester found a bug/exploit and didn't report it only to take advantage of it we will be very, *very* strict with them.
It isn't about exploits, it's about more information than others have. Trying to make it about exploits is, IMO, an attempt to sweep it under the rug.
Originally posted by
I fully understand your worry that a team in your league will have insider information when you play them next season, but keep in mind that the testers are playing on a test server. So things don't translate one to one from test to live server.
The test server can't be that different or, as others have pointed out, testing would be useless. Is stamina different? Is confidence different? How about strength and carrying for power backs? And so on.
Originally posted by
When Bort made the decision to open up a test server, he selected the people for it carefully, and I trust his decision. If his trust is proved to be misplaced we will deal with the people.
-Thorn
Again, not the point. It isn't about whether the testers are trustworthy. If they gained any information from testing that the rest of us don't have, and they would have, then they have an advantage, however slight and however much they try not to take advantage of it.
A big issue as well is the secrecy surrounding the test server and the selection of people to test, and now this attempt at hand waving to make it all go away. Upfront information to all would have been better, but now what is needed is a full explanation of how the testing worked. I for one don't care who was a tester, I just want to know what they could have found out, and for that information to be released to all.
However if we ever do find that a tester found a bug/exploit and didn't report it only to take advantage of it we will be very, *very* strict with them.
It isn't about exploits, it's about more information than others have. Trying to make it about exploits is, IMO, an attempt to sweep it under the rug.
Originally posted by
I fully understand your worry that a team in your league will have insider information when you play them next season, but keep in mind that the testers are playing on a test server. So things don't translate one to one from test to live server.
The test server can't be that different or, as others have pointed out, testing would be useless. Is stamina different? Is confidence different? How about strength and carrying for power backs? And so on.
Originally posted by
When Bort made the decision to open up a test server, he selected the people for it carefully, and I trust his decision. If his trust is proved to be misplaced we will deal with the people.
-Thorn
Again, not the point. It isn't about whether the testers are trustworthy. If they gained any information from testing that the rest of us don't have, and they would have, then they have an advantage, however slight and however much they try not to take advantage of it.
A big issue as well is the secrecy surrounding the test server and the selection of people to test, and now this attempt at hand waving to make it all go away. Upfront information to all would have been better, but now what is needed is a full explanation of how the testing worked. I for one don't care who was a tester, I just want to know what they could have found out, and for that information to be released to all.






























