User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Forum > Suggestions > Prestige Attributes - A way to reduce the "stagnation plateau" for higher level players and add more differentiation among cookie cutter builds
Page:
 
Dannyg28
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by GG
Originally posted by drifter


This idea is nowhere near an overhaul. I'm not sure why you keep posting that. It fits perfectly into the existing system without changing anything that is already in place.



Im not putting you or your ideas down, drifter. You're always a great thinker and poster etc.

I read Bort said a few pages back that my 200/SA idea was "scrap everything" and wasnt presented well...but a) it wasnt scrapping everything at all, it was returning SPs to people and working on the SAME attribute system that exists now, people re-doing their players, b) was presented well but at the time GLB wasn't as in uproar over how the game was broken, and i became scapegoated by everyone. So it became easier to just put me down personally as well as my idea and chuckle at me not appreciating that the game IS broken and the warnings about people leaving and the 100-0 scores and noobs losing interest weren't being taken seriously....admin just seeing people at the time spend money and think i was an idiot.

It's interesting that in time, all the people who put me down back then are today now accepting the game is broken at the core player-build level and needs re-doing. Look at the people in my 200 thread back then mocking me then today and the last couple of months have all ended up creating threads demanding overhauls and being angry at the broken game.

im not jealous if Bort likes other peoples ideas more than mine. That's totally not it. I dont care where ideas come from, and it's just great to have Bort genuinely interested and commits to literally over-hauling/re-doing things to improve the game. But it is a slap in the face to say "drifter has good ideas and so i cant be bothered reading anyone elses". There are millions of pages of suggestions over the last 6 months that have been made and yet the effort to bring them to Bort has broken down and it's a matter of people bumping and rebumping threads hoping to get Bort to notice, and he doesnt always either due to his time-contraints.

For instance, how many weeks has that Individual Player Tactics thread been rebumping, and ive asked for it to be stickied because it's bringing together everyone's ideas into one thread...but Bort hasnt noticed it, it hasnt been stickied, and instead 50 other people create new threads on the same topic. Where's the effort to grab that thread and make it happen? It's not even a re-do of anything. Just adding more tactics to their players.

And just one more thing, about the idea in this thread itself....

While level 35 players with level 5 prestige may not be significantly stronger than level 28 players with 0 prestige, it IS. Because already today level 25 players destroy level 20 players. So it's like another 10+ levels amplified. Also, youre just going to see teams signing level 35-40 players to BBB teams etc because they can. Because admin dont want to 'forbid' people from owning teams and bringing in all their own players. Which I agree with. But this idea would only create more disparity between vets and noobs, and will need then to have people/friends not allowed to bring in their own players to prevent that disparity from imbalancing the leagues and creating 100-0 scores or the effect it will have on back-ups.

It's the noobs who need to be focused on, not the vets. The noobs (new customers who try and MAYBE buy) are the ones abandoning the game in droves. While I agree vets need new hoops to jump thru, the very fabric of player-creation needs an idea like 200 because it does address that whole disparity and customization of players, does focus on the noob and lessening the 100-0 scores. New bells and whistles for vets can still be implemented on top of a player building model such as the '200' one.

The priority or chronology of re-doing a more robust/customizable player building model needs to be first establishing a kind of '200' concept where noobs and vets are put on a level playing field, and then secondly looking to enhance the vet experience thru bells and whistles. Not the latter first.




if you've ever played an mmo before, noobs and vets are never on the same playing level.
 
GG
offline
Link
 
I do like my 200 idea, but it's not about that per se. It's just that ideas LIKE that need to be done. The player building model needs re-doing. Can side-step and band-aid around it all one wants, but it's the problem/solution to everything.

1. First create a more level playing field (hence the '200' concept)
2. Then create true individuality/specialization/customization (hence the new-SA concept).
3. Then create bells and whistles for vet players on top of that whole foundation.

It doesnt have to be the 200 idea itself, but that's kinda the road it needs to go down.

The new-SAs idea or any idea like it is the right path to take when trying to solve the cookie cutter builds. Imo, removing trees and opening up position-specific SAs for players to choose say 10 of 50 to choose from.

People can debate and disagree about the specifics of the models suggested, but the bottom-line is that the chronology has to be addressed that way, and that the ideas have to kind of follow those concepts:-

a) level the playing field for noobs/vets
b) create true customization/individuality of players, hence true tactics and game-planning having more say in the results of games than the mere level disparity of skills between teams.
c) create bells and whistles for vets that do not aid 100-0 type games or discourage noobs from persisting with the game.
 
GG
offline
Link
 
Danny28...

This is a simulation cross mmorpg, not a strict mmorpg or a strict simulation. The reason GLB is broken and there are so many varied problems is BECAUSE of this level disparity. You name the problem and it relates to this disparity. The problems are not "oh well" because theyre the reason why people leave, not spend money, get frustrated etc etc.

And it's important because a) admin dont want to (and i agree here) forbid people or friends from owning a team and bringing in all their own players. So once you have that then you cannot have level disparity being so dominant. You cannot have ideas that only further create more disparity just because they're vet people and are bored. The noob is more important than the vet. If he werent, then these 8 regions of 16 leagues each with 32 teams in each league would end up collapsing from people quitting and it would end up just this small 1 league game played by 50 people.

Last edited Aug 26, 2008 19:00:25
 
Dannyg28
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by GG
I do like my 200 idea, but it's not about that per se. It's just that ideas LIKE that need to be done. The player building model needs re-doing. Can side-step and band-aid around it all one wants, but it's the problem/solution to everything.

