User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Forum > Suggestions > Provide a Refund to the Nashville Team in USA AA#1
Page:
 
Ken1
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Zurai
Originally posted by Ken1

Actually, this is an extreme example of the brokenness of O/D balance.

People break the NFL record for interceptions thrown, but never get near it for yards thrown for.


The NFL record for most yards passing in a single game is 554. The GLB record for most yards passing in a single game is 703.5: http://goallineblitz.com/game/game.pl?game_id=33666

The NFL record for most yards passing in a season is 5,084. The GLB record for most yards passing in a season is 5,756.5: http://goallineblitz.com/game/player.pl?player_id=26731&playoffs=0

Pull "facts" out of your ass much?


I said fairly evenly matched teams. You're talking about games in which the losing teams (likely gutted) were losing every game by 60+ points.

Let's just say that the GLB Season 3 sim has been awful. I plan to stay for Season 4 in the hopes that it improves. But I just want to see people stop defending the Season 3 game sim.
 
Yukon Don
offline
Link
 
Bort,

I liked Cybershots idea of limiting the decline of in-game morale during a bad performance like this. Could something be done to the effect of calculating his confidence which was 29...and saying

100 (base morale) - 29 (confidence) divided by 3= limit of decline in-game

So in his case he was at 99, - his confidence = 70/3= 23.333 so he couldn't drop in game below 76.7.

You may already have something like this, but this seems like it would reward confidence and prevent complete collapses like above.

p.s. tough game Larry, better luck next season.
Last edited Jul 14, 2008 16:46:06
 
Link
 
Originally posted by Ken1
Originally posted by Forbin

Originally posted by Bort


Ok, I looked over their players and tactics. They have some "aura" and "trash talk" guys on their team. They also gameplanned against the pass. Their secondary is very good. Their D-Line is also good. Jake pariah led the league in sacks and come in second for hurries. They have some o-line guys with 7+ in pancake skill and very good strength.

I've said it before and I'll say it again: low confidence can cause problems for every single player on the field when things are going wrong. Playing with low morale is like playing with low energy. If both are low, you're really in trouble!

Yes, 10 INT's is a lot, but it's not impossible. Some of them could have been PD's or incompletions, but the random number generator didn't go your way.

One selected game out of over 1000 per day does not mean everything is broken; everybody runs on the same code, same server. It just means you got unlucky. Somebody else probably got very lucky the other way in your stead. Also, comparing outcomes to games earlier in the season doesn't always work to figure out how it will go in the second matchup. Teams improve, boost, bring in new players, etc.

And no, we do not offer refunds just because a game didn't go your way.


If you take it in this context, with emphasis on the bolded portion above, it does start to make a bit more sense. In the NFL, a single season is half as many games as GLB simulates EACH DAY.

It stands to reason that a few egregious games will stand out here and there. It also stands to reason that a few amazing games will stand out (Possibly the same game, two teams lol)

In the course of season3, we simmed what? 30k regular season games? That's 60 years worth of NFL games. You're bound to see statistical anomalies more often when you're simming that many games.

However, I will say, 10 INTs for a playoff caliber team versus a team they had always played pretty evenly is rather strange, but if it doesn't happen very often, it's just one of those things. The sheer bulk of sims being done daily, as Bort said, makes these statistical anomalies occur more often.


The thing that's funny is that, yes, you'd expect that even in some relatively evenly matched games you might see an NFL record broken.

But I bet in no game where there wasn't a huge mismatch (and there wasn't a huge mismatch here) has an offensive record been broken in Season 3. I'd love to see a game, between fairly evenly matched teams, with more yards passing or yards rushing than the NFL record.



Here is how it can happen:

1.) Ravens won the division the year in our division the year before
2.) Ravens won the other match-up vs my Steelers 27-21


How would the other match-up of the 2007 season play out?
http://sports.espn.go.com/nfl/recap?gameId=271105023


38-7 Steelers and that could have been *much* worse! (35-0 at halftime!!)


Steelers set many records including 5 TD passes in the first half.


Previously unknown LB James Harrison goes for 2 FF's, 1 Fumble recovery, 3.5 sacks, AND and INT.

I guess the NFL should have re-done the game and gave all their fans their money back because the result was too unrealistic.


The Ravens blew us out twice the year before by 27-0 and 31-7 scores and brought 95% of the same exact team to face 95% of the same exact team we had the year before.


45-0 in this sim is NOTHING. If they were really blown out, I've seen many games in the 150-0 or 200-0 range.



Let's be clear. The better team won. Who cares what the score was. Try harder for next year....
Last edited Jul 14, 2008 16:48:03
 
sofa
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Zurai
Originally posted by Ken1

Actually, this is an extreme example of the brokenness of O/D balance.

People break the NFL record for interceptions thrown, but never get near it for yards thrown for.


