User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Forum > Goal Line Blitz > Non-World League Passing Results: Stats
Page:
 
vinman
offline
Link
 
Why should passing suck in the lower leagues? Last time I checked,boosting a WR cost the same at any level.
 
ryanshaw
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by chronoaug
Lower levels are reasonable at passing and all the skills. They aren't amazing and they screw up a lot but is to be expected. The game would be a waste if the performance was the same at all levels and it should not be. If that was the case there'd be no point in applying sp and leveling up if everyone just played the same

People are trying to make their dots WL caliber by slow building to the extreme but at the same time are confused why things are weird. When 1-2 attribtues are at 70-85natural and others are 12 with very little VAs and aeq and %modifiers people should expect a lot less out of their dots. Sorry if that enrages people but it's true


The OP was not about lower levels. It was basically talking about levels 30 up to Pro. The stats are dreadful in the higher levels but do get worse as you go down.

By mid-40s the builds have rounded out to the level that they should be mostly playable. Certainly for the guys in A/AA you cannot use slowbuilding as an excuse. Passing stats are far too low in all these leagues. It is not a problem with builds etc, it is just that the sim was test balanced for WL builds and not for anyone else.

In reference to your first paragraph, there is no reason why passing should suck (because people have lower skills) but pass defence doesn't. If you are going to play the 'lower level players suck' card you need to accept that they will suck across the board. You might expect to get more broken coverages or dropped passes, but overall it would not just show up as crap passing stats all the time and nothing else.
 
ryanshaw
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Dr. E
How did you determine the passing game isn't working correctly. Where is your control? Here's three alternate determinations.
1. It's preseason and a good number of teams aren't trying.
2. it's preseason and a good number of teams are experimenting.
3. Some teams are still trying to get away with the weakness from the previous versions of the SIM.


These points are fair. I personally do not think this is what is happening although clearly they would have some effect. The problem is that if you are wrong, and the passing game isn't working, a large proportion of GLB is going to have to go through the whole season with a hopeless passing game (just as we did a few seasons ago). Therefore, it needs to be investigated (and if necessary addressed) now. Bort and co could pull enough detailed stats off their database in a few hours to determine where the problem is. I have just tried to highlight that there may well be an issue.

FWIW, I have never seen mid-high level teams outside the WL/Pros running the deep passing into coverage offence, as it did not work before for builds at these levels. Most of the passing offences have always been pretty balanced in the leagues I have played in recently.
 
PLAYMAKERS
offline
Link
 
Nov 16, 2010
- Bump up lower level passing bonuses a bit
 
Adderfist
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by PLAYMAKERS
Nov 16, 2010
- Bump up lower level passing bonuses a bit


I'm so glad I wasted 96 hours.

Wish they would have actually tested the changes in the first place.

... Oh well, better late then never.
 
Dr. E
online
Link
 
Originally posted by ryanshaw
These points are fair. I personally do not think this is what is happening although clearly they would have some effect. The problem is that if you are wrong, and the passing game isn't working, a large proportion of GLB is going to have to go through the whole season with a hopeless passing game (just as we did a few seasons ago). Therefore, it needs to be investigated (and if necessary addressed) now. Bort and co could pull enough detailed stats off their database in a few hours to determine where the problem is. I have just tried to highlight that there may well be an issue.

FWIW, I have never seen mid-high level teams outside the WL/Pros running the deep passing into coverage offence, as it did not work before for builds at these levels. Most of the passing offences have always been pretty balanced in the leagues I have played in recently.


Because there are teams having very good preseason results with the passing game, and it only takes one, logic says it's not the SIM. It's up to us to figure out how to make passing work.
 
Deathblade
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Adderfist
I'm so glad I wasted 96 hours.

Wish they would have actually tested the changes in the first place.

... Oh well, better late then never.


Wow, what did you spent 96 hours doing?
 
ryanshaw
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Dr. E
Because there are teams having very good preseason results with the passing game, and it only takes one, logic says it's not the SIM. It's up to us to figure out how to make passing work.


I'm sorry, but this is not logical at all. In GLB, if your players have materially better builds than the competition, EVERYTHING works. It is why the old WL passing game came into existence - if your WRs and QBs had certain builds you could throw to them anywhere and they would still catch it, almost regardless of the D or the coverage. Most teams pretty much the same gameplan throughout the regular season. When they play a team that is worse than them the stats look great; when they play someone better they suck. This is just about relative team strength and not tactics.

Even if there are teams that consistently pass well even when they are outclassed, it does not necessarily mean that the sim works properly. They may simply have certain builds that the sim currently 'likes' in the same way the WL players did, and nobody thought that was sensible. The ability to field an averagely successful passing game should be available to teams with average builds - currently, I don't think this is the case.

To say that because just one team can do well passing means the sim functions properly is utterly incorrect. Game balance is about balancing the game for the majority of people who actually play it, not just a tiny percentage. It does not follow at all that because one team can construct a gameplan for a successful passing game, all teams (or even average teams) could do the same.
Edited by ryanshaw on Nov 17, 2010 12:31:24
 
aron26
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Adderfist
I'm so glad I wasted 96 hours.

Wish they would have actually tested the changes in the first place.

... Oh well, better late then never.


For levels lower than WL, we are the test.

If we don't squak then they assume everything is fine.

That said, Catch repeated several times that if it changed it would only be a slight change - so don't expect things to get that much better. Passing will still have to passed up at lower levels, and tweaked very carefully at higher ones.

 
whatje
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by ryanshaw
I'm sorry, but this is not logical at all. In GLB, if your players have materially better builds than the competition, EVERYTHING works. It is why the old WL passing game came into existence - if your WRs and QBs had certain builds you could throw to them anywhere and they would still catch it, almost regardless of the D or the coverage. Most teams pretty much the same gameplan throughout the regular season. When they play a team that is worse than them the stats look great; when they play someone better they suck. This is just about relative team strength and not tactics.

Even if there are teams that consistently pass well even when they are outclassed, it does not necessarily mean that the sim works properly. They may simply have certain builds that the sim currently 'likes' in the same way the WL players did, and nobody thought that was sensible. The ability to field an averagely successful passing game should be available to teams with average builds - currently, I don't think this is the case.

To say that because just one team can do well passing means the sim functions properly is utterly incorrect. Game balance is about balancing the game for the majority of people who actually play it, not just a tiny percentage. It does not follow at all that because one team can construct a gameplan for a successful passing game, all teams (or even average teams) could do the same.


just, no.
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.