User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Forum > Goal Line Blitz > Problem with Stamina/Substitution/Depth?
Page:
 
Tiny Tom
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Beef
From my perspective as a player (not an owner), I'm all for this issue being addressed before we are up and running on the next season.

I don't mind patiently working my way through the ranks as a backup to a point where I might someday start, but I'm appalled that the best way to win a GLB championship in Season 1 was to pare your team's roster down to the minimum number of players and let them play 100% of the snaps. It's inconsistent with the spirit of this "team game" (more participation = more fun, right?) as well as unrealistic at any level of actual football, from Pee Wee to the pros.

Let the players play!


I second this. I'll further echo the other gripes in the fact that a person running at 50% energy shouldn't be able to keep up with someone 1 step slower running @ 100% energy. There are currently so many players that extra teams have to be made, that's silly because most teams have NO depth due to the fact that DEPTH DOESN'T MATTER. As to the argument that owners will just sign players the same level as their starters, there only so many level 10's out there, eventually teams will have to sign other people that are slightly lower in order to stay competitive.
I know my team is a bunch of guys who are friends from else where and we don't truly care about who starts or scores td's or what ever, we just like the game. It seems unfair that our team was penalized for playing a lot of guys (who were the same level and mostly a higher level than our competitors) against opponents who just ran a single guy at every position.
Yes QB's play every play, but they aren't getting smacked around or all out sprinting like a WR or DE, and increasing the need for depth increases specialization. A team should be encouraged to recruit a Pass Rush line and a Run Stuff D-Line because there are advantages to both.
These of course are just my opinions, but I know by the end of a game when I'm tired a fresh sub who's usually much slower than me has no problem keeping up with me. That's real life and should be reflected in the sims, and sometimes I'm still tired from my exertion days later. Watch what jerome bettis used to have to do after games, he literally couldnt go upstairs in his house, thats lower than 69% energy.
 
Whatsdafus
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Tiny Tom
Originally posted by Beef

From my perspective as a player (not an owner), I'm all for this issue being addressed before we are up and running on the next season.

I don't mind patiently working my way through the ranks as a backup to a point where I might someday start, but I'm appalled that the best way to win a GLB championship in Season 1 was to pare your team's roster down to the minimum number of players and let them play 100% of the snaps. It's inconsistent with the spirit of this "team game" (more participation = more fun, right?) as well as unrealistic at any level of actual football, from Pee Wee to the pros.

Let the players play!


I second this. I'll further echo the other gripes in the fact that a person running at 50% energy shouldn't be able to keep up with someone 1 step slower running @ 100% energy. There are currently so many players that extra teams have to be made, that's silly because most teams have NO depth due to the fact that DEPTH DOESN'T MATTER. As to the argument that owners will just sign players the same level as their starters, there only so many level 10's out there, eventually teams will have to sign other people that are slightly lower in order to stay competitive.
I know my team is a bunch of guys who are friends from else where and we don't truly care about who starts or scores td's or what ever, we just like the game. It seems unfair that our team was penalized for playing a lot of guys (who were the same level and mostly a higher level than our competitors) against opponents who just ran a single guy at every position.
Yes QB's play every play, but they aren't getting smacked around or all out sprinting like a WR or DE, and increasing the need for depth increases specialization. A team should be encouraged to recruit a Pass Rush line and a Run Stuff D-Line because there are advantages to both.
These of course are just my opinions, but I know by the end of a game when I'm tired a fresh sub who's usually much slower than me has no problem keeping up with me. That's real life and should be reflected in the sims, and sometimes I'm still tired from my exertion days later. Watch what jerome bettis used to have to do after games, he literally couldnt go upstairs in his house, thats lower than 69% energy.


I third it.

I think there should be a depth chart submission... kinda like in baseball. before the game you have to hand in your line up card.

So lets say you just finished a game as an owner, you now have 48 hours to play with your line up. and right before the game or anytime during that 48 hours, you have to submit a 40 man depth chart which will lock in place your line up till after the game. you cannot submit a 39 or less depth chart. and if you forget to set your line up, if it is less then 40 players, the computer will automatcial place the people from the roster who arent on the DC, onto it and lock it.
 
