User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Forum > Suggestions > The solution!! For retiring players, teams playing 100+ plays per player/penalizing depth, and rewarding team with good defenses/quick scoring offenses
Page:
 
Malachorn
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by TrevJo
Question: What is the max amount of XP a player can gain from one game?


...who knows?
It'd be 90 plays in a game at level 1.
Anyone actually get that and looked to see exactly how much it was?

As you get more at lower levels and less at higher levels, knowing the answer to that question probably isn't worth very much unless you know the answer because you know exactly what the formula for XP is or something.
 
TrevJo
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Malachorn
Originally posted by TrevJo
Question: What is currently the max amount of XP a player can gain from one game? (Never mind how many plays it takes, I just want to know what the max possible XP gain is.)



...who knows?
It'd be 90 plays in a game at level 1.
Anyone actually get that and looked to see exactly how much it was?

As you get more at lower levels and less at higher levels, knowing the answer to that question probably isn't worth very much unless you know the answer because you know exactly what the formula for XP is or something.


Someone must know what the max amount of XP you can gain from a game is.
Otherwise it is completely impossible to do these calculations comparing the Play Right Away strategy vs the Sit The Bench For Awhile First strategy.
Last edited Apr 16, 2008 19:53:25
 
Barry Neal
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by mikestiddy
Model it after real life... The average QB plays 10-12 years, RB 7-11, WR/TE 10-12, OL 10-14, DL 10-14, LB 8-12, DB 8-12, P/K 15-20 Once they reach the lower level of that amount of years, their production/health goes down and their talents start to dwindle. Also take into account how many injuries they have throughout their career. I would like to see it mimic the duration of careers for the NFL players


That is the average maybe of a superstar in the NFL. The average NFL career is something more along the lines of 2-3 seasons
 
TrevJo
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Barry Neal
Originally posted by mikestiddy

Model it after real life... The average QB plays 10-12 years, RB 7-11, WR/TE 10-12, OL 10-14, DL 10-14, LB 8-12, DB 8-12, P/K 15-20 Once they reach the lower level of that amount of years, their production/health goes down and their talents start to dwindle. Also take into account how many injuries they have throughout their career. I would like to see it mimic the duration of careers for the NFL players


That is the average maybe of a superstar in the NFL. The average NFL career is something more along the lines of 2-3 seasons


While I am all for the idea of having about 10 years before the player starts to decline... let's keep in mind that the player development in this game is not remotely similar to that of an NFL player. A 5th year player in GLB is probably 5 times as good as a GLB rookie. Whereas in the NFL a 5th year player is maybe twice as good as a rookie. So 10 seasons in the GLB doesn't really resemble 10 years in the NFL. 10 seasons in the GLB is probably more like 20 years in real life, between age 10 and 30. Given that, there isn't really a need to get too sensitive about whether a GLB QB's career should last the same time as an NFL QB.
Last edited Apr 16, 2008 19:55:26
 
Rage Kinard
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Cybershot


Using 75*40 is not really accurate at all as a longterm measuring stick for XP growth.

Sorry if this is confusing to some, but

In season one, you would gain levels much faster than season 3-5, so using 75 as an average (100xp + 52xp(@ level 12 for Ex)/2 = 75) is not taking into consideration the amount of time your player would be stuck at those higher levels (12-19 or so).

Why?

Each level sees a -4 in XP per day. At level 14 for example (season 2-3 in your scheme), that would be -56 per training day, so only 44 XP per training. If you start that season at level 14, it will take over 22 days to level Once. I don't see many people being THAT patient.


Conclusion: You could probably afford to sit one season before it will no longer be worth it to gain those pitiful XP points vs playing.



In season 1, the player wouldn't bump at first. He waits until last day. He goes up on day 10, day 21, day 32, and has 760 points toward level 5. He uses his bumps and goes to level 7. On day 4 of season 2 he is at level 8. On day 18 he is at level 9. On day 34 he is at level 10. On last day of season he has 364 points toward level 11 and boosts to level 13. So if he only goes up an average of 1 level per season the next 3, he would be at level 25 with 9 more boosts. He may only get 24.5 though.


Not many may wait for 5 season, but 2 sure looks appetizing.
Last edited Apr 16, 2008 19:39:45
 
jearly
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by bmedders
To fix the shelving player, you could institute something where players have to play a minimum of xxx plays in a season, or xxx number is deducted. That number can increase with more seasons into the game, as players legitimately on the bench shouldn't be penalized. Something like:

Season 1 - 100 plays
Season 2 - 200 plays
Season 3 - 350 plays
Season 4 - 500 plays
Season 5 - 500 plays

If a player goes over the minimum number of plays, then the actual number is used instead of the minimum. But if they don't reach that number, then the minimum number is charge to their total (For the sake of argument let say it is 10000 plays for the career). If a player sits out five seasons, they will come in with an advantage, yes, but he only has 8350 plays left for his career.

