User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Forum > Suggestions > Playable Cheerleaders Compiled Suggestion
Page:
 
awesome
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Laggo
Did you read the other 200pg thread where this has started?

Have you been in the chat room?



I'll spell it out for you.

I
R
R
E
L
E
V
A
N
T
 
atm490
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by atm490
Laggo - Why have you avoided the several people that have mentioned that cheerleaders in reality do not have the effect that you claim they do, which is the foundation of this very idea?

Several of us have said that cheerleaders do NOT effect fans, do NOT effect morale, and are NOT a part of football.

Comments?


Quoted and asked again because the ones who think this idea is good still haven't responded...
 
Laggo
offline
Link
 
The thread on Playable Cheerleaders is irrelevant to the thread called Playable Cheerleader Compiled Suggestions which took the thoughts in the Playable Cheerleader thread and compiled it into one?

LOL?
 
morgan3
offline
Link
 
Screw giving cheerleaders attributes just make them all start at 250 lbs and ugly, and as they get skinnier they gain more appeal and are better
 
awesome
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Laggo
The thread on Playable Cheerleaders is irrelevant to the thread called Playable Cheerleader Compiled Suggestions which took the thoughts in the Playable Cheerleader thread and compiled it into one?

LOL?


Yes, "LOL." Quite the argument there. Once you reach the age of reckoning, perhaps you will understand the stupidity of this whole idea FROM A BUSINESS PERSPECTIVE.
 
Laggo
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by atm490
Originally posted by atm490

Laggo - Why have you avoided the several people that have mentioned that cheerleaders in reality do not have the effect that you claim they do, which is the foundation of this very idea?

Several of us have said that cheerleaders do NOT effect fans, do NOT effect morale, and are NOT a part of football.

Comments?


Quoted and asked again because the ones who think this idea is good still haven't responded...


Cheerleaders do affect fans, like I said in the misc. section this is taken more from a college aspect (which isn't that far fetched in the way this game goes in terms of realism). The cheerleaders are being suggested as a way to affect the fans - maybe they don't have as much as an affect in real life, but if it adds something fun to do to the game and it's not that hard then why not?

The fans do affect morale, I don't think you can argue against that point. Players try to ignore it but hey - thats why we have the confidence stat isn't it!

Cheerleaders may not be apart of the game itself, but stadiums / hot dog prices / etc. are not really part of the game itself yet they exist in the sim because this is a sim of the football world (which includes cheerleaders).
 
awesome
offline
Link
 
Furthermore, a huge thread of you and your other pre-pubescent friends fantasizing about creating cheerleaders that you can finally control doesn't have any ACTUAL BEARING on whether there is REAL community support for this idea.
 
Laggo
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by awesome


Yes, "LOL." Quite the argument there. Once you reach the age of reckoning, perhaps you will understand the stupidity of this whole idea FROM A BUSINESS PERSPECTIVE.


FROM A BUSINESS PERSPECTIVE?

From a business perspective, the way to make as much money as possible is to add as many entertaining FP sinks that encourage people to spend more FP. 50% of the game may never make a cheerleader, but if 50% of the game buys an extra 100 FP to do so, thats QUITE alot of extra FP in income. This is not including whether you want to allow cheerleader boosting (which if you don't is an area where people who DON'T pay for FP can stay competitive with others, which will encourage non-FP buying players to make a cheerleader).

If the other additions to the game are fun and worth the FP, people won't quit / stop buying FP just because something new is added to the game.

 
Laggo
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by awesome
Furthermore, a huge thread of you and your other pre-pubescent friends fantasizing about creating cheerleaders that you can finally control doesn't have any ACTUAL BEARING on whether there is REAL community support for this idea.


Run a poll then. Bort has stated he's going to start having to make polls for stuff like this because often one side is alot more vocal than the other.
 
caponesgun
offline
Link
 
oh lawd
 
essteeay
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Checkmate187
Originally posted by essteeay

Originally posted by Laggo




Please do not cite "realism" as a way to refute the idea.


Citing lack of realism is one of the best ways to cut down some of the absurd suggestions made around here. Another good appeal is to "relevance". Cheerleaders are meaningless, if not an actual distraction from the GAME (remember the game? football? with the ball and the players and the scoring?). We have no need for them in GLB.


Ever hear of morale? Do you realize it affects how your players play in this game? Wouldn't you like something that could boost your morale, thus making your players play better?

[sarcasm] Yeah, stupid idea. [/sarcasm]


Find me one NFL player who would claim that his team's cheerleaders affect his "morale".
 
awesome
offline
Link
 
"From a business perspective, the way to make as much money as possible is to add as many entertaining FP sinks that encourage people to spend more FP. 50% of the game may never make a cheerleader, but if 50% of the game buys an extra 100 FP to do so, thats QUITE alot of extra FP in income. This is not including whether you want to allow cheerleader boosting (which if you don't is an area where people who DON'T pay for FP can stay competitive with others, which will encourage non-FP buying players to make a cheerleader)."

Even though SOME people will spend more FP on this crap, MOST will not. MANY of these people will leave the game. The net result is surely to be a LOSS in revenue.
 
Link
 
Originally posted by Laggo
Originally posted by awesome

Furthermore, a huge thread of you and your other pre-pubescent friends fantasizing about creating cheerleaders that you can finally control doesn't have any ACTUAL BEARING on whether there is REAL community support for this idea.


Run a poll then. Bort has stated he's going to start having to make polls for stuff like this because often one side is alot more vocal than the other.



Again, it won't matter what any "poll" says--it could be 88 percent in favor and 12 percent opposed and the DEVELOPERS will STILL be wise enough to avoid this idea until EVERY SINGLE FOOTBALL RELATED IDEA has been addressed, perfected, and implemented. Why don't you and your little buddies go Google "cheerleaders" rather than wasting anymore time on this nonsense?
Last edited Jun 23, 2008 15:05:08
 
Checkmate187
offline
Link
 
Forget about cheerleaders for a moment.

Would you like a game feature that boosts in-game morale?
 
Laggo
offline
Link
 
Again.

Cheerleaders -> Fans -> Players

Lots of NFL players would agree that the fans affect their morale.

The purpose of cheerleaders are to motivate the fans, whether or not they are able to do that job in an NFL environment.

This is GLB however, and we can program it as such that the cheerleaders always do their job - and we get the relevant benefits.
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.