User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Forum > Goal Line Blitz > Ridiculous Playoff Upset
Page:
 
fsmileys
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Catch22
My response in the post linked previously in this thread was incorrect. CPU's will scale up or down to their opponent. CPU's still operate at a significant disadvantage to human players but it is possible to beat a human team with a CPU team if certain factors come into play (for example good game planning by the CPU team and terrible game planning by the human team). If you go through league games throughout GLB you will see that CPU teams are routinely dominated by teams that put any effort into the game.

I apologize for any confusion caused by my previous response. I will edit my statement there so it is not inaccurately quoted in the future.


Catch we ran the same ai for the whole season.
 
jdbolick
offline
Link
 
Regardless of whether he went 16-0 because of or in spite of his gameplan, he still went 16-0. It's one thing when an 8 seed comes up with a brilliant gameplan to foil their previously undefeated opponent, but it's quite another to win with a CPU roster when the GMs acknowledge that they didn't even put time into the game because they assumed they would lose.
 
Dub J
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Novus
Yes... a CPU roster that was good enough to make the playoffs. That just highlights what a truly awful league he was in.

fsmileys was making the argument that his gameplan MUST be fine because it went 16-0 in the regular season. But there's a REASON he went 16-0: because his league is so awful that even a CPU roster was able to sneak into the playoffs. When your league is that weak, it means you can put together the world's worst gameplan and still go 16-0 DESPITE your gameplan, not BECAUSE of your gameplan.

Bad gameplans lose to CPU teams every now and then. This ain't exactly the first time a CPU roster has defeated a human roster.

...

Probably couldn't hurt to have Bort and Catch reconsider how strong CPU players are anyway, but I think everyone needs to keep in mind that it is ALSO entirely possible that fsmileys lost this game because he's an awful gameplanner, not because CPUs are too powerful. That's all I'm saying.


Best post ITT imo
 
Link
 
Originally posted by Corey So Freaky
Welcome to GLB.


 
fsmileys
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by RufusBrutal
What a joke. The outcome of that game is an embarrassment and to defend it makes it look even worse.


your not kidding Catch please make up your mind (it;s a circle answer)
 
SWVAHoo
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by jdbolick
Regardless of whether he went 16-0 because of or in spite of his gameplan, he still went 16-0. It's one thing when an 8 seed comes up with a brilliant gameplan to foil their previously undefeated opponent, but it's quite another to win with a CPU roster when the GMs acknowledge that they didn't even put time into the game because they assumed they would lose.


That's not the reason we didn't put time into the game. The reason is that we're demoting and restocking our team with new guys, and we want to make sure our ducks are in a row while doing so. We just assumed we'd get slaughtered as a result.
Edited by InLondonWeTrust on Dec 22, 2010 11:54:31
 
Link
 
Originally posted by Triple_A
Boo fucking hoo. Way to bail out on your team.



Yes, he should be grateful to spend 400 flex per season to build a 16-0 team that loses to an 8-8 CPU team they already beat 61-6 earlier in the season. What a fun game this is.
 
superpunk
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by fsmileys
Catch we ran the same ai for the whole season.


Well after watching the game, that was a mistake.

Still, there were only about 10 plays (I didn't count exactly) where your terrible DAI plays came out.

I'll play both sides of the coin with that. In a close game, obviously those 10 plays made all the difference in the world. And all things being equal, you should have lost. But, the question is should all things be equal? Should you really be in danger of losing to a CPU team because of 10 bad plays?

To play devils advocate to my devils advocate, that still doesn't account for the CPU's ability to
(a) Force Fumbles and get Knocked Loose rolls even early in the game, and they did it consistently, like they were a team built for that.
(b) Absolutely dominate your offensive line at certain points.
(c) Complete passes into double coverage at significant moments in the game.
 
fsmileys
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Dub J
Best post ITT imo


Dub u know me I know what I am doing. There is no excuse for this. Game planning was done the whole season. Every game took every team seriously. I never saw some of the plays and my AI for defense wasn't used
 
Sarg01
offline
Link
 
Am I the only one who thinks maybe CPU players shouldn't be as lol as they are? I'm glad to see this upset.

You'd get a lot fewer gutjobs if teams that had 35-40 human players didn't know they stood no chance of being even minimally competitive.
 
Catch22
offline
Link
 
Here's the deal - if CPU filled teams were routinely beating evenly matched or superior human teams, we would consider adjusting the strength of CPU players. However, this happens very infrequently and usually when it does it is due to poor game planning by the human team. We will continue to monitor the performance of CPU players and if it is necessary we will make adjustments, but at this time there is not enough evidence of that being the case to compel us to do so. It is certainly unfortunate to lose to a CPU team and I understand your frustrations, but playing a team filled with CPU players does not automatically guarantee victory.
 
PsychoWard
plop
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Doc_Nilla
Precisely the reason for asking the question in the first place. Oh well.

Thanks for the correction, Catch.


see told you lol
 
deez11010
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by superpunk
watched it. I would be just as pissed.

He did have some problems with DAI plays, and his QB's tuck it setting activated far too often, BUT....

The CPUs were forcing fumbles and getting knocked loose rolls like noone's business. At several points in the game on scoring drives, they also start completing passes into double coverage and their DL starts absolutely dominating the offense. This could be explained away by saying this team has the absolute worst dot-builders in history, but that would mean the rest of the league is even worse (as they were the 1 seed) and that's unlikely.

This is ridiculous.


2 of those fumbles were from a blocking FB with 33 carrying. Vs level 70+, 33 carrying should probably fumble more that that. 2 more were from an elusive HB that has 32 career regular season fumbles, so I'd guess his carrying wasnt very high either. There was only 1 other fumble by a RB who probably was the only one with decent carrying, which imo is acceptable. Shit happens.

3 other fumbles were from WRs, who I'd once again wager that their carrying isnt high enough to be good vs level 70+'s.

People shouldnt be so surprised that their low attributes bite them in the ass when playing opponents of the same level as them.

 
Link
 
Originally posted by superpunk
Well after watching the game, that was a mistake.

Still, there were only about 10 plays (I didn't count exactly) where your terrible DAI plays came out.

I'll play both sides of the coin with that. In a close game, obviously those 10 plays made all the difference in the world. And all things being equal, you should have lost. But, the question is should all things be equal? Should you really be in danger of losing to a CPU team because of 10 bad plays?

To play devils advocate to my devils advocate, that still doesn't account for the CPU's ability to
(a) Force Fumbles and get Knocked Loose rolls even early in the game, and they did it consistently, like they were a team built for that.
(b) Absolutely dominate your offensive line at certain points.
(c) Complete passes into double coverage at significant moments in the game.


The same gameplan won them a game against the same team 61-6. If the CPU team did not adjust their gameplan (and it sounds like they didn't) the results should not be this wildly different.
 
Link
 

A+ thread, would read again
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.