User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Forum > Discuss GLB Issues With Catch22 > NOT A BUG - CLOSED > Preseason Games: Kinks / Bugs? Acknowledged
Page:
 
iamhylas
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by DigitalDaggers
Originally posted by Modok

Thanks for doing this Twilight.


+1

Sometimes people forget that we aren't some giant faceless corporation with thousands of slaving employees.

There are often kinks when changes are made. This is a CONSTRUCTIVE thread and I thank the OP for posting it.


I hope you aren't bitching about bug threads in the bug forum, DD.
 
Satchmo-n-Dizzy
Moderator
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Twilightbeckoned
After reviewing the game tonight, I felt my team performed closer than it would have otherwise been expected to. However, there were a few plays where I had some questions or thoughts about:

The #2 CB (my best cb overall as I swap them), Is lined up on the #2 WR who makes this catch. He then pulls off as you can see and looks like he wants to cover the WR5, then he either falls down or gets lost, and becomes a moot point on a big play. If he had covered his man this might not have happened.
(http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=79829&pbp_id=161535 )

He had a tough night in the replays, but I can't see how it's his vision, since that is one of his better stats. It could juke be a fluke. The refinement of the tactics is going well, and if you take some time to evaluate your coniditions, they do for the most part exactly what you tell them to.


IMO, this is a problem with the Cover 2 shell. In theory, the defense was run correctly since the CB released his cover responsibility to the deep safety in order to take an uncovered WR closer to the QB.

Obviously, in practice, it was a bad decision. However, there are a lot of things which may have contributed. The LB that should have covered the WR might be a liability in coverage; the sim may simply regard any WR/LB a mismatch that would 'encourage' the CB to step in; or possibly it was just a miscommunication between teammates. Since Bort has stated that a player may use his Vision to change a call based on his own pre-snap read, one must also assume it is possible for the same player to get it wrong on occasion.
 
Satchmo-n-Dizzy
Moderator
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by DawgHunter
any thoughts on this play the LB ran to the QB waited then turned and started being blocked as he ran from the QB
http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=81859&pbp_id=184585

at least thats what it looks like to me


I call holding on the play. The little dot had the play made and was horse-collared by the OL. I can't believe the official missed that one.
 
Link
 
Originally posted by williamcohms
In QB Favorite Targets I can only select from the TE's, HB's, and FB's.



GAH, one i forgot to mention, that i brought up myself two days ago. Good call.



** I'm off to the horse track today guys. Trying to win me some FP! er... Money. I'll be back tonight but this might be the last update for a few hours/

11:45 EST
 
Darwood
offline
Link
 
28+ Drops in this game.

http://goallineblitz.com/game/game.pl?game_id=81635
 
FK_Temp
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by voltageaav
Originally posted by XUMuskie85

I posted this in offensive AI also but maybe I'll consolidate it here:

I have a question about "special cirumstances." Did this provide problems for anyone?
I set my kicker's FG range at 50 yds and he still tried a 52 and 54 yarder, even though I had for FGs to happen only when "within FG range."

Also, in the 3rd quarter, we punted twice from the opponents 28.5 yard line. In my general settings, my 3rd input down (and 1st 4th down one) is a 4th and 3-15 yds between the opponent 30-3 yd line to kick a FG 100% of the time. But I also had the special circumstance set to "within FG range," which should have been 50 yds. yet we still punted.
I had no quarter specific settings for 4th down in the 3rd quarter either.

Anyone else have these problems/can provide any insight?

I assume the AI was on today because another team in our league said they went for it on every 4th down.


I have a feeling that the within 50 yeards is the yard line, but a field goal from the 50 yard line is closer to a 60 yard field goal because the uprights are near the back of the endzone.



A FG on the 50y line is a 67y FG. 50y for the ball spot + 10y for the EZ + 7y for the ball spot after long snap
 
neverdodge
offline
Link
 
It would also be nice if we get some hints about what are considered bug and what is considered working as intended.

For example it seem a lot of people are talking about the way RB did run (power back breaking a lot of tackle while elusive keep dancing and not moving forward)
It would be nice to know if that come from a bad build (edit : either from the OL or the RB) or from a sim issue
Last edited Jul 30, 2008 10:06:20
 
Juan Fiddy
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by lawdog
Ok, that's weird. Every play that Araceli and Cajun are in when it's a 2 WR set, Cajun is WR2 and Araceli is WR1. Whenver Araceli and either Hopscotch or Konartis are in a 2 WR set, Araceli is WR2.


I noticed that, off the top I assume it's an energy thing, but I can't be sure. I'm really beginning to think something is screwy with energy, but it is exceptionally tough to gauge due to everyone getting thrown back up to 100% after the game. I think a suggestion is in order to restore energy 24 hours after a scrim, as energy tactics are just as important to the experimental factor of these games.

I need to look into if or if Kon, or Hopscotch were ever thrown into WR#2. If not, then leaving the feild blank may actually be forcing the start.



 
Cruzi
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by
** Centers can get false start penalties for now. It's an atypical occurence (one I believe doesn't happen in pro football because it's not against the rules for a center to shift)


I dunno if it's been posted yet, but centers can false start as well. If they move the ball pre-snap, they get flagged. I've even seen centers get flagged for snapping the ball a count early. They jump and the rest of the line stays still. The center goofed.