Jed
offline
Link
 
Just catching up here. If I remember correctly (and it's been a long time), the biggest problem I had in Alpha was that we were all level 1-4 and trying to play the game. By the 4th quarter, it was just pathetic, guys on both teams couldn't even move.

At this point? Sure, we have enough higher level people to handle starting and lower level people to back people up.

The only thing I ask is, after it's announced exactly what is going to happen, give us a LOT of notice. At least a week real time before it goes into effect. Many times, mine included, will need some serious adjustments to work with a drastic change in the Stamina system, and I just want a chance to keep up with that change.

I'd also suggest, if a system like this is put into place, to use this as a time to lower the point where the "max exp" a good deal. It would make sense and put that in place as well to further discourage constant starters at all positions.
 
Bort
Admin
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Jed
Just catching up here. If I remember correctly (and it's been a long time), the biggest problem I had in Alpha was that we were all level 1-4 and trying to play the game. By the 4th quarter, it was just pathetic, guys on both teams couldn't even move.

At this point? Sure, we have enough higher level people to handle starting and lower level people to back people up.

The only thing I ask is, after it's announced exactly what is going to happen, give us a LOT of notice. At least a week real time before it goes into effect. Many times, mine included, will need some serious adjustments to work with a drastic change in the Stamina system, and I just want a chance to keep up with that change.

I'd also suggest, if a system like this is put into place, to use this as a time to lower the point where the "max exp" a good deal. It would make sense and put that in place as well to further discourage constant starters at all positions.


I was thinking of doing the changes gradually over a week or two to let people have time to adjust.

I'll look at the XP formulas too...I agree that 90 plays is a pretty high cutoff. Sure makes those min/maxers happy though.
 
Whatsdafus
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Jed
Just catching up here. If I remember correctly (and it's been a long time), the biggest problem I had in Alpha was that we were all level 1-4 and trying to play the game. By the 4th quarter, it was just pathetic, guys on both teams couldn't even move.

At this point? Sure, we have enough higher level people to handle starting and lower level people to back people up.

The only thing I ask is, after it's announced exactly what is going to happen, give us a LOT of notice. At least a week real time before it goes into effect. Many times, mine included, will need some serious adjustments to work with a drastic change in the Stamina system, and I just want a chance to keep up with that change.

I'd also suggest, if a system like this is put into place, to use this as a time to lower the point where the "max exp" a good deal. It would make sense and put that in place as well to further discourage constant starters at all positions.


sounds good, and jed i like that your actively in threads posting and voicing your playing issues too.

but i agree we went from one extreme to another. from being dead tires to superman. i think bort and dd will put the stam thing back inbetween those 2 settings and everything will be cool
 
salsendardo
offline
Link
 
For intents and purposes, those were my players the OP was noting. Because I love this game as much as all of you I would like to give as much information as possible. Both my players were playing on 'Hard' for their tactics.
 
the_old_days
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by hud
Originally posted by scarletmbb

Wow...thank you guys for uncovering this. This changes a lot of things. It is kind of sucky that no one said a word about it when we were all running around worrying about stamina. It would have been nice if someone had stepped in a little earlier to enlighten us, haha.


#1 it was the alpha players who were telling everyone to pump skill points into stamina. We learned in the first season that stamina was by FAR the MOST important stat. Sounds like a real fun way to build, huh? We had no idea, no special insight, that it was gonna work like this.

#2 situation dictated Borts dicision as much as "complaining" players. In alpha, you had to play CPU players becuase there were no humans. So obvioulsy we hated stamina being so important. Maybe Bort took it too far the other way, but i dont think so.

#3 now there are way way more humans that teams. So obviouly there are more backups who want their players on the field. the reason teams have the luxury of having deep rosters is becuase there arent enough teams to get players. If we swing stamina's value too far back the other way we will be making the same mistake... letting the situation dictate the game play. What happens when new team owners cant get 3 players at every spot? They will be more pissed off than you are right now because they are wasting PT on computer players who can perform. "they got three players per spot because they got a team when their were not enough teams. Why do they get an advantage over us?" It will be a frustration that makes people lose intrest fast. B&D, please don't make that mistake.

