User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Forum > Goal Line Blitz > Test Server Discussion
Page:
 
williamcohms
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by trentw
Yeah it's not so much me worrying about them finding something broken and not reporting it but it is still unfair for competitive players of GLB to be able to gain knowledge of how to build players in minutes when it takes us months and dollars.


Ding Ding Ding - And you will never stop this from happening because as long as testers play the game competitively this will be basic human nature.
 
Procrustes
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by bootyslayer4
If it were this bad, then why aren't all the testers teams undefeated? If they have such "godly" builds, woulnd't they be unstoppable?


Originally posted by Catullus 16
whether or not the testers were able to translate their insider information into success is irrelevant. even with complete information, you still have to deal with other people's builds/etc.

the bottom line is that the list of test users was held secret because they knew it was unethical. i'm still willing to think of this as a hasty PR mistake, but it's not looking that way.

 
Banned
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by bootyslayer4
If it were this bad, then why aren't all the testers teams undefeated? If they have such "godly" builds, woulnd't they be unstoppable?



all their players arent on the same team, most testers have one player, tpaterniti said he was a tester and his HB does great, but if a tester did have an all his players team, theyd be gods
 
bootyslayer4
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by ress5609
Originally posted by bootyslayer4

If it were this bad, then why aren't all the testers teams undefeated? If they have such "godly" builds, woulnd't they be unstoppable?


because they've only been at it for two weeks


And currently I see no, "godly team" 2 weeks is long enough to build a team.
 
Gary.
offline
Link
 
Bort is on now. He will most likely be here any second.
 
Banned
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Gary_Hughes
Bort is on now. He will most likely be here any second.


nice cant wait
 
Link
 
Originally posted by Drago
Originally posted by Darkus Black

Originally posted by Drago


Originally posted by Darkus Black



Originally posted by Drago




Originally posted by Darkus Black





Originally posted by jrry32






Now it can go wrong tpat if he sees that 10 in juke is WAY overpowered and decided to keep it to himself.


This assumes that the testers are selfish individuals and not interested in the development of the game though.


You haven't been around the internet very much, huh?


Long enough to have used a 14.4k modem. Just because a person has access to the internet it doesn't automatically make them an evil mind with the desire to rule the dot world.


Well listen hear youngin' - I had a 2400 baud modem at one point. You don't know how tough it was back then. YOU DON'T EVER WANT TO KNOW.

With that said, the Anonymous nature of the internet does lead a large group of individuals to perform selfish actions. Coupled with the fact this is a competitive game by nature, I think it's safe to say the greater of the "community" would take this information and do their best to put it to good use for selfish reasons.


Yes, I understand. The point I was making is that it might also be possible that the testers are not the kind of people to do this. It is always possible that they are as well though. The problem I see with this thread is that the majority of people are making the negative assumptions associated with the usual style of internet witch hunt, and not many are thinking rationally about it.


You used the word possible twice and assumption once - rationally only once. 3>1.

Get where I'm going with this?

Somebody has taken an organizational behavior class in college! Sadly though, I dont think anyone with power in GLB has.

 
islander1
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Gary_Hughes
Bort is on now. He will most likely be here any second.


Bort - "whoa boy, time to get some coffee"
 
Banned
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by bootyslayer4
Originally posted by ress5609

Originally posted by bootyslayer4


If it were this bad, then why aren't all the testers teams undefeated? If they have such "godly" builds, woulnd't they be unstoppable?


because they've only been at it for two weeks


And currently I see no, "godly team" 2 weeks is long enough to build a team.


well most people dont have a full team of their guys
 
12thKnight
offline
Link
 
If there were a group of test server users who were knowledgeable about football and GLB but completely separate - and I mean hermetically sealed - from actual competition on here, there would be no issue. Any person, trusted or not, who has access to both the test server and games of competition on GLB has an inherent advantage of those who were either denied access to the test server or were simply not invited. I don't think anyone can realistically challenge that assertion, as even with the proletariat on here having four scrimmages before real games, it's not nearly enough a chance to test out permutations of VAs and skill balances compared to the elite test server sub-population.

Management's reaction after "the secret" came out only reinforces the perception that there was significant advantage given to the testers.

Ugly. Just ugly. My impression of this site has taken a new low.
 
jamz
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Gary_Hughes
Bort is on now. He will most likely be here any second.


Stalker, imo.
 
cbarge
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by islander1
Originally posted by Gary_Hughes

Bort is on now. He will most likely be here any second.


Bort - "whoa boy, time to get some coffee"


I would not want to be in his shoes right now. Of course he deals with this sort of thing like once a month anyways.
 
ress5609
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by bootyslayer4
Originally posted by ress5609

Originally posted by bootyslayer4


If it were this bad, then why aren't all the testers teams undefeated? If they have such "godly" builds, woulnd't they be unstoppable?


because they've only been at it for two weeks


And currently I see no, "godly team" 2 weeks is long enough to build a team.


...

so they're supposed to take an existing team in the middle of a season and transform it into a godly team in under two weeks without any SP respec?

wat?
 
PierreThomas
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Thorn
Originally posted by TerrellOwns



What are you smoking? They use builds on the test server... and if those builds work, they won't use them on the live servers? I have been on test servers for several MMORPGs and you know what? They don't allow certain players to go on these servers and get advance knowledge of changes while keeping them secret from the public. They let every player on, and reveal the results to all players - even those who never bothered to join the test server.


You're going under the assumption that builds on the test server will work exactly like they will on the live server. This isn't necessarily true, we can and will make changes once things are done on the test server.
-Thorn


Thorn, I like you. You have always been helpful but downplaying this is not helping.

The competitive advantages are way too obvious here and I can't think of another way to possibly piss people off worse than to give them any reason to feel like they are being cheated and for anyone that spends a lot of time and money on this game it will be damn near impossible to avoid.

This thread has really killed my spirit for the game and I'm sure it has for others as well. Something needs to be done quick and trying to justify a terrible decision isn't what anyone wants to hear.

Not only has the damage been done, but in this case it is going to be very difficult to undo.
 
Painmaker
offline
Link
 
Well over a hundred pages chock full of concerned customer comments... not the most efficient way to start the offseason and execute other desirable features like endorsements. By that objective measure alone, I'm not sure the decision to pursue testing in secrecy instead of out in the open was the best course of action.

Might be a good time to reassess.
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.