Originally posted by krwynn
Originally posted by Bulldog2811
Having depth in any "real" game is extremely important... From what I've read, it doesn't matter in this game and owners are playing within the rules as stated. Kudos to them. However, for the rest of us that want that REAL GAME experience, IMO it needs to be the first thing addressed.
The NFL has 53 man rosters to allow them to deal with injuries, tired players, and situational plays. The same should be done here... The Energy stat needs to matter more than it apparently does now.
It sounds like a fairly simple change to implement... If your starter gets tired, he'll be subbed out. Problem solved.
Stamina should be tied directly to the Energy Bar... Hell it should be known as the Stamina/Energy Bar instead of an single adjustable Attribute as it is now. Maybe that's the answer to this problem... Remove Stamina from the Attributes.
53 players on teams with 80k seat stadiums, tv money, etc. etc. Can't expect us to have a roster of that size with 8000 seats and minimal cash. Just won't work. I don't understand the "real" expectation. This isn't "real" and never will be. There are 1000's of variables in the "real" game. In a sim thats just not possibile to replicate.
The "real" expectation may be a bit too extreme... I understand that. However, the BASICS should at least be in place to make it at least similiar to the actual game of football. The core element of Stamina/Energy is one reason why subs should not only be required but neccessary. That's the "real" aspect that I should've referred to more clearly.
53 man rosters are in place to allow actual coaches deal with injuries, tired players, etc... My point was that injuries/energy needs to be addressed to allow the most BASIC concept in the real game which is roster management. Every sim has it's limitations, however, roster management should be in place from the very beginning. Something needs to be in place to enforce actual player limitations such as Energy/Stamina... Otherwise you might as well call 'em robots and not players. Real Players get tired >> Hell, even robots might need their batteries charged. If that element isn't present in this sim, to the extent that it forces owners to sub players, then why not just change the theme to Robo-ball. It'd make more sense and be more acceptable to those involved.
Originally posted by Bulldog2811
Having depth in any "real" game is extremely important... From what I've read, it doesn't matter in this game and owners are playing within the rules as stated. Kudos to them. However, for the rest of us that want that REAL GAME experience, IMO it needs to be the first thing addressed.
The NFL has 53 man rosters to allow them to deal with injuries, tired players, and situational plays. The same should be done here... The Energy stat needs to matter more than it apparently does now.
It sounds like a fairly simple change to implement... If your starter gets tired, he'll be subbed out. Problem solved.
Stamina should be tied directly to the Energy Bar... Hell it should be known as the Stamina/Energy Bar instead of an single adjustable Attribute as it is now. Maybe that's the answer to this problem... Remove Stamina from the Attributes.
53 players on teams with 80k seat stadiums, tv money, etc. etc. Can't expect us to have a roster of that size with 8000 seats and minimal cash. Just won't work. I don't understand the "real" expectation. This isn't "real" and never will be. There are 1000's of variables in the "real" game. In a sim thats just not possibile to replicate.
The "real" expectation may be a bit too extreme... I understand that. However, the BASICS should at least be in place to make it at least similiar to the actual game of football. The core element of Stamina/Energy is one reason why subs should not only be required but neccessary. That's the "real" aspect that I should've referred to more clearly.
53 man rosters are in place to allow actual coaches deal with injuries, tired players, etc... My point was that injuries/energy needs to be addressed to allow the most BASIC concept in the real game which is roster management. Every sim has it's limitations, however, roster management should be in place from the very beginning. Something needs to be in place to enforce actual player limitations such as Energy/Stamina... Otherwise you might as well call 'em robots and not players. Real Players get tired >> Hell, even robots might need their batteries charged. If that element isn't present in this sim, to the extent that it forces owners to sub players, then why not just change the theme to Robo-ball. It'd make more sense and be more acceptable to those involved.






