The NFL record for most yards passing in a single game is 554. The GLB record for most yards passing in a single game is 703.5: http://goallineblitz.com/game/game.pl?game_id=33666

The NFL record for most yards passing in a season is 5,084. The GLB record for most yards passing in a season is 5,756.5: http://goallineblitz.com/game/player.pl?player_id=26731&playoffs=0

Pull "facts" out of your ass much?


http://goallineblitz.com/game/player.pl?player_id=40016&playoffs=0

6,882.5 passing yards 65 tds
 
Gator93
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by El_Windex
Originally posted by Larry Roadgrader

But don't piss on my leg and tell me its raining.



I burst out laughing.


Same haha that was hilarious
 
Ken1
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Zurai
Originally posted by Ken1

But I bet in no game where there wasn't a huge mismatch (and there wasn't a huge mismatch here) has an offensive record been broken in Season 3. I'd love to see a game, between fairly evenly matched teams, with more yards passing or yards rushing than the NFL record.


I hate to break it to you, but NFL offensive records are only broken in the NFL by huge mismatches, too.


The NFL doesn't have mismatches to nearly the extent GLB does. The losing team in one of the record breaking games:

06/13/2008 at Lowcountry Gators W 36-0
06/15/2008 Chicago Enforcers L 0-47
06/17/2008 at New Jersey Generals L 0-60
06/19/2008 ***Official*** Footballguys L 0-107
06/21/2008 at Richmond Razorbacks L 0-61
06/23/2008 Extreme Pipe Layers L 0-61
06/25/2008 at Chilton Roughnecks L 0-40
06/27/2008 Boston Nighthawks L 0-106
06/29/2008 at Cincinnati Who Dey L 0-115
07/01/2008 at Dallas Vaqueros L 0-117
07/03/2008 Buffalo Bearcats L 0-71
07/05/2008 at Washington Gladiators L 0-78
07/07/2008 Pocatello Punishers L 0-118
07/09/2008 at Green Bay Maulers L 0-132
07/11/2008 Brooklyn Legacy L 0-94
07/13/2008 Texas Twisters L 3-87

There aren't teams like that in the NFL.
 
Zurai
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Larry Roadgrader
In a 116-ZERO game. That's some quality sim-work there.



116-0 isn't THAT far off 66-0, the NFL record, and I'm willing to bet is actually very close to the NCAA record.
 
Ken1
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by SoFa
Originally posted by Zurai

Originally posted by Ken1


Actually, this is an extreme example of the brokenness of O/D balance.

People break the NFL record for interceptions thrown, but never get near it for yards thrown for.


The NFL record for most yards passing in a single game is 554. The GLB record for most yards passing in a single game is 703.5: http://goallineblitz.com/game/game.pl?game_id=33666

The NFL record for most yards passing in a season is 5,084. The GLB record for most yards passing in a season is 5,756.5: http://goallineblitz.com/game/player.pl?player_id=26731&playoffs=0

Pull "facts" out of your ass much?


http://goallineblitz.com/game/player.pl?player_id=40016&playoffs=0

6,882.5 passing yards 65 tds


5.8 yards per pass attempt, which would be one of the lowest ypa's in the NFL, which averages 6.9. Yet he's one of the most successful GLB QB's.

Again, I believe this will all get better for Season 4, and I'm not even going off about whether waiting for Season 4 was the right decision or not.

I just want to make it clear that the Season 3 sim is broken-- again, hopefully to be repaired for Season 4.
Last edited Jul 14, 2008 16:51:18
 
Bigdawg_56
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Zurai
Originally posted by Larry Roadgrader

In a 116-ZERO game. That's some quality sim-work there.



116-0 isn't THAT far off 66-0, the NFL record, and I'm willing to bet is actually very close to the NCAA record.


222-0 Georgia Tech vs Cumberland College.
 
Link
 
Originally posted by Ken1
Originally posted by SoFa

Originally posted by Zurai


Originally posted by Ken1



Actually, this is an extreme example of the brokenness of O/D balance.

People break the NFL record for interceptions thrown, but never get near it for yards thrown for.


The NFL record for most yards passing in a single game is 554. The GLB record for most yards passing in a single game is 703.5: http://goallineblitz.com/game/game.pl?game_id=33666

The NFL record for most yards passing in a season is 5,084. The GLB record for most yards passing in a season is 5,756.5: http://goallineblitz.com/game/player.pl?player_id=26731&playoffs=0

Pull "facts" out of your ass much?


http://goallineblitz.com/game/player.pl?player_id=40016&playoffs=0

6,882.5 passing yards 65 tds


5.8 yards per pass attempt, which would be one of the lowest ypa's in the NFL, which averages 6.9. Yet he's one of the most successful GLB QB's.




