Why are we still making VAs that give +30% to particular rolls? We should be scaling the current ones, back, no adding more...
Think of it this way, why do we have VA's that give a bigger boost than 3 pieces of AE stacked?
Also the way bull rusher and now max protect/overpower work is insane. +15% attribute VA's were overpowered and nerfed, but giving +15% weighted in rolls (which in effect includes equipment so its even more) is alright?
Lets do a comparison on an olinemen that has 100+55 (155) strength and 90 agility (the below are all with 15 VPs obviously)....
-Workout Warrior gives 100*0.045 = 4.5 strength
-Quick gives 90*0.045 = 4.05 agility
-Overpower gives 155*0.15 = 23.25 strength for the purposes of holding blocks on rushing plays (all you really care about as an olinemen is holding blocks)
-Max Protect gives 155*0.075 strength and 90*0.075 agility = 11.6 strength and 6.75 agility for the purpose of holding blocks on pass plays.
Do you want 4.5 strength /4.05 agility all the time, or 23 strength on run plays/11.6 strength+6.75 agility on pass plays? There is two more VAs that will never get chosen at the expense of these new ones. The same problem exists for bull rusher on defense of course, but my major problems with these VA's being added are...
1. The purpose of VAs is player choice, not balancing the sim. Super powerful VAs that are taken by everyone give players no choice.
2. Balancing overpowered defensive VAs with overpowered offensive VAs is the worst way to go about balance, because your balancing based on assumptions that people choose said VAs, rather than keeping the balance in the sim code.
3. The last off-season was step towards nerfing nasty overpowered "must-have" VA's like comeback kid and DvG. Instead you add stuff that gives +30% to hold block rolls, and +15% to strength including equipment.
4. High strength OLine (and DLine) is already the most popular kind. Bull Rusher and Overpower make it so builds with equipment in anything other than strength are even less viable, further nerfing high agility builds for no reason at all, other than trying to make VAs that sound cool.
*just note* that I am not one of those "VA's are evil" people. They have the potential to give some unique and fun choices for players. However the problem is VAs in this fashion do NOT give these choices and are not fun as a result. And in some cases even allow less player build choices, which is retarded and the opposite of the purpose of VAs....