Originally posted by pumph
If the center simulates a snap, it's not technically a false start, but a snap infraction. Both the referee's signal, and the penalty enforcement are exactly the same as a false start, but when we announce it on the PA and record it on our foul reports, it's a snap infraction.
The center can have a false start though. But it's extremely rare since he's the one controlling when the play starts. It normally occurs when the center attempts to draw an opponent offside by doing something other than using the ball or his hand that snaps the ball (which again, is rare).
Someone else said that the center's the only on who can move after he's set. That is not true. Every player can move. Every player can shift. Once a player puts his hands on the football, he is the center. Once a player on the offensive line (other than the center) puts his hands at or below the level of his knee (after the center has put his hands on the ball) that player cannot move. You'll see lineman in a 2-point stance point to defenders - that's legal because in a 2-point stance, the lineman's hands do not go to the knee or below. In a 3-point stance, one hand is on the ground, so that lineman cannot move. If they have not put a hand at or below the knee, the linemen can move or shift (legally) as much as they want.
Wow, THANK YOU for your detailed explanations Pumph! I find it extremely interesting to know the inner workings of a referee's mind. And the nuances of the rules is always good to know. And I believe Bort IS trying to make this as close to NFL rules as possible.
I AM however getting annoyed by all the people posting here w/o reading the WHOLE thread! Or atleast the OP for god's sake.
Most of your questions have been answered right there.
YES, broken tackles are up and will stay up.
YES, drops will happen more this season. I think it's high and will be tweaked, but they'll still be up.
Tackling on the Dline is GOING to be better b/c a lot of them have a high tackling number, so you WILL have more TFL's this season.
That double LB on the RB is NOT right and thank you for posting the examples.
ANY thing that needs to be looked at, POST EXAMPLES! Bort doesn't have time to find what you're talking about and asks for examples REPEATEDLY.
The LB running away from the QB IS wrong. Example, thanks.
pumph, throw your example of the 48 seconds left play up there.
In QB Favorite Targets, do you mean the QB's Advanced Tactics? Or on Team Tactics page. Because my QB can select WR's now. So either it's the Team's page, or it's fixed.
A CB is allowed to be in the path of a WR and the WR would have to go around him, maybe that's what the sim is thinking. But Bort did change how blocking, players bumping each other, and all that reacted to the sims. So it may get tweaked.
Vampires50 - Throw in your link so Bort can see it. That sounds fishy.
The WR1, WR2 - 5, too many plays, is a known issue (check the Original Post - OP). It may always be that way now. Some people are trying this. And if you did, PLEASE let us know if it worked....
WR1 - WR1, WR2, WR3, WR4, WR5
WR2 - WR2, WR3, WR4, WR5
WR3 - WR3, WR4, WR5
WR4 - WR4, WR5
WR5 - WR5
Same with CB's. And if you DID try that, like I said, please share your input.
PackMan, those look like they're button hooks or routes of a similar nature which would always favor the WR because they know when they're stopping and the CB has to react. So the CB will ALWAYS be a step behind on those routes.
Unspoken, did you have a LB shift to the strong side ON? Because that's where they should be if you had the shift on.
TB - Good Luck! Hope you win some $$$ (FP)!
