User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Forum > Discuss GLB Issues With Catch22 > NOT A BUG - CLOSED > My chemistry dropped way lower than it should have.
Page:
 
essteeay
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by caneswizard
If team chemistry doesn't count for much. Then why even have it?


Here's my theory. Chemistry was implemented so that the admins could pretend that they were doing something to combat the gutting of farm teams (UNCOMPETITIVE FARM TEAMS WHICH SHOULD BE FLAT OUT AGAINST THE RULES ANYWAY) without actually doing anything significant to hurt those who practice that sort of thing, since so many of the users who do are alpha testers and "big names" ($$) on GLB. If they really have now admitted that chemistry affects nothing significantly, then, well, wow.

 
Link
 
I've actually seen Mods/Admins try to swing that idea around before, forget the situation, maybe people complaining about something, but they were again downplaying its effects as if it mattered not.

Like I said before, tell Bort hes losing 9% of his expected earnings and see if it just boils down to, not making a difference.
 
oldskool
offline
Link
 
If you have the minimum chemistry and your opponent has the maximum, that's the 9% difference.

Somehow methinks if your team's bad enough to warrant having minimal chemistry and theirs is good enough to warrant maximum chemistry, you'd get your ass kicked regardless of "9%". Hence "it's not that important", i.e. "Stop blaming it for everything, suck it up & play".

Before chemistry it was morale; people love to point at bars and blame them for failures.
 
essteeay
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by oldskool
If you have the minimum chemistry and your opponent has the maximum, that's the 9% difference.

Somehow methinks if your team's bad enough to warrant having minimal chemistry and theirs is good enough to warrant maximum chemistry, you'd get your ass kicked regardless of "9%". Hence "it's not that important", i.e. "Stop blaming it for everything, suck it up & play".

Before chemistry it was morale; people love to point at bars and blame them for failures.


Uh, that's not really the point here.
 
oldskool
offline
Link
 
If that's not the point, then neither is "The admins are lazy fucks who are trying to con us into thinking they're doing work by implementing meaningless 'chemistry' bars".
 
essteeay
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by oldskool
If that's not the point, then neither is "The admins are lazy fucks who are trying to con us into thinking they're doing work by implementing meaningless 'chemistry' bars".


Yep, also true. You have a real knack for hitting on precisely what we are not discussing in this thread.
 
im4ut999
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by oldskool
If that's not the point, then neither is "The admins are lazy fucks who are trying to con us into thinking they're doing work by implementing meaningless 'chemistry' bars".


I don't care really which side the axe falls on, but it is obviously not very clear the way the hit is worded...

If I make a trade on day 18, that is the "activity" date I am making the change. If the system updates on the rollover, then it is the system doing that update.

Now if they document the chem hit in such a way that the "processing" of the activity must complete on day 24 (meaning you can add a FA or drop a player on day 24, but trades must be "processed" on rollover INTO day 24), then it is much easier to understand, rather than week 10-12 are double chemistry hit...

Ambiguous documentation has caused a lot of issues, and it has caused it multiple times...
 
Link
 
Originally posted by im4ut999
Originally posted by oldskool

If that's not the point, then neither is "The admins are lazy fucks who are trying to con us into thinking they're doing work by implementing meaningless 'chemistry' bars".


I don't care really which side the axe falls on, but it is obviously not very clear the way the hit is worded...

If I make a trade on day 18, that is the "activity" date I am making the change. If the system updates on the rollover, then it is the system doing that update.

Now if they document the chem hit in such a way that the "processing" of the activity must complete on day 24 (meaning you can add a FA or drop a player on day 24, but trades must be "processed" on rollover INTO day 24), then it is much easier to understand, rather than week 10-12 are double chemistry hit...

Ambiguous documentation has caused a lot of issues, and it has caused it multiple times...


Well said, but easy on the big words, the mod-job tryout will not be able to formulate a rebuttle and then we will have noone around to make us feel better about ourselves.
Last edited Aug 21, 2008 00:21:07
 
oldskool
offline
Link
 
*rebutt
And it would be rebuttal, while I'm at it.

Originally posted by Bort
Moves made between during weeks 10 - 12 (days 19 - 24)
- Cost double the chemistry hit. Make your moves early in the season to avoid the extra hits.
 
