User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Forum > Goal Line Blitz > Test Server Discussion
Page:
 
TerrellOwns
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by bootyslayer4
Originally posted by TerrellOwns

Originally posted by bootyslayer4


Does it really matter this much? I could care less if their was a test server that I am not a part of. As long as it comes to the public fine, im Ok.


Don't you get it? The point is that this information isn't coming to the public. The changes that affect your players and teams were known beforehand by god knows how many players/teams in your league.


Who cares? Its not that big of an advantage. I really wouldn't think that many people test it, let alone make builds to cheat it. They use those builds on...the TEST SERVER maybe? Jeesus. Its like you people have never been on a test server for an mmorpg before. Its nothing special.


What are you smoking? They use builds on the test server... and if those builds work, they won't use them on the live servers? I have been on test servers for several MMORPGs and you know what? They don't allow certain players to go on these servers and get advance knowledge of changes while keeping them secret from the public. They let every player on, and reveal the results to all players - even those who never bothered to join the test server.
 
Painmaker
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Koncorde
Originally posted by Painmaker

Thorn, far and away the thing that most has people upset here is the secrecy and lack of "read-only" access to the knowledge available on the test servers -- builds being tested, game replays, test forum discussions, etc. Can you tell us why this secrecy is necessary?


Because an exploit may be identified, but a fix takes a week to fix. It's instantly visible (not that exploits don't spread like wildfire anyway) and everyone has fun beating on each other with the screen pass or a nano-blitz rendering 3 games in the schedule null.

We've had it before without testing, it's feasible (especially with the defensive play creator) that it'll happen again.

Personally I'd just go for an announcement system - otherwise, if I was a tester, I'd move my discussions onto a private forum away from GLB.


If an exploit was achievable immediately, how is it that the tiny test server is more likely to find it than the massively larger "live" servers? I thought the test server was for testing unusual combinations of builds and tactics which would not be immediately achievable, or for testing currently possible builds and tactics under different versions of the sim engine? I don't buy the argument that testing secrecy is effective at preventing exploits being identified or used.

Getting additional opportunities to test things and keeping them secret from the population at large is exactly what upsets the population at large. That type of behavior should immediately disqualify anyone from testing if GLB is to maintain integrity in the game.
 
23yrwej
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Darkus Black
Originally posted by jrry32

Originally posted by Darkus Black


Originally posted by jrry32



Originally posted by Darkus Black




Yes, I understand. The point I was making is that it might also be possible that the testers are not the kind of people to do this. It is always possible that they are as well though. The problem I see with this thread is that the majority of people are making the negative assumptions associated with the usual style of internet witch hunt, and not many are thinking rationally about it.


Darkus, people are being plenty rational about it. They just expect the worst which is not the best way of thinking but in GLB, sadly, the worst thing is what usually ends up happening.


It is a shame that it has become so cynical around here though. I think I will talk about this thread on the radio show starting in 5 minutes. Click on the GLB radio link above or call in to discuss it live on the air. (646) 716-7443


I can't call in this time. My cellphone is in the car. I am too lazy to get it.



Cynicism AND apathy. You need to buck up your ideas young man.


Well at least I am not completely narcissistic, yet.
 
Thorn
Admin
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by jrry32


Well hopefully you do if something happens because it could be a HUGE problem if a tester starts giving away secret exploits.



Agree with you 100%, we'll make an example out of anyone we find. It is something we are on the watch for.
-Thorn

 
bootyslayer4
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Thorn
Originally posted by Gary_Hughes

Thorn,

I think the problem that everyone is talking about is that the select few still play the game with everyone else, and hold an unfair, and hidden advantage.

I am blown away at how this is affecting people. I believe I even saw mention of this a few seasons ago. I think a little icon for beta tester, like the alpha one would fix some of the complaints.


My worry is that it would be viewed as a scarlet letter, and people would complain every time they lost to that person's team. People don't need much to complain when losing, and if they see that scarlet letter it just seems too easy. It might scare of the testers.
The decision is up to Bort, but that is just my opinion.
-Thorn


Exactly, the only reason people want the name of testers is to either attack them or have an excuse for losing to them. If bort were to release the names, give the testers the option to let theirs out.
 
wombat killer
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Thorn
Originally posted by Gary_Hughes

Thorn,

I think the problem that everyone is talking about is that the select few still play the game with everyone else, and hold an unfair, and hidden advantage.

I am blown away at how this is affecting people. I believe I even saw mention of this a few seasons ago. I think a little icon for beta tester, like the alpha one would fix some of the complaints.


My worry is that it would be viewed as a scarlet letter, and people would complain every time they lost to that person's team. People don't need much to complain when losing, and if they see that scarlet letter it just seems too easy. It might scare of the testers.
The decision is up to Bort, but that is just my opinion.
-Thorn


The problem now is this is pretty much out there. Might as well identify them now.
 
imnott
offline
Link
 
I wanna test...
 
About2 Break
offline
Link
 
Thorn,

One question:

If this is a Beta game then a Beta game by definition is a test right?
Then why does a Beta(test) game need a test server! A test of a test sounds interesting! Just my 2 cents!
 
PackMan97
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Thorn
People don't need much to complain when losing, and if they see that scarlet letter it just seems too easy. It might scare of the testers.
The decision is up to Bort, but that is just my opinion.
-Thorn


If you are worried about that...there are lots of really sharp, honest folks I know that would be happy to wear a scarlet letter in return for making the game better.
 
Gary.
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Thorn
Originally posted by Gary_Hughes

Thorn,

I think the problem that everyone is talking about is that the select few still play the game with everyone else, and hold an unfair, and hidden advantage.

I am blown away at how this is affecting people. I believe I even saw mention of this a few seasons ago. I think a little icon for beta tester, like the alpha one would fix some of the complaints.


My worry is that it would be viewed as a scarlet letter, and people would complain every time they lost to that person's team. People don't need much to complain when losing, and if they see that scarlet letter it just seems too easy. It might scare of the testers.
The decision is up to Bort, but that is just my opinion.
-Thorn


Ahh I see that is a good point. But does it not also raise the question... Is it right to think that way?

 
TerrellOwns
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by F8n4tune

Originally posted by Animalmother


Solutions?
1) List or identify everyone with access
2) Give everyone access
3) Forbid anyone with access from also playing GLB
4) Allow everyone to "re-roll" and test builds
5) 100% Flex return for retiring anyone created before this point
6) Deny and downplay this whole thing and pray it goes away
7) ?



7) Just take the money and the run ?


 
jamz
offline
Link
 
*** Mode change "+o jamz" on channel #SecretTestServerInfomation by testserver.goallineblitz.com
 
Outlaw Dogs
offline
Link
 
So what did I miss?
 
trentw
offline
Link
 
What about the fact that being able to test different builds without waiting or paying to level is an exploit in itself...even if the sim is "working as intended"?
 
DrkSandman
Baseballs
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Thorn
Originally posted by the man of doom

thorn y doesnt DD sell his teams


Because of DD's secret plan to turn them all into prison teams. But it is a secret, so don't tell anyone.


QFepic
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.