Obviously the numbers I came up with are completely arbitrary, and just to show the framework of how something could be done.


I like this - kind of combination with Drifters' idea. prevents people from sitting forever... (of course the number's given are arbitrary.
 
8mile
offline
Link
 
okay I stopped reading this at thread page 4 so sry if this was suggested..




so people are saying only give EXP for 60 plays instead of 90....what about the people who spent alot of thier attribute points on Staminia so they would play more to get in more plays to not only help thier team but thier players...


this will actully serverly hurt the people that spend alot of points on staminia and help the people who spent little to no points at all on staminia.

Just saying a rule like this will survily effect everyone in a big way...





also the idea of shortening someone's career because thier in so many plays...again that there just kills the people who spent alot of poitns on staminia...cause now they are afraid to be a starter because thier afraid of having to retire quickly...



sure i may be a single guy looking at the situation like that...but I'm saying a rule like this could be really unfair for some people.


(p.s...this isn't a biasts decision like 80% of the poeple on this thread who has said yea they liked the idea cuase thier a GM and like to play everyone and would really help my team out....both my players have very good staminia(20+)...but didn't go crazy with staminia like some other people that have 35+ staminia already..


Just saying a major rule like this would give the people who built thier guys without staminia a huge advantage over the guys with alot of staminia...so now the ting will be Zomg don't spend any points on staminia...you will still get almost the max amount of plays in a game anyone(if your a starter) and yoru career will be much longer.




Also...I am a Olinemen, I have 20 staminia...in both playoffs games I have been in the game over 50 plays...and I'm playing on hard....this is now going to make everyoen play on hard as well since there will be no reason to play on relaxed or normal cause you don't want to be in alot of plays..cause you won't get the EXP for more then 60 plays and longer career.



if anyone disagrees with my point, I'm sorry...I'm only speaking of which I see....and as I doub I'll be back to this thread again cause I have to go...this will be my only post on it.


If someone wants me to go in actully depth on this situation just PM me and I could explain more negatives if you choose...but well I'm out peace
 
8mile
offline
Link
 
oh yea..what bout when your high lvled...with only a 60 play EXP cap...YOUR NEVER GOING TO LEVEL!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
 
TrevJo
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by 8mile
okay I stopped reading this at thread page 4 so sry if this was suggested..




so people are saying only give EXP for 60 plays instead of 90....what about the people who spent alot of thier attribute points on Staminia so they would play more to get in more plays to not only help thier team but thier players...


this will actully serverly hurt the people that spend alot of points on staminia and help the people who spent little to no points at all on staminia.

Just saying a rule like this will survily effect everyone in a big way...


Well, those people got a jump on everyone in the alpha/beta stages (season 1). But there was nothing final or official about the system for season 1. They would have to earn it the hard way like everyone else from season 2 on.
 
jearly
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by 8mile
okay I stopped reading this at thread page 4 so sry if this was suggested..




so people are saying only give EXP for 60 plays instead of 90....what about the people who spent alot of thier attribute points on Staminia so they would play more to get in more plays to not only help thier team but thier players...


this will actully serverly hurt the people that spend alot of points on staminia and help the people who spent little to no points at all on staminia.

Just saying a rule like this will survily effect everyone in a big way...





also the idea of shortening someone's career because thier in so many plays...again that there just kills the people who spent alot of poitns on staminia...cause now they are afraid to be a starter because thier afraid of having to retire quickly...



sure i may be a single guy looking at the situation like that...but I'm saying a rule like this could be really unfair for some people.


(p.s...this isn't a biasts decision like 80% of the poeple on this thread who has said yea they liked the idea cuase thier a GM and like to play everyone and would really help my team out....both my players have very good staminia(20+)...but didn't go crazy with staminia like some other people that have 35+ staminia already..


Just saying a major rule like this would give the people who built thier guys without staminia a huge advantage over the guys with alot of staminia...so now the ting will be Zomg don't spend any points on staminia...you will still get almost the max amount of plays in a game anyone(if your a starter) and yoru career will be much longer.




Also...I am a Olinemen, I have 20 staminia...in both playoffs games I have been in the game over 50 plays...and I'm playing on hard....this is now going to make everyoen play on hard as well since there will be no reason to play on relaxed or normal cause you don't want to be in alot of plays..cause you won't get the EXP for more then 60 plays and longer career.



if anyone disagrees with my point, I'm sorry...I'm only speaking of which I see....and as I doub I'll be back to this thread again cause I have to go...this will be my only post on it.


If someone wants me to go in actully depth on this situation just PM me and I could explain more negatives if you choose...but well I'm out peace



a possibility is to have stamina or a durability attribute decrease the "wear and tear" effect... add more variability.
 
