User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Forum > Goal Line Blitz > In Response to Bort's Final Post in the Test Server Thread
Page:
 
smallbugger
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by tpaterniti

If someone were to, as has been suggested, realize that an SA was overpowered and not report it bort would figure that out pretty quick. First of all people do not test against their own teams so there is a level of accountability there, and when someone in the real GLB figures out the problem it would be a simple matter for bort to look and see who was testing this or that and why they didn't report it.


Will you be building players that you from testing don't work? The answer is no.

You will build players to make them to whatever goal you have.You just have more information than the normal user. You also have two teams and are a GM of several teams, obviously you never share or use the knowledge right?
 
wombat killer
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by tpaterniti
Some people are glad testing is being done. Others are outraged.


I haven't seen anyone outraged that testing is being done. Any outrage is directed at who is doing the testing.

 
Link
 
Originally posted by sjmay
And accuse me of being pro GLB or pro Bort or whatever it is you can think of to call me to make yourself feel better,

I really give a flying fuck what an idiot like you thinks to be honest, but seriously give your fucking head a shake about what you are trying to demand from a guy who has put his livelihood and his family's welfare, in the hands of a internet crowd whose seemling maturety level barely reaches the instant gratification stage.


sjmay get off your knees.
 
Signalsgt
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by
Not sur what you are getting at, that the code doesn't resemble football? So you have a basis to sue?


If you purchase anything that does not do what it represents itself to do that is called fraud. That was more of a response to Cronus's asinine statement that Bort can do whatever he want's because it's "his code". Which would be true if paying for flex wasn't an option.
 
sjmay
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by UsCtRoJaNs1820
Originally posted by tpaterniti

Originally posted by UsCtRoJaNs1820


Originally posted by tpaterniti



I have already said everything I think I can say. People will at that point think what they think. To me getting testers who don't play the game is worthless because they wouldn't know enough to test and Bort has chosen them carefully. There is what tjking or whoever said about a tester giving him inside information (???) but unless he says who told it to him and what that inside information was that was so advantageous I am really skeptical.

I am with Mike in that people ask me questions, like what is ideal vision for a WR now and I say I honestly I have no idea. That is not what we do at all. What we would do is take a WR with 100 vision 20 catching and one with 20 vision 100 catching and see if the sim really goes haywire when we do that. As far as honing in on an "ideal" vision to catching ration I have no idea because we really don't test for that. It is a lot of extremes. That way in season 8 we don't get someone screaming bloody murder because he made a WR with 20 catching 90 vision who catches everything in spite of only having 20 catching.

In terms of how effective this or that SA is, our ultimate goal is for balance which means that there are, say, 10 different ways to break a tackle (hypothetical number). There is no "best way". You could do lots of strength, no SAs, lots of carrying, no SAs, a little less of strength + SAs, a little less carrying + SAs, a mix of strenght and carrying + SAs, a mix of strength and carrying without SAs, lots of speed low agility, medium speed, very high agility, a balance of speed, agility, carrying, strength, and any combinations of the last four choices with SAs. Ultimately each of these combos or any other ones you could dream up would require different things to stop or negate them on defense. Thus the issue becomes not the "best" way to build a HB, but just what you want to do and coming up with a team offensive concept that he fits into. When that happens the game will be balanced and there will be lots of different ways to succeed without any one type of build being overpowered or out of balance. That is what we are working towards, which is actually antithetical to the idea of us getting an advantage since the entire reason for our existence is to eliminate elements of the game that are overpowered or unbalanced.

If someone were to, as has been suggested, realize that an SA was overpowered and not report it bort would figure that out pretty quick. First of all people do not test against their own teams so there is a level of accountability there, and when someone in the real GLB figures out the problem it would be a simple matter for bort to look and see who was testing this or that and why they didn't report it.


Ok so if there's no real advantage of testing then why not give everyone access to the testing site? Don't give a lame excuse either.




Are you willing to pay twice as much for FPs? Because it would take literally twice the server space and twice the bandwidth as regular GLB for everyone to be able to test.


I'm not spending another penny on this site. Why would I when we don't get a level playing field. Answer my question you just avoided it.



He didn't avoid it you ignorant jerkwad, he just told you there is no server space available to open it to everyone, I know you probably didn't understand that, but take away from your righteous indignation and try to figure this out.

THIRTY servers just to hold the live game up.

You want another thirty servers just to be able to access the test server, that is going to cost more money,

Got it?
 
sjmay
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Signalsgt
Originally posted by

Not sur what you are getting at, that the code doesn't resemble football? So you have a basis to sue?


If you purchase anything that does not do what it represents itself to do that is called fraud. That was more of a response to Cronus's asinine statement that Bort can do whatever he want's because it's "his code". Which would be true if paying for flex wasn't an option.


Got it.
 
Koncorde
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by tpaterniti
Originally posted by Koncorde

Originally posted by Zeke Woodson


Nice work, Koncorde.

Of course i specified my agility back when attempting the outside stuff. I would have been better off sticking with the power guy, apparently.


Probably. My team in WE Pro had the issue all season with "dancing" elusive backs being stuck trying to run up the middle rather than bounce to the outside.

Against very fast defences your O-Line generally can't buy the space it needs for your HB to get to the outside edge - especially with speed DE's (even if they don't beat the RT) causing the line to collapse a little by stretching out the blocking requirements.


