User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Forum > Suggestions > What sense is it that the best teams only have 1 person on the depth chart.
Page:
 
Bulldog2811
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by krwynn
Originally posted by Bulldog2811

Having depth in any "real" game is extremely important... From what I've read, it doesn't matter in this game and owners are playing within the rules as stated. Kudos to them. However, for the rest of us that want that REAL GAME experience, IMO it needs to be the first thing addressed.

The NFL has 53 man rosters to allow them to deal with injuries, tired players, and situational plays. The same should be done here... The Energy stat needs to matter more than it apparently does now.

It sounds like a fairly simple change to implement... If your starter gets tired, he'll be subbed out. Problem solved.

Stamina should be tied directly to the Energy Bar... Hell it should be known as the Stamina/Energy Bar instead of an single adjustable Attribute as it is now. Maybe that's the answer to this problem... Remove Stamina from the Attributes.





53 players on teams with 80k seat stadiums, tv money, etc. etc. Can't expect us to have a roster of that size with 8000 seats and minimal cash. Just won't work. I don't understand the "real" expectation. This isn't "real" and never will be. There are 1000's of variables in the "real" game. In a sim thats just not possibile to replicate.



The "real" expectation may be a bit too extreme... I understand that. However, the BASICS should at least be in place to make it at least similiar to the actual game of football. The core element of Stamina/Energy is one reason why subs should not only be required but neccessary. That's the "real" aspect that I should've referred to more clearly.

53 man rosters are in place to allow actual coaches deal with injuries, tired players, etc... My point was that injuries/energy needs to be addressed to allow the most BASIC concept in the real game which is roster management. Every sim has it's limitations, however, roster management should be in place from the very beginning. Something needs to be in place to enforce actual player limitations such as Energy/Stamina... Otherwise you might as well call 'em robots and not players. Real Players get tired >> Hell, even robots might need their batteries charged. If that element isn't present in this sim, to the extent that it forces owners to sub players, then why not just change the theme to Robo-ball. It'd make more sense and be more acceptable to those involved.

 
stevegamer
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by drifter
Originally posted by MLA

Originally posted by tpaterniti


Rather than force people to get depth just for its own sake, we make the game inherently reward depth in the same way that real football does. Then owners will get depth without us having to force them to do it because it will actually be in their best interest.

Damn straight. Situational players and actions matter. The game actually mitigates against that at present by having the playing out of position penalty so you're not going to get Mike Vrabel catching TDs in GLB.

Injuries should be a great step forward and the design proposed to have a time-related diminution of some attributes will help if the injuries are significantly severe. I'd personally like to see players get knocked out of the game and so have their backups come in and have the injury cause a small attribute negative for a few games afterwards.



The recent revelation that being tired doesn't effect play much and the energy bar will never go below 70 really sucks. Both of these factors, if implemented properly would force depth. If a tired player, played significantly worse or if an owner had to decide to rest guys to get their energy bars back up, depth would instantly be a factor.



The energy bar does go below 70: if they guy plays on hard, trains on intense, and doesn't listen.
 
Pumchavas28
offline
Link
 
I have 49 players & currently it works just fine for me... Just saying....

And I'll be adding 2 more once the season ends...
Last edited Apr 18, 2008 13:09:33
 
hydro2584
offline
Link
 
how about being able to buy a trainer.the better your trainer is the faster your players will heal during games our after games.our lik a training staff.or you can make trainer like a position and the trainer can level up
 
Schaff
offline
Link
 
Maybe its a just a matter of adjusting the severity of the penalty after a certain number of plays(based on Stamina), so no matter how good a player is at the start they are useless if utilized accessively.
 
bigtisme
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Schaff
Maybe its a just a matter of adjusting the severity of the penalty after a certain number of plays(based on Stamina), so no matter how good a player is at the start they are useless if utilized accessively.


But if we try to go realistic....in reality there ARE alot of players that can play an entire game in the NFL.
 
stevegamer
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by bigtisme
Originally posted by Schaff

Maybe its a just a matter of adjusting the severity of the penalty after a certain number of plays(based on Stamina), so no matter how good a player is at the start they are useless if utilized accessively.


But if we try to go realistic....in reality there ARE alot of players that can play an entire game in the NFL.


Yes, but they aren't as effective. The problem is that there really doesn't seem to be much of a drop in effectiveness.
 
Bulldog2811
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by bigtisme
Originally posted by Schaff

Maybe its a just a matter of adjusting the severity of the penalty after a certain number of plays(based on Stamina), so no matter how good a player is at the start they are useless if utilized accessively.


But if we try to go realistic....in reality there ARE alot of players that can play an entire game in the NFL.


In reality there are a lot of players that get injured too. A lot of players need a chance to rest or "take a breather" in between plays as well. Specialty Players get subbed in based on down-and-distance...

If there isn't a happy medium found in THIS game you might as well cap rosters at 25 players and create a TON of leagues. At this point, there's no incentive for owners to play back-ups and there will be a lot of unhappy free agents.
 
Tiger2112
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by bigtisme
Originally posted by Schaff

Maybe its a just a matter of adjusting the severity of the penalty after a certain number of plays(based on Stamina), so no matter how good a player is at the start they are useless if utilized accessively.


But if we try to go realistic....in reality there ARE alot of players that can play an entire game in the NFL.


And if those players were converted to GLB attributes, what would their Staminas be?
 
