User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Page:
 
DaRealest
offline
Link
 
Please, thunderdoozer, PLEASE stop!!!
 
Devolution
offline
Link
 
honestly, 10 pages of arguing? holy crap people
 
thunderdoozer
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Devolution
honestly, 10 pages of arguing? holy crap people


+1

The last logical post in the thread:

CBs do not respond realistically to the passing game. They give too much cushion in many situations where they shouldn't, such as 3rd and medium and goal line situations. They rarely get breaks on the ball, and more often break AWAY from the ball. When covering a WR tightly, the CB gives up a catch far more often than is realistic.

LBs assigned to man coverage will drop back on running plays, sometimes as much as 10 yards.

The COMBINATION of the new tackling and the increased effect of forward momentum on break-tackle ability has made power backs disproportionally strong in the game.
 
ShakeNBake
offline
Link
 
-1

Last edited Aug 16, 2008 15:11:40
 
PinTBC
offline
Link
 
Just because he is taking alot of flack. Thunderdozer certainly has some VERY good points.

A WR in double or triple coverage should NOT be coming down with the ball at anywhere near a 70% clip.

If the dots are not accurate enough to judge the clarity of the game against, then they are not accurate enough to game plan with. I'm hoping the first statement is very false for a lot of reasons that should be fairly obvious.

Corners are not reacting in a logical manner in certain situations.

Now, I fully agreed with him until the last couple games. I've had a chance to muck with the defensive settings on two teams for five games now, and I've found that the settings play a MAJOR part in the triple covered WR problem. They also can help the corners not acting logically.

The old days of setting your defense on close coverage/go for the interception is gone. If you do that, your guys will get burned.

The other problems he mentioned are also still there. Linebackers dropping back on running plays is a tough one.

PinTBC
 
dpell
offline
Link
 
The passing game is more realistic than it was last season, but it still needs work. CB's are still reacting too quickly, WR's are struggling to get open according to the dots.

However, now WR's are catching the ball in triple coverage.

I'd like to see CB's bite a little more on routes and WR's get more open once in awhile, and when the CB is in position the WR shouldn't be making the catch nearly as often. Still, I'll take this season over last. Too many games where
 
PinTBC
offline
Link
 
So, in your opinion, a Wide Receiver facing a Corner back who is equally well trained in the appropriate stats should be able to complete a pattern 70% of the time? According to Ken1, that is exactly what his thoughts on statistics say.

Personally, I disagree. I believe that equally trained people should start off at a 50% success rate, which would then be increased or decreased by special abilities, and tactics. While this is in fact a SIM, it is also a game, and you need to allow people the belief that they are not just speed bumps, and that training actually means something.

PinTBC
 
NWWarrior
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by PinTBC
So, in your opinion, a Wide Receiver facing a Corner back who is equally well trained in the appropriate stats should be able to complete a pattern 70% of the time? According to Ken1, that is exactly what his thoughts on statistics say.

Personally, I disagree. I believe that equally trained people should start off at a 50% success rate, which would then be increased or decreased by special abilities, and tactics. While this is in fact a SIM, it is also a game, and you need to allow people the belief that they are not just speed bumps, and that training actually means something.

PinTBC


You make way to much sense there TBC
 
RMiller517
offline
Link
 
Thread locked by moderator.
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.