Originally posted by tpaterniti
I have already said everything I think I can say. People will at that point think what they think. To me getting testers who don't play the game is worthless because they wouldn't know enough to test and Bort has chosen them carefully. There is what tjking or whoever said about a tester giving him inside information (???) but unless he says who told it to him and what that inside information was that was so advantageous I am really skeptical.
I am with Mike in that people ask me questions, like what is ideal vision for a WR now and I say I honestly I have no idea. That is not what we do at all. What we would do is take a WR with 100 vision 20 catching and one with 20 vision 100 catching and see if the sim really goes haywire when we do that. As far as honing in on an "ideal" vision to catching ration I have no idea because we really don't test for that. It is a lot of extremes. That way in season 8 we don't get someone screaming bloody murder because he made a WR with 20 catching 90 vision who catches everything in spite of only having 20 catching.
In terms of how effective this or that SA is, our ultimate goal is for balance which means that there are, say, 10 different ways to break a tackle (hypothetical number). There is no "best way". You could do lots of strength, no SAs, lots of carrying, no SAs, a little less of strength + SAs, a little less carrying + SAs, a mix of strenght and carrying + SAs, a mix of strength and carrying without SAs, lots of speed low agility, medium speed, very high agility, a balance of speed, agility, carrying, strength, and any combinations of the last four choices with SAs. Ultimately each of these combos or any other ones you could dream up would require different things to stop or negate them on defense. Thus the issue becomes not the "best" way to build a HB, but just what you want to do and coming up with a team offensive concept that he fits into. When that happens the game will be balanced and there will be lots of different ways to succeed without any one type of build being overpowered or out of balance. That is what we are working towards, which is actually antithetical to the idea of us getting an advantage since the entire reason for our existence is to eliminate elements of the game that are overpowered or unbalanced.
If someone were to, as has been suggested, realize that an SA was overpowered and not report it bort would figure that out pretty quick. First of all people do not test against their own teams so there is a level of accountability there, and when someone in the real GLB figures out the problem it would be a simple matter for bort to look and see who was testing this or that and why they didn't report it.
Ok so if there's no real advantage of testing then why not give everyone access to the testing site? Don't give a lame excuse either.