And 4 yards per attempt and 4.4 yards per attempt in the only close games on his schedule--the 5.8 season average is grossly inflated by the absurd walkover games.
 
Gator93
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Larry Roadgrader
Originally posted by sully

You're right. No football game has ever had close to double digit interceptions in a game. We'll just ignore the fact that quarterbacks in the NFL and NCAA have thrown 6, 7, 8, even 9 interceptions in a game before.

Wait a minute... Didn't your QB throw 9 interceptions? So your game didn't sim like a damn football game should sim, even though there have been games where QBs did as bad as yours did?

It appears we have a contradiction. Just because it "almost never" happens... Almost Never isn't never. Wash the sand out of your vagina, then we'll talk.


Hey asshole: what part of PLAYOFF game don't you get? What part of "Only 15 picks on the season" don't you get? Please tell me the last QB you have record of throwing 9 picks in a PLAYOFF game?



Farve threw 6 in 2001 against St. Louis.
 
Link
 
Originally posted by Ken1
Originally posted by Zurai

Originally posted by Ken1


But I bet in no game where there wasn't a huge mismatch (and there wasn't a huge mismatch here) has an offensive record been broken in Season 3. I'd love to see a game, between fairly evenly matched teams, with more yards passing or yards rushing than the NFL record.


I hate to break it to you, but NFL offensive records are only broken in the NFL by huge mismatches, too.


The NFL doesn't have mismatches to nearly the extent GLB does. The losing team in one of the record breaking games:

06/13/2008 at Lowcountry Gators W 36-0
06/15/2008 Chicago Enforcers L 0-47
06/17/2008 at New Jersey Generals L 0-60
06/19/2008 ***Official*** Footballguys L 0-107
06/21/2008 at Richmond Razorbacks L 0-61
06/23/2008 Extreme Pipe Layers L 0-61
06/25/2008 at Chilton Roughnecks L 0-40
06/27/2008 Boston Nighthawks L 0-106
06/29/2008 at Cincinnati Who Dey L 0-115
07/01/2008 at Dallas Vaqueros L 0-117
07/03/2008 Buffalo Bearcats L 0-71
07/05/2008 at Washington Gladiators L 0-78
07/07/2008 Pocatello Punishers L 0-118
07/09/2008 at Green Bay Maulers L 0-132
07/11/2008 Brooklyn Legacy L 0-94
07/13/2008 Texas Twisters L 3-87

There aren't teams like that in the NFL.



Exactly. There are no gutted teams in the NFL with inactive owners. lol.
 
Zurai
offline
Link
 
The 2007 Miami Dolphins would like to speak with you.
 
Link
 
Originally posted by rbedgood
Bort,

I liked Cybershots idea of limiting the decline of in-game morale during a bad performance like this. Could something be done to the effect of calculating his confidence which was 29...and saying

100 (base morale) - 29 (confidence) divided by 3= limit of decline in-game

So in his case he was at 99, - his confidence = 70/3= 23.333 so he couldn't drop in game below 76.7.

You may already have something like this, but this seems like it would reward confidence and prevent complete collapses like above.

p.s. tough game Larry, better luck next season.



He doesn't have a limit on how many sacks a OT can give up because he is too slow or too weak. Why limit confidence?

This game will just start making players think about getting that confidence score up to 49 as quickly as they do blocking or speed now.

Bort has been telling people it is important but no one listened. Maybe now they will....
 
Yukon Don
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by SteelersInsider
Originally posted by rbedgood

Bort,

I liked Cybershots idea of limiting the decline of in-game morale during a bad performance like this. Could something be done to the effect of calculating his confidence which was 29...and saying

100 (base morale) - 29 (confidence) divided by 3= limit of decline in-game

So in his case he was at 99, - his confidence = 70/3= 23.333 so he couldn't drop in game below 76.7.

You may already have something like this, but this seems like it would reward confidence and prevent complete collapses like above.

p.s. tough game Larry, better luck next season.



He doesn't have a limit on how many sacks a OT can give up because he is too slow or too weak. Why limit confidence?

This game will just start making players think about getting that confidence score up to 49 as quickly as they do blocking or speed now.

Bort has been telling people it is important but no one listened. Maybe now they will....


I wasn't saying to limit the number of sacks or even the number of INTs. I also still think confidence should be built up. What I was saying is to create a floor on morale drop in-game. Basically if he started at 99, he had nowhere to go but down, and by the end of this game he was probably around 30 or so. What I was suggesting would be to limit how far his morale could drop, based on his starting point (99) and his confidence (29.10) He may have still thrown all the INTs...but proably would've been closer to 5 or 6 INTs instead of 9. Still a bad game, but more realistic. Once a guy throws 3-4 he isn't going to hang his head any lower when he throws #5. He's already down in the dumps.
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.