User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Forum > Goal Line Blitz > GLB Insider: The truth behind all the teams leaving.
Page:
 
Link
 
Originally posted by islander1
Originally posted by Vanilla Thunder


Originally posted by



8. (11:00AM CDT)Teams being purchased by people without fully realizing what they are getting into thus setting them up for failure from the start.


QFT yet again.

The biggest issue of the game isn't parity, the AI, or even the SIM code. It's the player base.

The survival of this game depends on a players willingness to be a 10-6 team that loses in the first round of the playoffs 3 years in a row. People have to be willing to spend time in Football Purgatory along with the Buffalo Bills and Seattle Seahawks.

Many players come into the game with experience in Madden and WoW and expect to instantly be able to not only compete but to progress at their own pace and reach some sort of endgame. Sadly, GLB isn't like that, it's a competitive MMORPG and we're going to need players for all levels of the pyramid, not just the top.



But see Vanilla, this is where one of the game's greatest failings shows its ugly head.

No one wants to be 10-6 for 3 years, because the current economic structure in GLB is so heavily skewed towards the top 3 teams it's game breaking. If you don't consistently have multiple home playoffs games most seasons, economically your team will fail, long term. Thats not speculation, that's fact.

When the 7th place team gets 100k for their playoff participation, and the second place team gets 30 million, hello...can we say retard economics?


Huh? Your team will only fail if you spend carelessly. I suppose over 8-10 years, you might go bankrupt, but at that point it's not the economy, it's you.

I'm not saying the economy doesn't need tweaks. I'll pretend the search function is working and tell you to search my name and GLB-economy, I'm all over the place talking about how important that is.

That point being, if you can't win anything by the time you start to run out of cash, you're doing something wrong. Teams cost about 1.5-2 mil in salary a year, and yet even at their lowest, teams will make 6-8 mil a year. With responsible money-management, money shouldn't be a problem.
 
dimmy finster
offline
Link
 
I don't mind the gutted teams at all.


Without gutted teams, a team in the middle has a hard time advancing, no way of mass FA's to sign players.
 
Tito716
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Juan Fiddy
Fire sales need to go.


Do they?

Why?

Because they hurt the competitive balance of a league? Is this better or worse than the effects of completely open Free Agency?

What about the Player's rights? Why should they be forced to be on a team if they don't want to be? Playing for an owner they don't want?

That's the interesting (yet shitty) paradigm in GLB. An owner is a bad guy if he leaves other people's players on his team when he sells it. An owner is a bad guy if he gets rid of them all before selling it (even if he gets cash for them). A new owner is a bad guy for refusing to release the players on the team when he acquires it. A new owner is also a bad guy for getting rid of all of the players that were on the team when he got it.

 
papabear
offline
Link
 
Will GLB need to go through a sifting to wait and see who is comitted and who is not? Will it be a 10 season BETA in order to get things worked out and then unleash a full version?
 
Link
 
Originally posted by papabear
Will GLB need to go through a sifting to wait and see who is comitted and who is not? Will it be a 10 season BETA in order to get things worked out and then unleash a full version?


Probably not, as an accurate football sim is hard to code (just ask EA, and even 2K5 wasn't perfect).

However, after 10 years, we will get to see the cycling of players, so that's going to be huge in terms of player movement.
 
Link
 
Bottom line is, I don't know that I would renew my team ownership for another season unless I hit the lotto. Then I would create enough players and boost them all to have all the depth in the world. I could then PM myself and complain I'm not getting enough time on the field. I could bitch about my salary and then tell myself I want to be released to go to my other new team. (sarcastic)
 
Ramius
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Vanilla Thunder

That point being, if you can't win anything by the time you start to run out of cash, you're doing something wrong. Teams cost about 1.5-2 mil in salary a year, and yet even at their lowest, teams will make 6-8 mil a year. With responsible money-management, money shouldn't be a problem.


I'm not sure where you are getting this. My fringe playoff team carries a salary of 4.2 million per season, and i am paying most of my players not much above the minimum salaries. Only teams with players level 2-8 can run a team on only 1.5-2 mil per season.

The game economics are broken horrendously. Sure, i know how to run my team and i make sure i have enough left over. But take a top team versus a middle team over the course of 2 seasons (same stadium size, same team salary, etc), and the top team will bank 50-80 million while the middle tier will bank 20 million. Top teams get more fan support and thus can charge insane ticket prices, making money, and they also get huge bonuses for hosting playoff games.

The game really is broken in that both from an economic and a player standpoint, it is all but impossible to rise from the middle tiers to the top tiers. Good teams stay good, and bad teams stay bad. Dont try and say otherwise. 3 seasons in my South America AAA league, and every season, there are the same 4-5 great teams, the same 6 or so teams fighting for the final playoff spots, and the same 4-5 absolute crap teams.
 
islander1
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Vanilla Thunder
Originally posted by islander1

Originally posted by Vanilla Thunder



Originally posted by




8. (11:00AM CDT)Teams being purchased by people without fully realizing what they are getting into thus setting them up for failure from the start.


