User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Forum > Goal Line Blitz > This was the best suggestion on how to balance extreme attributes...
Page:
 
Deathblade
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by jdbolick

All non-custom equipment. That way you don't have 150+ in an attribute, but you also reduce the currently overpowered effects of % pieces. The beauty is that you could do it immediately since it would apply to everyone equally, and wouldn't need to force-remove or replace some pieces the way that limitations would.


If you think cutting EQ in half would be a quick and easy fix then lololol
 
tautology
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Deathblade
If you think cutting EQ in half would be a quick and easy fix then lololol


This probably does more harm to relatively balanced builds than to extreme builds. A balanced LB with most eq in speed putting him at 125 gets seriously hammered by a change like this, while an extreme guy is still going to be very fast. Extreme builds have the bare minimum in all secondary attributes and massive enhancement in one attribute. They retain this quality with an equipment change.

Balanced guys have the minimum necessary for good performance in their highest attribute, and strong supporting secondary attributes. They lose their minimum necessary level in a primary with a change like this.


 
Deathblade
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by tautology
Balanced guys have the minimum necessary for good performance in their highest attribute, and strong supporting secondary attributes. They lose their minimum necessary level in a primary with a change like this.


Your theory crafting does a good job of ignoring the fact that "minimum necessary" is relative of the "extreme builds"
 
PrizzlePulse
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by GwalltOren
dont like this, limits the variety of builds.

-1


yeah man dem 150 speed wrs, without everyone being able to pump out speed insanely it would eliminate the insane difference in wr builds we currently have! I mean cmon GLB, its not like players have other attributes to use, let em pump those attributes!
 
tautology
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Deathblade
Your theory crafting does a good job of ignoring the fact that "minimum necessary" is relative of the "extreme builds"


Agree to some extent, but really a lot of what determines minimum speed has to do with the speed of the ball in flight and the pre-handoff timing of running plays.

It's not entirely a speed vs speed player equation.

 
charwh
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Deathblade
Your theory crafting does a good job of ignoring the fact that "minimum necessary" is relative of the "extreme builds"


"Minimum necessary" is also relative to "maximum possible", which will still be somewhere around natural 120-124 (depending on archetype) if all equipment was removed.

Edited to add:

And also relative to 6 cap, which is where soft caps start becoming farther apart in regards to SP's, and therefore most lucrative for ALG's. That leaves a range between 80 and 120 for "just high enough" primaries, which isn't really that big.

Edited by charwh on Oct 21, 2010 16:40:08
Edited by charwh on Oct 21, 2010 16:39:14
 
Tully Mars
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by PrizzlePulse
yeah man dem 150 speed wrs, without everyone being able to pump out speed insanely it would eliminate the insane difference in wr builds we currently have! I mean cmon GLB, its not like players have other attributes to use, let em pump those attributes!



[marcellus]
English Motherfucker!
Do you speak it?
[/marcellus]
 
foshizzel17
my drizzt
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Tully Mars
Originally posted by PrizzlePulse

yeah man dem 150 speed wrs, without everyone being able to pump out speed insanely it would eliminate the insane difference in wr builds we currently have! I mean cmon GLB, its not like players have other attributes to use, let em pump those attributes!



[Julius]
English Motherfucker!
Do you speak it?
[/Julius]


fyp
 
jdbolick
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Deathblade
If you think cutting EQ in half would be a quick and easy fix then lololol

Quick and easy to implement. There would be forum rage, but there will be about any change to equipment. Halving is by far the best option if anything is going to be done to EQ.


Originally posted by tautology
This probably does more harm to relatively balanced builds than to extreme builds. A balanced LB with most eq in speed putting him at 125 gets seriously hammered by a change like this, while an extreme guy is still going to be very fast.

If they both have the same amount of equipment in speed, then they obviously get affected by the same amount. The interactions which would be most affected are those where equipment isn't used the same way, such as an all speed/agi DL versus a strength equipment OL, or an all speed blitzing ROLB versus an OL with no equipment in speed.

 
charwh
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by jdbolick

If they both have the same amount of equipment in speed, then they obviously get affected by the same amount. The interactions which would be most affected are those where equipment isn't used the same way, such as an all speed/agi DL versus a strength equipment OL, or an all speed blitzing ROLB versus an OL with no equipment in speed.



Going from 130 to105 is a 20% drop in speed, but going from 150 to 125 is only a 17% drop in speed.

also, raising a secondary attribute from 70 to 90 is a 29% gain, but raising an attribute from 50 to 70 is a 40% gain.

Balanced builds would loose a greater percentage of speed, and gain back a lower percentage of secondaries.

i.e. it would encourage more imbalanced builds.

Edited by charwh on Oct 21, 2010 17:32:48
Edited by charwh on Oct 21, 2010 17:32:31
 
jdbolick
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by charwh
Going from 130 to105 is a 20% drop in speed, but going from 150 to 125 is only a 17% drop in speed. also, raising a secondary attribute from 70 to 90 is a 29% gain, but raising an attribute from 50 to 70 is a 40% gain. Balanced builds would loose a greater percentage of speed, and gain back a lower percentage of secondaries.

Do you not see why that is irrelevant? Percentage loss doesn't even matter. If Player X has 150 speed and Player Y has 130, then that's exactly the same speed difference in the sim as if they only had 125 and 105. A 20 point difference in the speed attribute produces the same difference in actual speed within the sim, barring other factors like energy.
 
wlarson
offline
Link
 
I think just in general the non-physical stats still need a boost. Work was done to make carrying, blocking, tackling, etc more valuable. I feel like vision is still neglected to a point. Defenders need it, obviously, but a lot of offensive dots are able to get away with poor vision.

Unfortunately that is going to take a substantial amount of work. If, for example, WRs with high vision could look for holes in the defense, they'd still be challenged by the fact that few teams play zone. Man coverage is too easy and has been since day one. Hard to say what the right fix is there, but I tend to think close coverage needs to less effective vs deep routes and loose coverage needs to be less effective vs short routes. There needs to be a reason for good coverage builds to play loose. Right now there isn't one.

edit: and i'm not sure where i went with that one..... so... in order to nerf WRs, we need to first nerf CBs? something like that. i think i should go home now. work.. work... work...
Edited by wlarson on Oct 21, 2010 17:39:16
Edited by wlarson on Oct 21, 2010 17:38:55
 
charwh
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by jdbolick

Do you not see why that is irrelevant? Percentage loss doesn't even matter. If Player X has 150 speed and Player Y has 130, then that's exactly the same speed difference in the sim as if they only had 125 and 105. A 20 point difference in the speed attribute produces the same difference in actual speed within the sim, barring other factors like energy.


no it's not, that's like saying 5 mph is as equally close to 25 mph as 135 mph is to 155 mph.

or like 0 mph is as equally close to 20 mph.

Edited by charwh on Oct 21, 2010 17:41:00
Edited by charwh on Oct 21, 2010 17:41:00
 
jdbolick
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by charwh
no it's not, that's like saying 5 mph is as equally close to 25 mph as 135 mph is to 155 mph.

It is.
 
tautology
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by jdbolick

Do you not see why that is irrelevant? Percentage loss doesn't even matter. If Player X has 150 speed and Player Y has 130, then that's exactly the same speed difference in the sim as if they only had 125 and 105. A 20 point difference in the speed attribute produces the same difference in actual speed within the sim, barring other factors like energy.


You are wrong about this for a variety of reasons.

You would be right if the two players were engaged in a 100 m dash and this were a track meet game....but it's not.


There are a whole host of areas where the amount of speed you need is related to things other than the speed of an opposing player.


 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.