8mile
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by TrevJo
Originally posted by 8mile

okay I stopped reading this at thread page 4 so sry if this was suggested..




so people are saying only give EXP for 60 plays instead of 90....what about the people who spent alot of thier attribute points on Staminia so they would play more to get in more plays to not only help thier team but thier players...


this will actully serverly hurt the people that spend alot of points on staminia and help the people who spent little to no points at all on staminia.

Just saying a rule like this will survily effect everyone in a big way...


Well, those people got a jump on everyone in the alpha/beta stages (season 1). But there was nothing final or official about the system for season 1. They would have to earn it the hard way like everyone else from season 2 on.


seems like your player has been in alot of plays this eyar....guess a rule like this would servivly kill your player huh(joking)


and I guess i realized my play has been in alot of plays due to me joing the league early in the season..so a rule like this would kill my player so I guess I'm a hypocrit in that regards...but you see the poitn I was getting at, at least???or no everyone here is all for this idea and it dosn't even matter what I say and shouldn't prolly waiste my eime(which is okay since I showed up here 1 more time then I played on anyway lol)
 
8mile
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by jearly
Originally posted by 8mile

okay I stopped reading this at thread page 4 so sry if this was suggested..




so people are saying only give EXP for 60 plays instead of 90....what about the people who spent alot of thier attribute points on Staminia so they would play more to get in more plays to not only help thier team but thier players...


this will actully serverly hurt the people that spend alot of points on staminia and help the people who spent little to no points at all on staminia.

Just saying a rule like this will survily effect everyone in a big way...





also the idea of shortening someone's career because thier in so many plays...again that there just kills the people who spent alot of poitns on staminia...cause now they are afraid to be a starter because thier afraid of having to retire quickly...



sure i may be a single guy looking at the situation like that...but I'm saying a rule like this could be really unfair for some people.


(p.s...this isn't a biasts decision like 80% of the poeple on this thread who has said yea they liked the idea cuase thier a GM and like to play everyone and would really help my team out....both my players have very good staminia(20+)...but didn't go crazy with staminia like some other people that have 35+ staminia already..


Just saying a major rule like this would give the people who built thier guys without staminia a huge advantage over the guys with alot of staminia...so now the ting will be Zomg don't spend any points on staminia...you will still get almost the max amount of plays in a game anyone(if your a starter) and yoru career will be much longer.




Also...I am a Olinemen, I have 20 staminia...in both playoffs games I have been in the game over 50 plays...and I'm playing on hard....this is now going to make everyoen play on hard as well since there will be no reason to play on relaxed or normal cause you don't want to be in alot of plays..cause you won't get the EXP for more then 60 plays and longer career.



if anyone disagrees with my point, I'm sorry...I'm only speaking of which I see....and as I doub I'll be back to this thread again cause I have to go...this will be my only post on it.


If someone wants me to go in actully depth on this situation just PM me and I could explain more negatives if you choose...but well I'm out peace



a possibility is to have stamina or a durability attribute decrease the "wear and tear" effect... add more variability.



the word your looking for would be something called "injury"

injury would be the injury resistance rating...not only would it prevent you from getting injuryed as much..your recovery time would be greater
 
lillya10
offline
Link
 
wow, this is a very good idea
 
TrevJo
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by 8mile
Originally posted by TrevJo

Originally posted by 8mile


okay I stopped reading this at thread page 4 so sry if this was suggested..




so people are saying only give EXP for 60 plays instead of 90....what about the people who spent alot of thier attribute points on Staminia so they would play more to get in more plays to not only help thier team but thier players...


this will actully serverly hurt the people that spend alot of points on staminia and help the people who spent little to no points at all on staminia.

Just saying a rule like this will survily effect everyone in a big way...


Well, those people got a jump on everyone in the alpha/beta stages (season 1). But there was nothing final or official about the system for season 1. They would have to earn it the hard way like everyone else from season 2 on.


seems like your player has been in alot of plays this eyar....guess a rule like this would servivly kill your player huh(joking)


and I guess i realized my play has been in alot of plays due to me joing the league early in the season..so a rule like this would kill my player so I guess I'm a hypocrit in that regards...but you see the poitn I was getting at, at least???or no everyone here is all for this idea and it dosn't even matter what I say and shouldn't prolly waiste my eime(which is okay since I showed up here 1 more time then I played on anyway lol)


My point is that I don't think we should worry too much about whether the efforts of season 1 players produce the effects they were intended to. Season 2 is really the first season that isn't experimental, so I think now is the time to make decisions that are best for the game in the long-run.
 
Imboden
offline
Link
 
jearly - I think you've come to one of the most sound solutions I've seen yet. Good job!
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.