QFT yet again.

The biggest issue of the game isn't parity, the AI, or even the SIM code. It's the player base.

The survival of this game depends on a players willingness to be a 10-6 team that loses in the first round of the playoffs 3 years in a row. People have to be willing to spend time in Football Purgatory along with the Buffalo Bills and Seattle Seahawks.

Many players come into the game with experience in Madden and WoW and expect to instantly be able to not only compete but to progress at their own pace and reach some sort of endgame. Sadly, GLB isn't like that, it's a competitive MMORPG and we're going to need players for all levels of the pyramid, not just the top.



But see Vanilla, this is where one of the game's greatest failings shows its ugly head.

No one wants to be 10-6 for 3 years, because the current economic structure in GLB is so heavily skewed towards the top 3 teams it's game breaking. If you don't consistently have multiple home playoffs games most seasons, economically your team will fail, long term. Thats not speculation, that's fact.

When the 7th place team gets 100k for their playoff participation, and the second place team gets 30 million, hello...can we say retard economics?


Huh? Your team will only fail if you spend carelessly. I suppose over 8-10 years, you might go bankrupt, but at that point it's not the economy, it's you.

I'm not saying the economy doesn't need tweaks. I'll pretend the search function is working and tell you to search my name and GLB-economy, I'm all over the place talking about how important that is.

That point being, if you can't win anything by the time you start to run out of cash, you're doing something wrong. Teams cost about 1.5-2 mil in salary a year, and yet even at their lowest, teams will make 6-8 mil a year. With responsible money-management, money shouldn't be a problem.


You mean spend carelessly on the quality players you NEED to buy to do better then 10-6, only to find you can't really afford to give them the hundreds of thousands in cash for equipment that they can get from another team who is consistently 14-2 and has tens of millions sitting around in the bank thanks to playoff games?

You are missing the point here.

The economy is broken. Couple this with the bar constantly raising for high quality, high level players, and what you have is an extremely broken system here in GLB that promotes gutting

The deck is unbelievably stacked against teams who don't get a solid amount of playoff income. That's not opinion, that's fact.

Last edited Aug 29, 2008 10:56:13
 
LordEvil
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by
Originally posted by Vanilla Thunder

That point being, if you can't win anything by the time you start to run out of cash, you're doing something wrong. Teams cost about 1.5-2 mil in salary a year, and yet even at their lowest, teams will make 6-8 mil a year. With responsible money-management, money shouldn't be a problem.

I pay 4.7 mil and thats on the cheap end
 
Statbase
offline
Link
 
I think the structure of the game is causing most of the issues. What I mean is for this game to be successful people have to be competitive. When I say competititve I don't mean everyone must have a good team, I mean they must be trying to get better.

The structure of this game allows for way too many conflicts of interest.
1.) An owner should only be allowed one team
2.) A person should only be allowed to GM for one team
3.) A owner/GM should not be allowed any of his/her players on that team

I know these opinions are generally unpopular, but a large part of this game boils down to competing in a free market system for players. When you have massive conflict of interests like these you end up with massive problems.

Right now it seems the admins are attacking these problems (gutting/collusion or in general people playing and not trying to win) backwards by making rules that are aimed at the symptoms and not the cause. (i.e. chemistry, trade retrictions, trade mins and max's, salary mins and max's, league level caps, etc...). These restrictions inevitably end up hurting the people you are trying to protect making it less fun for everyone. While the people that don't want to compete in the spirit of the game will continue to find other ways to circumvent the rules. Leading to more restrictions.

Besides eliminating these conflicts or interest, I would suggest when someone signs up or buys a team it be made clear that it is contingent on them competing in the true spirit of the game. Maybe put it in the Terms of Use.

 
Link
 
Originally posted by Ramius
Originally posted by Vanilla Thunder


That point being, if you can't win anything by the time you start to run out of cash, you're doing something wrong. Teams cost about 1.5-2 mil in salary a year, and yet even at their lowest, teams will make 6-8 mil a year. With responsible money-management, money shouldn't be a problem.


I'm not sure where you are getting this. My fringe playoff team carries a salary of 4.2 million per season, and i am paying most of my players not much above the minimum salaries. Only teams with players level 2-8 can run a team on only 1.5-2 mil per season.


I'm "getting" it from my records as it's exactly what I did. You're not understanding what I said though. I don't mean you can pay lvl. 28s 1.5 mil a year, but rather, salaries increase by that rate.

If you're paying more, then you should look to retool your roster. In GLB, income grows exponentially, while costs grow in a linear fashion.

