User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Forum > Goal Line Blitz > Test Server Discussion
Page:
 
Deathblade
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Thorn

My worry is that it would be viewed as a scarlet letter, and people would complain every time they lost to that person's team. People don't need much to complain when losing, and if they see that scarlet letter it just seems too easy. It might scare of the testers.
The decision is up to Bort, but that is just my opinion.
-Thorn


Why not make the tests viewable by the public, but only let the testers conduct it? It would make it near impossible for an exploit to go undetected and abused by a tester, and it would also eliminate their inside information advantage.
 
Thorn
Admin
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by TerrellOwns


What are you smoking? They use builds on the test server... and if those builds work, they won't use them on the live servers? I have been on test servers for several MMORPGs and you know what? They don't allow certain players to go on these servers and get advance knowledge of changes while keeping them secret from the public. They let every player on, and reveal the results to all players - even those who never bothered to join the test server.


You're going under the assumption that builds on the test server will work exactly like they will on the live server. This isn't necessarily true, we can and will make changes once things are done on the test server.
-Thorn
 
bootyslayer4
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by TerrellOwns
Originally posted by bootyslayer4

Originally posted by TerrellOwns


Originally posted by bootyslayer4



Does it really matter this much? I could care less if their was a test server that I am not a part of. As long as it comes to the public fine, im Ok.


Don't you get it? The point is that this information isn't coming to the public. The changes that affect your players and teams were known beforehand by god knows how many players/teams in your league.


Who cares? Its not that big of an advantage. I really wouldn't think that many people test it, let alone make builds to cheat it. They use those builds on...the TEST SERVER maybe? Jeesus. Its like you people have never been on a test server for an mmorpg before. Its nothing special.


What are you smoking? They use builds on the test server... and if those builds work, they won't use them on the live servers? I have been on test servers for several MMORPGs and you know what? They don't allow certain players to go on these servers and get advance knowledge of changes while keeping them secret from the public. They let every player on, and reveal the results to all players - even those who never bothered to join the test server.


The testers usually don't go and use the good builds they find out about before the public knows about them. You do realize these testers are hand picked and I assume they are trusted not to use them for an unfair advantage.
 
23yrwej
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by trentw
What about the fact that being able to test different builds without waiting or paying to level is an exploit in itself...even if the sim is "working as intended"?


It's like Testing Out Boosting without having to do it which does suck.
 
Link
 
good thing you sign your messages because there is no way of knowing who is posting
 
Painmaker
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Thorn
Originally posted by Gary_Hughes

Thorn,

I think the problem that everyone is talking about is that the select few still play the game with everyone else, and hold an unfair, and hidden advantage.

I am blown away at how this is affecting people. I believe I even saw mention of this a few seasons ago. I think a little icon for beta tester, like the alpha one would fix some of the complaints.


My worry is that it would be viewed as a scarlet letter, and people would complain every time they lost to that person's team. People don't need much to complain when losing, and if they see that scarlet letter it just seems too easy. It might scare of the testers.
The decision is up to Bort, but that is just my opinion.
-Thorn


My worry is that any competition is suspect so long as there are secretly people who have the advantage of additional information which the community at large doesn't. I don't see the appeal in playing a game where suspicion is the rule of the day.
 
ress5609
offline
Link
 
I don't like quoting myself, but with thorn here and the conversation about exploits, I'd love to get an answer to my question:

Originally posted by ress5609

Another example would be knowing the result of a nerf before the nerf is implemented for everyone else.

A few seasons ago it was possible for Kickers to hit 50 yard FG's with 30 strength. Now that can't happen (as far as I know). If a tester knew about that change 2 weeks before it was announced to the rest of GLB, then he has an additional 2 weeks to correct his SP allocation. And there's nothing to report to bort for fixing because it's working as intended, but that person was given a head start on that knowledge.

Hopefully that makes sense. It's not all about exploits, it's also about being privy to knowledge about sim changes sooner.

(I know there were no testers when the kicking change was made, I'm just using it as a theoretical example)



Thorn, if testers are testing upcoming sim changes and, through testing for exploits, discover the effects of those changes sooner, what's to stop them from preparing their players builds for the upcoming changes before the rest of GLB has a chance to discover the effects themselves? Even with good intentions, if I discovered that one of my players was going to need more vision next season, I wouldn't continue to put SP's in speed. It's not exploiting a bug so much as having a head start on everyone else.
 
77racing
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by 77racing
I think Bort is BERNIE MADOFF.. what ponzi scheme this has become![/QUOTEor maybe a relative

 
cbarge
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Mindfreak
good thing you sign your messages because there is no way of knowing who is posting


Hahahaha
 
atingwald
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Thorn
Originally posted by TerrellOwns



What are you smoking? They use builds on the test server... and if those builds work, they won't use them on the live servers? I have been on test servers for several MMORPGs and you know what? They don't allow certain players to go on these servers and get advance knowledge of changes while keeping them secret from the public. They let every player on, and reveal the results to all players - even those who never bothered to join the test server.


You're going under the assumption that builds on the test server will work exactly like they will on the live server. This isn't necessarily true, we can and will make changes once things are done on the test server.
-Thorn


If they don't equate, why even test it?? That really doesn't make a lot of sense....
 
cbarge
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by 77racing
Originally posted by 77racing

I think Bort is BERNIE MADOFF.. what ponzi scheme this has become![/QUOTEor maybe a relative



You think that was witty enough to quote?
 
HootyHoo
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Thorn
Originally posted by TerrellOwns



What are you smoking? They use builds on the test server... and if those builds work, they won't use them on the live servers? I have been on test servers for several MMORPGs and you know what? They don't allow certain players to go on these servers and get advance knowledge of changes while keeping them secret from the public. They let every player on, and reveal the results to all players - even those who never bothered to join the test server.


You're going under the assumption that builds on the test server will work exactly like they will on the live server. This isn't necessarily true, we can and will make changes once things are done on the test server.
-Thorn


If a person on the test server changed any equipment to reflect what they have found during testing = permanent ban.
 
nflcardholder
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by cbarge
Originally posted by 77racing

Originally posted by 77racing


I think Bort is BERNIE MADOFF.. what ponzi scheme this has become![/QUOTEor maybe a relative



You think that was witty enough to quote?


he didnt actually quote his own joke. did he?
 
Procrustes
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by PackMan97
Originally posted by Darkus Black
The problem I see with this thread is that the majority of people are making the negative assumptions associated with the usual style of internet witch hunt, and not many are thinking rationally about it.

That is going to happen when you keep secrets. Secrets are bad and they always come out. Even if they are good secrets, assumptions will be made until the secret keeper comes clean.


bingo.
 
williamcohms
offline
Link
 
Again Thorn,

What happens when a tester notices that maxing out a particular SA gives a really nice boost to a particular position's performance. So he mentions it to Bort, and Bort says, "That's how I want it to work."

Now that tester knows something very few other people do. And do you think they won't spread that information to their teams? This is why everyone is outraged. We're being asked to spend real money and pour SP into SA's and VP into VA's we have no real idea how they work. We're spending seasons working our players builds. Now you give someone the ability to test that out instantly. Do really think they won't notice what's working best? Do you really think that won't start to trickle down to their teams and players? This is what we're upset about.
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.