Coach Greedy
offline
Link
 
I for one am going to slow down on this game now until this key issue of Depth/Injuries/realism is properly addressed. I do understand just how hard the developers are working, and feel they have created a good game that has captured a lot of imagination. I have played this nearly non stop in my free time for the last three weeks, I have a team and 8 players and to keep leveling my players will cost about $50 over the next month or so, compare this to the cost of other MMORPG`s I have played and this is by far the most expensive. So we have a right to ask for these unfair and unreal issues to be addressed.
Its all very nice having new trophys for the home pages but this is the priority, and this will lose the site money!
 
1VBChaos
offline
Link
 
"I do not mind people finding ways to game the system, that is part of competing".

Therein lies the major problem. And seeing as this view seems to be shared by some forum moderators, it only makes the problem worse.

Sure - we all want to win - but winning by 'playing the system' is like completeing the latest game by getting the cheats off the internet. OK, so you've completed the game and you can tell your friends you've completed it. But you've not actually ACHIEVED anything and the only person you're kidding is yourself.

And when the honest players who are trying to play within the spirit of the game realise that the 'gamers' always win, because they know how to play the system, then all that will be left is the minority of (what are nothing more than) cheats.

And another online game will have been ruined..........

 
Butternuts
offline
Link
 
I think for injuries a player should miss a game or 2 max; 2 if it's very serious so agents dont have their players miss out on xp for too long a time. But as well as missing a game they should have their energy put down very low and maybe a percentage stat decrease - something like 10% stat decrease, every day goes back up by 1%. But % decrease would change according to seriousness.

I think this would be better than a player being out for a season which would annoy the hell out of agents.
Possibly a small XP penalty for the game after injury or something..
Last edited Jun 18, 2008 09:49:17
 
MrMoose
offline
Link
 
My theory on injuries:

They shouldn't ever knock a player out of the game.

1) You're taking way too much control out of the hands of the players and reducing the fun they get to have with the game even more. With all the constant complaining of there not being enough to do for players, knocking them out of a game or two because the dice roll didn't go their way is kinda harsh. Then they'd have less to do and be more likely to quit GLB.

2) Keeping depth would screw team over. Players don't want to be the backup to the backup on a team, because experience is so hard to come by if you don't get playing time. Why should I, as an owner, be forced to play a level 1 or 2 (since they're all that would take a backup spot), when said 1 or 2 will get run over by a level 20? Worse yet, why should I have to play that level 1 or 2 as a starter for a few games while my star got screwed by an injury, and essentially lose 3 games because of it?

In the NFL, injuries happen and people are happy being backups because they get big paychecks. Not nearly as big as a starter, but even $1,000,000 a year would make me more than happy to be a backup. In GLB, the only real rewards to a player are stats and XP. As a backup, they don't get those. There's no real motivation for a player to ride the bench incase someone gets injured, and no real motivation for a team to carry a level 1 or 2 backup that will get mauled by higher level players.
 
McToastee
offline
Link
 
players shouldnt be out for the entire season.. that will get more inactives because there is nothing else for players to do right now but train and play. As far as depth, I keep madden type depth of 3, then at certain positions 4 or 5 (CB) it doesnt hurt my team that much. (Although I use my players to take the backseat so other players can play)

As far as the qb controversity and how can that level 22 play all the snaps...omg.

If you are so amazed about that, try turning on the NFL sometimes.. there are tons of qb who take all the snaps in every game the whole season. Thats not strange
 
SmithersOT
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by 1VBChaos
"I do not mind people finding ways to game the system, that is part of competing".

Therein lies the major problem. And seeing as this view seems to be shared by some forum moderators, it only makes the problem worse.

Sure - we all want to win - but winning by 'playing the system' is like completeing the latest game by getting the cheats off the internet. OK, so you've completed the game and you can tell your friends you've completed it. But you've not actually ACHIEVED anything and the only person you're kidding is yourself.

And when the honest players who are trying to play within the spirit of the game realise that the 'gamers' always win, because they know how to play the system, then all that will be left is the minority of (what are nothing more than) cheats.

And another online game will have been ruined..........



Very nicely said.

What I find humorous are the people who say that they want a change to the system...just not one that will force teams to change. This is really very simple: either depth should become a meaningful and necessary part of team building or it should not. This is NOT a baseball sim, it's football, and in football teams need significant depth for a lot of reasons -- even if that depth isn't utilized every game.

Some changes need to happen for this to work. First, experience for backups needs to be significantly improved -- in the NFL the "backup" is often training to replace the starter. Here, with every game that's played, the backup will fall further and further behind the starter. If he signed with a singal team and stayed backup throughout the starter's entire career, by season ten he might be thirty levels behind. That's silly. The entire experience system LOOKS elegant and logical until you consider it further -- it's broken and will not work with anything but a new league.

Second, energy needs to fall off FAST, with every play, and the lower the energy the greater the hit on stats, the higher the likelyhood of injury, and the greater the potential injury severity. As an example imagine an energy and SKILL falloff of .5% per play, and a recovery of .5% per play on the bench. A player starting a game with 50 speed who plays 25 plays in a row would run the next play at speed 43.75. After 50 plays (with no break) his speed would be 37.5. This would apply equally to all skills. Stamina could be factored in as a modifier to the falloff, or more easily as a buffer (with, say, that character's stamina score equalling the number of plays in game the character can participate in at half cost). A system like this would allow owners to play starters all game if they choose, but this would be a bad idea unless they either significantly outleveled their opponent or their opponent did the same.

Injurues need to be implemented. They should range from a few plays to multiple games, with the later only impacting players who willingly take this risk. multi-game injuries should only occur when players are exhausted, making this a risk players and owners opt for. With this they would need to add a minimum energy level to the player's tactics so that they can opt to take themselves out and avoid this risk.


Last edited Jun 18, 2008 14:25:34
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.