If you're going broke, it's you.
Originally posted by

The game economics are broken horrendously. Sure, i know how to run my team and i make sure i have enough left over. But take a top team versus a middle team over the course of 2 seasons (same stadium size, same team salary, etc), and the top team will bank 50-80 million while the middle tier will bank 20 million. Top teams get more fan support and thus can charge insane ticket prices, making money, and they also get huge bonuses for hosting playoff games.


And what does the top team do what all that money? Nothing, it's largely worthless. Equipment gets expensive, but having it isn't gamebreaking.

Originally posted by

The game really is broken in that both from an economic and a player standpoint, it is all but impossible to rise from the middle tiers to the top tiers. Good teams stay good, and bad teams stay bad. Dont try and say otherwise. 3 seasons in my South America AAA league, and every season, there are the same 4-5 great teams, the same 6 or so teams fighting for the final playoff spots, and the same 4-5 absolute crap teams.


My team went from AA to PRO, and our sister team went from BBB (or A, not sure) to USA AAA. It can be done. Most owners just aren't good enough.
 
Link
 
Originally posted by islander1

You mean spend carelessly on the quality players you NEED to buy to do better then 10-6, only to find you can't really afford to give them the hundreds of thousands in cash for equipment that they can get from another team who is consistently 14-2 and has tens of millions sitting around in the bank thanks to playoff games?

You are missing the point here.

The economy is broken. Couple this with the bar constantly raising for high quality, high level players, and what you have is an extremely broken system here in GLB that promotes gutting

The deck is unbelievably stacked against teams who don't get a solid amount of playoff income. That's not opinion, that's fact.



That word, fact, doesn't mean what you think it means. Simply because a player wants a golden Porcshe doesn't mean you have to give it to them. If you're paying above normal training (and giving bonuses for equip), then you're spending more then needed.

The deck isn't stacked. In CPL we have teams that compete with more or less money. People believe money is this huge boggie man, but if that were true, I wouldn't be sitting with 55 mil in my bank unable to spend it.
 
F8n4tune
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by WSUfanatic
Originally posted by Haavoc

Originally posted by phthalatemagic



Create special non-boosting leagues, and players that exist on that database or league must stay there.


That's the one thing that would make me quit. What's the point to buying flex if I can join a league where I can stay competitive without it?


It would completely ruin the game.


No it wouldn't , it would make those players as viable for testing as paying players and that's all we're doing is testing anyway. And I boost. What scares you and most others is the fact that more people would chose not to pay and in turn that would hurt the game but in all honesty enough people like/chose to pay so there should be no worries there.

Also most people who don't pay to play are the ones that sit on the inactive lists anyway , but that also has to do with them actually having nowhere to play at all because they don't boost.
 
Juan Fiddy
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Tito716
Originally posted by Juan Fiddy

Fire sales need to go.


Do they?

Why?

Because they hurt the competitive balance of a league? Is this better or worse than the effects of completely open Free Agency?

What about the Player's rights? Why should they be forced to be on a team if they don't want to be? Playing for an owner they don't want?

That's the interesting (yet shitty) paradigm in GLB. An owner is a bad guy if he leaves other people's players on his team when he sells it. An owner is a bad guy if he gets rid of them all before selling it (even if he gets cash for them). A new owner is a bad guy for refusing to release the players on the team when he acquires it. A new owner is also a bad guy for getting rid of all of the players that were on the team when he got it.



If the player himself is this concerned, then they should only be signing year end contracts.

I have much less of a problem with a new owner wishing to rebuild within the scope of their own vision, but a previous owner who is of the mind to relinquish control of a team, shouldn't be able to destroy the team.

When you have this many teams, and take a high tier team and gut it, the prospect for that team to regain competitiveness is several months/seasons away. New owners walking into a situation like this are much less likely to feel they got a return for their investment. It hurts the competitive nature of the game in much more of a way, than conference ranking and stats.

It does rely on the playerbase, as many have said. The freemarket system, compiled with the fickleness of the players tends to do more harm than good and some checks really need to be in place to prevent mass migration and balance issues.
 
Link
 
Originally posted by LordEvil
Originally posted by

Originally posted by Vanilla Thunder

That point being, if you can't win anything by the time you start to run out of cash, you're doing something wrong. Teams cost about 1.5-2 mil in salary a year, and yet even at their lowest, teams will make 6-8 mil a year. With responsible money-management, money shouldn't be a problem.

I pay 4.7 mil and thats on the cheap end


Again, missing the point.

Player salary costs go up 1.5-2 mil a year, while stadium income goes up exponentially.

The economy is broken, but not in the direction people seem to think.

Owners are overspending on players, neglecting their stadiums, and then wondering why they don't have money.

The issue with GLB-money is that it's a "must" and not a "want". In real life, we want to get as much money as we can, but in GLB, we only need enough to train and buy equip. If there were more uses for money, that ol' "Monetary utility" phrase I use so much, combined with a salary cap, you'd see a drastic improvement.

Bad owners would still suck, but responsible owners would be on more even footing.

Thankfully, Bort's working on that, likely as we type.
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.