#4 realism is overated. You want everything real, then you would lose a player you spent good money to boost to a career ending injury. you would have teams that have far better players and tactics lose to sucky teams because it happens. You would have cities paying taxes for stadium builds. you would have Agents taking 30% of your players salary. there would be T.O.'s that kill a great team. You would have your players have stretches where they get no stats and dont perform to their abilities due to family problems. the whole game would suck next season due to the sophmore jinx. your players would get suspended from GLB for off field antics, your top ranked QB would be in prison after you spent 50 bucks on him in 5 seasons. I could go on.
Realism is not the real complaint. No one wants realism. We want to play a game that does some things like the real sport and some things like a game. The complaint is that someone lost or someone isnt getting enough PT. the complaint is what someone thought the game should play like didnt happen. I personally think that practice and timing is what makes a team great, not just skill. And some chemisty bar isnt gonna fix that. But it would make this game boring and cumbersum as would finding 2-3 players at every position.

Let me ask it this way? If there were enough teams and good owners that we could have teams with 32 active players per team that got more PT and leveled up faster, wouldn't that be more fun that finding 52 players so you could have some sit the bench and hope to get 25% of the plays so he could level 25% as fast as the starters? Wouldnt be more ideal for all players to have 70-90 plays, than some having 60 while other hope to get 20 a game? That's a game, not reality. Everyone wants to play, not support a team from the bench. Im not investing time (or money) into a game to watch you. And seriously, building players through PT is what drives this game, so lets get the team to player balance right and then worry about changing stamina. Until that happens, live with it.

Thats my essay and Im stickin to it.



This is a flawed arguement. There will always be more players than teams. If the one man depth strategy is continued to be used, exactly how will the player/team balance work itself out?
It won't, it will only get worse. You will have a bunch of low level, new players who can't find teams or who will find themselves doing exactly what this poster stated that they didn't want to do, sit the bench. How will brand new players find teams down the road once all the new teams are bought up and incorporated? They won't, unless new teams are added very regularly.

I understand you guys have a good thing going with the one man depth, I consider it exploiting a develpment oversight, but you have to realize that your are not the only person who has spent money on this game. Your arguments are made not for the betterment of the game, but for the advantage of your team.

Last edited Apr 18, 2008 12:01:48
 
bulletbait
offline
Link
 
Anyone surprised that Tim Harper's 6th seed USA Pro Team is using this strategy to rip up the playoffs?
 
Link
 
Not really, Tim Harper is the closest thing to Bill Belichick currently in the game.
 
salsendardo
offline
Link
 
Depth and stamina need to be fixed.
It will allow for all the low level new players to play a bigger role for their team and keep them here longer thus maximizing profits for Bort and DD.

If stamina is to play a real role, then the coaches need more specific sub management as well to encourage them to use depth.
 
Tempest
offline
Link
 
bulletbait:

I read several pages of this thread before I went and checked out the game in question. It looks to me that you were victimized by long sustained drives.

In fact, checking it out, you had 4 three and outs and they had only 2. Several of the drives were almost 20 plays! So, while your defense was out there sweating and getting the ball driven on you, their players were on the sidelines drinking Gatorade and flirting with the cheerleaders. By the time you got off the field, they were incredibly rested, you went three and out and here comes your D again.
 
F8n4tune
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Bort
Hey, I have no problem with making energy affect you more, for next season. It used to be, but people got me second guessing myself. I should probably go with my gut more often than letting the internets sway me.


I mean it's sim modeled after the REAL game in most respects right ? Make it so Capt.

There is so much to this game that imbalances things one side or another (which is why we are testing) that when something is found to create balance NO MATTER how many people cry , it should be instituted. Just my .02
 
GRiPSSL
offline
Link
 
Part of the problem is on the player's as well...I have had a few low level people ask to be traded or released because they won't start being that a higher level player is ahead of them. Players need to be realistic about stuff like that...How many lvl 1's through lvl 4's would even get a starting job. None at this point in the game. Making the stamina/effectiveness ratio matter will help back ups get more PT.
 
Kcirdor
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by WTFPILLOWSHIRT
Not really, Tim Harper is the closest thing to Bill Belichick currently in the game.


so your calling him a cheater?
 
flames54
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Kcirdor
Originally posted by WTFPILLOWSHIRT

Not really, Tim Harper is the closest thing to Bill Belichick currently in the game.


so your calling him a cheater?


Nice call.
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.