But, yeah. It happens in pro football.
 
Link
 
Originally posted by Cruzi
Originally posted by

** Centers can get false start penalties for now. It's an atypical occurence (one I believe doesn't happen in pro football because it's not against the rules for a center to shift)


I dunno if it's been posted yet, but centers can false start as well. If they move the ball pre-snap, they get flagged. I've even seen centers get flagged for snapping the ball a count early. They jump and the rest of the line stays still. The center goofed.

But, yeah. It happens in pro football.


Anyone can false start. All it takes is rocking back in your stance or simulating the act of a snap. Most of the time it is called an illegal procedure on the center though.

Leave Centers out of this though Cruzi!

 
rutko
offline
Link
 
be thankful that there was the foresight to give us two preseason games to recognize these issues.


That is the answer to my question: why aren't stats posting... preseason.

Figures, my players had their greatest games ever.

 
Unspoken
offline
Link
 
Can the proper LBers be put in there proper spots when you play Strong Side 4-3 set please. Each play they are all over the place. (MLB playing LOLBer, ROLB playing MLBer and so on) Thanks.
 
Link
 
edit.
Last edited Jul 30, 2008 11:42:57
 
Snaza
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by pumph



If the center simulates a snap, it's not technically a false start, but a snap infraction. Both the referee's signal, and the penalty enforcement are exactly the same as a false start, but when we announce it on the PA and record it on our foul reports, it's a snap infraction.

The center can have a false start though. But it's extremely rare since he's the one controlling when the play starts. It normally occurs when the center attempts to draw an opponent offside by doing something other than using the ball or his hand that snaps the ball (which again, is rare).

Someone else said that the center's the only on who can move after he's set. That is not true. Every player can move. Every player can shift. Once a player puts his hands on the football, he is the center. Once a player on the offensive line (other than the center) puts his hands at or below the level of his knee (after the center has put his hands on the ball) that player cannot move. You'll see lineman in a 2-point stance point to defenders - that's legal because in a 2-point stance, the lineman's hands do not go to the knee or below. In a 3-point stance, one hand is on the ground, so that lineman cannot move. If they have not put a hand at or below the knee, the linemen can move or shift (legally) as much as they want.


Wow, THANK YOU for your detailed explanations Pumph! I find it extremely interesting to know the inner workings of a referee's mind. And the nuances of the rules is always good to know. And I believe Bort IS trying to make this as close to NFL rules as possible.

I AM however getting annoyed by all the people posting here w/o reading the WHOLE thread! Or atleast the OP for god's sake.
Most of your questions have been answered right there.
YES, broken tackles are up and will stay up.
YES, drops will happen more this season. I think it's high and will be tweaked, but they'll still be up.
Tackling on the Dline is GOING to be better b/c a lot of them have a high tackling number, so you WILL have more TFL's this season.
That double LB on the RB is NOT right and thank you for posting the examples.

ANY thing that needs to be looked at, POST EXAMPLES! Bort doesn't have time to find what you're talking about and asks for examples REPEATEDLY.

The LB running away from the QB IS wrong. Example, thanks.
pumph, throw your example of the 48 seconds left play up there.
In QB Favorite Targets, do you mean the QB's Advanced Tactics? Or on Team Tactics page. Because my QB can select WR's now. So either it's the Team's page, or it's fixed.
A CB is allowed to be in the path of a WR and the WR would have to go around him, maybe that's what the sim is thinking. But Bort did change how blocking, players bumping each other, and all that reacted to the sims. So it may get tweaked.
Vampires50 - Throw in your link so Bort can see it. That sounds fishy.
The WR1, WR2 - 5, too many plays, is a known issue (check the Original Post - OP). It may always be that way now. Some people are trying this. And if you did, PLEASE let us know if it worked....
WR1 - WR1, WR2, WR3, WR4, WR5
WR2 - WR2, WR3, WR4, WR5
WR3 - WR3, WR4, WR5
WR4 - WR4, WR5
WR5 - WR5
Same with CB's. And if you DID try that, like I said, please share your input.
PackMan, those look like they're button hooks or routes of a similar nature which would always favor the WR because they know when they're stopping and the CB has to react. So the CB will ALWAYS be a step behind on those routes.
Unspoken, did you have a LB shift to the strong side ON? Because that's where they should be if you had the shift on.
TB - Good Luck! Hope you win some $$$ (FP)!
 
XUMuskie85
offline
Link
 
The WR1, WR2 - 5, too many plays, is a known issue (check the Original Post - OP). It may always be that way now. Some people are trying this. And if you did, PLEASE let us know if it worked....
WR1 - WR1, WR2, WR3, WR4, WR5
WR2 - WR2, WR3, WR4, WR5
WR3 - WR3, WR4, WR5
WR4 - WR4, WR5
WR5 - WR5
Same with CB's. And if you DID try that, like I said, please share your input.



I did that for my WRs and CBs depth chart.

Here were my play counts (although we were favoring backups the entire 2nd half):
WR1 (low 40s stamina): 44
WR2 (low 30s stamina): 51
WR3: 39
WR4: 57
WR5: 39

I don't really get how my WR#1 was out so much in the 1st half, but otherwise everyone seemed to sub well in the 1st half. I don't have exact numbers because I didn't go through each play, maybe I'll do that now...
Last edited Jul 30, 2008 12:03:03
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.