1. First create a more level playing field (hence the '200' concept)
2. Then create true individuality/specialization/customization (hence the new-SA concept).
3. Then create bells and whistles for vet players on top of that whole foundation.

It doesnt have to be the 200 idea itself, but that's kinda the road it needs to go down.

The new-SAs idea or any idea like it is the right path to take when trying to solve the cookie cutter builds. Imo, removing trees and opening up position-specific SAs for players to choose say 10 of 50 to choose from.

People can debate and disagree about the specifics of the models suggested, but the bottom-line is that the chronology has to be addressed that way, and that the ideas have to kind of follow those concepts:-

a) level the playing field for noobs/vets
b) create true customization/individuality of players, hence true tactics and game-planning having more say in the results of games than the mere level disparity of skills between teams.
c) create bells and whistles for vets that do not aid 100-0 type games or discourage noobs from persisting with the game.


if i remember correctly, your idea involved getting rid of levels and giving everyone 200 SP to use however they feel correct?

That kind of idea goes directly against what an MMORPG is, which is what this game is. In MMORPGs noobs can never compete with the vets, the trick is separating the noobs from the vets. In WoW you don't have level 19s playing in battlegrounds against level 60s.

An idea to do that, that probably wouldn't happen due to people not wanting to move out of the current league they are in,and the fact that bort would have to completely redue the leagues is to have each league be players created on a certain season. USA players created season 1 day 0- season 2 day 20, Canada season 2 day 21-4, etc.
or something to that effect.
 
Nuge20
offline
Link
 
great idea
 
Dannyg28
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by GG
Danny28...

This is a simulation cross mmorpg, not a strict mmorpg or a strict simulation. The reason GLB is broken and there are so many varied problems is BECAUSE of this level disparity. You name the problem and it relates to this disparity. The problems are not "oh well" because theyre the reason why people leave, not spend money, get frustrated etc etc.

And it's important because a) admin dont want to (and i agree here) forbid people or friends from owning a team and bringing in all their own players. So once you have that then you cannot have level disparity being so dominant. You cannot have ideas that only further create more disparity just because they're vet people and are bored. The noob is more important than the vet. If he werent, then these 8 regions of 16 leagues each with 32 teams in each league would end up collapsing from people quitting and it would end up just this small 1 league game played by 50 people.



one of the things people are complaining about is that at level 20+ they no longer start leveling and the game becomes much more boring, the 200(or something similar to it) would have that problem from day 1.
 
dpell
offline
Link
 
Veteren backup - reduces the number of snaps needed for full exp when playing in a non-stater role on the depth chart.

Special teams expert - similar to above but for special team

Hard count - QB increases the chance of false start penalties

Intimidating presence - for OL/DL - causes false start, encroachment, and off sides penalties in the opposing line
 
GG
offline
Link
 
Danny28...

About my '200' idea...

No, levels werent abolished. Players level up because they still earn XP and these earned SPs would be used ONLY in the new-SA area. So they have to level up of course. All I said was to change the wording from Level to Season, so that it creates a different perception.

And the 200 idea was basically---you build a new player, you have 200 SPs that have to be used in the base area ONLY. All level ups in time the SPs can only go to the new-SA area (where you customize your player). Your base attributes CAN increase only thru training (as in real life) but you also get the 'reward' to move your attributes up/down 5 pts each time you level up (eg, moving speed from 55 to 50 and then moving vision up from 20 to 25).
Last edited Aug 26, 2008 19:17:45
 
Dannyg28
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by GG
Danny28...

About my '200' idea...

No, levels werent abolished. Players level up because they still earn XP and these earned SPs would be used ONLY in the new-SA area. So they have to level up of course. All I said was to change the wording from Level to Season, so that it creates a different perception.

And the 200 idea was basically---you build a new player, you have 200 SPs that have to be used in the base area ONLY. All level ups in time the SPs can only go to the new-SA area (where you customize your player). Your base attributes CAN increase only thru training (as in real life) but you also get the 'reward' to move your attributes up/down 5 pts each time you level up (eg, moving speed from 55 to 50 and then moving vision up from 20 to 25).


how would that idea help newbies? wouldn't a level 20(or w/e) still be significantly better than a level 1 with daily training and much increased SA?
 
cane__boy
offline
Link
 
i like the idea , but the likely hood of it happening is .0000000000000001%
 
drifter
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by cane__boy
i like the idea , but the likely hood of it happening is .0000000000000001%


Might want to read the thread.
 
Xiong Yoshi
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by cane__boy
i like the idea , but the likely hood of it happening is .0000000000000001%


Which is exactly why Bort stickied it and commented a few times - just like all the other ideas that have .0000000000000001% chance of happening.
 
dpell
offline
Link
 
One More thing... The game is more "broken" right now because vet players are stagnating and new players with the benefit of better mechanics knowledge are surpassing them. Slow building, primary stat maxing, I'm seeing lvl 21-22's with equal builds to lvl 27-28 players right now. Season 1 players didn't even know soft caps existed or that there was a huge advantage to getting your primary stars there ASAP. They've essentially been punished for building balanced players early on. This idea gives them something else to make their high levels worth something.
 
cane__boy
offline
Link
 
i dont have a century to read 100 pages but if it takes bort half a season to fix a vision problem think how long it would take for him to make this happen
 
Dannyg28
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by cane__boy
i dont have a century to read 100 pages but if it takes bort half a season to fix a vision problem think how long it would take for him to make this happen


did you forget the amount of bug fixes he had to do the start of the season?
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.