Link
 
Wasnt yesterday week 9 for the even leagues? And day 18 for everyone? I think it was.
Next.
Last edited Aug 21, 2008 00:24:58
 
timpjynx
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by oldskool

Originally posted by Bort

Moves made between during weeks 10 - 12 (days 19 - 24)
- Cost double the chemistry hit. Make your moves early in the season to avoid the extra hits.


from our perspective, we did just that... by definition, "early" means ANYTIME BEFORE DAY 19...

thats pretty much everyone's point here (well almost everyone).... the trades we "made" were "made" on day 18... once they clear the 1-hour "retractable" period, they are set in stone... period... a trade "made" on day 18 should count for day 18... common sense imo... don't understand just because the system "processes" them after midnight they should count for day 19 rather than the day they were proposed, accepted, and made irreversable after the 1-hour waiting period...

 
oldskool
offline
Link
 
What day did the trades go through? Day 19.
What day does double chemistry start? Day 19.
What does Bort suggest? Make your moves early in the season to avoid the extra hits.

You took the risk of taking a double chemistry hit when you made the moves. Is there ambiguity there, sure, you made a decent argument about 'Day 25 trades' a page or so back (I consider it a whining prevention tool because people wouldn't realize the connection and would think they could make trades on Day 24 only to find they'd already missed the deadline, personally).

The point is that you had 17 days without any ambiguity whatsoever about chemistry costs to make those moves and for whatever reason you waited until the last possible second & took the chance. Did you get screwed, maybe, is it anyone's fault but your own you were in position to be screwed, no.
 
essteeay
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by oldskool
What day did the trades go through? Day 19.
What day does double chemistry start? Day 19.
What does Bort suggest? Make your moves early in the season to avoid the extra hits.

You took the risk of taking a double chemistry hit when you made the moves. Is there ambiguity there, sure, you made a decent argument about 'Day 25 trades' a page or so back (I consider it a whining prevention tool because people wouldn't realize the connection and would think they could make trades on Day 24 only to find they'd already missed the deadline, personally).

The point is that you had 17 days without any ambiguity whatsoever about chemistry costs to make those moves and for whatever reason you waited until the last possible second & took the chance. Did you get screwed, maybe, is it anyone's fault but your own you were in position to be screwed, no.


Just stop. Your act is tired. This guy has obviously done nothing wrong, it's absolutely not his fault, and from what I've seen the response from the admins has been completely unacceptable.
 
DaRealest
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by essteeay
Originally posted by oldskool

What day did the trades go through? Day 19.
What day does double chemistry start? Day 19.
What does Bort suggest? Make your moves early in the season to avoid the extra hits.

You took the risk of taking a double chemistry hit when you made the moves. Is there ambiguity there, sure, you made a decent argument about 'Day 25 trades' a page or so back (I consider it a whining prevention tool because people wouldn't realize the connection and would think they could make trades on Day 24 only to find they'd already missed the deadline, personally).

The point is that you had 17 days without any ambiguity whatsoever about chemistry costs to make those moves and for whatever reason you waited until the last possible second & took the chance. Did you get screwed, maybe, is it anyone's fault but your own you were in position to be screwed, no.


Just stop. Your act is tired. This guy has obviously done nothing wrong, it's absolutely not his fault, and from what I've seen the response from the admins has been completely unacceptable.


I agree with oldskool.
 
timpjynx
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by oldskool
What day did the trades go through? Day 19.
What day does double chemistry start? Day 19.
What does Bort suggest? Make your moves early in the season to avoid the extra hits.


early=can only be defined as any before day 19 in this context
what day were the trades "made"? Day 18.. all i'm saying is i don't understand why it should be our problem that the system "processes" them a day later...

Originally posted by oldskool

The point is that you had 17 days without any ambiguity whatsoever about chemistry costs to make those moves and for whatever reason you waited until the last possible second & took the chance. Did you get screwed, maybe, is it anyone's fault but your own you were in position to be screwed, no.


not necessarily true.... i had a player that unexpectedly went AWOL. was my starting HB and TE since the inception of my team.. no clue what happened to him -- was never inactive before and could be dead now for all i know..

but when it became apparent that he may not come back, i had no choice to start looking around for replacements... we're an undefeated team that has had 100% chemistry for 2 straight seasons... this was VERY unexpected, but hey it happens... as such, i wasn't about to risk the season by continuing to play a HB/TE combo that wasn't using his SPs, wasn't using his boosts, etc... talk about bad business!

anyway, the HB replacement happened pretty quickly because there's a ton of em to begin with... the TE, not so much... i can give you a list of probably 20 TEs agents/owners that i recruited over 6 days to no avail until the day came when i could add the additional argument of "lets get something done today so we don't take double hits tomorrow"...

and if you happened to notice the trade forums on DAY 18, the threads were saturated with mentions of "today is final day for trades" ... so its pretty apparent that was the general consensus as to how the whole day 18 vs day 19 threshold was going to work...
Last edited Aug 21, 2008 01:12:31
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.