I have my quasi elusive back set to power style since the start of this season but I just learned this from his game film long before there ever was a test site.


Same here. Like the Passing Logic thread from last season that produced our batch of updates or season 7, my "testing" came from sacrifices I made. My understanding of the code and game mechanics comes from 7 years of experience.

The idea this would all be questioned if I should be a tester, despite providing previous levels of supoprt etc, bothers me.
 
tpaterniti
Lead Mod
offline
Link
 
Is this sarcasm? What is illogical about the fact that if everyone who plays GLB now plays the test form of GLB it takes twice as much server space and bandwdth. Also there would be such a quantity of results they would be impossible to manage and organize. We were essentially letting everyone on regular GLB test for 7 seasons, but that only allowed bort to test based on existing builds, which meant he was always one step behind when a new build would expose a programming problem. Now he can be proactive about it. The DT slingshot bug is a perfect example. Once something like that manifests itself, now he has to make a decision. ALlow something obviously faulty to continue because the season has started or change it mid season despite the fact people have already boosted and assigned skill points (i.e. nerf their build so to speak). This is a dilemma he is largely able to avoid by allowing people to test extremem builds ahead of time.
 
sjmay
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by UsCtRoJaNs1820
Originally posted by sjmay

And accuse me of being pro GLB or pro Bort or whatever it is you can think of to call me to make yourself feel better,

I really give a flying fuck what an idiot like you thinks to be honest, but seriously give your fucking head a shake about what you are trying to demand from a guy who has put his livelihood and his family's welfare, in the hands of a internet crowd whose seemling maturety level barely reaches the instant gratification stage.


sjmay get off your knees.


Wow, that was intelligent, great response there in a lively discussion,

You have anything more to contribute or can we give you your $5 bucks back and kick you to the curb?
 
Link
 
Originally posted by Signalsgt
Originally posted by

Not sur what you are getting at, that the code doesn't resemble football? So you have a basis to sue?


If you purchase anything that does not do what it represents itself to do that is called fraud. That was more of a response to Cronus's asinine statement that Bort can do whatever he want's because it's "his code". Which would be true if paying for flex wasn't an option.


Also false advertisment. I thought we were all supposed to have level playing field but that is not the case.

 
smallbugger
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Darkus Black
Originally posted by smallbugger

Originally posted by Darkus Black




I would deal with the situation as quickly as possible. This is not my business though and I have said that, regardless of how you feel it is being dealt with, the intention is not to screw anyone out of anything.

And yes, I am British.


Sounds like how Bort should try to work.... his silence sounds more like he just doesn't care about his current paying customers


Yes, but we have no idea what reason is behind him not being here now. If people make the assumption that he is away because he is avoiding then there will be issues of course as people get more annoyed and angry. Communication is the key factor in any dispute. I also know the feeling that things like this can bring about so I am just saying to let him work it out and give his response rather than turning it into a bit of a witch hunt.


I work as a independent contractor for several businesses... half the job is communication. As a mod you should know by now. Most of Bort's biggest issues have been from failing to communicate and yet he continues to do just that.

 
mantis7
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by tpaterniti
Many [MMORPG's] allow testers to play and all of them chose testers carefully.


This is simply untrue. I don't know if you actually believe this, or you are just a 'company man' or fanboy or whatever you want to call it...But MANY rpgs allow ALL users to be on the test servers, especially PVP rpgs (which esentially this IS a PVP rpg)....

I will name 3 right now to stave off the 'no they don't' crowd:

Sony - Planetside (MMOFPS , PVP)

NCsoft - City of Heroes / City of Villians (PVP oriented or PVE)

Secondlife (PVE or PVP etc..)

Last edited Feb 15, 2009 19:40:58
 
sjmay
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by UsCtRoJaNs1820
Originally posted by Signalsgt

Originally posted by


Not sur what you are getting at, that the code doesn't resemble football? So you have a basis to sue?


If you purchase anything that does not do what it represents itself to do that is called fraud. That was more of a response to Cronus's asinine statement that Bort can do whatever he want's because it's "his code". Which would be true if paying for flex wasn't an option.


Also false advertisment. I thought we were all supposed to have level playing field but that is not the case.



Wrong as it was never advertised as such,

Next.
 
Koncorde
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by UsCtRoJaNs1820
Originally posted by Koncorde

Originally posted by UsCtRoJaNs1820




He owes a refund. So give me a refund of either all my Flex Points spent in season 7 or my money I've spent on this game. It's that simple.



Why season 7? The testers haven't, by Borts statements, actually had time to test anything for Season 7 as they were working on updated code.


You need to go back and read. It's very easy to see what has and what was able to test and I might add it just happend to be at playoff time of all times go figure.



I suggest you don't tell me what can and can't be tested, or has or has not been tested - as you cannot have that knowledge, let alone the confidence that someone in your league actually gained from the testing taking place on the testing server.
 
Signalsgt
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by wombat killer
Originally posted by tpaterniti

Some people are glad testing is being done. Others are outraged.


I haven't seen anyone outraged that testing is being done. Any outrage is directed at who is doing the testing.



Outrage is a strong word, I'm not even annoyed. I can see a clear advantage of being able to run sim after sim to determine plays that are broken at a code level. Then run them over and over to win.

So before I join the pitchfork and lit torch crew, I want to know what exactly was available to these select few and how did their teams do from the time the learned their "secret handshake".
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.